Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43581 (KAR)

SRI BASANAGOUDA @ BASAVANAGOUDA v. SRI PRAKASH AND ANR

MFA/200940/2022 · 2025-11-12

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$ %! & '!%! & '!#'$ # ! !%% ($) *+ ! !%% * + ! " " " # $!!%&!# ' Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (#)**+& " (#%***+ " , - !&*!*. ! , , !&! , , ' !*!*! / ' !#!*!+ ,' * + " 0 " ! - 3 - " " " # $!!%&!# ' (#)**+& , !- !#*)* , , !&! , ' !*!*! !#!*!+ ' , ' ,/ , ' 1' 1' ' ' 1' ! 2343 5663574 89:3; 3<=>?9 !&! ?@ ?=?; 32><734 <= !+%% 23;3>95@=3; ;3@3;;3: =? 54 A=23 <=/ 25B3 C339 @>73: CD =23 <75>E59= 59: 948;59<3 ?E659D <257739F>9F =23 G8:FE39= :5=3: !*!*! 65443: CD - 4 - 39>?; >B>7 '8:F3 59: 2?;568; >9 ?!#!*!+ ,5<=4 F>B>9F ;>43 =? =23 @>7>9F ?@ =23 566357 C;>3@7D 4=5=3: 5;3 =25= ?9 *.**!+ H239 =23 <75>E59= 59: 59?=23;H546;?<33:>9F?9E?=?;<D<73C35;>9F;3F>4=;5=>?9 ?"I#I)% =?H5;:4 ?45J?=3 =? "8;5E 5>7H5D 4=5=>?9 239 =23D ;35<23: 935; 25==5;52577> '89<=>?9 5= =25= =>E3 <5; C35;>9F ;3F>4=;5=>?9 ?"I *!I#*)&C3>9F:;>B39CD>=4:;>B3;5=52>F24633:59: >95;54259:93F7>F39=E5993;G8E63:=234>F957<5E3 @;?E ?66?4>=3 4>:3 59: :5423: =? =23 B32><73 ?@ =23 <75>E59= 4 5 ;3487= ?@ =23 5@?;345>: 5<<>:39= =23 <75>E59=484=5>93:F;>3B?84>9G8;>3459:H542?46>=57>K3: 23<75>E59=@>73:563=>=>?989:3;3<=>?9!))?@=23 <=433J>9F<?E63945=>?9=H546735:3:=25=234639= 4>F9>@><59=5E?89==?H5;:4E3:><573L639434<?9B3D59<3 <25;F34 59: ?=23; ;375=3: <?4=4 = H54 @8;=23; 6735:3: - 5 - =25= =23 5<<>:39= ?<<8;;3: 4?737D ?9 5<<?89= ?@ ;542 59: 93F7>F39=:;>B>9F?@=23?@@39:>9FB32><73CD>=4:;>B3; . 6?9 43;B><3 ?@ 9?=><3 =23 ;346?9:39= ?4! 59: 56635;3:=2;?8F2=23>;<?8943759:@>73:H;>==394=5=3E39= :39D>9F=235B3;E39=4E5:3>9=23<75>E63=>=>?9 # 9 =23 C54>4 ?@ =23 6735:>9F4 ?@ =23 65;=>34 =23 75>E4;>C8957@;5E3:=23>4483459:=23;35@=3;;3<?;:3: =23 3B>:39<3 23 ;>C8957 CD >E68F93: G8:FE39= 59: 5H5;:25465;=7D577?H3:=23<75>E63=>=>?959:237:=25= =23 <75>E59= >4 39=>=73: =? 5 <?E63945=>?9 ?@ 4!.%#*%I57?9FH>=2>9=3;34=5==23;5=3?@)M65 59: :>;3<=3: =23 948;59<3 ?E659D =? :36?4>= =23 <?E63945=>?9 5E?89= 57?9F H>=2 >9=3;34= 3>9F 5FF;>3B3:=236;3439=566357254C339@>73: ) 23 735;93: <?89437 @?; =23 <75>E59= 254 ;5>43: =23 @?77?H>9F<?9=39=>?94 5 ,>;4=7D =23 <75>E59= 5443;=4 =25= 23 H54 35;9>9F 4#***I63;E?9=2CDH?;J>9F54E57398;43>9?93D - 6 - 377 ?E659D =2;?8F2 ?8=4?8;<3;/4 5F39<D 377?F? 3;B><34 B= =: 59: 254 6;?:8<3: 4575;D <3;=>@><5=3 L& ?H3B3; =23 ;>C8957 254 3;;3: >9 =5J>9F =23 >9<?E354E3;37D544+***I63;E?9=2 C 3<?9:7D =23 <75>E59= 254 3L5E>93: =23 :?<=?; 54 I23;>C895789:3;B5783:=23<75>E59=14H2?73IC?:D :>45C>7>=D5=#M<?9=;5:><=>9F=233B>:39<3?@=23:?<=?; =25= =23 <75>E59= 48@@3;3: ))%%M 63;E5939= 65;=>57 62D4><57:>45C>7>=D83=?=23:>45C>7>=D=233E67?D3;254 ;3E?B3: =23 63=>=>?93; @;?E =23 43;B><3 59: 23 254 7?4= =23G?C < 54=7D :83 =? =23 5<<>:39= =23 <75>E59= 254 484=5>93:F;>3B?84>9G8;>343H54=;35=3:54>965=>39=@?; 5 63;>?: ?@ !# :5D4 B39 5@=3; :>4<25;F3 @;?E =23 2?46>=5723H549?=>956?4>=>?9=?:>4<25;F32>4;3F875; H?;J 3 254 48@@3;3: 7?= ?@ 65>9 :8;>9F =;35=E39= ?94>:3;>9F =23 45E3 =23 ?B3;577 <?E63945=>?9 5H5;:3: CD=23;>C8957>4?9=237?H3;4>:3 - 7 - >=2 =23 5C?B3 <?9=39=>?94 =23 735;93: <?89437 4?8F2==?577?H=23566357 & 9 =23 ?=23; 259: =23 735;93: <?89437 @?; =23 948;59<3 ?E659D 254 ;5>43: =23 @?77?H>9F <?89=3;I <?9=39=>?94 5 ,>;4=7D=235443;=>?9?@<75>E59==25=23H5435;9>9F 4#***I 63; E?9=2 ;3E5>94 8948C4=59=>5=3: :83 =? 75<J ?@ :?<8E39=5;D 3B>:39<3 3 254 6;?:8<3: 4575;D <3;=>@><5=3IL& C8= 254 9?= 3L5E>93: =23 58=2?; ?@ =23 :?<8E39=9=235C439<3?@6;??@?@>9<?E3=23;>C8957 2545443443:=23>9<?E3?@=23<75>E59=9?=>?9577D C 3<?9:7D=23<75>E59=2543L5E>93:=23?<=?;59: 23 254 :36?43: =25= =23 <75>E59= 254 48@@3;3: ))%%M 63;E5939= 65;=>57 :>45C>7>=D @ ?93 =2>;: >4 <?94>:3;3: >= <?E34=?M23;>C89572545443443:=23H2?73C?:D :>45C>7>=D54#M>4?9=232>F23;4>:3 < 54=7D <?94>:3;>9F =23 >9G8;>34 484=5>93: CD =23 <75>E59= 59: <?94>:3;>9F =23 5F3 59: 5B?<5=>?9 ?@ =23 <75>E59= =23 ?B3;577 <?E63945=>?9 5H5;:3: CD =23 - 8 - ;>C8957 >4 G84= 59: ;354?95C73 59: >= :?34 9?= H5;;59= >9=3;@3;39<3 >=2 =23 5C?B3 <?9=39=>?94 =23 735;93: <?89437 4?8F2==?:>4E>44=23566357 % 35;: =23 735;93: <?89437 @?; =23 65;=>34 59: 63;843:=23G8:FE39=59:5H5;:?@=23;>C8957 + = >4 9?= >9 :>468=3 =25= =23 <75>E59= 254 484=5>93: >9G8;>34>9=23;?5:=;5@@><5<<>:39=?<<8;;3:?9*.**!+ :83=?;54259:93F7>F39=:;>B>9F?@=23?@@39:>9FB32><73 CD>=4:;>B3; !* 23<75>E59=<75>E4=25=23H5435;9>9F4#***I 63; E?9=2 3 254 6;?:8<3: 4575;D <3;=>@><5=3IL& C8= 254 9?= 3L5E>93: =23 58=2?; ?@ =23 :?<8E39=4 59: 9? C59J ;3<?;:4 25B3 C339 6;?:8<3: ?94>:3;>9F 2>4 3:8<5=>?9 N857>@><5=>?9 54 < 8;4>9F 59: H?;J>9F 54 5 E573 4=5@@ 98;43 H3 5;3?@ =23 ?6>9>?9 =25= =23 E?9=27D >9<?E3?@=23<75>E59=<59C3<?94>:3;3:544!#***I - 9 - !! 463;H?89:<3;=>@><5=3=23<75>E59=254484=5>93: >9G8;>3454 65>9:3@?;E>=D?@H;>4=59:65>9:3@?;E>=D 59: :>45C>7>=D >9 E?B3E39= ?@ 73@= 2>6 59: H57J>9F 4>9<3 5<<>:39= 37?H 5;3 =23 7>4= ?@ >9G8;>34 48@@3;3: CD =23 <75>E59= ! >F2= :>4=57 ;5:>84 <?EE>98=3: >9=;5 5;=><875;@;5<=8;3 3@= @3E8; 59: 48C =;?<259=3;>< @;5<=8;3 H>=2 >9=3; =;?<259=3;>< 3L=>9<=>?9 5E?9F ?=23;>9G8;>34 ! 23 463<>@>< <543 ?@ =23 <75>E59= >4 =25= 23 H54 H?;J>9F 54 5 E573 4=5@@ 98;43 >9 ?93DH377 ?E659D =2;?8F259?8=4?8;<35F39<D83=?=23:>45C>7>=D23254 C339;3E?B3:@;?E=2343;B><3?94>:3;>9F=233B>:39<3 ?@=23:?<=?;=23<75>E59=/45F359:5B?<5=>?9H35;3?@ =23?6>9>?9=25==23H2?73C?:D:>45C>7>=D<59C35443443: 54.*M23<75>E59=>45F3:5C?8=+D35;45==23=>E3 ?@ =23 5<<>:39= 23 ;>C8957 254 ;>F2=7D 5443443: =23 E87=>67>3; 54 A!&/ 284 =23 <75>E59= >4 39=>=73: @?; - 10 - <?E63945=>?9 ?@ ," * 4!#***O!O!&O.*M ?9 5<<?89= ?@ 17?44 ?@ @8=8;3 >9<?E31 ! 23 95=8;3 ?@ >9G8;>34 >9:><5=34 =25= =23 <75>E59= E84=25B3C33989:3;;34=59:=;35=E39=@?;563;>?:?@ E?9=24 ?943N839=7D =23 <75>E59= >4 39=>=73: @?; <?E63945=>?9 ?@ ,* 4!#***O E?9=24 89:3;=23235:A7?44?@>9<?E3:8;>9F75>:8663;>?:/ !. 83 =? =23 5<<>:39= =23 <75>E59= 254 48@@3;3: F;>3B?84 >9G8;>34 59: 574? 89:3;F?93 48;F3;D 23 <75>E59=H542?46>=57>K3:5459>965=>39=@?;E?;3=259!# :5D4 >9 =23 2?46>=57 59: 48C43N839=7D ;3<3>B3: @8;=23; =;35=E39= ?94>:3;>9F =23 6;?7?9F3: 65>9 :8;>9F =;35=E39=54H37754=2363;E5939=:>45C>7>=D<3;=>@>3:CD =23:?<=?; H3 5;3 >9<7>93: =? 39259<3=23 <?E63945=>?9 5H5;:3: CD =23 ;>C8957 89:3; =23 235: ?@ 165>9 59: 48@@3;>9F41 @;?E 4!****I =? , * 59: 89:3; =23 235: ?@ 17?44 ?@ 5E39>=>341 @;?E 4!****I =? ,* - 11 - !# 7=2?8F2 =23 3B>:39<3 ?@ =23 :?<=?; 48FF34=4 =25= =23 <75>E59= ;3N8>;34 =? 89:3;F? ?93 E?;3 48;F3;D @?; ;3E?B57 ?@ >E6759=4 =23 <75>E59= 254 9?= 6;?B>:3: 59D 34=>E5=3@?;@8=8;348;F3;D?94>:3;>9F=2395=8;3?@=23 >9G8;>34 59: =23 3B>:39<3 ?@ =23 :?<=?; H3 5;3 ?@ =23 ?6>9>?9=25=1@8=8;3E3:><573L6394341254=?C35H5;:3: ,*59:=2>45E?89=:?349?=<5;;D59D>9=3;34= !) ?94>:3;>9F=2395=8;3?@>9G8;>34=23<?E63945=>?9 5H5;:3: CD =23 ;>C8957 89:3; ?=23; 235:4 >4 G84= 59: ;354?95C73 !& 284 =23 <75>E59= >4 39=>=73: =? =23 @?77?H>9F <?E63945=>?9 -./0,1230405/6 53/6/02/15, ,17165/5 892:/ 638401; (,) ,17165/5 892:3, 462 (,) 5>959:48@@3;>9F4 !**** )**** 3:><573L639434 <?9B3D59<398=;>=>?9 59:5==39:59=59:?=23; %*.)*% %*.)*% - 12 - >9<>:39=57<25;F34 ?44?@>9<?E3:8;>9F 75>:8663;>?: !%*** .#*** ?44?@5E39>=>347>@3 <?E@?;=459:3L63<=59<D ?@7>@3 !**** .**** ?44?@@8=8;3>9<?E3?9 5<<?89=?@63;E5939= :>45C>7>=D ).)** !.*** ,8=8;3E3:><573L639434 I #*** 21; "< < < < !% 9=23;3487==23@?77?H>9F?;:3;>465443: 5 23566357@>73:CD=23<75>E59=>41;;7/5 30.162 C 23566357@>73:CD=23948;59<3?E659D >453,-3,,/5 < 23 G8:FE39= ?@ =23 75>E4 ;>C8957 >4 E?:>@>3: - 13 - : 23 <75>E59= >4 39=>=73: =? 5 =?=57 <?E63945=>?9?@, < <* 3 23 948;59<3 ?E659D >4 :>;3<=3: =? :36?4>= =23 <?E63945=>?9 5E?89= 57?9F H>=2 >9=3;34= )M 65 @;?E =23 :5=3 ?@ @>7>9F ?@ =23 <75>E 63=>=>?9 =>77 =23 :5=3 ?@ ;357>K5=>?9 H>=2>9 5 63;>?: ?@ 4>L H33J4 @;?E =23 :5=3 ?@ ;3<3>6= ?@ <?6D ?@ =2>4 G8:FE39= ?H3B3; =23 <?E63945=>?9 5H5;:3:89:3;=23235:?@1@8=8;3E3:><57 3L6394341425779?=<5;;D59D>9=3;34= @ 23:36?4>=59:;373543?@5E?89=42577C3 E5:3>9=3;E4?@=235H5;:?@=23;>C8957 F 23 ;>C8957 >4 :>;3<=3: =? ;373543 =23 39=>;3 <?E63945=>?9 5E?89= >9 @5B?8; ?@ =23<75>E59=5@=3;:83B3;>@><5=>?9 - 14 - 2 E?89= >9 :36?4>= >4 ?;:3;3: =? C3 =;594@3;;3:=?=23;>C8957 !5* (%!) ' !5* (#'$ #) ' >4=?!7?..