- 1 - ! "# $"% " &"' ! "# $ %& #$ # # # # ! ' # # # # ! ( $ % $! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # # & ! " # $ ## & ) * ( # (+ # & , & & # & - $ & #( ' & - & $ & # ( ' - & $ # # # & #$ # ,, #,# ( ' # & # . . /$ % & # ./$ % & 0123241564716181790127035:;7<09=:224 #>?0@1290127035:;7<09=:2A60B0A4A4:70217324 2;7@;>12 >12C:731BB1 9012703 5:;7<09 =:2 20<B:7307A<:173 - 3 - 64<B0A4A4:74<=4903:7A60C2:;73A61A1BB019 =4903 ;7302 A60 1271A1@1 217<B12075D 47 #;?945 #2:5;20>07A< 5A +++ 2013 E4A6 ;90 + := A60 1271A1@1 217<B12075D 47 #;?945 #2:5;20>07A< ;90< 6020471=A02 20=02203 A: 1< F## 5AG 519947C 47 H;0<A4:7 20805A4:7 := A07302 := A60 B0A4A4:702 :7 A60 C2:;73 := 094C4?494AD 524A0241 E1< 7:A A1@07 :7 205:23 173 A07302 E1< 199:AA03 A: 20<B:7307A 7:( 30<B4A0 A60 B0A4A4:702 A2D47C A: =490 1BB019 1C147<A <143 :2302 ?0=:20 20<B:7307A 7: E6: 4< 1BB0991A0 1;A6:24AD 1< B02 A60 B2:I4<4:7<60E1<B20I07A03=2:>07A0247C47A:B20>4<0< ?D & 1< B02 A60 34205A4:7< := 20<B:7307A 7: 60 B0A4A4:7021AB121C21B67:61<A1@07<B054=455:7A07A4:7 A61A=15AA61A60613?007A::==450:=20<B:7307A7:A: =490 1BB019 ;7302 05A4:7 , := A60 ## 5A 6:E0I02 20<B:7307A 7: 343 7:A 199:E A60 B0A4A4:702 A: 07A02 A60 0<A1?94<6>07A:==450 <4A;1A0347 # 61@A471C12E6456 4< 59:<09D C;12303 ?D 07A219 73;<A2419 05;24AD &:250 &E6456=:2503A60B0A4A4:702A:<073A601BB019?D - 4 - # 6:;C6 A60 <1>0 E1< 20504I03 20<B:7307A 7: 3437:AA1@017D15A4:717347A60>017E6490E:2@:2302 61<?0074<<;0347=1I:;2:=20<B:7307A7:(55:2347C9D 60<:;C6AA:199:EA60B0A4A4:717334205A20<B:7307A7: A:5:7<4302A601BB019173B1<<1BB2:B241A0:2302< ( 0=;A47C A60 <;?>4<<4:7 := 9012703 5:;7<09 =:2 A60 B0A4A4:702 24 2;7@;>12 >12C;731BB1 9012703 5:;7<09 I060>07A9D 307403 1990C1A4:7< >130 1C147<A 20<B:7307A7:1AB121C21B67:47A:A:173<;?>4AA03 A61A B0A4A4:702 E1< 7:A B20I07A03 =2:> =4947C A60 1BB019 173 7:E A60 E:2@ :2302 61< ?007 4<<;03 47 =1I:;2 := 20<B:7307A7:(17347A600I07AE:2@:23024<<A1D034A E:;930==05AC07021A4:7:=0905A2454AD:E0I02A601BB019 E6456 61< ?007 <07A A62:;C6 # E:;93 ?0 5:7<430203 ?DA601BB0991A01;A6:24AD1731BB2:B241A0:2302<E:;93?0 B1<<03E4A647=:2A74C6A55:2347C9D60<:;C6AA:34<>4<< A60B0A4A4:7 ! 0123A6090127035:;7<09=:2?:A6B12A40<173 B02;<03A6007A420B1B02<:=E24AB0A4A4:7 - 5 - #121C21B67::=A60E24AB0A4A4:74<0JA215A03 ?09:E=:201<D20=020750. ! ! " #$#% & '"(( ) $$$ '"((* ### ! + , *"(- - . - / 0.-/1 " ! , ! *"(-2 , < B02 <;?>4<<4:7 := 9012703 5:;7<09 =:2 20<B:7307A<4=B0A4A4:702E1<7:AB20I07A03=2:>07A0247C A60 :==450 A6020 4< 7: 201<:7 =:2 64> A: <073 A60 1BB019 - 6 - A62:;C6 # 7A60<05425;><A1750<A64<:;2A4<:=A60 :B474:7 A61A A60 1BB019 ?047C 1 <A1A;A:2D 1BB019 ;7302 05A4:7 , := ## 5A 1BB09917A 1;A6:24AD 4< ?:;73 A: 5:7<4302 A60 1BB019 173 34<B:<0 :== A60 <1>0 7D 30I41A4:7 173 4<<;1750 := E:2@ :2302 47 61<A0 590129D <6:E< 12?4A212470<< := 1;A6:24AD A A60 <1>0 A4>0 4A <6:;937:A?09:<A<4C6AA61A #4<C07021A47C0905A2454AD 1735:7A47;:;<>147A071750:=E:2@4<20H;4203=:2E6456 A60A07302E1<519903 :7<430247C A60 <1>0 A64< :;2A 4< := A60 :B474:7A61AA60E:2@:23024<<;0347=1I:;2:=20<B:7307A 7:( ?0 @0BA 47 :?0D1750 A499 34<B:<19 := A60 1BB019 ?D 1BB0991A0 1;A6:24AD 40 20<B:7307A 7: <4750 A60 094C4?494AD 524A0241 =:2 199:A>07A := A07302 4< 519903 47 H;0<A4:7E64562013<1<;7302. 34564"7.*"3*)0(8*.89"8-1: " ! ! ; ! (;0(*.3691 - 7 - 3< : " = = * 6 = = + 0=*,-1. > &## ?*(;@# ,(;@# ?*(;$# > < * ## 4 03< 5-"1 0 ##; #; #; #;A #A;%1 " 5 B ##=C ) . ) 0C #D 12 = A6020 4< 17D 647321750< 47 C07021A4:7 := 0905A2454AD =:2 <6:2A := >147A071750 <B054194<03 <02I450< 47I:9I47C >056174519 E:2@< 4759;347C A60 E:2@ := K :;A470 #20I07A4I0 173 $201@3:E7 147A071750 := 499 0805A173947CD<A0> 1735:7I0D:2?09A:=<4L0 ,>> E43A6 := 74A , 173 M := 1456;2 602>19 #:E02 A1A4:7 # A60 0129402 12217C0>07A< B24:2 A: - 8 - A073027:A4=451A4:7?05:7A47;03A49934<B:<19:=A601BB019 ?DA601;A6:24A40< + BB0991A01;A6:24AD4<34205A03A:A1@01BB019:7 205:234<<;07:A450A:20<B:7307A7:(173A60305430A60 4<<;0 1=A02 C4I47C :BB:2A;74AD A: ?:A6 B12A40< E4A647 17 :;A0294>4A:=31D<=2:>A:31D 4A6 A60<0 :?<02I1A4:7< E24A B0A4A4:7 4< () &"' % % 4<A:. 9:.+