- 1 - ! "#$ $$ % & '( $$ % & ' ( !"" # $ " % & #'(" %)* +$ * , Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % (( ,' "- " (( "" "- !" # """ (%. &***** "' $ ( ( %# $ ( " ' "" ( , ' ** ) " %* + , # $ " ( %% ' +/ %' */ ' ( !"" # $ " % - 3 - #'(" %)* +$ * , % (( ,' "- " (( " " "- !" # """ (%. &** %*** "' $ ( ( %# $ ( " ' "" ( , ' ** ) " %)* + , # $ " ( *) ' +/ )' */ "" ( , ' 0, " - 4 - # 1232 4552463 472 7235289:;26< =:62> ?< 912 864:@4A934B4:A399128C@@CADE>B@2A94A>4F47>>492> ** )54332>?<912>>:9:CA46:397:894A>233:CA3 ,E>B2 4A> :>47 3:99:AB 49 146G: H=C7 31C79 I7:?EA46JK :A C3% 4A> %) C= * + 322G:AB 2A14A82@2A9C=8C@52A349:CA * 12 :ADE72> 864:@4A93 @29 F:91 4A 488:>2A9 CA %* + 4A> 3E394:A2> B7:2;CE3 :ADE7:23 12< =:62> 864:@ 529:9:CA3 ?2=C72 912 7:?EA46 322G:AB 8C@52A349:CA =7C@9127235CA>2A93127:?EA464=9278CA3:>27:AB912 2A9:72 2;:>2A82 CA 728C7> 4F47>2> 912 8C@52A349:CA C= 3%% :A C%* + 4A> 3*) :A C%)* +F:91:A92723949+/5274AAE@=7C@912 >492 C= 529:9:CA3 9:66 7246:L49:CA 4A> >:72892> 7235CA>2A9 C% A3E74A82 C@54A< 9C 54< 912 8C@52A349:CA BB7:2;2>?<91234@2864:@4A93472?2=C7291:3CE79:A 912:77235289:;24552463 - 5 - % 247> 47BE@2A93 C= ?C91 912 5479:23 4A> 527E32> 912 @4927:463 4;4:64?62 CA 728C7> :A ?C91 912 4552463 12@4:A8CA92A9:CAC=9124552664A93864:@4A93 :A?C919124552463:391497:?EA46143AC94F47>2>4A< 8C@52A349:CA 9CF47>3 6C33 C= 4@2A:9:23 :A 6:=2 4A> 8CA;2<4A82 8147B23 4A> 9149 912 8C@52A349:CA 4F47>2> EA>27C9127124>3:3@24B728C@52A349:CA A(C* %%** 247A2> 8CEA326 =C7 912 4552664A9 8CA92A>2> 91499127:?EA461432772>:A433233:AB>:34?:6:9<49*/ 91CEB1912C89C71434332332>%/>:34?:6:9< 9:3463C 3E?@:992>9C2A14A829127492C=:A9272399C)/434B4:A39 +/4F47>2>?<9127:?EA46 + 552664A91433E394:A2>=7489E72C=7:B196492746 @4662C6E34A>87E31:ADE7<4A>=7489E72C=7:B19=2@E72 F43 1C35:946:L2> =C7 >4<3 4A> EA>27BCA2 3E7B27<4A> =C66CF E5 97249@2A9 A 3E55C79 C= 1:3 8432 864:@4A9 - 6 - 2M4@:A2>912C89C743"'%F1C3949239149864:@4A9143 6C33 C= 74AB2 @C9:CA C= 7:B19 GA22 72>E82> 4A> @E3862 3972AB9147CEA>7:B19GA22F1:811239492>91498C@?:A2> >:34?:6:9< C= @C?:6:9< 8C@5CA2A9 :3 4332332> 49 / 4A> 394?:6:9< 8C@5CA2A9 :3 4332332> 49 %+/ 4A> AC92> C9127 >:==:8E69:23 =482> ?< 912 549:2A9 4A> =:A466< C5:A2> 9149 864:@4A91433E394:A2>527@4A2A95479:46>:34?:6:9<C=912 6:@?49%/4A>:33E2>:34?:6:9<279:=:849243527M") 7:?EA46 8CA3:>272> 912 >:34?:6:9< 49 */ 247A2> 8CEA326=C79124552664A93E?@:9391498CA3:>27:AB9124B2 4A>A49E72C=:ADE7:23912>:34?:6:9<:39C?2:A872432> A 7256< 6247A2> 8CEA326 =C7 912 7235CA>2A9 N A3E74A82 C@54A< 3E?@:93 9149 %7> C= %/ 8C@23 9C CA6< / 4A>9127:?EA461436:?27466<94G2A*/4A>:9A22>3AC :A927=272A82 1272=C72 91:3 CE79 =:A>3 :9 DE39 4A> 7243CA4?628CA=:7@912>:34?:6:9<94G2A?<9127:?EA46 12 864:@4A9 143 AC9 57C>E82> 4A< >C8E@2A9 9C57C;21:3:A8C@23912488:>2A9:3C=912<247* + 43527912BE:>26:A23:33E2>?<91247A494G494922B46 - 7 - 27;:823 E91C7:9< 91:3 CE79 >22@3 :9 4557C57:492 9C 72433233 912 :A8C@2 C= 912 864:@4A9 49 3 527 @CA9199129:@2C=488:>2A9912864:@4A9F434B2>+ <2473 4A> 4557C57:492 @E69:56:27 4556:84?62 9C 1:3 4B2 B7CE5:3IJ88C7>:AB6<912864:@4A9:32A9:962>=C76C33 C==E9E72247A:AB43EA>27 3M *MM*/O3 12 864:@4A9 F43 4>@:992> :A 912 1C35:946 =C7 >4<3CA3:>27:AB912527:C>C=1C35:946:L49:CAA49E72 C= :ADE7:23 4A> C9127 7262;4A9 =489C73 91:3 CE79 =:A>3 :9 7243CA4?62 9C 4F47> 4A 4@CEA9 C= 3 =C7 54:A 4A> 3E==27:AB 3* =C7 6C33 C= 4@2A:9:23 4A> 3% =C7 974A35C7949:CA 2M974 ACE7:31@2A9 4A> 4992A>4A9 8147B23 (E79127 >E2 9C :ADE7:23 912 864:@4A9 @:B19AC914;24992A>2>4A<FC7G4962439=C74527:C>C= @CA913 12A82 91:3 CE79 =:A>3 :9 7243CA4?62 9C 4F47> 3% =C7 6C33 C= :A8C@2 >E7:AB 64:> E5 527:C> CF2;27 912 8C@52A349:CA C= 3) 4F47>2> ?< 9127:?EA46=C7@2>:8462M52A323A22>3AC:A927=272A82 - 8 - ) 12 8C@52A349:CA 4F47>2> ?< 912 7:?EA46 :3 @C>:=:2>43EA>27 6 C 24>3 F47>?<912 7:?EA46 F47>?<91:3 CE79 "4:A 4A> 3E==27:AB 3 3 * 2>:846 M52A323 3) 3) % C33 C= =E9E72 247A:AB84548:9< 3 % 3 74A35C7949:CA 2M974 ACE7:31@2A9 4A> 4992A>4A9 8147B23 3 3% C33 C= 4@2A:9:23 3* + C33 C= :A8C@2 >E7:AB 64:> E5 527:C> 3 + 3% C946 3%% 3* 1272F:66?22A14A82@2A9C=3 + - 9 - A(C* % ** 247A2> 8CEA326 =C7 912 4552664A9864:@4A9 8CA92A>2> 9149 912 7:?EA46 143 2772> :A 433233:AB >:34?:6:9< 49 */ 91CEB1 912 C89C7 143 4332332> / >:34?:6:9< 4A> 91E3 72PE2392> =C7 2A14A82@2A9 C= 8C@52A349:CA 552664A91433E394:A2>8C@@:AE92>=7489E72C= =CE7 @294947346 4A>51464AB23 C= 7:B19 =CC9 =7489E72A28G C= 91 4A> 91 @294947346 7:B19 14A> =7489E72 57CM:@46 51464AM C= 91 =:AB27 2 F43 972492> 43 :A549:2A9 =7C@ %* + 9C %* + 4A> EA>27BCA2 =C66CF E5 97249@2A9 A3E55C79C=1:384324552664A92M4@:A2>CA 8C@@:33:CA912C89C743"'F1C3949239149864:@4A9 1436C33C=74AB2@C9:CAC=7:B19GA2272>E82>4A>@E3862 3972AB91 47CEA> 7:B19 GA22 F1:81 12 4332332> )/ 43 @C?:6:9<8C@5CA2A94A>394?:6:9<8C@5CA2A949%%/2 463C 394923 7:B19 E5527 6:@? :3 14;:AB >2=C7@:9< C= 7:B19 14A> 92A>27A233 57232A9 72397:892> @C;2@2A9 C= 14A> 57232A9>:==:8E69<9C6:=9912F2:B19@E38625CF27C=14A> - 10 - 72>E82> 9C / 4A> 6CF27 6:@? :3 4332332> 49 / 4A> C5:A2> 9149 864:@4A9 143 3E394:A2> 527@4A2A9 5479:46 >:34?:6:9< C= 912 6:@? 49 / 4A> :33E2> :34?:6:9< 279:=:8492 43 527 M"* 7:?EA46 8CA3:>272> 912 >:34?:6:9< 49 */ 247A2> 8CEA326 =C7 912 4552664A9 3E?@:9391498CA3:>27:AB9124B24A>A49E72C=:ADE7:23912 >:34?:6:9<:39C?2:A872432> A7256<6247A2>8CEA326=C7 9127235CA>2A9N A3E74A82C@54A<3E?@:939149 %7>C= / 8C@23 9C CA6< / 4A> 912 7:?EA46 143 6:?27466< 94G2A */ 4A> :9 A22>3 AC :A927=272A82 1272=C72 91:3 CE79 =:A>3 :9 DE39 4A> 7243CA4?62 8CA=:7@ 912 >:34?:6:9< 94G2A?<9127:?EA46 * 12 864:@4A9 143 AC9 57C>E82> 4A< >C8E@2A9 9C57C;21:3:A8C@23912488:>2A9:3C=912<247* + 43527912BE:>26:A23:33E2>?<91247A494G494922B46 27;:823 E91C7:9< 91:3 CE79 >22@3 :9 4557C57:492 9C 72433233 912 :A8C@2 C= 912 864:@4A9 49 3 527 @CA9199129:@2C=488:>2A9912864:@4A9F434B2>+ <2473 4A> 4557C57:492 @E69:56:27 4556:84?62 9C 1:3 4B2 - 11 - B7CE5:3IJ88C7>:AB6<912864:@4A9:32A9:962>=C76C33 C==E9E72247A:AB43EA>27 3M *MM*/O3 % 12 864:@4A9 F43 4>@:992> :A 912 1C35:946 =C7 >4<3CA3:>27:AB912527:C>C=1C35:946:L49:CAA49E72 C= :ADE7:23 4A> C9127 7262;4A9 =489C73 91:3 CE79 =:A>3 :9 7243CA4?62 9C 4F47> 4A 4@CEA9 C= 3 =C7 54:A 4A> 3E==27:AB 3* =C7 6C33 C= 4@2A:9:23 4A> 3% =C7 974A35C7949:CA 2M974 ACE7:31@2A9 4A> 4992A>4A9 8147B23 (E79127 >E2 9C :ADE7:23 912 864:@4A9 @:B19AC914;24992A>2>4A<FC7G4962439=C74527:C>C= @CA913 12A82 91:3 CE79 =:A>3 :9 7243CA4?62 9C 4F47> 3% =C7 6C33 C= :A8C@2 >E7:AB 64:> E5 527:C> CF2;27 912 8C@52A349:CA C= 3) 4F47>2> ?< 9127:?EA46=C7@2>:8462M52A323A22>3AC:A927=272A82 12 8C@52A349:CA 4F47>2> ?< 912 7:?EA46 :3 @C>:=:2>43EA>27 - 12 - 6 C 24>3 F47>?<912 7:?EA46 F47>?<91:3 CE79 "4:A 4A> 3E==27:AB 3 3 * 2>:846 M52A323 3) 3) % C33 C= =E9E72 247A:AB84548:9< 3 % 3 74A35C7949:CA 2M974 ACE7:31@2A9 4A> 4992A>4A9 8147B23 3 3% C33 C= 4@2A:9:23 3* + C33 C= :A8C@2 >E7:AB 64:> E5 527:C> 3 + 3% C946 3*) 3%+ 1272F:66?22A14A82@2A9C=3 + 235CA>2A9 C% N A3E74A82 C@54A< 143 46724>< >25C3:92> 912 8C@52A349:CA 4@CEA9 4F47>2> ?< 9127:?EA46CA912?C91912864:@529:9:CA3 + A912723E69912=C66CF:ABC7>27:354332> - 13 - #:$ 552463472 #::$ 12 864:@4A93 472 2A9:962> =C7 912 2A14A82> 8C@52A349:CA C= 3 + 2481 F:91:A92723949+/5274AAE@=7C@912>492C= 529:9:CA9:66912>492C=7246:L49:CA #:::$ 235CA>2A9 C% N A3E74A82 C@54A< :3 >:72892> 9C >25C3:9 912 4=C7234:> 8C@52A349:CA4@CEA946CABF:91:A927239F:91:A CA2 @CA91 =7C@ 912 >492 C= 91:3 DE>B@2A9 :A ?C919124552463 #:;$ A 3E81 >25C3:9 912 864:@4A93 472 527@:992>9CF:91>74F9122A9:724@CEA946CAB F:91:A9272394887E2>CA:9 )*' %$& # :39C 6C + ,