Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43588 (KAR)
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA v. NINGAPPA S/O DEVINDRAPPA CHAMANALLI AND ORS
CRL.A/200107/2016 · 2025-12-10
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43588 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43588 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#! "##$ !! %&
'%(!)*+,%))
-
!! %!! !!)
! "
! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
"
""
$ % !! &
%
!! '
!"
.! % $')
&'() ()
) ) %
!!$
% $!" #*!"
+
# !+ ! $# ! #* ) %
!!$ %
$!" #*!"
+
- 3 -
# !+ ! $#! #*
%
!!" , -
. %
. % %
$# ( . % %)
/012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ ;<==<1 >?62=/19 639/6 !!$ @3AA/6 78 9:/ 0A940;9 316 /AA0<1A %?62/ 36204001<$!"316<#*!"B:/4/019:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9< ' 34/ 3;C?099/6 <D 9:/ <DD/1;/ ;:342/6 32301A99:/=019:/;3A/9:/@4<A/;?90<1:3A3@@4<3;:/6 9:0A<?49B09:9:/@4/A/193@@/3E
! 10903EE8 9:/ ;3A/ B3A 4/20A9/4/6 32301A9 9:/ ?1F1<B1@/4A<1A<19:/;<=@E3019<D 3=3113< 0643=3@@3 3=@01 3EE/2012 9:39 :0A D39:/4 0643=3@@3 3=@013 (D<4 A:<49 ,9:/ 6/;/3A/6) B3A =0AA012 :/4/3D9/4 <1 9:/ ;<=@E3019 <D !+:34313@@3 9:/
- 4 -
31<9:/4A<1<D6/;/3A/69:/;3A/B3A4/20A9/4/632301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A D<4 9:/ <DD/1;/A @?10A:37E/ ?16/4 /;90<1A # #& #' !+ ! ! $# 4/36 B09: /;90<1#*<D16031/13E<6/(D<4A:<49,-)
:/ 740/D D3;9A <D 9:/ ;3A/ 3EE/2/6 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1A0A9:399:/6/;/3A/6B3A9:/4/A06/19<D 3613EE0 50EE32/ :/ 3;;?A/6 < 0A B0D/ <D !+ :34313@@30/9:/3;;?A/6<0A9:/63?2:9/4+01+E3B <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ 3;;?A/6 < 0A 9:/ 13905/ <D 3613EE0 50EE32/ :/4/ B3A 0EE/23E 0190=3;8 7/9B//1 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 3;;?A/6 < :/ ! :36 A//1 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <A 316 B:/1 9:/8 B/4/ 01 ;<=@4<=0A/ @<A090<1 B09: /3;: <9:/4 <1 3 7/6 01 9:/ 102:9 :<?4A 9 9:3990=/9:/#399/=@9/69<;39;::<E69:/3;;?A/6 < 7?9 :/ 606 1<9 A?;;//6 :/4/3D9/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <E/D99:/50EE32/<D3613EE0316A:/A9349/69<4/A06/ 01:/4@34/19A:<?A/D9/49:/01;06/199:/3;;?A/6< E/D9 3613EE0 50EE32/ 316 :/ B3A 4/A06012 01 3E37?4320 01 9:/:<?A/<D9:/3;;?A/6<!/60A;E<A/69:/D3;99:39
- 5 -
9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B3A 31 01DE?/1903E 316 31248 @/4A<1 D :/ ;3=/9<F1<B<D9:/0EE/23E0190=3;87/9B//19:/3;;?A/6 <316;/49301E8:/B<?E61<9A@34/9:/3;;?A/6< 316 1<9 3EE<B :0= 9< 4/A06/ 01 3613EE0 50EE32/ 316 9:/ 6/;/3A/6B<?E6F0EE3;;?A/6<:/4/3D9/4<1/6389:/ 3;;?A/6<A9<":39;:/6;<1A@043;8019:/:<?A/<D9:/ 3;;?A/6<!9<D010A:<DD9:/6/;/3A/619:/=//9012<D ;<1A@043;89:/3;;?A/6<316!235/9:/4/A@<1A070E098 9<3;;?A/6<$<D;3?A0126/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6/1;/ 9:/3;;?A/6<316!=36/@E319<;3?A/6/39:<D9:/ 6/;/3A/678205012?@3409<9:/3;;?A/6<$:/4/D<4/ 9:/3;;?A/6 <! 74<?2:9 9:/ 3;;?A/6<$ 9< :0A :<?A/ 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 324//6 9< ;3?A/ 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 D<4 B:0;: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 324//6 9< @38
A"+ 3A ?@340 3=<?19 :/4/3D9/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ ;<EE/;9/6 01D<4=390<1 37<?9 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 <1 $&!# 316 :/ B3A 3E<12 B09: :0A ;<=@310<1A 39 3D34037:3A09?39/6<1?=3137364<363937<?9' 3= 9 9:39 90=/ 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < ! 316 * B/4/
- 6 -
@4/A/19 :/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 ! 235/ 01D<4=390<1 9< 3;;?A/6<$9:399:/6/;/3A/6B3A3,?>340-316:/B3A @/4D<4=012 @<<>3 01 60DD/4/19 50EE32/A 316 :/1;/ 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 01D<4=/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 !
9:39 :/ B<?E6740129:/6/;/3A/6A380129:39:/:36@<<>39<7/ @/4D<4=/601:0A:<?A/39:3:37363169:/4/3D9/4D010A:
<DD 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 1 $&!# 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 4/;/05/6 A!+ D4<= 3;;?A/6 < 3A @349 <D 9:/ ;<1A06/4390<1 <D ?@340 3=<?19 <D A"+ :/ 3;;?A/6 < 324//6 9< @38 4/=301012 3=<?19 <D
A+ 3D9/4 ;3?A012 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ 3;;?A/6 < ! 316 $ :39;:/6 3 @E31 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ A:<?E6 2< 9< 9:/ :<?A/ <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 4/C?/A9/6:0=9<;<=/9<:3:3736D<4@/4D<4=012@<<>3 019:/:<?A/<D9:/3;;?A/6<$A@/49:/A306@E31<1 !#&!#3937<?93=9:/3;;?A/6<$B/199< 3613EE0 50EE32/ 78 <9<4;8;E/ 316 :/ 3@@4<3;:/6 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 01 :0A :<?A/ 39 3613EE0 50EE32/ 316 4/C?/A9/6 9:/6/;/3A/6 9< @/4D<4= @<<>3 01:0A :<?A/39 :3:3736
- 7 -
<1!'&!#;;<46012E89:/3;;?A/6<$@3063A?= <D A+ 3A 36531;/ 316 4/=301012 3=<?19 <D
A#+B3A324//69<7/@3063D9/49:/@/4D<4=31;/<D @<<>3:/4/3D9/4<1!'&!#3937<?9*3=9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 $ 9< * B/19 9< 93G0 A9316 1/34 3E37?4320 098 ?A 9316 316 /1232/6 3 34 7/34012 4/20A94390<1 < +! 7/E<12/6 9< $+ :34313@@3 :3>31940 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ B/19 <1 <9<4;8;E/ 7/34012 < +!'%+"*!
316 4/3;:/6 8353==3/=@E/39#@=316235/01D<4=390<19< 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < & 9< * 9< A938 9:/4/ :/4/3D9/4 :/ 3E<1/B/19<1<9<4;8;E/9<3613EE050EE32/3163937<?9 # @= :/ 74<?2:9 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 <1 :0A <9<4;8;E/ :0E/ 2<012 9<B346A 362040 3D9/4 ;4<AA012 E0@?4 3163 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ A9<@@/6 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ 316 9:/4/3D9/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <& 316 ' ;3=/ <5/4 9< 9:/ A@<9 316 9:/8 9<2/9:/4 ;3?A/6 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 78 A94312?E390<1 902:9/1012 9:/ B04/ <1 9:/ 1/;F <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 D9/4 ;<1D04=012 9:/ 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 9:/8 @?9 9:/6/36 - 8 - 7<68 01 9:/ @09 316 9:/4/78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;<==099/69:/3EE/2/6<DD/1;/ # D9/4;<=@E/9012015/A902390<19:/;<=@E301319 <E0;/D0E/6;:342/A://932301A99:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A316 9:/;3A/B3A;<==099/6789:/E/341/6320A9439/9<9:/ 9403E<?49D<49403E;;<46012E89:/=399/4B3A93F/1?@ 7/D<4/9:/9403E<?49 " :/3;;?A/6<9<'B/4/<1730E6?40129:/ 9403E D9/4 ;<1A06/4012 9:/ =39/403EA <1 4/;<46 9:/ 9403E <?49 4/20A9/4/6 9:/ ;3A/ 32301A9 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 01 <$!":/;3A/32301A93;;?A/6<"316*B3AA@E09 ?@:/4/3D9/49:/3;;?A/6<"B3AA/;?4/6316:/1;/ 9:/ ;3A/ 01 <#*!" B3A 4/20A9/4/6 32301A9 :0= <9:9:/37<5/A306;3A/A34/93F/1?@9<2/9:/4D<49403E $ :/ ;:342/ B3A D43=/6 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <9<'D<49:/<DD/1;/A@?10A:37E/?16/4/;90<1# #&#'!+!!$#4/36B09:/;90<1#*<D :/ @4<A/;?90<1 /G3=01/6 !& B091/AA/A 3A 9< - 9 - !&316@4<6?;/6#*6<;?=/19A39GA9<#*:/ @4<A/;?90<13EA<@4<6?;/639/403E7>/;9A3A@/4 9< & D9/4;E<A012<D9://506/1;/<D@4<A/;?90<19:/ 9403E<?49/G3=01/69:/3;;?A/6<9<'?16/4/;90<1 <D 4 B:/4/01 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 6/10/6 9:/ /506/1;/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 B091/AA/A 3A D3EA/ ?9 9:/8 606 1<9;:<<A/9<@4<6?;/318<43E/506/1;/01A?@@<49<D9:/04 ;<19/190<1 <B/5/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 2<9 =34F/6 6<;?=/19A39 GA 9< 01 9:/ ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1<D 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 @4<A/;?90<1 B091/AA/A 01 A?@@<49 <D 9:/04 ;<19/190<1A@?9D<49:019:/6/D/1;/ ' D9/4:/340129:/342?=/19A<D7<9:9:/@3490/A 316 ;<1A06/4012 9:/ <43E 316 6<;?=/19348 /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 <1 4/;<46 9:/ 9403E <?49 :3A D<?16 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9< ' 1<9 2?0E98 <D 9:/ <DD/1;/A ;:342/6 32301A9 9:/= 316 9:/4/78 9:/8 B/4/ 3;C?099/6 <D 9:/ <DD/1;/A?16/49:/0=@?21/6>?62=/19 - 10 - * /012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ 0=@?21/6 >?62=/19 9:/@4<A/;?90<1:3A;<=/?@B09:9:/@4/A/193@@/3E:/ 24<?16A?42/6789:/E/341/666E939/?7E0;4<A/;?9<4 (D<4A:<49,9:/E/341/666E)34/9:399:/9403E<?49 :3A D30E/6 9< 3@@4/;039/ 9:/ /506/1;/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 9< @4<5/ 9:/ ;:301 <D ;04;?=A931;/A E/36012 9< 9:/ ;<==0AA0<1<D;40=/://506/1;/<D9:/A<1<D9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 " 9:/ ;04;?=A931903E B091/AA 0A 1<9 3@@4/;039/6789:/9403E<?49:<?2:9:/@4<A/;?90<1:3A A?;;/AAD?EE8@4<5/69:/=<905/9:399:/3;;?A/6<B3A :35012 0EE0;09 4/E390<1A:0@ B09: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 9:39 #:36A//1:0AB0D/9:/3;;?A/6<01;<=@4<=0A/ @<A090<1B09:9:/3;;?A/6<316940/69<;39;::<E6<D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < :/4/3D9/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < B:< 0A 63?2:9/4+01+E3B <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 E/D9 9:/ =3940=<103E :<?A/ 316 A9349/6 9< 4/A06/ B09: 9:/ @34/19A :<?A/ 316 9:399:/6/;/3A/6B3A31248B09:9:/3;;?A/6<316:/ 9<E69:39:/B<?E6D010A:<DD9:/3;;?A/6<31609B3A 9:/ =<905/ D<4 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19 :/ 9403E <?49 :3A - 11 - D30E/69<3@@4/;039/A?;:/506/1;/D<49:;<=012<14/;<46 :/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A A?;;/AAD?EE8 @4<5/6 9:/ ;<1A@043;8 3=<12 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9< ;3?A/ 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6:/;<1;/41/65/:0;E/A?A/6D<49:/;<==0AA0<1 <D 9:/ <DD/1;/ B/4/ A/0H/6 316 @4<6?;/6 01 9:/ ;3A/ 4 //@3F ?191<<4/ ;<16?;9/6 @<A9 =<49/= <D 9:/6/367<68<D9:/6/;/3A/6:/3@@4<3;:<D9:/9403E <?499<9://506/1;/<D0A1<9@4<@/43169:/4/78 9:/9403E<?49:3AB4<12E8;<=/9<9:/;<1;E?A0<19:399:/ 6/36 7<68 4/;<5/4/6 B3A 1<9 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ 9403E <?49 B3A B4<12 01 3;C?099012 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 78 ;<1A06/4012 =01<4 ;<194360;90<1A 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 :/9403E <?49 A:<?E6 :35/ A//1 9:/ <5/43EE ;<1;E?A0<1 <D 9:/
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
/346 9:/ E/341/6 66E 316 3EA< 9:/ E/341/6;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A@/4?A/69:/<43E 3166<;?=/19348/506/1;/D<49:;<=012<14/;<46 - 14 - <B9:/@<0199:39340A/AD<49:/;<1A06/4390<1 <D9:0A<?490A9:39 :/9:/4 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A =36/ <?9 318 24<?16 9< A:<B 9:39 9:/ 9403E <?49 :3A ;<==099/6 31 /44<4 01 3;C?099012 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A <D 9:/ <DD/1;/ ;:342/6 32301A99:/=019:/;3A/3169:/4/789:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A =36/ <?9 318 24<?16 9< 019/4D/4/ B09: 9:/ 0=@?21/6 >?62=/19 <D 9:/9403E <?49 39 9:/ :316A <D9:0A <?49 019:/3@@/3E3AA<?2:9D<4I # :/ 342?=/19 <D 9:/ E/341/6 66E 0A 9:39 9:/ 9403E <?49 :3A D30E/6 9< 3@@4/;039/ 9:/ D3;9 9:39 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 78 09A /506/1;/ :3A @4<5/6 ;:301 <D ;04;?=A931;/A E/36012 9< ;<==0AA0<1 <D ;40=/ 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A :/ 9403E <?49 :3A D30E/6 9< 3@@4/;039/ 9://506/1;/<DB:<0AA<1<D9:/6/;/3A/6316" B:< 0A ;04;?=A931903E B091/AA 4<= 9:/04 /506/1;/ 09 B<?E67/;E/349:399:/3;;?A/6<$9<<F9:/6/;/3A/6<1 :0A <9<4;8;E/ <1 9:/ @4/9/G9 <D @/4D<4=012 @<<>3 01 :0A - 15 - :<?A/ 316 9:/4/3D9/4 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B3A 93F/1 01 160;3 34 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 9< ' 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;3?A/66/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6 " 90A3EA<9:/342?=/19<D9:/E/341/666E 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < B:< 0A 63?2:9/4+01+E3B <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 01 <46/4 9< :06/ :/4 2?0E9 <D :35012 0EE0;09 4/E390<1A:0@ B09: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 6/;06/69<;3?A/6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/63A9:/6/;/3A/6 ;3=/9<F1<B37<?99:/0EE0;094/E390<1A:0@<D9:/3;;?A/6 < 316 316 9:39 :/ B<?E6 F0EE 9:/= :/4/ 0A ;04;?=A931903E/506/1;/9<@4<5/9:399:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A ;<1A@04/69<2/9:/4316;3?A/66/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6316 9:/A?@340B3A205/1789:/3;;?A/6<9<9:/3;;?A/6 <$ :/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A @4<5/6 9:/ =<905/ D<4 9:/ ;<==0AA0<1<D9:/<DD/1;/3163EA<9:/;<1A@043;83=<12 9:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A9<;3?A/6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A @4<5/6 9:/ E3A9 A//1 9:/<48 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ B3A D<?16 93F012 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 <1 :0A <9<4;8;E/ - 16 - $ :/ 342?=/19 <D 9:/ E/341/6 66E 0A 3EA< 9:39 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A @4<5/6 9:/ 06/19098 <D 9:/ 6/36 7<689:4<?2:=/60;3E/506/1;/:/3@@4<3;:<D9:/9403E <?499<9://506/1;/<D316!"0A1<9@4<@/4316 09:3AB4<12E8;<=/9<9:/;<1;E?A0<19:399:/6/367<68 4/;<5/4/6 B3A 1<9 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ 9403E <?49 0A B4<12013;C?0990129:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A;<1A06/4012=01<4 60A;4/@31;0/A 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 :/ 9403E <?49 A:<?E6 :35/ A//1 9:/ <5/43EE ;<1;E?A0<1 <D 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 /506/1;/ B:0;: @<019A <?9 9<B346A 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:39 9:/8 ;<==099/6 9:/ ;40=/ /1;/ 9:/ A?7=0AA0<1 <D 9:/ E/341/6 66E 0A 9:39 50/B/6 D4<=318312E/9:/0=@?21/6>?62=/19<D9:/9403E<?49 0A0EE<20;3E?1A?A930137E/316;<1943489<9:/D3;9A316E3B 316 9:/4/D<4/ 9:/ 66E :3A @438/6 D<4 3EE<B012 9:/ 3@@/3E3169:/4/789<A/93A06/9:/>?62=/19<D9:/9403E <?494/23460123;C?0993E<D9:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A & 19:/<9:/4:3169:/E/341/6;<?1A/ED<49:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A :3A 342?/6 9:39 9:/ 9403E <?49 :3A - 17 - @4<@/4E8 3@@4/;039/6 9:/ <43E 316 6<;?=/19348 /506/1;/ 3530E37E/<14/;<4601@4<@/4@/4A@/;905/316;<=/9<9:/ ;<1;E?A0<19:399:/4/34/60A;4/@31;0/A316;<194360;90<1A 01 9:/ /506/1;/ 316 :/1;/ 9:/ 9403E <?49 :3A 402:9E8 3;C?099/69:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A?16/40=@?21/6>?62=/19 :/4/D<4/ 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A :3A@438/6D<460A=0AA3E<D9:/3@@/3E ' 9 9:/ 5/48 <?9A/9 09 0A @/4901/19 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9: 506/1;/<D@4<A/;?90<14/A9A<1;04;?=A931903E /506/1;/ 5/1 9:<?2: 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A @?9 D<49: 9:/ E3A9 A//1 9:/<48 9:39 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B3A D<?16 B09: 9:/ 3;;?A/6<$2<012<1<9<4;8;E/7/D<4/:0A6/39:D<49:/ E3A9 90=/ 78 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 B091/AA/A 09 0A @/4901/19
9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/ ;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 0A 1<9 73A/6 <1 604/;9 /506/1;/ 7?9 <1 ;04;?=A931903E /506/1;/ /1;/ 3A A?7=099/6789:/E/341/6;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A ?1E/AA 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 @4<5/A 7/8<16 4/3A<137E/ 6<?79 9://5/48E01F019:/;:301<D;04;?=A931;/AB:0;:B<?E6 @<019 <?9 9<B346A 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:39 9:/8 - 18 - ;<==099/69:/<DD/1;/A3A3EE/2/6789:/@4<A/;?90<11< ;3A/;317/=36/<?932301A99:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1AD<49:/ <DD/1;/A ;:342/6 316 9:/8 ;311<9 7/ ;<150;9/6 D<4 318 A?;: <DD/1;/ 1 9:0A 73;F24<?16 09 0A 4/E/5319 9< 3@@4/;039/ 9:/ <43E 316 6<;?=/19348 /506/1;/ D<49: ;<=012<14/;<46 * 9 0A 1<9 01 60A@?9/ 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 0A 63?2:9/4+01+E3B <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 0/ A:/ 0A B0D/ <D # :34313@@3B:<0A<1/<D9:/A<1A<D9:/6/;/3A/6:/ =<905/ D<4 9:/ <DD/1;/ ;:342/6 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 0A 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 :36 0EE0;09 4/E390<1A:0@ 316 9:/ A306 D3;9 ;3=/ 9< 9:/ F1<BE/62/ <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 <1 D/34 9:39 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B<?E6 F0EE 3;;?A/6<3169:/3;;?A/6<:39;:/69:/@E31<D ;3?A012 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 ;<1A@04012 B09: <9:/4 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A /A@/;03EE8 B09: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 316 235/ A?@340 9< 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 316 9:/4/78 3E<12 B09: <9:/43;;?A/6@/4A<1A9:/3;;?A/6<316;3?A/69:/ 6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6 - 19 - ! <B/5/4 39 9:/ 010903E A932/ 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 B3A A/9 019< =<90<1 <1 9:/ ;<=@E3019 <D 3=3113 B:< 0A <1/ <D 9:/ A<1A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B:< 235/ ;<=@E30199<9:/@<E0;/9:39:0AD39:/49:/6/;/3A/6B3A =0AA012A01;/!'!#90A@/4901/199<1<9/9:399:/ ;<=@E3019 39 G <D B3A 205/1 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ <1 '!# 0/ 3D9/4 D<?4 638A D4<= 9:/ 639/ <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6B3A=0AA012A@/49://506/1;/<D37<?9 8/34316=<19:A32<3A<19:/639/<D:0A/506/1;/ :0A D39:/4 B3A =0AA012 / 3E<12 B09: :0A 74<9:/4A 316 <9:/4 @/4A<1A A/34;:/6 D<4 :0A D39:/4 316 :/ /1C?04/6
"+3EE0F34>?13$+34/@@3316&+:3193@@3316 9:/89<E6:0=9:3937<8<D37<?9!"8/34A9<<F:0AD39:/4 <1 3 <9<4;8;E/ D<4 @/4D<4=012 @<<>3 01 9:/ :<?A/ 01 :3:3736:/4/3D9/4:/235/;<=@E30199<9:/@<E0;/3A @/4 G 9 9:39 90=/ :/ 3EA< 235/ @:<9< 9< 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 39 G! 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ 1 9:/ ;<=@E3019 39 G<1E8=0AA012;3A/B3A4/20A9/4/6
- 20 -
! <B/5/4 :3A D?49:/4 6/@<A/6 9:39 3D9/4 =0AA012 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! ;3=/ 9< :0A 50EE32/3169<E6&/53@@3B:89:/8B/4/A/34;:012 D<49:/6/;/3A/63169:39:/3E<12B09:9:/3;;?A/6< 3163163EA<<9:/43;;?A/6@/4A<1A;3?A/66/39:<D9:/ 6/;/3A/6 /1;/ 9:/4/3D9/4 :0A /E6/4 74<9:/4 !
:34313@@3B/199<9:/@<E0;/A9390<1316235/;<=@E3019 :/4/3D9/4 B3A ;3EE/6 9< 3632040 @<E0;/ 316 39 9:/ 90=/9:/3;;?A/6<9<E69:/@<E0;/9:39:/B<?E6A:<B 9:/ @E3;/ <D 7?403E <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 9:/4/78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9<<F :0= 3E<12 B09: 9:/ @<E0;/ 9<
@E<31 50EE32/316A:<B/69:/@E3;/1/341//=94//
!! 90A3EA<9://506/1;/<D9:39399:3990=/ 9:/ AA0A9319 <==0AA0<1/4 ;3=/ 9< 9:/ A@<9 316 01 :0A @4/A/1;/ 9:/ 6/36 7<68 B3A 93F/1 <?9 D4<= 9:/ 7?40/6 @E3;/ 316 :/ 06/190D0/6 9:/ 6/36 7<68 3A <D :0A D39:/4 :/4/B/4/A:049?6?63433163EA<6?2<19:/1/;FB/4/ D<?16<19:/6/367<68@:<9<AB/4/93F/1399:3990=/ 3A @/4 GA 9< " / 06/190D0/6 9:/ A306 A:049 316
- 21 -
?6?6343 3A 7/E<12012 9< :0A D39:/4 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 A3=/ 34/ =34F/6 39 9< D9/4 ! =<19:A <D 4/;<5/48<D9:/6/367<689:/@<E0;/A:<B/6:0=A0E5/4 F36323A 316 :/ 06/190D0/6 9:/ A3=/ 3A 7/E<12012 9< :0A D39:/4316A3=/34/=34F/639#9<$
! /2346012 9:/ =<905/ D<4 ;3?A012 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6789:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A9://506/1;/<D01 :0A;:0/D/G3=01390<10A9:39
! "
#
$
%
&
'
()
*&
+,%
-./ $)
0
)
0
1 2 3)
! " %
(&
4)
! " 5
67 8&(9)
! "%
:) (,+ 8&
9
2 3)
! " %
& 5&
! (;
(7 # 7&
9
%
< & 4
%
%
(&
#
6
'= )(>
, # 7&
90
2 %
<
? )(>
,
5
# &
' (
%< @&
%
& &(>
! " #A&
9 & (
(,7
%
&
'
(8&
9? %
<&B
- 22 -
!# :/ :3A 3EA< 6/@<A/6 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <316!34/4/E3905/A9:/3;;?A/6<#0A;<?A01<D9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <" 0A D39:/4 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < ?;: 4/E390<1A:0@ 3=<12 9:<A/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A0A1<960A@?9/6789:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A<B/5/4 3A A?7=099/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A0D9://506/1;/<D0A93F/19<;<1A06/4390<1 09 B<?E6 7/ ;E/34 9:39 9:/ ;3A/ 4/20A9/4/6 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:39 9:/8 ;3?A/6 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B3A <1E8 <1 9:/ 73A0A <D 9:/ A<+;3EE/6 /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1<D9:/3;;?A/6<!7/D<4/&/53@@3
!" ;9?3EE8 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 B3A A/9 019< =<90<1 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A D<4 9:/ <DD/1;/ @?10A:37E/ ?16/4/;90<1!<D3E<12B09:<9:/4<DD/1;/A<19:/ ;<=@E3019<D!/1;/9://506/1;/<D!316& 3E<12 B09: 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 ;04;?=A931903E B091/AA/A D<49:;<=012<14/;<460A5/48=?;:=39/403E9<@4<5/9:/ ;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 :/4/D<4/ D<4 3@@4/;039012 9:/ /506/1;/ <D 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 B091/AA/A 09 0A 1/;/AA348 9<
- 23 -
;<1A06/4 9:/ 015/A902390<1 6<1/ 78 9:/ @<E0;/ 01 9:/ ;3A/ <1:316
!$ !
:34313@@3 0A /G3=01/6 3A # A =/190<1/6 :/4/01 37<5/ 09 0A ?160A@?9/6 D3;9 9:39 :/ 0A <1/<D9:/A<1A<D9:/6/;/3A/63169:/3;;?A/6<0A B0D/ <D # 1 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D /G3=01390<1 09A/ED #:3A6/@<A/69:39:/F1/B9:39:0AB0D/9:/3;;?A/6 <B3A:350120EE0;094/E390<1A:0@B09:9:/3;;?A/6< 7<?9 # =<19:A /34E0/4 9< 9:/6/39:<D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ A3B 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 01 AE//@012 9<2/9:/4 01 ;<=@4<=0A/ @<A090<1 01 :0A :<?A/ 316 9:/4/3D9/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 431 3B38 D4<= 9:/ A@<9 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <B/199<:/4@34/19A.:<?A/?7A/C?/19E8:/;3=/ 9< F1<B 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < B3A 4/A06012 B09: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 01 3E37?4320 ?9 3A A?7=099/6 78 9:/ E/341/6;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A090A5/48A94312/ 1<9/9:39/5/19:<?2:9:/#0A:?A7316<D9:/3;;?A/6 <316:/;3=/9<F1<B9:39:0AB0D/9:/3;;?A/6< B3A :35012 0EE0;09 4/E390<1A:0@ B09: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < :/
- 24 -
:361<993F/1318A9/@A32301A99:/3;;?A/6<D<49:/ @/40<6 <D # =<19:A /1;/ 9:/ 3EE/2/6 =<905/ 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6<316!B/4/:350120EE0;094/E390<1A:0@3169:39 9:/A306D3;9B3A;3=/9<9:/F1<BE/62/<D9:/6/;/3A/6 316 9:/4/78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 3E<12 B09: <9:/4 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;<1A@04/6 B09: /3;: <9:/4 9< ;3?A/ 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B<?E6 ;4/39/ 6<?79 01 9:/ =016 <D 9:/ <?49 :/4/D<4/ ?1E/AA 9:/4/ 0A ;<2/19 /506/1;/ 9< @4<5/ 7/8<164/3A<137E/6<?799:/=<905/3163EA</5/48E01F01 9:/;:301<D;04;?=A931;/A1<;3A/;317/=36/32301A9 9:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1AD<49:/<DD/1;/A;:342/632301A99:/= 019:/;3A/
!& #! 3EE0F34>?1 3:36/53@@3 3@@01 0A 9:/ 9:/1 <D 9:/ ;<=@E301319 <E0;/ 9390<1 / :3A 7//1 /G3=01/6 3A ! A @/4 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ! <1 '!#3937<?9"@=B:/1:/B3A019:/@<E0;/ A9390<1 3=3113;3=/9<9:/@<E0;/A9390<1316235/ ;<=@E301939G316<19:/73A0A<DA306;<=@E3019:/ 4/20A9/4/6 =0AA012 ;3A/ 01 40=/ <'!!# 1 9:/
- 25 -
1/G9 638 0/ <1 #'!# :/ 50A09/6 :<?A/ <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6013613EE050EE32/31664/BA@<9@31;:313=339 G$ 01 9:/ @4/A/1;/ <D ! 316 # A @/4 9:/ 6<;?=/19 39 G$ 9:/ A@<9 B3A A:<B1 9< :0= 78
3=3113
!' 9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ! 01 :0A ;:0/D+ /G3=01390<1 9:39 <1 9:/ A3=/ 638 :/ 4/;<46/6 9:/ A939/=/19 <D #+:34313@@3 "+3EE0F34>?13 316 $+343@@3:/4/3D9/4<1&'!#316'!# :/6/@?9/69:/;<1;/41/6A93DDD<4A/34;:0129:/=0AA012 0643=3@@3 3=@01 :/ ! :3A 3EA< 6/@<A/6 01 :0A /506/1;/01;:0/D+/G3=01390<19:39<1#*!#3937<?9 * 3= # ;3=/ 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ A9390<1 316 235/ ;<=@E301939G*316<19:/73A0A<D9:/A306;<=@E3019 :/=/190<1/69:/<DD/1;/A@?10A:37E/?16/4/;90<1A# #&#'!!$#316 B/;90<1#*<D9< 9:/ ;3A/ 4/20A9/4/6 01 40=/ <'!!!# 316 A?7=099/6 9:/4/@<499<9:/;<1;/41/6320A9439/:/A3064/@<490A =34F/639G$
- 26 -
!* 4<= 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ! 09 0A @/4901/19 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/ ;3A/ 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A B3A 3;9?3EE8A/9019<=<90<1<1#*!#0/3D9/4=<4/9:31 <1/=<19:D4<=9:/639/<D=0AA012<D9:/6/;/3A/6 :3AA939/601:0A/506/1;/9:393A9:/;3A/4/20A9/4/6B3A D<4 2435/<DD/1;/A 9:/ D?49:/4 015/A902390<1 B3A6<1/ 78 #+3E3;:31643 3FF3= 9:/ 9:/1 :/ D?49:/4 /506/1;/ <D ! 01 ;:0/D+/G3=01390<1 0A 4/2346012 :0A 3AA0A931;/ 9< # 01 9:/ 015/A902390<1 <D 9:/ ;3A/ :/4/D<4/ /34E0/4 9< ;<1A06/4012 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ! D?49:/4090A1/;/AA3489<;<1A06/49://506/1;/<D# 9:/9:/1B:<3EE/2/6;<16?;9/69:/015/A902390<1
#:3A7//1/G3=01/63A!":/!" :3A 6/@<A/6 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01;:0/D+/G3=01390<1 9:39 <1
"*!!# :/ 9<<F ?@ D?49:/4 015/A902390<1 <D 9:/ ;3A/ D4<= !
316 <1 9:/ A3=/ 638 :/ 50A09/6 3613EE0 0EE32/3164/;<46/69:/A939/=/19A<D"3EE0F34>?13 $+34/@@3 316 &+:3193883 / <43EE8 604/;9/6 !D<43@@4/:/160129:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A019:/;3A/
- 27 -
A@/49:/@4<A/;?90<1;3A/"3EE0F34>?13 $+34/@@3 316 &+:3193883 34/ 3EE/2/6 9< 7/ 9:/ B091/AA/AB:<A3B9:/6/;/3A/6D<49:/E3A990=/B09:9:/ @/4A<1 <D 9:/ 32/ <D 37<?9 !" 8/34A A @/4 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 ;3A/ 9:<A/ @/4A<1A 9<E6 9:39 3 7<8 <D 37<?9 !" 8/34A 9<<F 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 <1 3 <9<4;8;E/ D<4 @/4D<4=012 @<<>3 39 :3:3736 :/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A 1<9 /G3=01/6$316&<B/5/4"3EE0F34>?13:3A 7//1/G3=01/6789:/@4<A/;?90<1
! A @/4 9:/ /506/1;/ <D
" 01 ;:0/D+ /G3=01390<1 37<?9 8/34 316 =<19:A 32< 3A <1 9:/ 639/ <D 4/;<46012 <D :0A /506/1;/ <1 !*!" :/ A3B 9:/6/;/3A/6D<49:/E3A990=/:/4/3D9/4:/6061<9A// 9:/6/;/3A/6:/4/E/5319@<490<1019://506/1;/<D" 4/36A9:?A (
C
! "D &
E (% 8
F
5
#
(
&
)
8 GH
' &
&(>
! " # ? ) # &
&
; #
)
G(
:
'= '
- 28 -
&(>
! "# %
8
(!(
& (
*&(>
! "# %
3)@5)#
I
*&(7 A&
* )
&(>
! " # %
#(J(&
5 K&
($ !
L( (
M
>
, # )
$<
@&
#A&
B
9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D " 9:39 3D9/4 =<19:A 9:/ @<E0;/ A:<B 9:/ A306 7<8 39 3632040 04;E/ 1A@/;9<4.ADD0;/316:/06/190D0/69:/A3067<8:/" 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D+ /G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 4/234601206/190D0;390<1<D9:/A3067<87/D<4/9:/<?493A 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ " 3EA< 06/190D0/6 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ 01 B:0;: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ B3A 3EE/2/6 9<<F 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 3169:/A306<9<4;8;E/0A2<9=34F/639*019:/;:0/D+ /G3=01390<1<D"
# :/ E/341/6 66E :3A 4/E0/6 =?;: <1 9:/ /506/1;/<D"316A?7=099/69:399:/"0A9:/@/4A<1 B:<A3B9:/6/;/3A/6B09:9:/3;;?A/6<$D<49:/E3A9 90=//1;/<19:/73A0A<DE3A9A//19:/<489:/E/341/6
- 29 -
66E:3A940/69<;<11/;99:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A9<9:/ 6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/60150/B<D9://506/1;/<D"
" <B/5/4 9:/ A?7=0AA0<1 <D 9:/ E/341/6;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A0A9:390D393EE9:/
"3AF/69:/3;;?A/6<$399:/4/E/531990=/B:/1:/ A3B9:/6/;/3A/6D<49:/E3A990=/B09:9:/3;;?A/6<$ :/ ;<?E6 :35/ /1C?04/6 9:/ 13=/ <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ ?99:/4/0A37A<E?9/E81</506/1;/D<49:;<=012D4<=" 9<A:<B9:39:/9<E631806/190D0;390<1A<D9:/@/4A<1B:< 0A 3EE/2/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 7/D<4/ 9:/ @<E0;/ B:/1 :/ 235/318A939/=/197/D<4/9:/!"
$ <4/<5/4/G;/@9A9390129:399:/<9<4;8;E/01 B:0;:9:/6/;/3A/6B3A93F/1789:/3;;?A/6<$B3A <D4/6;<E<?49:/4/0A1<<9:/406/190D0;390<1=/190<1/678
" 9< @4<5/ 9:39 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ 39 0A 9:/ A3=/ <9<4;8;E/ 01 B:0;: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ B3A 3EE/2/6E8 9<<F 9:/6/;/3A/6399:/4/E/531990=/
- 30 -
& ?49:/43A @<019/6 <?978 9:/E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A " 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<1:3A6/@<A/69:39
N./
O
M&
#
)
P&(>
! "#
%
! &
G(
:
'= ' &
# &
B @&
(
! 5
& #A
C 36
(
! 5 Q(R
5 )
%
S8&()
! 5= Q(R
5 %
< ! 5
#
%(7 J
(
@
56D
C%
&
M'=@
T! H U;
5 8&
%
?&( C %
IM
5
$<
' 9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D " 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<19:39
C 36
(
! 5
Q(R
5 )
%
S8&()
! 5= Q(R
5
%
< ! 5
#
%(7 J
(
@
56D
C %
&
M'= @
T!
H U;
5 8&
%
?&( C
- 31 -
%
IM
5
$<
3
4
V # C %
(
WM
5 8
3 C
8&
9+,% & WM)(+X#0
6(
&()
.J(;
(
C 8
B
* <B/5/4":3AD?49:/46/@<A/69:39:/A3B 9:/3;;?A/6<$019:/<?4937<?9!9<90=/A/34E0/49< :0A 06/190D8012 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 7/D<4/ 9:/ <?49 3A 9:/ @/4A<1E3A9A//1B09:9:/6/;/3A/6<4/<5/4?1E/AA9:/
" F1/B 318 <9:/4 06/190D0;390<1 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ /G;/@99:/3@@4<G0=39/32/<D9:/@/4A<1B:<B3AA//1 D<49:/E3A990=/B09:9:/6/;/3A/69://506/1;/<D" ;311<97/93F/1D<4;<1A06/4390<19<;<11/;99:/3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9< 9:/ 3EE/2/6 ;40=/ 316 9:/4/78 ;<=/ 9< 9:/ ;<1;E?A0<1 9:39 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A @4<5/6 7/8<16 4/3A<137E/ 6<?799:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;3?A/6 6/39: <D9:/6/;/3A/63A3EE/2/6789:/@4<A/;?90<1
# :/ /506/1;/ <D !" 0A 3EA< 9:39 <1
"*!!# 09A/ED :/ <43EE8 604/;9/6 9:/ ! - 32 -
3EE0F34>?13 9< 3@@4/:/16 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;;<46012E8 <1 9:/ 1/G9 638 0/ <1 $*!!# ! 344/A9/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 ! D4<= 3E37?4320 316 @4<6?;/69:/=7/D<4/:0=//1C?04/69:/3;;?A/6< 316!3169:/8235/5<E?19348A939/=/19A7/D<4/:0=A @/4 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !" 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 01 :0A A939/=/19:3AA939/69:39
Y%
, 0
&
G(
:
'=
@.N Z.
[/N
%
< &(>
! "
'
(8
\] #(+&
9 L()
L %) &
% ;
%<B @&
#A& &
; #A J^() ) 3 _, )
$
'(`%
%
<
&
; #A) ? 2
S
3 _a@b)
%
<
S 3 _acb))
$
'(`%
&4
2
?&
9 @
=)
0
d0
d K&
J:'= ! 1
(& 1
&(>
%
<
_J( ? X e < (8 3 E ! 1
( & %
( &
;
J:'=
)()
'
(E,)
$
'(7&B
- 33 -
# :/A306@<490<1<DA939/=/190A2<9=34F/639 G*AA?7=099/6789:/E/341/666E3A@/49:/ A939/=/1939G*<D9:/3;;?A/6<<1/=<70E/B09: 9B<A0=AB3A4/;<5/4/6D4<=9:/3;;?A/6<3A@/49:/ @31;:313=339G&019:/@4/A/1;/<D+:31643=3 316*+373113:/A306=<70E/0A@4<6?;/639&
#! 19:/A3=/63839@=!"A/;?4/6 +06:343=3 /6683E0@390E316&31?=319:33A @31;:3A 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9<<F :0= 3E<12 B09:
@31;:3A 9<
@3E<31 50EE32/ 316 1/34 9:/ :0EE 39 3 1//= 94// 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < A:<B/6 9:/ A@<9A B:/4/01 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 3EE/2/6E8 7?40/6 6/36 7<68 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6;;<46012E8:/64/B@31;:313=339G01 9:/@4/A/1;/<D316&3163EA<@4/@34/6AF/9;: 39G(7)
# :/ !" :3A 3EA< 6/@<A/6 9:39 :/ A/;?4/6 @4/A/1;/ <D ?7+050A0<13E 320A9439/AA0A9319 <==0AA0<1/4 316 9:/ 6<;9<4 9:4<?2: !!
E03A :=/6
- 34 -
316B09:9:/:/E@<D;<<E0/!#+ 3A:0139:9:/A@<9B3A 2<96?23169:/6/367<68<D9:/6/;/3A/6B3A93F/1<?9 9 9:39 90=/ 9:/4/ B3A <1/ @E3A90; 9:4/36 D<?16 34<?16 9:/1/;F<D9:/6/367<68316A3=/B3AA/0H/6316 # 06/190D0/6 9:/ 6/36 7<68 3A 9:39 <D 9:/04 D39:/4 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 9 9:/ A@<9 !! 64/B @31;:313=3 :/4/3D9/4 9:/ 6/36 7<68 B3A A/19 9< <5/41=/19 <A@093E 3E37?4320D<4@<A9=<49/=
## :/ !" :3A 3EA< 6/@<A/6 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <A:<B/69:/A@<91/34789:/A94/3=3169<E69:399:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A :36 9:4<B1 9:/ A:3BE <1/ A90;F 316 ;:3@@3EA <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 019< 9:/ B39/4 01 9:/ A94/3= /1;/ B09: 9:/ :/E@ <D 9:/ A93DD 316 01 9:/ @4/A/1;/ <D @31;:3A&316!:/A/34;:/6D<49:<A/@4<@/490/A 7?9 9:/8 B/4/ 1<9 D<?16 :/ @31;:313=3 G B3A 643B1399:/A@<9://506/1;/<D!"0A9:39<19:/ A3=/638:/4/;<46/69:/A939/=/19A<D!#316& ?163@@39:/<B1/4<D9:/;<1;/41/6E316<B/5/43A @<019/6 <?9 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6
- 35 -
@/4A<1A&6/10/69:39:/235/318A939/=/197/D<4/ 9:/3A@/4G!*
#" :/ !" :3A 3EA< 6/@<A/6 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D /G3=01390<1 9:39 9:/4/3D9/4 <1 9:/ A38 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9:39 :/ B<?E6 @4<6?;/ 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ :/ 3E<12B09:9:/@31;:3A316&B/199<9:/:<?A/ <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < A:<B/6 3 <9<4;8;E/ 7/34012 < ++'" /1;/ 01 9:/ @4/A/1;/ <D 9:/ 37<5/ A306 @31;:3A !" 64/B @31;:313=339G#316A/0H/69:/A306<9<4;8;E/1 9:/1/G96380/<1&*!#9:/3;;?A/6<316!
B/4/ @4<6?;/6 7/D<4/ 9:/ <?49 316 <1 9:/ A3=/ 638 !" 4/;<46/6 9:/ A939/=/19A <D + 3=3113 "+ /53@@3 $+:053==3 316 '+/53@@3 1 9:39 638 :/ 2<9 93F/1 506/< <D 9:/ A@<9 9:4<?2: 9:/ A93DD '+:31643A:/F:34 1 9:/ A3=/ 638 :/ A/0H/6 9:/ @4<@/490/A 39 9< @4<6?;/6 7/D<4/ :0= 78 9:/ A93DD!+3>/1643B:<;<EE/;9/69:/A3=/399:/90=/ <D @<A9 =<49/= /G3=01390<1 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 9:<A/
- 36 -
@4<@/490/AB/4/A/0H/63A@/49:/@31;:313=339G 01 9:/ @4/A/1;/ <D +:319:3 /668 316 $ 3EE3883
#$ !#+ 3A:0139: 0A 3EE/2/6 9< 7/ 3 ;<<E0/ B09: B:<A/:/E@9:/@E3;/<D7?403EB3A6?23169:/6/367<68 B3A4/=<5/6:/!#:3A6/@<A/601:0A/506/1;/9:39 37<?98/3432<3A<19:/639/<D:0A/506/1;/3937<?9 #" @= :/ B3A 9<E6 78 9:/ @<E0;/ 9< 602 9:/ A@<9 B:/4/019:/6/367<68B3A7?40/6:/1:/B3A6022012 9:/A@<99:/7<1/A<DGB/4/D<?163169:/4/3D9/4<1/ 6/36 7<68 B3A D<?16 7?9 B/ 606 1<9 F1<B 3A 9< B:<A/ 6/36 7<68 B3A D<?16 <?9 /1;/ 9:/4/ 0A 1< /506/1;/ D4<= !# 9:39 :/ 235/ 318 A939/=/19 7/D<4/ 9:/ 4/23460129:/;3A/<4/<5/4!#6061<906/190D89:/ 6/367<683A9:39<D9:/6/;/3A/6:/4/D<4//5/10D090A 3;;/@9/63A94?9:9:399:/6/367<68B3A4/=<5/6399:/ A@<9 ?1E/AA 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 @4<5/A 9:39 9:/ A306 6/36 7<68 0A <D9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;3?A/6 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !# 6</A 1<9
- 37 -
=/409 ;<1A06/4390<1 9< =3F/ <?9 318 ;3A/ 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1D<49:/<DD/1;/A;:342/6
#& +:31643=30A3EE/2/69<7/9:/399/A9<49< 9:/@31;:313=339G&4/2346012A/0H?4/<D9:/=<70E/ @:<1/39&A@/4:0A/506/1;/9:/@<E0;/;3EE/6:0= 9<DD0;/393632040316399:3990=/9:/3;;?A/6< B3A @4/A/19 316 :/ @4<6?;/6 9:/ =<70E/ @:<1/ 39 316399:3990=/9:/@<E0;/64/B@31;:313=339G&9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D 9:39 3D9/4 # 638A 9:/ @<E0;/ 32301;3EE/6:0=9<9:/DD0;/393632040316399:39 90=/ 9:/ 3;;?A/6<# B3A @4/A/19 316 :/ @4<6?;/6 9:/ =<70E/@:<1/31609B3AA/0H/6019:/@4/A/1;/<D3A @/4 9:/ @31;:313=3 39 G' :/ =<70E/ @:<1/ 3EE/2/6 9<:35/7//1@4<6?;/6789:/3;;?A/6<#0A=34F/63A '
#' DA?;:/506/1;/<D0A;<1A06/4/609B<?E6 7/ ;E/34 9:39 /5/1 9:<?2: :/ :3A 6/@<A/6 4/2346012 A/0H?4/ <D 9:/ =<70E/ @:<1/A 39 & 316 ' D4<= 9:/
- 38 -
@<AA/AA0<1<D3;;?A/6<316#3A@/49:/@31;:313=3A 39GA&316'4/A@/;905/E83A@/49://506/1;/<D# 9:<A/=<70E/@:<1/AB/4/A/0H/6789:/@<E0;/019:/<DD0;/ <D9:/:/4/D<4/9://506/1;/!"0A1<9A?@@<49/6 789://506/1;/<DB:<0A<1/<D9:/@31;:3A9<9:/ @31;:313=3A 39 GA& 316 ' 4/2346012 A/0H?4/ <D 9:/ =<70E/@:<1/A39&316'4/A@/;905/E8
#* ?49:/4 01 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1 :3A6/@<A/69:39
&
;
(E
%
<[? *)
0
J:'=
f ?%
< @&
) #0
5, )
46 (
(' '$<6
&
;
(E
%
< [ ? *)
0
'
3
#
?5
'(7& @&
) #0
5, )
46
(E
%
< [,
#PIH )
%
?
46B
" A A?7=099/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1A0D9:/37<5/4/D/44/6/506/1;/<D0A ;<1A06/4/6 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< =39/403E D<49:;<=012 D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< ;<11/;9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9<
- 39 -
9:/ =<70E/ @:<1/A 39 & 316 ' 9< ;<=/ 9< 9:/ ;<1;E?A0<1 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 34/ 01 318 B38 ;<1;/41/6B09:9:/6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6
" :/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A 1<9 /G3=01/6 :319: /668B:<0A3EE/2/69<7/<1/<D9:/@31;:3A9< 9:/ @31;:313=3 39 G $+3EE3883 0A 31<9:/4 399/A9<4 9< 9:/ @31;:313=3 39 G :/ /506/1;/ <D $ 01 :0A ;:0/D+/G3=01390<1 0A 9:39 37<?9 8/34 ! =<19:A 32< 3A <1 9:/ 639/ <D :0A /506/1;/ 7/D<4/ 9:/ <?49 :/ B3A ;3EE/6 9< 3632040 ?43E <E0;/ 9390<1 316 @<E0;/A/0H/69<:/@31;:313=33A@/4G B3A643B1:0A/506/1;/<D$01;:0/D/G3=01390<13A A?7=099/6789:/E/341/6;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A D3EA0D0/A9://506/1;/<D!"9:399:/@4<@/490/A39 9<B/4/A/0H/6399:/3EE/2/6A@<9<D7?403E@E3;/<D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 01 9:/ @4/A/1;/ <D @31;:3A 3A @/4 G /1;/ 3A A?7=099/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A D30E/6 9< @4<5/ 9:/ A/0H?4/ <D 9:/ @4<@/490/A 39 9< 3A @/4 9:/
- 40 -
@31;:313=3GB09:9:/A?@@<49<D318016/@/16/19 B091/AA/A
"! :/!":3A6/@<A/601:0A/506/1;/01;:0/D /G3=01390<1 9:39 <1 *!!# 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 # B/4/ 344/A9/6 316 @4<6?;/6 78 !
7/D<4/ :0= B09:
4/@<49 / /1C?04/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 # 316 9:<A/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 235/ 5<E?19348 A939/=/19A 7/D<4/ :0= :/ 3;;?A/6 <# 9<E6 9:39 :/ B<?E6 @4<6?;/ :0A =<70E/ @:<1/9:4<?2:B:0;::/;<193;9/69:/3;;?A/6<399:/ 4/E/531990=//1;/019:/@4/A/1;/<D:31643=3 3=@013 316 *+373113 :/ 64/B 31;:313=3 39 G' 316 A/0H/6 9:/ =<70E/ @:<1/ <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < B:0;: 0A @4<6?;/6 316 =34F/6 39 ' :/4/3D9/4 :/ @4<6?;/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 316 # 7/D<4/ 9:/ E/341/6 320A9439/
" A60A;?AA/6:/4/0137<5/9:/:31643=3 01 :0A /506/1;/ :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 9:/=<70E/39 'B3A A/0H/6 01 :0A @4/A/1;/ 78 9:/ @<E0;/ 3A @/4 9:/ 31;:313=3G'?9?1E/AA9:/;<19/19A<D9:/=<70E/
- 41 -
@:<1/ 39 ' 34/ @4<5/6 78 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 7/8<16 4/3A<137E/6<?79=/4/A/0H?4/<D'6</A1<9=3F/<?9 318;3A/32301A99:/3;;?A/6
"# :/ !" :3A D?49:/4 6/@<A/6 9:39 <1 !*!#:/4/;/05/69:/731F3;;<?19/G943;939G$ <D 9:/ 3;;<?19A <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < D4<= # <?435 9:/ 31F 3132/4 9 B3A 4/5/3E/6 6?4012 9:/ 015/A902390<1 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <# @306 3=<?19 9< 9:/ 3;;?A/6<:/4/E/5319/19484/23460129:/;4/609<D 3=<?19<D A+019:/731F3;;<?1939G!$0A =34F/6 39 G!$(3) A A?7=099/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 66E #+<?4350A9:/9:/13132/4<D9:/939/31F <D 86/43736 ?1> 4/3 431;: 3632040 316 :/ @4<6?;/69:/3;;<?19/G943;939G!$
"" #:3A6/@<A/601:0A/506/1;/9:399:/4/0A /194801G!$9:399:/3=<?19B3AB09:643B178?A012 ;346 9 9:0A A932/ 09 0A 4/E/5319 9< 4/D/4 9< 9:/ 6<;?=/19 39 G!$ 9 0A 94?/ 9:39 9:/ 6<;?=/19 39
- 42 -
G!$0AA9316012019:/13=/<D9:/3;;?A/6<?9 3A A?7=099/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< /1948 01 9:/ 6<;?=/19 39 G!$9<A:<B9:393183=<?19B3A@306789:/3;;?A/6 < 9< 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ <4 9< 318 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;<1;/41012B09:9:0A;3A/399:/4/E/531990=/:/4/D<4/ 9:/6<;?=/1939G!$3169://506/1;/<D#6<1<9 =3F/<?9318E01F019:/;:301<D;04;?=A931;/A9<@<01939 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:39 9:/8 ;<==099/6 9:/ <DD/1;/A ;:342/6019:/;3A/
"$ A@/49://506/1;/<D!"<1"*!#:/ 4/;/05/69:/;3EE6/930EA<D9:/3;;?A/6<3A@/4G# :/;<19/190<1<D!"01:0A/506/1;/0A9:393A@/49:/ ;3EE 6/930E 4/20A9/4 39 G# <1 !'&!# 9:/ 9<B/4 E<;390<1 B<?E6 A:<B 9:39 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 @/4A<1 ;3=/ 9< 3632040 9:4<?2: :3:@?4 4<36 316 9:/4/78 B/19 9< @3E<31<D 3E37?4320:/4/E/5319/194801@32/<<D G#0A=34F/639G#(3)
- 43 -
"& :/ !" :3A 3EA< 6/@<A/6 9:39 <1 **!# ! 9:/ 9:/1 <E0;/ <1A937E/ 3>/1643 <E0;/<1A937E/+:0543>316"<E0;/<1A937E/ 0993E344/A9/69:/3;;?A/6<&316'316@4<6?;/69:/= 7/D<4/ :0= 316 :/ /1C?04/6 9:<A/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 316 4/;<46/6 9:/04 5<E?19348 A939/=/19A 316 9:/4/3D9/4 @4<6?;/69:/=7/D<4/9:/<?49?99:/4/0A1<=39/403E D<49:;<=012 D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< A:<B 9:39 318 6<;?=/19A <4 @4<@/490/A B/4/ A/0H/6 D4<= 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <& 316 ' 01 9:/ ;3A/ 9< ;<11/;9 9:/= 9< 9:/ 01;06/19 3EE/2/6019:/;3A/
"' :/ /506/1;/ <D !" 4/2346012 9:/ D?49:/4 015/A902390<10A9:39<1!"*!#:/4/;/05/64/@<49 39 G!! D4<= 4//@3F 316 9:/4/3D9/4 <1
"!#9:/3;;?A/6<$B3A@4<6?;/67/D<4/:0=78 ! 3>/1643 9:/ 9:/1 <E0;/ <1A937E/ :/ !" /1C?04/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 235/ 5<E?19348A939/=/197/D<4/:0=B:/4/019:/@<490<1<D9:/ A939/=/194/36A9:?A
- 44 -
'
(8&
g0
%
< '
(
6h!
7& G(
:
'=
%
< '
(&
&(>
! " %
: '?&
9i
)
)
0
#(e
! 8
&(7B
"* :/A306@<490<1<D9:/3EE/2/6A939/=/19<D9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 7/D<4/ !" 0A 2<9 =34F/6 39 G# :/ A02139?4/ <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 1<$ 01 9:/ A306 A939/=/19 0A =34F/639G#(3)://506/1;/<D!"0A9:39<19:/ 73A0A<D9:/A939/=/1939G#:/A/;?4/69:/@31;:3A * ://=34383 316 * 373113 316 3A A:<B1 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ :/ B/19 3E<12 B09: 9:/ @31;:3A 9< @E<31 50EE32/ 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 9<<F 9:/= 9< 9:/ :<?A/ <D 3=/A: A09?39/6 01 053A:3F9:0 3234 <D 3E37?4320 316 A:<B/6 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ @34F/6 01 D4<19 <D 9:/:<?A/<D :/ A306 <9<4;8;E/B3A ?A/6 019:/ 3EE/2/6 <DD/1;/ :/ A306 <9<4;8;E/ 0A 7/34012 < + !'%+"*!*3163;;<46012E8019:/@4/A/1;/<D37<5/A306 @31;:3A:/A/0H/69:/A306<9<4;8;E/99:3990=/!" 4/;<46/69:/A939/=/19<D 3=/A:
- 45 -
$ 90A3EA<9://506/1;/<D!"9:399:/4/3D9/4 9:/3;;?A/6<$9<<F:0=3E<12B09:9:/@31;:3A9<:0A :<?A/ 316 @4<6?;/6 9:4// A0E5/4 31FE/9A 3EE/2/6E8 7/E<120129<9:/6/;/3A/6/A/0H/69:<A/31FE/9A019:/ @4/A/1;/ <D @31;:3A * 316 * 3A @/4 9:/ @31;:313=3 39 G' :/ * 3EE3113 0A 9:/ 9:/1 /36 <1A937E/ / @4<6?;/6 393 160;3 34 7/34012 < +!+ 7/D<4/ !" 01 9:/ <DD0;/ 316 :/1;/!"A/0H/69:/A3063478643B012@31;:313=3 39G*019:/@4/A/1;/<D*://=34383316* 373113:/"A/;?4/6@4/A/1;/<D 3=3113316
" /53@@3 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ A9390<1 316 A:<B/6 9:/ 31FE/9A9<9:/=3169:/806/190D0/69:<A/31FE/9A3A9:/8 B/4/B<41789:/6/;/3A/6B:/1:/B3A3E05/
$ ?49:/4 09 0A 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !" 9:39 " 3EE0F34>?1 $ 34/@@3 316 & :3193883 06/190D0/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 01 9:/ @<E0;/ A9390<1 :/4/3D9/4 <1 !!# :/ 4/;<46/6 9:/ A939/=/19 <D $ :34313@@3 :0=34383 316 ! 09:?1 1
- 46 -
"!# :/ 4/;<46/6 9:/ A939/=/19 <D
"+
35//1643 ?=3499:0AA932/09A/ED090A4/E/53199<1<9/ 9:39 $ 316 " 01 9:/04 /506/1;/ :35/ 6/10/6 9:39 9:/8235/318A939/=/19A7/D<4/9:/@<E0;/3A@/4G!' 316G!&4/A@/;905/E8
$! :/ /506/1;/ <D !" 4/2346012 9:/ 015/A902390<10A3EA<9:39<1*!#:/A/199:/A/0H/6 3490;E/A 9< 316 <1!!!#:/4/;/05/6<@010<1<D 4//@3F 3A @/4 G! 316 <1 9:/ A3=/ 638 :/ <79301/6 @/4=0AA0<1 D4<= 9:/ E/341/6 320A9439/ 9< 93F/ 7E<<6A3=@E/A<D 3=3113316#:34313@@3316 9:/4/3D9/4 <1 !&!!# 316 # B/4/ @4<6?;/6 7/D<4/ 9:/ E/341/6 320A9439/ 316 01 9:/ @4/A/1;/ <D 9:/ E/341/6 320A9439/ 9:/ 7E<<6 A3=@E/A <D 316 # B/4/93F/1316A3=/B/4/A/199<360B3E01A/3E/6 @3;F D<4 9/A9 / 3EA< A/19 9:/ A9/41?= 316 D/=?4 7<1/A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 ;<EE/;9/6 39 9:/ 90=/ <D @<A9 =<49/= /G3=01390<1 D<4 9/A9A 3E<12 B09: 9:/ 7E<<6 A3=@E/A
- 47 -
$ :/ /506/1;/ <D !" 0A 3EA< 9:39 <1 $*!#!9:/9:/1@4<6?;/6<1/316:/ 4/;/05/6 9:/ A3=/ 316 4/;<46/6 9:/ A939/=/19 <D !
/3EA<4/;<46/69:/A939/=/19<D!34A0123 3<9:/ @<E0;/ A93DD 4/2346012 9:/ A/16012 <D 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 @4<@/490/A 9< 9/A9 316 4/;/05/6 9:/3;F1<BE/62=/19 4/2346012 9:/ A3=/ 1 !*!# :/ 4/;/05/6
/G943;9<D9:/E3164/2346012A@<9<D01;06/19316A3=/0A 39G#1!!!!#:/4/;/05/6AF/9;:<D9:/A@<9 @4/@34/6 78 # %3236/53 <90 9:/ 9:/1 G/;?905/ 1201//4<D3A@/4G'3163D9/4;<=@E/90<1<D9:/ 015/A902390<1<1!*!#:/D0E/6;:342/A://932301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A A:<B012 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <" 316 *3A 37A;<16012 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 3A 9:/8 B/4/ 1<9 3@@4/:/16/66?40129:/015/A902390<1<D9:/;3A/
$# :/!":3A3EA<6/@<A/69:39A?7A/C?/19E8 <1''!":/4/;/05/64/@<4939G!"316D013E <@010<1 <D 9:/ 6<;9<4 39 G!# 316 @4<6?;/6 9:/ A3=/ 7/D<4/9:/<?491 &!!":/4/;/05/64/@<49
- 48 -
316@4<6?;/69:/A3=/7/D<4/9:/E/341/6320A9439/:/ A306 4/@<49 0A 39 G## /1;/ 9:/ /1904/ /506/1;/ <D !"0A4/23460129:/015/A902390<1<D;3A/6<1/78:0=
$" A60A;?AA/6/34E0/4090A@/4901/199<1<9/9:39 9:/4/0A1</8/B091/AA9<9:/3EE/2/601;06/19://1904/ ;3A/<D@4<A/;?90<14/A9A<1;04;?=A931903E/506/1;/" 3EE0F34>?1 $ 344/883 316 & :3193883 34/ 3EE/2/69<7/9:/@/4A<1AB:<A3B9:/6/;/3A/6B09:9:/ 3;;?A/6<$D<49:/E3A990=//34E0/49<9:/6/39:<D9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A 1<9 /G3=01/6 $+ 34/@@3316&+:319383
$$ :/ " 3EE0F34>?1 :3A 7//1 /G3=01/6 3A
" 0A /506/1;/ 0A 3E4/368 60A;?AA/6 /34E0/4 G;/@9 A380129:39:/A3B37<832/637<?9!9<!"8/34A93F012 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 01 3 4/6 ;<E<?4 <9<4;8;E/ 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E81</506/1;/D<49:;<=012D4<="9<A:<B9:39 :/06/190D0/69:/3;;?A/6<$3A9:/@/4A<1B:<3EE/2/6E8 9<<F 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 <4/<5/4 9:/4/ 0A 1< /506/1;/ D4<=
- 49 -
"9<@4<5/9:39:/06/190D0/69:/@3490;?E34<9<4;8;E/01 B:0;: 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ B3A 3EE/2/6 9< :35/ 93F/1 9:/ 6/;/3A/6
$& ?49:/4 9:/ /1904/ ;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 3EE/2/6 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A B3A <1 9:/ 73A0A <D 9:/ 3EE/2/6 /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! /1;/ ?1E/AA 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 @4<5/A 7/8<16 4/3A<137E/ 6<?79 9:/ 4/;<5/48 <D 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 3490;E/A @4<@/490/A D4<=9:/3;;?A/6<9:/3;;?A/6<!3169:/3;;?A/6 <$ <1 9:/ 73A0A <D 9:/04 3EE/2/6 A939/=/19A ?16/4 /;90<1 !& <D 506/1;/ ;9 9:/ 4/;<5/40/A <D ;<1;/41/6 @4<@/490/A ;311<9 7/ 3 24<?16 9< ;<=@E/9/ 9:/ ;:301 <D ;04;?=A931;/A 9< @<019 39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:39 <1E8 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;<==099/6 9:/ 3EE/2/6 <DD/1;/A 1 9:0A73;F24<?16090A4/E/53199<4/D/49<9:/016/@/16/19 /506/1;/D<49:;<=012<14/;<46
$' ://G943>?60;03E;<1D/AA0<1<D9:/3;;?A/6<! 0A 3EE/2/6 9< :35/ 7//1 205/1 9< &+/53@@3 :/
- 50 -
&:3A7//1/G3=01/63A'/:3A6/@<A/601:0A /506/1;/9:393D9/4=<19:316638AD4<==0AA012<D 9:/6/;/3A/6 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! ;3=/ 9< 34313:3EE0316 :/B3A?16/4019<G0;390<1316019:/4<36<D9:/50EE32/39 37<?9!1<<19<3=9:/3;;?A/6<!=/9:0= 3169<E6:0=4/23460129:/3EE/2/601;06/19:/4/E/5319 @<490<1019://506/1;/01;:0/D/G3=01390<1<D'4/36A 9:?A %
4)
(%
(
&
?&@&
#A& (
5
(%
(
@&
#A& %(
D
23)
! "D D -&
! " 8
6
7
5Z1(
(8
!(;
WH&(>
! "# %
'
(8&9@& #A&
( )
( '
(8
Z;
@&
A&&
, &(>
! "# % '
0
d!(&
(8
&
(,7% '
(8
*@&
#A&
B
$* A @<019/6 <?9 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1A'01:0A/506/1;/01;4<AA/G3=01390<1 :3A9<E69:39:/B3A01;<4603E4/E390<1A:0@B09:316 # 316 :/ ?A/6 9< 2< 9< 9:/04 :<?A/ 316 9:/8 ?A/6 9<
- 51 -
;<=/ 9< :0A :<?A/ / :3A 6/10/6 9:39 9:/4/ B3A 318 60A@?9/7/9B//19:/3;;?A/6<316316#:/ 4/E/5319 @<490<1 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ' 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<14/36A9:?A
2
%
< - #()
2 3)
! " #j
&^
(7(e?&9&
#
%(7J (e?
*46B
& ?49:/4 ' :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 0A 1<9 7/E<12012 9< :39:13EE0 50EE32/ / 235/ A939/=/199<9:/@<E0;/4/23460129:/;3A/3D9/4"638A<D 9:/3;;?A/6 <! ;<1D/AA/6 9<:0= 4/2346012 9:/3EE/2/6 01;06/19:/':3A3EA<A939/601:0A/506/1;/01;4<AA /G3=01390<19:39
1
&(>
%
&
&
;
ZO
$A&
%
( 2
%
< - #
%(7 ! 5
& #A
) (
&
&
;ZO
$A6B
& <B/5/4090A5/48@/4901/199<1<9/9:39/5/1 9:<?2:'F1/B9:39235/;<=@E30199<9:/@<E0;/
- 52 -
4/2346012=0AA012<D9:/6/;/3A/6090AA94312/9:39:/606 1<9 A939/ 7/D<4/ 9:/ @<E0;/ 37<?9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 0==/6039/E83D9/49:/3;;?A/6<!3EE/2/6E8;<1D/AA/69< :0= 4/2346012 ;<==0AA0<1 <D 9:/ <DD/1;/ :/ 3;;?A/6 <! 3EE/2/6E8 ;<1D/AA/6 7/D<4/ :0= 9:39 :/ 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 3E<12 B09: <9:/4 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;3?A/6 6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6
&! <4/<5/4 4/2346012 9:/ E3A9 A;/1/ 9:/<48 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ' 01 :0A ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 0A 9:39 A<=/ <9:/4@/4A<1AB:<B/4/A0990121/3431?=319/=@E/01 9:/0450EE32/A3B9:/?1F1<B1@/4A<193F0129:/6/;/3A/6 <1<9<4;8;E/<1#*!#3937<?9#@=?91< A?;: 016/@/16/19 B091/AA/A :35/ 7//1 /G3=01/6 78 9:/ 01 9:/ ;3A/ ?49:/4 3A @<019/6 <?9 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A9:/'01:0A/506/1;/ 01;4<AA+/G3=01390<13AA939/69:39
1
&(>
F;) & # )
&
(
$<&
9;&
) %
! ;1
?& (
. O
M 1
&(>
F
5)
0
- 53 -
# 4
B @&
(
! 5
& WH #A
5#A
46
1
&(>
%
((`
8&
5 ?&
9
D
F
5
<
5
&^(#
2k
(2)
G (;) ) JI
(7&
9 % 4) (%
(
&
?&@&
#A&
(
5
(%
( @&
#A&B@&
! 5
& WH#A
5#A `
46B
& :/':3A6/@<A/69:39B:/19:/6/367<68 B3A93F/1<?9D4<=9:/7?403E@E3;/09B3A016/;<=@<A/6 3169:/;:0E64/1<D9:/6/;/3A/606/190D0/69:/6/367<68 3A<D9:/04D39:/4?9':3A6/10/69:39:/A939/69:/ A306 D3;9 01 :0A A939/=/19 3EE/2/6E8 205/1 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ /1;/9:/A306@<490<1<DA939/=/190A2<9=34F/6789:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1A39G! &# <4/<5/4 09 0A 5/48 @/4901/19 9< 1<9/ 9:39 /34E0/4 9< 9:/ 6/36 7<68 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B3A D<?16 9:/ ;:0E64/1 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 06/190D0/6 <1/6/36 7<68 A:<B1 9<9:/=789:/@<E0;/3A9:/6/367<68<D9:/04D39:/4316
- 54 -
9:/8 7?40/6 9:/ A306 6/36 7<68 01 9:/04 50EE32/ :/ 4/E/5319@<490<1019://506/1;/<D'4/36A9:?A
&
;
)
*&
+,%
1 K& ! 5
&(>
! "# %
,A)% ;
&
; &(>
! "# &@&
#AK
"&
&
%
<
%
&
; &(>
! " # ?
,0
%
eZ
&
5 (,
(8&
9
B
&" 90A@/4901/199<1<9/9:39#B:<0A9:/A<1 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :3A 3EA< 36=099/6 9:/ A306 D3;9 01 :0A /506/1;/01;4<AA+/G3=01390<1B:0;:4/36A9:?A
2 3)
! " %
h! 0(
)(>
&
#
$< )
l&
#
$<
&
;
&
#
$<
4P
% ;
&
+,% 1D ! 5
2/ ;&
N 4
)
0
1 (6&
5 c49&
9 K&
%
&
) % ;
&
; %
&
&
? %
<& @&
#A&
9;&
&
;
, (
* %
+>
(8
(4
IH&9
*
%
< ! L (
$<&9
* (
*
&
;
%
&
&
6 @& #A&
#
M'=
L (
; ?&
& %
&
@&
#A
)K
"&
&
;
M'= %
&
&
#A K%(<
! M
()
) K
"&
)m(
*@= ;))
5
%
<?%
! 5 S;
4n(;)
A) n
(M4
IH
46D
)
&
;
- 55 -
(%
> % ;&
9
&
;
&
!^ G % ;
56B
&$ ?9090A5/48@/4901/199:39/5/19:/#<4:0A 318<9:/474<9:/4A6061<9205/318;<=@E301932301A99:/ ;<1;/41/63EE/20129:399:/8B/4/D<4;/6789:/@<E0;/ 9<06/190D89:/A3066/367<683A9:39<D9:/04D39:/4316 9:/8 @/4D<4=/6 9:/ E3A9 409/A <D 9:/ A306 6/36 @/4A<1 <4/<5/49:/!"9:/<D9:/;3A/:3A3EA<6/@<A/6 01:0A/506/1;/01;4<AA+/G3=01390<19:39
&(>
! " # %
(R
(&
%
6
* 4
)
0
'K&
('=&
5&(>
! "# %# 6 KP
Y%
+<
&#
&
+& @&
%
<
&
; #(! ! 5 2(
%
< 2
! " ? ;)
S IH
@&
$A&
4
%
<&
&
;
,
%
&
;
+<
(
*
#
e(VD
(VD k
(%
#
%
?&
&
(V
%
< '@
*&
)m i\%
! 8 0
d
&
, @ ! ;X
(
J()
%
<& #(! ! 5
&
;
& @ ! ;X (8
%
<
Y%
&#
#
8@=@ G
H) 0
! 8&
9 ? %
<& &
&(i')
0
! >
&
5 WM)#(e
!
8
'(7
46B
- 56 -
&& 9 0A 5/48 A94312/ 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E81<6<;?=/19348/506/1;/D<49:;<=012D4<=9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< A:<B B:39 :3@@/1/6 9< 9:/ /34E0/4 6/36 7<6806/190D0/6789:/;:0E64/1<D9:/6/;/3A/63A<D9:/04 D39:/43D9/49:/6/367<68<D9:/6/;/3A/6B3AD<?163A 3EE/2/6019:/;3A/?49:/43AA?7=099/6789:/E/341/6 ;<?1A/ED<49:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A9://506/1;/<D!"01 ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1 B<?E6 D3EA0D8 9:/ 3EE/2/6 ;3A/ 316 09 B<?E6 ;4/39/ 6<?79 01 9:/ =016 <D 9:/ <?49 4/2346012 4/;<5/48<D9:/6/367<68D4<=9:/3EE/2/6@E3;/
&' <4/<5/4 3A =/190<1/6 :/4/01 37<5/ 9:/ @/4A<1B:<6?29:/@E3;/:3AA939/69:399:/7<1/A<D<G B/4/D<?16399:/@E3;/?9!"B:<0A3EE/2/69<:35/ 7//1@4/A/19399:/90=/<D6022012<D9:/A@<9:3AA939/6 9:399:/4/B3A1<7<1/<D9:/<GD<?16399:/@E3;/:/ 4/E/5319 @<490<1 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !" 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<14/36A9:?A
- 57 -
&
; h! 0(
)
l&
#
$<
&
; eZ
&
5&
9 #
$<&
9L()
)
(6,@$<
@6)
0 &
;L()
&
5
4
46B
&* ?49:/4 0D 9:/ /506/1;/ <D # 01 ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 0A 93F/1 9< ;<1A06/4390<1 9:/ D3;9 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! ;<1D/AA/6 4/2346012 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19 9< '3@@/34A9<7/1<97/E0/537E/#01:0A/506/1;/01 ;4<AA/G3=01390<1:3A6/@<A/69:39 2E &
! " %
& cn
(
#
? 4)
&()
5
%
&
&()
5
&^
O
H 1
(7 ? 56D (
*
) # 7
& (
$<
56
%
<%
)& # )
&
(
$<
56B
' :0A /506/1;/ <D # 0A C?09/ ;<194348 9< 9:/ /506/1;/<D'(&)B:<9<E69:39:/B3A01;<4603E 9/4=AB09:9:/6/;/3A/6316:0A;:0E64/1316:/?A/69< 2< 9< 9:/ :<?A/ <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 :0A ;:0E64/1 B3A ;<=0129<:0A:<?A/
' <4/<5/4 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< =39/403E D<49:;<=012 D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< @4<5/ 9:39 9:/
- 58 -
3;;?A/6 <! :36 318 ;<4603E 4/E390<1A:0@ B09: ' 316 9:/A3063;;?A/6:36318D309:01#9<;<1D/AA9:39:/ 3E<12B09:<9:/43;;?A/6@/4A<1A;<==099/69:/<DD/1;/<D ;3?A0126/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6
'! A :/E6 78 9:/ <1.7E/ @/G <?49 9:/ /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 0A B/3F /506/1;/
1E/AA 09 0A ;<44<7<439/6 78 ;<2/19 /506/1;/ A?;: /506/1;/ <D /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 ;311<9 7/ 3 73A0A D<4 4/;<46012 ;<150;90<132301A99:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A:/4/D<4//5/10D /506/1;/ <D ' 316 # 34/ 93F/1 019< ;<1A06/4390<1 9:39 9:/ !
;<1D/AA/6 7/D<4/ ' 9:39 :/ 3E<12 B09: <9:/43;;?A/6@/4A<1A;3?A/66/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6A?;:
/506/1;/ <D ' 6</A1<9 A9316 D<4 ;<1A06/4390<1 <1 9:/ D3;9A <D 9:/ ;3A/ 316 3EA< 01 E3B 9< =3F/ <?9 318 ;3A/ 32301A93;;?A/6@/4A<1AD<49:/<DD/1;/A;:342/67/8<16 4/3A<137E/6<?79
' $ 3EE3883 0A 3EE/2/6 9< 7/ 9:/ 399/A9<4 9< 9:/ @31;:313=3 39 G 4/2346012 A/0H?4/ <D 9<
- 59 -
A@/4:0A/506/1;/9:/A306@4<@/490/AB/4/A/0H/6 789:/@<E0;/019:/@<E0;/A9390<1
'# &31?=319:30A<1/<D9:/399/A9<4A9<9:/ 31;:313=3AGA!3164/23460124/;<5/48<D 9:/6/367<68?93A@/49://506/1;/<D!"3163EA< 3A6/@<A/678&0109A;:0/D/G3=01390<19:/4/B3A1< @4<@/498 D<?16 01 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 A@<9 316 :/1;/ 9:/ @31;:313=339GB3A643B1399:39A@<9G!0A 9:/ 01C?/A9 @31;:313=3 643B1 78 9:/ ?7+050A0<13E 320A9439/399:/A@<9&:3A6/@<A/69:399:/3;;?A/6 <9<<F9:/@<E0;/3E<12B09:9:/@31;:3A9<9:/:<?A/ <D9:/3;;?A/6<!3169:/@<E0;/A/0H/6<1/<9<4;8;E/ 3A@/49:/@31;:313=339G#:/A306<9<4;8;E/0A 7/34012 < ++'" 316 A3=/ 0A =34F/6 39 ?9 9:/4/ 0A 1< 016/@/16/19 /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< ;<11/;9 9:/ A306 <9<4;8;E/ 9< 9:/ 3EE/2/601;06/19
- 60 -
'" '+/53@@3 0A 9:/ @/4A<1 9< B:<= 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 0A 3EE/2/6 9< :35/ ;<1D/AA/6 4/2346012 9:/ ;<==0AA0<1 <D 9:/ <DD/1;/A 0A /506/1;/ 0A 3E4/368 60A;?AA/6/34E0/4316:0A/506/1;/;311<97/;<1A06/4/69< @4<5/ 9:/ 3EE/2/6 /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 316 :/1;/ 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ' 6</A 1<9 =/409 ;<1A06/4390<1 9< =3F/ <?9 318 ;3A/ 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A
'$ * :0=34383 0A <1/ <D 9:/ @31;:3A B:< 3;;<=@310/6 9:/ @<E0;/ 3E<12 B09: 3;;?A/6 <$ 9< 9:/ A;/1/<D@E3;/B:/4/9:/6/367<68B3A7?40/6:/* :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ A:<B/6 9:/A@<9 316 9:/@:<9<B3A93F/13A@/4G":/3;;?A/6<$3EA< A:<B/6<1/7E3;F;<E<?4/6<9<4;8;E/9<9:/@<E0;/399:/ :<?A/ 01 053A:3F9:0 32343 3E37?4320 316 9:/ @<E0;/ A/0H/6 9:/ A306 <9<4;8;E/ :/4/3D9/4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ @4<6?;/69:4//31FE/9A3169:/@<E0;/9<<F@:<9<A399:/ A@<93A@/4GA$316&:/@31;:313=3B3A643B1 3A @/4 G' :0A /506/1;/ <D * 0A C?09/ ;<194348 9<
- 61 -
9:/ /506/1;/ <D 01 B:0;: 09 0A A939/6 9:39 9:/ A@<9 <D 01;06/19 B3A A:<B1 9< 9:/= 39 9:/ 010903E A932/ 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6<3169:/;<1;/41/6<9<4;8;E/B3AA/0H/639 9:/ 01A931;/ <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <!
:/4/D<4/ 9:/4/ 34/ ;<194360;90<1A 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D * B09: 9:/ ;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1
'& <4/<5/43A@<019/6<?9789:/E/341/6;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A * 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<1:3A6/@<A/69:39 &
; eZ
&
5&
9 L()
& 5& (
*& <)
0
e <
(8 86
&
;eZ
&
5K&
&
& IH) ?&
9 &
5 0
,0
(
(7
%(< @& #A&
)) $<6 &
;eZ
&
5&
9
&
;
g0
&
5 o
()
5 @=o ()
5 f
&
%
(;
46
&
;
g0
&
5 (
2%(
)?&9
*B &
;
-
#A
#
%(7
&
; g0
&
5 ! 5 f & %
(;
46 ;
%
&
(
2%( )?&9
*
- 62 -
'' 9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D * 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<19:39 i
)
)
0
(6, (
K0
) # &
& o
4&
9;&
! 5
f &
%
(; 8
46(5)#(+ 0
d
i
)
)
0 !:+i
)
)
A) 8? 56:
5#(+ 0
d
i
)
, 8?%
<! 5
5!
1
(&
S %)&
5
(
2%(
)?&9
*(
*5 2%(
)?&(9)
Je
(
4
46B
'* :/ /506/1;/ <D * 0A 3EA< 9:39 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B 9:/ ;<19/19A <D 9:/ @31;:313=3 39 G' 316 :/ 6061<9F1<B9:/<B1/4<D9:/34A/0H/6789:/@<E0;/39 9:/@<E0;/A9390<1<4/<5/43AA?7=099/6789:/E/341/6 ;<?1A/E 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 09 0A 5/48 @/4901/19 9< 1<9/9:399:/6061<9;<16?;931806/190D0;390<1@3436/ D<49:/06/190D0;390<1<D9:/3;;?A/6<$9<@4<5/9:39:/ 0A 9:/ @/4A<1 B:< B3A E3A9 A//1 78 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 B091/AA/A 3E<12 B09: 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 /1;/ 3A 60A;?AA/6 :/4/01 37<5/ 9:/4/ 34/ ;<194360;90<1A 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D *<4/<5/4019://506/1;/01;4<AA/G3=01390<1*
- 63 -
:3A 36=099/6 9:39 :/ 0A 4/E3905/ <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/4/D<4/:0A/506/1;/6</A1<9=/409;<1A06/4390<1
*
3=/A:390E0A3EE/2/69<7/9:/@/4A<1 B:<B3A@4/A/19399:/90=/<DA/0H?4/<D*<9<4;8;E/ 1 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D /G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ 316 9:/ A306 3;;?A/66061<9@34F318<9<4;8;E/7/34012< +!'%+
"*!* 01 9:/ D4<19 <D :0A :<?A/ :/ /506/1;/ <D 0A 9:39<1"!#9:/@<E0;/74<?2:99:/3;;?A/6<$9< :0A :<?A/ 316 9<<F 9:/ A306 <9<4;8;E/ :/ A306 <9<4;8;E/0A06/190D0/678:0=3A@/4*<B/5/49:/4/ 0A 1< =39/403E D<49:;<=012 D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< A:<B 9:39 9:/B3A@4/A/19 399:/ A@<9 B:/1 9:/3EE/2/6 <9<4;8;E/B3AA/0H/6?49:/49:/4/0A1<=39/403E019:/ /506/1;/<D9<;<11/;99:/<9<4;8;E/39*9<9:/ 3EE/2/601;06/19
* +//=343830A3EE/2/69<:35/@?4;:3A/6 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ 7/34012 < ++'" B:0;: B3A
- 64 -
A/0H/6 316 @4<6?;/6 01 9:/ ;3A/ 3A @/4 / :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 :/ A<E6 9:/ A306 <9<4;8;E/ 9< 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 7?9 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B B:/9:/4 9:/ 4/;<46 <D 9:/ <9<4;8;E/B3A;:312/6019:/13=/<D9:/3;;?A/6< <4/<5/4 ?1E/AA 9:/4/ 0A 016/@/16/19 /506/1;/ D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< ;<11/;9 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ 39 9< 9:/ 3EE/2/601;06/199://506/1;/<D6</A1<9A9316D<4 ;<1A06/4390<1 9< =3F/ <?9 318 ;3A/ 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1AD<49:/<DD/1;/A;:342/6
*! !09:?1J316?431230A3EE/2/69<:35/ A<E6 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ 39 * 9< 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <$ / :3A 06/190D0/6 9:/ A306 <9<4;8;E/ 01 :0A /506/1;/ ?9 01 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 ! :3A 6/10/6 9:39 :/ 235/ 318 A939/=/19 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ 6?4012 015/A902390<1 <D 9:/ ;3A/ 4/2346012 9:/ D3;9A A939/6 01 :0A /506/1;/ :/4/D<4/ 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !
3EA< 6</A 1<9 A9316 D<4 ;<1A06/4390<1 9< @4<5/ 9:39 9:/ <9<4;8;E/ < 39 *B3A ?A/6 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 01 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19
- 65 -
* 4 //@3F ?191<<4/ 0A 9:/ 9:/1 AA0A9319 4<D/AA<4 9:/ /@349=/19 <D <4/1A0; /60;01/ 01?E734231A909?9/<D/60;3E;0/1;/A/0A3EE/2/69< :35/;<16?;9/69:/@<A9=<49/=<D9:/6/367<68<D9:/ 6/;/3A/6 A @/4 :0A /506/1;/ <1 $*!# 39 # @= :/ 4/;/05/6 E/99/4 D4<= AA0A9319 <==0AA0<1/4 ?E73423 D<4 ;<16?;9012 @<A9 =<49/= /G3=01390<1 <D 9:/ 6/367<683D9/44/;<5/40129:/7<68D4<=9:/7?403E34/3 ?9 09 0A @/4901/19 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/ @<A9 =<49/= /G3=01390<1B3A1<96<1/399:/A@<9<D7?403E34/37?909 B3A6<1/019:/:<A@093E
*# :/ 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D/G3=01390<1 :3AA939/69:399://G3=01390<1A9349/6019:/7?403E@E3;/ :/7<68B3A01A?@01/@<A090<1E<9:/A<19:/7<68B/4/ B/9 B09: 6/;<=@<A090<1 DE?06 /A@/;03EE8 <1 @<A9/40<4 3A@/;9:/6/;<=@<A090<1B3AA//13EE<5/49:/7<68B09:
360@<;/4<?A D<4=390<1 <5/4 9:/ 319/40<4 3A@/;9 <D 1/;F 94?1F 316 E<B/4 E0=7A 1 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D
- 66 -
/G3=01390<1 09 0A 6/@<A/6 78 9:39 3A 09 B3A E39/ /5/101209B3A6/;06/69<A:0D99:/6/367<689<0A940;9 <A@093E?E73423D<46/930E/6@<A9=<49/=/G3=01390<1 ?/;34/B3A93F/17/D<4/A:0D90129:/7<681<99<E<A/<4 3E9/4 318 /506/1;/ :0A /506/1;/ <D B<?E6 A:<B 9:399:/6/367<68B<?E67/;<=@E/9/E86/;<=@<A/6
*" ?49:/4 01 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D /G3=01390<1 09A/ED :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 3EE 9:/ D3;03E =?A;E/A 34/ 6/;<=@<A/6/G@<A012AF?EE7<1//8/A<;F/9AB/4//=@98 9//9: B/4/ /G@<A/6 316 =31607E/ B3A D43;9?4/6 <1 E/D9 A06/90A3EA<6/@<A/6789:399:/A;3E@B3A@349E8 6/;<=@<A/6 D3;03E =?A;E/A B/4/ 6/;<=@<A/6 /G@<A012 9:/ AF?EE 7<1/ =31607E/ B3A D43;9?4/6 74301 316 A@013E ;<46 B3A E0C?/D0/6 316 =/=7431/A B3A 6/;<=@<A/6 / :3A 0AA?/6 @<A9 =<49/= 4/@<49 316 @4<50A0<13E ;/490D0;39/3A@/4GA!316!!4/A@/;905/E8
*$ A @/4 9:/ /506/1;/ <D :/ 4/A/45/6 :0A <@010<13A9<;3?A/<D6/39:<19:/73A0A<D9:/4/A?E9<D
- 67 -
;:/=0;3E 313E8A0A 4/@<49 / ;<EE/;9/6 9:/ 0A;/43 <4231A A?;:3AF061/8AA3=@E/A01#7<99E/AD<4A/160129:/A3=/ D<4 /G3=01390<1 :<A/ 50A;/43 <4231A 34/ @0/;/A <D A9<=3;: A=3EE 019/A901/ B09: 9:/04 ;<19/19A @0/;/A <D F061/8AE05/4316A@E//1/3EA<;<EE/;9/6/349:A3=@E/A D4<= 9:/ 6/36 7<68 :/ :?=/4?A 316 A9/41?= B/4/ ;<EE/;9/6D<4313E8A0A
*& :/ /506/1;/ <D
0A 3EA< 9:39 <1 !!#:/31AB/4/69:/C?/A90<11304/A430A/6789:/ 316 9:/ 31AB/4A B/4/ 205/1 78 :0= 3A @/4 G!
?49:/4<19:/73A0A<D4/@<49:/0AA?/6D013E<@010<1 E/99/4 <1 !&!" 3A @/4 G!# 316 :/ B3A <D 9:/ <@010<19:399:/6/39:B3A6?/9<A94312?E390<1316A?;: A94312?E390<1=02:97/B09:9:/:/E@<D4<@/D<?16<19:/ 7<68 :/ 4<@/ B3A 06/190D0/6 78 3A @/4 <B/5/4 3A 342?/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:/ 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 :/ 606 1<9 =/3A?4/ 9:/ ;04;?=D/4/1;/<D9:/1/;F:3A3EA<6/@<A/69:39:/
- 68 -
606 1<9 @4/@34/ 318 6<;?=/19 9:31 9:/ 4/@<49 4/2346012:0A50A099<9:/@E3;/<D7?403E316<7A/45390<1<D 9:/7<68399:/A@<9
*' <4/<5/4 <1/ E/99/4 4/;/05/6 78 9:/ AA0A9319 <==0AA0<1/4 <1 $*!# :3A 7//1 ;<1D4<19/6 9< 019:/;4<AA+/G3=01390<1789:/E/341/6;<?1A/ED<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 316 9:/ A306 6<;?=/19 0A 2<9 =34F/6 39 G
01 :0A /506/1;/ :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 /16<4A/=/19 =36/ 78 :0= <1 G 316 90=/ B3A <5/4B4099/13169:/90=/B3A/34E0/4=/190<1/63A# @= 316 09 B3A ;<44/;9/6 3A # @= 316 :/ 606 1<9 @?9318010903E01A?;:;<44/;90<119://506/1;/01;4<AA /G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 3D9/4 4/;/0@9 <D 4/@<4939G!":/0AA?/6D013E<@010<1E/99/439G!# ?9:0A/506/1;/0A9:399:/4/@<4939G!"6</A1<9 ;<19301 9:/ 4/@<49 <D /G3=01390<1 <D :?=/4?A 316 A9/41?=B:0;:B/4/3EE/2/6E8@4/A/45/6019:/7?;F/9
- 69 -
** 9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D 01 :0A ;4<AA /G3=01390<19:399:/6/;<=@<A090<1B3A3EE<5/49:/7<68 316 A<=/ @<490<1 <D 9:/ 7<68 B3A @?94/D0/6 :/ 6/36 7<68 =02:9 :35/ 7//1 01A06/ D<4 =010=?= 9:4// B//FA 7?9:/6061<9=/190<101:0A4/@<493A9<:<B=318 638A32<9:/6/39:7<68<D9:/6/;/3A/6=02:9:35/7//1 93F/1:/:3A3EA<6/@<A/69:39/G;/@99:/9:4/36 391<<9:/4;E<9:012B3AD<?16<19:/6/367<68
9 0A @/4901/19 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/ /506/1;/ <D 01:0A ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1 0A9:39 <1 A//0129:/ D3;/ <D 9:/ 6/36 7<68 7/;3?A/ <D 6/;<=@<A090<1 09 B3A 1<9 @<AA07E/D<43@/4A<19<06/190D83A9<B:<A/6/367<6809 B3A:0A/506/1;/<DB<?E6;E/34E82<9<A:<B9:39 9:/ ! 316 # B:< 34/ 9:/ A<1A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 ;<?E6 1<9 :35/ 06/190D0/6 9:/ 6/36 7<68 3A 9:39 <D 9:/04 D39:/4
<4/<5/4 3A 60A;?AA/6 :/4/01 37<5/ 09 0A 36=099/6 D3;9 9:39 /34E0/4 ! 316 # 4/;/05/6 6/36
- 70 -
7<68D4<=9:/3169:/806/190D0/69:/6/367<683A<D 9:/04 D39:/4 316 9:/8 7?40/6 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 @?9 ?@ A3=36:0 316 9:/8 B/4/ @/4D<4=012 @<<>3 :/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E81<=39/403ED<49:;<=012D4<=9:/@4<A/;?90<19< A:<B3A9<B:39:3@@/1/69<9:/6/367<687?40/6/34E0/4 3D9/49:/6/367<68<D9:/6/;/3A/6B3AD<?16<?9
!
:/4/ 0A 1< =39/403E D<49:;<=012 9< 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< A:<B 9:39 9:/ 2<9 ;<16?;9/6 @<A9 =<49/=<D9://34E0/46/367<68:/4/D<4/6<?79340A/A 4/2346012 9:/ D3;9 9:39 9:/ 6/36 7<68 <D B:0;: 9:/ @<A9 =<49/= B3A ;<16?;9/6 78 0A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 9:/4/789<;<11/;99:/=/60;3E/506/1;/<14/;<469<9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9< ;<=/ 9< 9:/ ;<1;E?A0<1 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1A;3?A/66/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/63A3EE/2/6 789:/@4<A/;?90<1 A60A;?AA/6:/4/0137<5/#<?4350A9:/ 3132/4 <D 9:/ 31F B:< @4<6?;/6 3;;<?19 /G943;9 39G!$4/23460129:/731F3;;<?19<D9:/3;;?A/6< - 71 - A @/4 9:/ A306 A939/=/19 09 0A 1<9 ;E/34 4/2346012 9:/ @E3;/ B:/4/ 9:/ 3;;?A/6 B09:64/B 9:/ 3=<?19 D4<= :0A 3;;<?199:4<?2:<4/<5/4/5/19:<?2:6<;?=/1939 G!$0A;<1A06/4/63A1<90160A@?9/9:/4/0A37A<E?9/E8 1< /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 D4<= @4<A/;?90<1 9< @4<5/ 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < B09:64/B 9:/ 3=<?19 39 3 @3490;?E34 @E3;/;<11/;9/6B09:9:/3EE/2/601;06/19?49:/49:/4/0A 1<=39/403ED<49:;<=012019://506/1;/<D#9<A:<B 9:39 318 3=<?19 B3A ;4/609/6 9< 9:/ 3;;<?19 <D 3;;?A/6 < B:0;: B3A 3EE/2/6E8 205/1 01 ;<11/;90<1 B09: 9:/ 01;06/19<D9:/;3A/399:/4/E/531990=/ # " 3501643 ?=34 B3A 6405/4 <D 9:/ 34 B:0;: 7/E<12/6 9< !+:34313@@3 J :34313 ?9 01 9://506/1;/01;:0/D/G3=01390<1":3A6/@<A/69:39 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B B:< 9<<F 9:/ A306 34 <1 4/19 <1 !'&!#/:3A3EA<A939/69:39:/6061<9F1<BB:< 3=<12 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9<<F 9:/ 34 <1 4/19 <1 !&'!# ?49:/4 :/ :3A 6/10/6 9:39 :/ 235/ 318 A939/=/19 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ 4/2346012 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19 - 72 - /1;/9://506/1;/<D"0AC?09/;<1943489<9:/;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 316 :/ 0A 94/39/6 :<A90E/ 316 A?7>/;9/6 9< ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 78 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 B:/4/01 :/ :3A 6/10/6 9:39 :/ 235/ 318 A939/=/19 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ 3A @/4 G!& " $+:34313@@3 0A 3EE/2/6 9< 7/ 9:/ @/4A<1 B:< B3A E<<F012 3D9/4 9:/ =3132/=/19 <D 9:/ ;34 7/340121?=7/4 !+B:0;:B3A 019:/13=/<D :0A A<1 :31643F3193 3>31940 1 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D /G3=01390<1$:3A6/@<A/69:39019:/=<19:<D%?E8 !# " 3501643 ?=34 B3A 6405/4 <D 9:/ A306 34 7?9 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B <1 !'&!# 9< B:0;: 50EE32/ 9:/ A306 34 B3A 93F/1 316 B/19 <1 4/19 1 9:/ =<19: <D <5/=7/4!#9:/@<E0;/;3=/316A/0H/69:/A30634 B:0;: B3A @34F/6 01 9:/ D4<19 <D :0A :<?A/ 3169<<F 9:/ 34 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ A9390<1 ?9 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B 01 B:0;: =?46/4 ;3A/ 9:/ A306 34 B3A 4/C?04/6 78 9:/ @<E0;/ :/4/3D9/43A@/49:/<46/4<D9:/;<1;/41/6320A9439/ :/ 2<9 4/E/3A/6 9:/ 34 9< :0A @<AA/AA0<1 <B/5/4 9:/ - 73 - A306 /506/1;/ 01 $ 0A C?09/ ;<194348 9< @4<A/;?90<1 ;3A/ 316 :/1;/ :/ 0A 94/39/6 :<A90E/ 316 A?7>/;9/6 9< ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 78 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1B:/4/01$:3A 6/10/69:39:/235/318A939/=/199<9:/@<E0;/ $ &?163@@3:0==3>0<?E00A<B1/4<D9:/ @4<@/498 7/34012 ?45/8 <& <D @E<31 50EE32/ =/3A?4012 $ 3;4/A * 2?193A 1 9:/ A306 E316 9:/ 6/36 7<68 <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 0A 3EE/2/6 9< :35/ 7//1 7?40/6 & 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;:0/D /G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 01 9:/ =<19: <D /@9/=7/4+!# 9:/ @<E0;/ 01 :0A @4/A/1;/6061<96029:/E3167/E<B9:/1//=94//316318
6/36 7<68 B3A 1<9 4/=<5/6 D4<= 9:/ @E3;/ / 606 1<9 205/ 318 A939/=/19 9< 9:/ @<E0;/ 4/2346012 9:/ ;3A/ :/4/D<4/9:/D3;9<D/G943;90129:/6/367<68019:/E316 7/E<12012 9< & 3A 3EE/2/6 78 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 0A 1<9 A?@@<49/678&B:<0A<B1/4<D9:/A306E316/1;/ &:3A9?41/6:<A90E/9<9:/;3A/<D@4<A/;?90<1316:/ 0A A?7>/;9/6 9< ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 78 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 01 - 74 - B:0;: :/ :3A 6/10/6 9:39 :/ 235/ 318 A939/=/19 9< 9:/ @<E0;/3A@/4G!& & ' :31643A/F:34 0A 9:/ 9:/1 <E0;/ <1A937E/ 01 9:/ <DD0;/ <D A @/4 :0A /506/1;/ <1 $*!# 3A @/4 9:/ 604/;90<1 <D 9:/ :/ B/19 9< @E<31 50EE32/ 316 3A @/4 9:/ <46/4 <D 9:/ AA0A9319 <==0AA0<1/4 :/ 506/<243@:/6 9:/ 4/=<53E <D 9:/ 6/36 7<68 D4<= 9:/ 7?40/6 @E3;/ <B/5/4 01 9:/ ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<1 ' :3A A939/6 9:39 :/ 0A 1<9 /G@/49 01 506/<243@:8 316 9:/ 506/< ;3=/43 78 B:0;: :/ 506/< 4/;<46/6 7/E<12/6 9< :0A <DD0;/ D9/4 506/<243@:012 :/ 235/ 9:/ ;3=/43 9< 7?9 :/ 606 1<9 F1<B B:39 :3@@/1/69<9:/A306506/<D?49:/4/1;/B09:<?99:/4/ 7/012 @4<@/4 /506/1;/ 01 @4<<D <D 318 506/< 4/;<46/6 39 9:/A@<9=/4//506/1;/<D'6</A1<9@4<5/9:399:/ 3;;?A/6@/4A<1A34/01318B38;<1;/41/6B09:9:/6/39: <D9:/6/;/3A/6 - 75 - ' <4/<5/49:/4/0A37A<E?9/E81<=39/403E019:/ /506/1;/<D'9<@4<5/9:399:/3;;?A/6<<4318<D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A B3A @4/A/19 39 9:/ A@<9 316 39 9:/ 01A931;/<DA?;:3;;?A/69:/6/367<68<D9:/6/;/3A/6 B3A4/;<5/4/6D4<=9:/@E3;/09B3A3EE/2/6E87?40/6 * * 3EE3113 0A 9:/ 9:/1 /36 <1A937E/ <D ;<=@E301319 @<E0;/ A9390<1 A @/4 :0A /506/1;/ <1 "!# 3A @/4 9:/ 604/;90<1 <D 9:/ :/ B/19 9< 3E37?4320 316 D<?16 9:39 9:/ 34 7/34012 < +!+ B3A 39 93G0 A9316 01 098 7?A A9316 ?E73423 / A/0H/6 9:/ A306 34 D4<= " 316 B09: 9:/ 4/@<49 39 G :/ @4<6?;/6 9:/ A306 34 7/D<4/ 1 !!#3A@/49:/604/;90<1<D:/:36A:<B19:/ A@<9 <D 01;06/19 9< #"+%3236/53 //9:0 9:/ 1201//4 316 :/ 3EA< 940/6 9< 3@@4/:/16 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <" 316 * ?99:<A/3;;?A/6@/4A<1AB/4/1<9943;/6316:/1;/:/ 235/4/@<499<9:/4/23460129:/A3=/3A@/4G - 76 - D9:/3D<4/A306/506/1;/<D*0A93F/1019< ;<1A06/4390<1 09 0A ;E/34 9:39 :/ 3AA0A9/6 9:/ 01 9:/ 015/A902390<1 <D 9:/ ;3A/ ?9 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< =39/403ED<49:;<=012019://506/1;/<D*32301A9318 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9< ;<11/;9 9:/= 9< 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19<D9:/6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/6 <4/<5/4 " B:< B3A 6405/4 <D 9:/ 34 7/34012< +!+:3A9?41/6:<A90E/9<9:/;3A/<D @4<A/;?90<1 /1;/ /5/1 0D 9:/ /506/1;/ <D
* 0A 3;;/@9/63A94?/4/2346012A/0H?4/<D9:/A30634?1E/AA 9:/4/ 0A /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 D4<= 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 9< ;<11/;9 9:/ A306 34 9< 318 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 4/2346012 9:/ ;<==0AA0<1 <D 9:/ 3EE/2/6 <DD/1;/ 9:/ /506/1;/ <D * 0A 1< B38 :/E@D?E 9< 9:/ ;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 ! ! 3>/1643 0A9:/ 9:/1 <E0;/ <1A937E/<D ;<=@E301319 @<E0;/ A9390<1 A @/4 :0A /506/1;/ <1 &*!# :/ B3A 6/@?9/6 01 9:/ 6?98 <D B39;:012 9:/
- 77 -
6/36 7<68 316 <1 9:/ A3=/ 638 :/ 4/;/05/6 A:049 ?6?6343 316 4<@/ 39 9< D4<= 9:/ 6<;9<4 B:< ;<16?;9/6 9:/ @<A9 =<49/= 316 9:/4/3D9/4 @4<6?;/6 9:<A/ @4<@/490/A 7/D<4/ 9:/ 316 235/ 4/@<49 3A @/4 G! 1 '*!# :/ 3E<12 B09: :0543> 316 ! 0993E B3A 6/@?9/6 <1 6?98 D<4 3@@4/:/16012 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;;<46012E8 <1 **!# 0/ <1 9:/ 1/G9 638 9:/8 D<?16 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <& 316 ' 01
@E<31 50EE32/ 1/34 B39/4 931F 316 9:/8 344/A9/6 9:/= 316 @4<6?;/6 9:<A/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 7/D<4/ 316 235/ 4/@<49 3A @/4 G /1;/ 9:/ /506/1;/ <D ! 0A 4/2346012:0A3AA0A931;/9<019:/015/A902390<1<D9:/ ;3A/
://506/1;/<D!0A3EA<9:39:/@4<6?;/6 9:/ @4<@/490/A 39 9< 7/D<4/ 9:/ @<E0;/ 3D9/4 4/;/05012 9:/ A3=/ D4<= 9:/ 6<;9<4 B:< ;<16?;9/6 @<A9 =<49/=/G3=01390<1<D9:/6/367<68?9?1E/AA9:/4/0A 016/@/16/19/506/1;/D<49:;<=012D4<=9:/@4<A/;?90<19< @4<5/9:399:/9<B/4/D<?16<19:/6/367<68
- 78 -
316 9:/8 B/4/ 7/E<12012 9< 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <& 316 ' 34/ 01 318 B38 ;<11/;9/6 B09: 9:/ 6/39:<D9:/6/;/3A/69://506/1;/<D!0A011<B38 :/E@D?E9<9:/;3A/<D@4<A/;?90<1
# ! 343A01243<0A 9:/ 9:/1<E0;/ <1A937E/ <D9:/;<=@E301319@<E0;/A9390<1A@/4:0A/506/1;/<1 *!# :/ ;<EE/;9/6 9:/ 50A;/43 <4231A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6D4<=9:/6<;9<43169:4<?2:9:/8:/9<<F 9:/= 9< 32013:3EE0 1 !&!# :/ B/19 9< /123E?4?316<1!'!#:/235/9:<A/@4<@/490/A9< /19/4 /123E?4? 316 4/2346012 9:/ A3=/ :/ 235/ A939/=/197/D<4/9:/
" !! E03A :=/6 0A 9:/ 9:/1 ?7+050A0<13E 320A9439/A@/4:0A/506/1;/<19:/4/C?/A9<D<1 $*!#:/;<16?;9/69:/01C?/A9@31;:313=3<D9:/ 6/367<683A@/4G!316:/4/;<46/69:/A939/=/19A <D 316 # :/4/3D9/4 :/ A/19 9:/ 6/36 7<68 9< <5/41=/19 <A@093E 3E37?4320 D<4 @<A9 =<49/=
- 79 -
/G3=01390<1/2<993F/19:/@:<9<A<D9:/6/367<683A @/4G9<G"/06/190D0/69:/9<3A9:/ ;E<9:/?6?63433164<@/D<?16<19:/6/367<68316:/ ;<EE/;9/69:/=316A/199:/=9<9:/
$ <B/5/43A@<019/6<?9789:/E/341/6;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 01 9:/ ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !! 0A 9:39 39 9:/ 90=/ <D 01C?/A9 @31;:313=3 # & !
316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < B/4/ @4/A/19 / 606 1<9 93F/ 9:/ A939/=/19 <D 3;;?A/6 < 01 B409012 39 9:39 90=/ ?49:/4 09 0A 5/48 @/4901/199<1<9/9:399://506/1;/<D!!01:0A;4<AA+ /G3=01390<10A9:399:/:369:/F1<BE/62/<D9:/A306 A@<9 /34E0/4 9< 9:/ 9<<F :0= 9< 9:/ A@<9 <D 01;06/19 :/4/E/5319@<490<1019://506/1;/<D!!4/36A9:?A
&
;
#
$IH&
9 L())
& # )
&
+,%
1 o
;)
&
;
#
$&
9 L()
)m
(S$?%
<B
& :0A /506/1;/ <D !! B<?E6 D3EA0D8 9:/ ;<19/190<1<D9:/9:399:/3EE/2/6@E3;/B3AA:<B19<
- 80 -
:0= 78 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < :/4/D<4/ 9://506/1;/ <D 9:/ !! 316 <9:/4 ;<1;/41/6 @/4A<1A 4/2346012 /G943;9 <D 9:/6/367<68D4<=9:/7?40/6@E3;/B<?E6D3EA0D89:/;3A/ 9:399:/6/367<68B3A4/=<5/6D4<=9:/7?40/6@E3;/39 9:/01A931;/<D3;;?A/6<
' <B 09 0A 4/E/5319 9< 4/D/4 9< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !$ 4 3A353AB3=0 9:/ 6<;9<4 39 3632040 <5/41=/19 <A@093E B:< 0A 3EE/2/6 :35/ /G943;9/6 9:/ 7E<<6A3=@E/A<D316#3A@/49:/6<;?=/19A39 GA#"316#$4/A@/;905/E8:/7E<<6A3=@E/A<D 316 # B/4/ 93F/1 D<4 A?7>/;9012 9:/= 9< 9/A9 /1;/1<B090A4/E/53199<4/D/49<9://506/1;/<D!& 4 ?4?A:<993= B:< 0A 9:/ ;0/190D0; DD0;/4 <D /19/4/123E?4?:/!&0A3EE/2/69<:35/A?7>/;9/6 9:/A9/41?=316:?=/4?A7<1/A<D9:/6/;/3A/6;<EE/;9/6 789:/6<;9<4399:/90=/<D@<A9=<49/=/G3=01390<1
* A @/4 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !& 9:/ A/19 9:/ 7E<<6 A3=@E/A <D 316 # 316 9:/ A9/41?= 316
- 81 -
:?=<4<?A 7<1/A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 D<4
9/A9 ;;<46012E8 :/ A?7>/;9/6 9:/ A9/41?= 316 :?=<4<?A 7<1/A<D9:/6/;/3A/63169:/7E<<6A3=@E/A<D316 # 9< 9/A9 316 235/ 4/@<49 3A @/4 G## :/ GA#" 316 #$ 34/ 9:/ 06/190D0;390<1 D<4=A 316 9:/ GA#& 316 #' 34/ 9:/ D<4B346012 1<9/A <D 316 # 4/A@/;905/E8 / 06/190D0/6 9:/ A3=@E/ A/3E <D /19/4/123E?4?3A@/4G#*
! <B/5/43A@<019/6<?9789:/E/341/6;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 01 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA /G3=01390<1!&:3A6/@<A/69:399:/4/0A1<=/190<101 9:/6<;?=/1939G#*3A9<B:/19:/A306A/3EB3A@?9 D9://506/1;/<D!&01:0A;4<AA/G3=01390<10A93F/1 019< ;<1A06/4390<1 09 0A ;E/34 9:39 9:/ A9/41?= 316 1?=/4<?A 7<1/A <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 B/4/ 1<9 @4<@/4E8 ;<EE/;9/6316A/3E/6D<4A/160129:/A3=/D<49/A901 <46/49<=3F/<?93;E/34;3A/9:399:/4/B3A1<;:31;/<D 93=@/4012<D9:<A/A3=@E/A
- 82 -
! 9 0A 3EA< 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !& 01 ;4<AA+ /G3=01390<1 9:39 9:/ /G@/49 B3A 1<9 @4/A/19 39 9:/ 90=/<D;<EE/;90<1<D9:/A9/41?=316:?=<4<?A7<1/A<D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/ 4/E/5319 @<490<1 01 9:/ /506/1;/ <D !&01;4<AA+/G3=01390<14/36A9:?A
(&
;
<)
0
)
>S
(6, 8@=@ &
>4&
KP %
Lp
q
W(
g0
,
0
S
& %
<
&
; %
Lp
&
;
&
5 #(e;
J
@& i(
? %
<& @&
#0
&
;
6D &
'
T (
'=(r(s$!(;
@
4
!
<
&
5 q
W(
g0
&
'8@=@&
>&
KP%
Lp
? &
, <
>
)
0
%)&
0
dJ(7
%
<& @&
& (j
'(7&aN2/bB
!! :0A /506/1;/ <D !& B<?E6 A:<B 9:39 9:/ !& 36=09A 9:39 3A @/4 9:/ 9:/<48 9:/ /G@/49 A:<?E6 7/ @4/A/19 B:0E/ ;<EE/;9012 9:/ A3=@E/ D<4 A?7>/;90129:<A/A3=@E/A9<9/A9/1;//5/10D090A 3;;/@9/69:393A@/49:/4/@<4939G##9:/6/;/3A/60A @4<5/69<7/9:/70<E<20;3ED39:/4<D316#6<?79 340A/A 4/2346012 9:/ =/9:<6 01 B:0;: 9:/ ;<1;/41/6
- 83 -
A3=@E/AB/4/;<EE/;9/6D4<=9:/6/367<68D<4A?7>/;9012 9:/=9<9/A9
! ?49:/4 /5/1 0D 09 0A 93F/1 3A @4<5/6 9:39 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 0A 9:/ D39:/4 <D 316 # ?1E/AA 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 @4<5/A 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A F0613@@/6 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 ;<1A@04/6 9< ;3?A/ 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 9:/4/78 ;3?A/6 :0A 6/39: 1< ;3A/ ;31 7/ =36/ <?9 32301A99:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A<1E8<19:/73A0A<D/506/1;/ <D!&3169:/4/@<4939G##
!# <B 0D 9:/ /1904/ <43E 316 6<;?=/19348 /506/1;/ 0A A?==/6 ?@ 09 B<?E6 7/ ;E/34 9:39 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 < 9< " & 316 ' <4/<5/4 /5/1 9:<?2: 9:/ ;3A/ 0A 73A/6 <1 9:/ /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 3EE/2/6E8 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6<!7/D<4/'3A60A;?AA/6:/4/0137<5/B:0E/ 60A;?AA0129://506/1;/<D'09B<?E67/;E/349:399:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 9<E6 9:/ D3;9 4/2346012 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19 9<'?16/4019<G0;390<1<4/<5/49://506/1;/<D'
- 84 -
32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 0A C?09/ ;<194348 9< 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1;3A/:/3EE/2/6A939/=/19<D'7/D<4/9:/ @<E0;/0A6/10/678:0=01:0A;4<AA+/G3=01390<1316A3=/ 34/ 2<9 =34F/6 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A3A@/4GA316!:/':3A6/@<A/69:39 B:/1 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 3EE/2/6E8 9<E6 :0= 9:/ D3;9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! B3A ?16/4 019<G0;390<1 <D :35012 64?1F/1 3443;F
!" ?49:/4 01 9:/ /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA /G3=01390<1 ':3A6/@<A/69:399:/3;;?A/6<!6</A1<97/E<12 9< :0A 50EE32/ 316 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! 0A 7/E<12012 9< :39:13:3EE850EE32/:/4/E/5319@<490<1019://506/1;/ <D'4/36A9:?A
1
&(>
%
)(>
&
6
1
&(>
%
1
WAd)(>
& ) 1
WAd)(>
&
5# 6
%
<
)
0
?#)@&
) ) $<6
!$ :0A /506/1;/ <D ' B<?E6 A:<B 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <!
=02:9 1<9 :35/ ;<1D/AA/6 9< ' <D
- 85 -
;<==0990129:/3EE/2/6<DD/1;/?49:/4/5/19:<?2:' 01 :0A /506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 316#34/01;<4603E9/4=AB09::0=316:/?A/69< 50A099:/:<?A/<D316#9:/#01:0A/506/1;/ 01 ;4<AA+/G3=01390<1 :3A 6/@<A/6 9:39 /09:/4 :0=A/ED <4 :0AD39:/4:36318;<4603E4/E390<1A:0@B09:'/53@@3 < :0=34383 316 9:/8 606 1<9 50A09 9:/ :<?A/ <D ' 316 9:/ ' 3EA< 606 1<9 50A09 9:/04 :<?A/ D 9:/ 37<5/ 4/D/44/6 /506/1;/ 0A 93F/1 019< ;<1A06/4390<1 9:/4/ 34/ ;<194360;90<1A 4/2346012 9:/ D3;9 9:39 # 0A 01 ;<4603E 9/4=A B09: ' /1;/9:/;3A/ <D@4<A/;?90<1 9:39 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <!
;<1D/AA/6 9< ' 9:39 :/ 3E<12 B09: <9:/4 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A ;<==099/6 9:/ ;40=/ 316 9:39 E39/4 9:/ A306D3;9B3A9<E678'9<#0A1<9393EE7/E0/537E/ :/4/D<4/6<?79340A/A4/23460129:/@4<A/;?90<1/506/1;/ D<49:;<=012<14/;<46
!& ?49:/4 9:/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< 016/@/16/19 ;<44<7<439/ /506/1;/ 9< @4<5/ 9:/ A/0H?4/ <D 318 ;<1;/41/6 @4<@/490/A D4<= 9:/ @<AA/AA0<1 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6
- 86 -
<!316$4/23460129:/3EE/2/601;06/19A60A;?AA/6 :/4/01 37<5/ 9:/ ;<1;/41/6 016/@/16/19 =39/403E B091/AA/A:35/9?41/6:<A90E/9<9:/;3A/<D@4<A/;?90<1 1E8<19:/73A0A<D019/4/A9/69/A90=<18<D316# 3169://506/1;/<D'1<;3A/;317/=36/<?932301A9 9:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1AD<49:/<DD/1;/A;:342/6
!' A 60A;?AA/6 /34E0/4 09 0A ;E/34 9:39 9:/ /1904/ ;3A/ <D @4<A/;?90<1 0A 73A/6 <1 ;04;?=A931903E /506/1;/ 316:/1;/0D9:/4/340A/A3186<?794/2346012318<D9:/ E01FA 01 9:/ ;:301 <D ;04;?=A931;/A 9:/ 7/1/D09 <D A?;: 6<?79A:<?E67/205/101D35<?4<D9:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A9 0A 9:/ 7?46/1 <D @4<A/;?90<1 9< @4<5/ 7/8<16 4/3A<137E/ 6<?79 9:/ <DD/1;/A ;:342/6 32301A9 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A <4/<5/4 3A @<019/6 <?9 78 9:/ E/341/6 ;<?1A/E D<4 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A 9:/ <1.7E/ @/G <?49 01 9:/ ;3A/ <D 3B31 ?=34 :<?43A03 A 939/ <D 0:34 4/@<49/6 01 !!05/3B()*&:3A:/E69:39 K/1/43EE8 09 0A 3 B/3F @0/;/ <D /506/1;/ <B/5/4 3 ;<150;90<1 ;31 7/ A?A9301/6<1 9:/
- 87 -
73A0A <D /G943+>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 @4<506/6 9:39 9:/ ;<1D/AA0<1 0A @4<5/6 9< 9:/ 5<E?19348 316 94?9:D?E 9 A:<?E6 7/ D4// <D 318 016?;/=/19 :/ /506/190348 53E?/ <D A?;: ;<1D/AA0<1 3EA< 6/@/16A <1 9:/ @/4A<1 9< B:<= 09 0A =36/ <012789:/139?43E;<?4A/<D:?=31;<16?;9 1<4=3EE83@/4A<1B<?E6;<1D06/37<?93;40=/ ;<==099/6 78 :0= <1E8 B09: A?;: 3 @/4A<1 01 B:<=:/:3A0=@E0;09D309: <4=3EE83@/4A<1B<?E61<9=3F/3;<1D/AA0<1 9< A<=/<1/ B:< 0A 9<93EE8 3 A94312/4 9< :0= <4/<5/49:/<?49:3A9<7/A390AD0/6B09:9:/ 4/E0370E098<D9:/;<1D/AA0<1F//@0120150/B9:/ ;04;?=A931;/A01B:0;:090A=36/A3=399/4 <D4?E/;<44<7<4390<10A1<94/C?04/6<B/5/4 0D31/G943+>?60;03E;<1D/AA0<10A;<44<7<439/678 <9:/4 /506/1;/ <1 4/;<46 09 3;C?04/A =<4/ ;4/6070E098L
!* 1 9:/ ;3A/ <1 :316 9:/4/ 0A 1< ;<44<7<43905/ /506/1;/ 01 A?@@<49 <D /506/1;/ <D ' 4/2346012 9:/ 3EE/2/6 /G943>?60;03E ;<1D/AA0<1 <D 9:/ 3;;?A/6 <! :/ ;<150;90<1;311<97/4/;<46/632301A99:/3;;<?19<!
:/ ;<150;90<1;311<97/4/;<46/632301A99:/3;;<?19<! 316$3163EA<32301A9<9:/43;;?A/6@/4A<1A<1E8<19:/ 73A0A <D /506/1;/ <D ' :/4/ 0A 1< ;04;?=A931903E
- 88 -
/506/1;/ 9< @4<5/ 9:/ 3EE/2/6 =<905/ ?49:/4 9:/ @4<A/;?90<1 :3A D30E/6 9< @4<5/ B09: 9:/ A?@@<49 <D ;04;?=A931903E /506/1;/ 9:39 3EE 9:/ 3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A :39;:/6 318 ;<1A@043;8 9< ;3?A/ 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 316 F0613@@/6 :0= 316 9:/4/78 ;3?A/6 6/39: <D 9:/ 6/;/3A/6 :/4/ 0A 37A<E?9/E8 1< /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 D4<=9:/@4<A/;?90<19<;<11/;99:/3;;?A/6<9<"& 316'01318B389<9:/3EE/2/601;06/19?49:/4/5/19:/ /506/1;/D<49:;<=012<14/;<4632301A99:/3;;?A/6< !316$;4/39/A6<?79019:/=016<D9:/<?494/2346012 9:/ 3EE/2/6 01;06/19 /1;/9:/@4<A/;?90<1 :3AD30E/69< @4<5/ 7/8<16 4/3A<137E/ 6<?79 9:/ <DD/1;/A ;:342/6 32301A99:/3;;?A/6@/4A<1A019:/;3A/
/90;?E<?A;<1A06/4390<1<D9:/4/3A<1012<D9:/ 9403E<?49 01 9:/0=@?21/6 >?62=/19 B<?E6 ;E/34E8A:<B 9:399:/9403E<?49:3A;<1A06/4/6/3;:316/5/483A@/;9 <D <43E 316 6<;?=/19348 /506/1;/ D<49:;<=012 <1 4/;<46 01 @4<@/4 @/4A@/;905/ 316 9:/4/78 ;<44/;9E8 ;<=/ 9< 9:/ ;<1;E?A0<19:399:/@4<A/;?90<1:3AD30E/69<@4<5/7/8<16
- 89 -
4/3A<137E/6<?799:/<DD/1;/A;:342/32301A99:/3;;?A/6 @/4A<1A :/4/D<4/ 9:/ E/341/6 66E :3A D30E/6 9< =3F/ <?9 318 24<?16 9< 019/4D/4/ B09: 9:/ 0=@?21/6 >?62=/19 <D 9:/ 9403E <?49 01 9:/ 3@@/3E 316 9:/4/78 9< A/9 3A06/ 9:/ 0=@?21/6 >?62=/19 <1A/C?/19E8 B/ 34/ <D9:/;<1A06/4/650/B9:399:/0=@?21/6>?62=/196</A 1<9;3EED<4318019/4D/4/1;/399:/:316A<D9:0A<?4901 9:/ @4/A/19 3@@/3E /1;/ 9:/ 3@@/3E 0A E037E/ 9< 7/ 60A=0AA/6
19:/4/A?E9B/@4<;//69<@3AA9:/D<EE<B012
:/3@@/3E0A:/4/7860A=0AA/6
<1A/C?/19E8 9:/ ;<==<1 >?62=/19 639/6 !!$ 01 <$!" 316 <#*!"@3AA/6789:/0A940;9316/AA0<1A %?62/362040A:3EEA9316;<1D04=/6
- 90 -
/16 73;F 9:/ 9403E <?49 4/;<46A 3E<12 B09: ;<@8 <D 9:0A >?62=/19 9< 9:/ 9403E <?49 D<49:B09:
/* %!) #
/* %#$) #
0A9<E<$