- 1 - !"! # $"%& $" ## '() % !"#$% & ' (' !"#$% ' &) %*%&%& + Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' ,' + ' + %,%"&%&% ' ! *&%$ ' + - +. - " - +. /01 233425 01 364746648 9: ;/4 <520=2>;2334552>; ?/@ 1A774648 2<<084>;25 0>BA6041 @> %%&%$ ?/4> /4 ?21 36@<4480>C @> 2 @;@6<:<54 94260>C 64C01;62;0@> @ !&#+!#,% 21 2 30550@> 60846 6A0146 443 94260>C@ !.!%*"?/0</<2=476@=;/4@33@10;4 8064<;0@> /0; 2C20>1; ;/4 1208 =@;@6<:<54 @> 2<<@A>; @7 ?/0</ ;/4 60846 @7 ;/4 =@;@6<:<54 1A<<A=948 ;@ ;/4 0>BA6041 1A1;20>48 2>8 ;/4 2334552>; /4640> 1A1;20>48 C604D@A10>BA6041 - 3 - & /4 2334552>; 364746648 @*&%$ 947@64 ;/4 609A>25 144E0>C <@=34>12;0@> @7 1&%%%%%%! /4 609A>25 2?26848 2 ;@;25 <@=34>12;0@>@7 1"&"%!?0;/0>;4641;2;;/462;4@7 $F32 /4 0>BA6: 1A774648 9: ;/4 <520=2>; 0> ;/4 2<<084>; 2>8 ;/4 5029050;: @7 ;/4 >1A62><4 @=32>:6413@>84>; @& ;@ 32: ;/4 <@=34>12;0@> 264 >@;0>1460@A18013A;421;/4>1A62><4 @=32>:/21>@; </2554>C48;/4BA8C=4>;2>82?268 ; 01 ;/4 <@>;4>;0@> @7 ;/4 5426>48 <@A>145 7@6 ;/4 2334552>; ;/2; ;/4 <@=34>12;0@> 2?26848 A>846 D260@A1 /4281 264 >@; 0> <@==4>1A62;4 ?0;/ ;/4 0>BA6041 1A1;20>489:;/4 2334552>;;/4609A>25/21>@;36@3465: <@>1084648 ;/4 =480<25 4G34>141 0><A6648 2>8 251@ 2?26848 541146 <@=34>12;0@> ;@?2681 5@11 @7 7A;A64 426>0>C1 <@>108460>C ;/4 7A><;0@>25 80129050;: 2; "F ?/46421 ;/4 2334552>; /21 1A1;20>48 7@A6 762<;A641 4 - 4 - ;/4647@64 1@AC/; ;@ 4>/2><4 ;/4 <@=34>12;0@> 2?26848 9:;/4609A>25 " /4 5426>48 <@A>145 2334260>C 7@6 6413@>84>; @& /21 <@>;4>848 ;/2; ;/4 609A>25 /2D0>C ;2E4> 0>;@ <@>108462;0@> 255 ;/4 6454D2>; =2;460251 2>8 23364<02;0>C ;/4 4D084><4 @> 64<@68 2?26848 2 BA1; 2>8 6421@>2954 <@=34>12;0@>;@;/4<520=2>;2>80;8@41>@;64HA0642>: =@8070<2;0@> <<@680>C5: /4 1@AC/; ;@ 801=011 ;/4 233425 $ /42334552>;014G2=0>4821+& +01;/4 8@<;@6?/@/21011A48;/40129050;: 46;070<2;4!G &2>8 1342E1 29@A; ;/4 80129050;: 1A774648 9: ;/4 2334552>; G1$ 2>8 , 264 ;/4 ?@A>8 <46;070<2;4 2>8 801</26C4 1A==26: G# 01 ;/4 01</26C4 268 G* 01 ;/4 /@130;259055125@>C?0;/*=480<2590551G%01;/4&" =480<25643@6;1 G01;/43641<603;0@>G&01;/4 2680@C62= 43@6;G2>8G*264;/4;/644G!62: 705=1G1$;@#264;/4643@6;12>854;;46011A489: ;/48@<;@6 - 5 - , /4=2;46025@>64<@6864D425;/2;;/42334552>; 1A1;20>48 8077A14 <4649625 484=2 762<;A64 @7 >2125 9@>4 762<;A64 @7 60C/; 0502< <641;!?0>C 762<;A64 1/27; @7 60C/; 74=A6762<;A64@72>8=4;2<26325547;/2>821?455 21 0>BA6041 ;@ /428 2>8 60C/; ;/0C/ G$ ?@A58 801<5@14;/2;;/464012 428!8077A14<4649625484=2 '2<4 ! >2125 9@>4 <@==0>A;48 762<;A64 @7 60C/; 0502< <641;!?0>C2>8 762<;A64@75@?4668'60C/;1346 ;/4 (!62: 643@6;1 ;/464 01 2 762<;A64 @7 60C/; 74=A6 2>8 547; /2>8 2>8 =4;2<26325 /4 8@<;@6 /21 @30>48 ;/2;0>BA6041;@"264C604D@A10>>2;A642>8$2>8,264 10=354 0> >2;A64 'A6;/46 21 346 G, ! 801</26C4 1A==26: ;/4 2334552>; ?21 28=0;;48 ;@ ;/4 /@130;25 @> %%&%$ 2>8 801</26C48 @> $%&%$ 2>8 2; ;/2; ;0=4 /4 ?21 802C>@148 7@6 8077A14 <4649625 @484=2 <@==0>A;48 762<;A64 60C/; 0502< <641;!?0>C 762<;A64 @7 5@?4668'60C/;762<;A641/27;@760C/;74=A6762<;A64 @72>8=4;2<26325/2>8'A6;/46G#I801</26C4 <268 1/@?1 ;/2; /4 ?21 @><4 2C20> 28=0;;48 @> - 6 - $%&%$ @3462;48 @> #%&%$ 2>8 801</26C48 @> &$%&%$ # /4 8@<;@6 /21 21141148 ;/4 80129050;: 2; &%F ;@;/4A334650=9/4609A>25;2E0>C0>;@<@>108462;0@> ;/4 80129050;: 21141148 9: ;/4 8@<;@6 @30>48 ;/2; ;/4 2334552>; /21 1A1;20>48 "F 80129050;: ;@ ;/4 ?/@54 9@8: 2D0>C 346A148 ;/4 =480<25 8@<A=4>;1 80129050;: <46;070<2;42>8;/44D084><4@7;/48@<;@62>8<@>108460>C ;/4 0>BA6041 04 762<;A641 1A1;20>48 9: ;/4 2334552>; ?4 264@7;/4<@>1084648D04?;/2;;/480129050;:;@;/4?/@54 9@8:<2>94211411482;%F0>1;428@7"F211411489: ;/4609A>25 * /4609A>25/212?2684821A=@7 1"&"%! ;@?2681 =480<25 4G34>141 ;2E0>C 0>;@ <@>108462;0@> G* I @130;25 0551 /4 5426>48 <@A>145 7@6 ;/4 2334552>;/21<@>;4>848;/2;0>72<;$=480<2590551?/0</ 264 36@8A<48 947@64 ;/4 609A>25 ?464 >@; ;2E4> 0>;@ <@>108462;0@> 9: ;/4 609A>25 2>8 ;/4649: ;/4 - 7 - <@=34>12;0@> 2?26848 ;@?2681 =480<25 4G34>141 01 @> ;/45@?461084 % +4 /2D4 346A148 ;/4 =2;46025 @> 64<@68 ?/4640>?470>8;/2;;/42334552>;/2136@8A<4829@A;$ =480<2590551/482;4@7=480<2590551<@66413@>8;@;/4 82;4 @7 2<<084>; /464 264 >@ 6421@>1 2110C>48 9: ;/4 609A>25 ;@ 801<268 ;/@14 =480<25 90551 2>8 2?268 @>5: 2 1A= @7 1"&"%! ;@?2681 =480<25 4G34>141 /464 01 >@ <@>;62 4D084><4 352<48 9: ;/4 6413@>84>;>1A62><4 <@=32>:;@1/@?;/2;;/4=4802590551?/0</26436@8A<48 9: ;/4 2334552>; 8@ >@; 0> 2>: ?2: <@66413@>8 ;@ ;/4 ;642;=4>; @9;20>48 9: /0= @> 2<<@A>; @7 ;/4 2<<084>; 0> HA41;0@>+4264;/4647@640><50>48;@2<<43;$=480<25 90551 36@8A<48 947@64 ;/4 609A>25 2=@A>;0>C ;@ 1""",! 6@A>848 @77 ;@ 1""%%%! ?/0</ 2=@A>; 2334552>; 01 4>;0;548 ;@?2681 =480<25 4G34>141 2>8 ;/4 1208 2=@A>; 0><5A841 2 1A= @7 1"&"%! 2?268489:;/4609A>25;@?2681=480<254G34>141 - 8 - @>108460>C ;/4 >2;A64 @7 0>BA6041 04 ;/4 762<;A6411A1;20>489:;/42334552>;21A=@7 1%%%%! 2?26848 ;@?2681 320> 2>8 1A77460>C 01 4>/2><48 ;@ 1#%%%%!1A=@7 1"%%%!2?26848;@?26817@@8 2>8 >@A601/=4>; 01 4>/2><48 ;@ 1&%%%%! 1A= @7 1"%%%! 42</ 2?26848 ;@?2681 2;;4>82>; </26C41 2>8 <@>D4:2><4 </26C41 264 4>/2><48 ;@ 1"%%%! 42</ 2>8 2 1A= @7 1%%%%! 2?26848 ;@?2681 5@11 @7 2=4>0;041 2>8 /2330>411 01 4>/2><48 ;@ 1&"%%%! 'A6;/4621A=@7 1&$&"%!012?26848;@?26815@11@7 0><@=48A60>C5208A33460@8 & /4 609A>25 /21 ;2E4> ;/4 0><@=4 @7 ;/4 2334552>;2; 1,%%%!346=@>;//42334552>;/21>@; 36@8A<48 2>: 4D084><4 ;@ 1/@? /01 0><@=4 @?4D46 ;2E0>C 0>;@ <@>108462;0@> ;/4 82;4 @7 2<<084>; 2>8 CA08450>41 011A48 9: ;/4 26>2;2E2 ;2;4 4C25 46D0<41 A;/@60;: ;/4 0><@=4 /21 ;@ 94 ;2E4> 2; 1#,"%! 21 2C20>1; 1,%%%!;2E4>9:;/4609A>25/42C4@7;/4 2334552>;940>C,:4261;/42336@3602;4=A5;03504601J"K - 9 - 4><4;/42334552>;014>;0;548;@21A=@7 1","%%! 1#,"%G&G"G%%% ;@?2681 5@11 @7 0><@=4 8A4 ;@ 7A><;0@>25 80129050;: 21 2C20>1; 1$%%%! 2?26848 9: ;/4609A>25 /4 8@<;@6 0> /01 4D084><4 /21 1;2;48 ;/2; ;/4 32;04>; 01 <@>;0>A0>C ;/4 ;642;=4>; @7 762<;A64 @7 1/27; 74=A660C/;?0;/762<;A64;0902&682>8@30>48;/4>448@7 4G34>80;A647@664=@D25@76@812>80=352>;@79@;/74=A6 2>8 ;0902 4 /21 1;2;48 ;/2; 2334552>; =2: 64HA064 2336@G0=2;45: 2 1A= @7 1"%%%%! 0><5A80>C =480<25 90551 /4 609A>25 /21 >@; 2?26848 2>: 2=@A>; ;@?2681 7A;A64 =480<25 4G34>141 > ;/4 72<;1 2>8 <06<A=1;2><41@7;/4<214?42640><50>48;@2?26821A= @7 1&"%%%! A>846 ;/4 1208 /428 4><4 ;/4 2334552>;<520=2>; 01 4>;0;548 7@6 2 ;@;25 <@=34>12;0@> @7 1"#,"%!21A>846 - 10 - " /4 <520=2>; 0> 255 01 4>;0;548 7@6 2 ;@;25 <@=34>12;0@> @7 1"#,"%! 21 2C20>1; 1"&"%! 2?26848 9: ;/4 609A>25 2>8 4>/2><48 <@=34>12;0@> @7 1$,"%%! 1/255 <266: 0>;4641; 2; ;/4 62;4 @7 $F 346 2>>A=76@=;/482;4@734;0;0@>;05564250L2;0@> 5 @ 4281 ?2689:;/4 609A>25 ?268489:;/4 0C/ @A6; @11@77A;A64426>0>C :609A>25 ,%%%G&G"G"F : 0C/ @A6; #,"%G&G"G%F 1$%%%! 1","%%! & 20>2>81A77460>C 1%%%%! 1#%%%%! 480<254G34>141 1"&"%! 1""%%%! 'A;A64 =480<25 4G34>14 !! 1&"%%%! " '@@8 2>8 >@A601/=4>; 1"%%%! 1&%%%%! $ ;;4>82>;</26C41 1"%%%! 1"%%%! , @>D4:2><4</26C41 1"%%%! 1"%%%! # @11@72=4>0;0412>8 /2330>411 1%%%%! 1&"%%%! * @11@70><@=48A60>C 5208A33460@8 !! 1&$&"%! *+, - . - . >/2><48 <@=34>12;0@> -/0 . - 11 - $ <<@680>C5:?43211;/47@55@?0>C 0 /423342501 00 /4BA8C=4>;2>82?26882;48%,%"&%&% 0> @*&%$3211489:;/4 @A6; @7 885 4>0@6 0D05 A8C4 2>8 !(0B2:23A6201=@807048 000 /42334552>;<520=2>;014>;0;5487@62;@;25 <@=34>12;0@> @7 1"#,"%! 21 2C20>1; 1"&"%! 2?26848 9: ;/4 609A>25 2>8 4>/2><48 <@=34>12;0@> @7 1$,%%! 1/255 <266: 0>;4641; 2; ;/4 62;4 @7 $F 346 2>>A= 76@= ;/4 82;4 @7 34;0;0@> ;055 64250L2;0@> 0D /4 &>8 6413@>84>; I >1A62><4 <@=32>: 1/255843@10;;/42=@A>;?0;/0>23460@8@7 10G ?44E1 72050>C ?/0</ ;/4 2=@A>; 1/255 <266:8472A5;0>;4641;2;*F3462>>A= - 12 - D /4;6025 @A6;64<@6811/25594;62>1=0;;48 ;@;/4609A>257@6;/?0;/ 1. '%&) " 1. ') " 262@1;@$ 262@1,;@" 01;@5@