Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43583 (KAR)

VINOD @ VINAYAK v. THE STATE

CRL.A/200003/2022 · 2025-09-12

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #"$"" "!! % &%'!()%(( )* "!! % &%'!()%(( "!! % &%'!()%(( ) * Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !" # !$%&! %&%& '&%& ( $) ) * & ** % ! !" # %&%& %'&%& !$%&! &%&$ ( $) - 3 - ) * * # % +),)&% !" # # $) - ,%& %&%& '&%& # - - 4 - $" - ./ 011/220345 63 7686302 11/02 9%%%%&% :/63; 0<<=5/> 95& 03> " 011/22034 63 7686302 11/02 9%%%%% :/63; 0<<=5/> 9 03> 011/22034 63 768630211/02 9%%"%&:/63;0<<=5/> 907/ 681=;363; 4./ <98893 ?=>;8/34 9@ <93A6<4693 >04/> %&%& 03> 97>/7 9@ 5/34/3</ >04/> %'&%& 1055/> 63 /55693 05/ 95!$%&! &%&$ 03> ,%& 93 4./ @62/ 9@ 4./ 2/073/> >>6469302 65476<4 /556935 =>;/ 020:=70;6 @97 5.974 B7602 9=74C <93A6<463; 4./8 @97 4./ 9@@/3</ 1=365.0:2/=3>/7 /<4693 $)9@3>603/3029>/@975.974BC03>5/34/3<63; 49=3>/7;976;979=5681765938/34@9701/769>9@!D/075 03>4910D@63/9@5)%%%+/0<.E64.>/@0=245/34/3</5 0<45 9@ 4./ <05/ 63 :76/@ 07/ 4.04 #"+4./ 63?=7/>29>;/>4./@675463@97804693E64.70.801=7926</ 404693 020:=70;6 0;06354 =3F39E3 1/75935 @97 4./ 9@@/3</1=365.0:2/=3>/7/<4693$)9@<<97>63;2D - 5 - 4./<08/ 49 :/7/;654/7/>63 768/ 9,!%&./ 63A/546;04693 E05 =3>/740F/3 =763; 4./ 63A/546;04693 0<<=5/> 95&49"E/7/0117/./3>/>03>4./@63027/1974 <08/ 49 :/ @62/> 0;06354 0<<=5/> 95& 49 ) ./ 47602 0;06354 0<<=5/> 9& E05 ./2> 63 9&%&$ 47602 0;063540<<=5/> 9E05./2>63 9,%&03>47602 0;06354 0<<=5/> 95 49 ) E05 ./2> 63 9!$%&! ./0<<=5/>011/07/>:/@97/4./76029=7412/0>/>394 ;=624D03><2068/>49:/476/> 9 179A/ 4./ ;=624 9@ 4./ 0<<=5/> 4./ 1795/<=4693 /G0863/> #5& 49 , ;94 807F/> G5& 49 &% 03> 6>/346@6/> 5& 03> 63 5=11974 9@ 645 <934/34693.650<<=5/>.0A/>/36/>0224./63<768630463; 804/76025 0A0620:2/ 93 7/<97> 63 4./67 5404/8/34 =3>/7 /<4693&9@7:=44./D.0A/3942/>03D/A6>/3</ 635=119749@4./67>/@/3</ " @4/7 40F63; 6349 <9356>/704693 022 4./5/ 804/76025937/<97>4./76029=74<08/494./<93<2=5693 4.04 4./ 1795/<=4693 65 5=<</55@=2 63 179A63; 4./ ;=624 9@ - 6 - 0<<=5/>:/D93>7/05930:2/>9=:403>0<<97>63;2D1055/> 4./ 681=;3/> ?=>;8/34 9@ <93A6<4693 03> 97>/7 9@ 5/34/3</@974./9@@/3</1=365.0:2/=3>/7/<46935$)9@ /63;0;;76/A/>:D4./508/0<<=5/> 95&49"07/ :/@97/4.659=74 )/07>7670>//1=8072/073/>86<=5=760/ @970<<=5/> 9760.034/5. /506<9=35/2@974./ 011/220345+0<<=5/> 95& 03> " 76 050A0263; 056 2/073/> <9=35/2 @97 4./ 011/22034+0<<=5/> 9 03> 76 9102 765.30 0>0A 2/073/> 6;. 9=74 9A/738/34 2/0>/7 @97 4./ 7/5193>/34+404/ /7=5/> 4./ 804/76025 63<2=>63;4./76029=747/<97>5 ' 3 A6/E 9@ 4./ 76A02 <934/346935 =7;/> :D 2/073/><9=35/2@97:94.4./10746/54./196344.04E9=2> 0765/@978D<9356>/70469365 - 7 - ! D 035E/7 49 4./ 0:9A/ 19634 65 63 4./ @974./@9229E63; , 4654./<934/346939@4./1795/<=46934.044./ 011/220345 :/63; 0<<=5/> 95& 49 " ./7/63 0293; E64. 0<<=5/> 9) <988644/> 79::/7D :D 5304<.63; 4./ ;92> <.063 @798 #" :D 0550=24/> .68 03> <0=5/> 63?=76/5 ./1795/<=4693/G0863/>#&+4./>9<497E.9/G0863/> 4./A6<468+#"03>655=/>E9=3></746@6<04/051/7G& #5 03> 07/ 4./ 1926</ 9@@6<6025 E.9 .0A/ 0117/./3>/> 0<<=5/> 95& 49 #" 65 4./ 63?=7/> A6<468 E.9 29>;/> 4./ @6754 63@978/> 03> >/195/> 0:9=4 4./ 63<6>/34 03> 5304<.63; 0E0D 9@ .65 ;92> <.063 / 6>/346@6/> 4./ 508/ 05 03> &+89:62/ .03> 5/4 9E/A/7 4.65 E643/55 .05 394 6>/346@6/> 03D 9@ 4./5/ 0<<=5/> 63 .65 /A6>/3</ #5) 03> ' 07/ 4./ 80.0H07 E643/55/5 49 G5) 03> '+5194 80.0H075 G!+65 4./ 5/6H=7/ 80.0H07 E./7/+=3>/7 4./ 89497<D<2/ E05 5/6H/> 04 4./ 635403</ 9@ 0<<=5/> 9 03> G,+65 4./ 5/6H=7/ - 8 - 80.0H07=3>/7E.6<.4./;92><.06303>89:62/.03>5/4 5& 03> E/7/ 7/<9A/7/> 04 4./ 635403</ 9@ 0<<=5/> 9& #! 65 4./ 1926</ 9@@6</7 E.9 0117/./3>/> 0<<=5/> 9" #,+65 4./ 3A/546;0463; @@6</7 E.9 7/;654/7/> 4./ 03> @62/> 4./ @6302 7/1974 0@4/7 63A/546;04693 $ ./ 804/76025 93 7/<97> >65<295/ 4.04 4./ 1795/<=4693655=<</55@=263179A63;4.04#"E0540F/3 @97<6:2D 03> .65 89:62/ .03> 5/4 03> ;92> <.063 E/7/ 79::/>:D@9=749@6A/1/7593534./63<6>/34#".05 5=54063/>63?=76/5058/34693/>634./E9=3></746@6<04/04 G& ./ <08/ 49 :/ 7/;654/7/> 0;06354 =3F39E3 1/7593535164/9@4.04394/546>/346@6<046931070>/E05 ./2> :D 4./ 3A/546;0463; @@6</7 93 0117/./3>63; 4./ 0<<=5/> #" .05 3/A/7 6>/346@6/> 03D 9@ 4./5/ 0<<=5/> /A/3 >=763; 47602 3>/7 5=<. <67<=85403</5 4./7/ 07/ 0:592=4/2D 39 804/76025 49 <933/<4 4./5/ 0<<=5/> 49 4./ 9@@/3</ 63 I=/54693 /3</ 4./ 0<<=5/> 07/ /34642/> @97 0<I=64402:D/G4/3>63;4./84./:/3/@649@>9=:4 - 9 - &% .0A/;93/4.79=;.4./681=;3/>?=>;8/349@ <93A6<469303>97>/79@5/34/3</1055/>:D4./76029=74 ./ 7602 9=74 .05 394 40F/3 6349 <9356>/704693 4./ @0<4 4.04 63?=7/> #" 3/A/7 6>/346@6/> 03D 9@ 4./ 0<<=5/> 4 .050259295456;.49@4./@0<44.04#"E.9506>49.0A/ 0<<981036/> #" 04 4./ 468/ 9@ 63<6>/34 E05 394 /G0863/> :/@97/ 4./ 7602 9=74 ./ 7/<9A/7D 80.0H07 E643/55/5#5)03>'.0A/4=73/>.95462/03>4./D.0A/ 394 5=11974/> 4./ <05/ 9@ 4./ 1795/<=4693 3>/7 5=<. <67<=85403</5 64 .05 179<//>/> 49 <93A6<4 4./ 0<<=5/> E64.9=4 03D 2/;02 /A6>/3</ ./7/@97/ 4./ 681=;3/> ?=>;8/349@<93A6<469303>97>/79@5/34/3</>1055/>:D 4./76029=7465260:2/49:/5/4056>/ && 3A6/E9@4./0:9A/035E/74./0:9A/19634 634./03>179<//>4910554./@9229E63; 6 ./768630211/02507/ - 10 - 66 ./ 681=;3/> ?=>;8/34 9@ <93A6<4693 >04/> %&%& 03> 97>/7 9@ 5/34/3</ >04/>%'&%&1055/>63/5569305/ 95!$%&! &%&$ 03> ,%& 93 4./ @62/ 9@ 4./ 2/073/> >>6469302 65476<4 /556935 =>;/ 020:=70;6 65 ./7/:D5/4056>/ 666 935/I=/342D011/2203450<<=5/> 95&49 "07/0<I=644/>@974./9@@/3</1=365.0:2/ =3>/7/<4693$)9@ 6A 062:93>9@4./0<<=5/>6@03D03>4.04 9@4./675=7/46/55.0225403><03</22/> A 63/089=346@03D>/19564/>:D0<<=5/> 65 97>/7/> 49 :/ 7/@=3>/> 49 4./8 0@4/7 011/02 1/769> 65 9A/7 93 >=/ 6>/346@6<04693 /;6547D 49 5/3>:0<F 4./ 76029=74 /<97>5 0293; E64.<91D9@4.65?=>;8/34@9763@9780469303>@973//>@=2 0<4693 Page Nos.10 and 11 are retyped and replaced vide Court order dated 25.09.2025 - 11 - /@97/ 107463; E64. 4./ 8044/7 4./ @//5 9@ 86<=5 =760/65@6G/>045&%%%%+ ./ 2/073/> >>6469302 /;654707 /3/702 65 >67/<4/> 4980F/3/</5507D07703;/8/345@9710D8/349@4./@//5 494./86<=5=760/ +) %""( $ 654 9&2 9&, Page Nos.10 and 11 are retyped and replaced vide Court order dated 25.09.2025