- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %!& '( $$ ) *%!& ' ( ! " #! $ ! % ! ! ! ! & ! ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &! " # ' ( &!&)! & $ ' ' %#$ ' !' ' * !& ! & * ! & ' !+ &% +&& ! && &&& , '* ! ) ' * ( ! ! & ! ! ''' '' & ! " # $ - 3 - ! ( ! ! ) ! +! " #! ' !&! & $ ' ' %#$ ' ' ! & !& ! & * ( * ! & !& ! & * ( ' * ! ' * -* - 4 - # #-* $ ' .! &&%+ & /0 1/234 56 783 9::3229;7 <29/=9;7 >;43? 3<7/.; %#$ .1 .7.? 38/<230 <7 ,<89223;@/;@ 783A>4@=3;7 9;49B9?4 /;.! & 49734!& ! & :9003456783 3;/.? /C/2 *>4@3 ( 8/779:>? 7. =.4/16 9;4 3;89;<3783<.=:3;097/.;!'.! &&,%& & /01/234 567831.?0377/;@90/4378309/4A>4@=3;7! ! 83 ?9;D0 .1 783 :9?7/30 9?3 ?379/;34 90 :3? 7837?/5>;921.?78309D3.1<.;C3;/3;<3! !39?47839?@>=3;70.1783239?;34<.>;0321.? 783 9::3229;7 <29/=9;7 9;4 239?;34 <.>;032 1.? ?30:.;43;7 .0! 9;4 ! .7/<3 7. ?30:.;43;7 .! /0 4/0:3;034B/78! +! 83 /;A>?34 <29/=9;7 9@34 & 639?0 4./;@ 9@?/<>27>?3 B.?D =37 B/78 9; 9<</43;7 .; &+! ! &% 9;4 1/234 <29/= :37/7/.; <29/=/;@ <.=:3;097/.; .1 - 5 - 0! && &&& B/78 /;73?307! 83 7?/5>;92 <.;0/43?/;@ 783 3;7/?3 3C/43;<3 .; ?3<.?4 @?9;734 9; 9=.>;7 .1 0!+ &% +&& B/78/;73?30797783?973.1)E:!9!1?.= 4973.1:37/7/.;7/224973.143:.0/7! !@@?/3C34B/7878309/4.?43? /;A>?34<29/=9;7 1/2349::392/;'!.! &&%+ & 9;4<.;73;4347897 83B9039?;/;@0!& &&& :3?=.;78 5>77837?/5>;92 890 79D3; .;26 0! &&& ! 83 4.<7.? 90030034 783 4/095/2/7690&E 5>77837?/5>;9289079D3;.;26+&E! 83 9=.>;7 @?9;734 >;43? 783 .783?83940 9?3 =39@3? 9;4/;73?307;33407.533;89;<34! )! 83 /;0>?9;<3 <.=:9;6 920. :?313??34 9;.783? 9::392/;'.! &&&,%& & 9@9/;0778309=39B9?4 9;47836<.;73;43478977839<</43;7.<<>??34/08394.; <.22>0/.;537B33;7B.C38/<230!30:.;43;7.!890;.7 =943783.B;3?9;4/;0>?3?.1783=.7.?<6<2390:9?7/30 7. 783 <29/= :37/7/.;! 9;4 /7 /0 594 1.? ;.;A./;43? .1 ;3<3009?6 :9?7/30! 30:.;43;7 .! B8. B90 ?/4/;@ 783 =.7.?<6<23 /; 9 ?908 9;4 ;3@2/@3;7 =9;;3? B/78.>7 - 6 - .503?C/;@ 9;6 /;4/<97/.;0 <9=3 /; 9 F/@F9@ =9;;3? B/78.>71.22.B/;@7837?911/<?>2309;44908347835>0!0 :3? G!% '/;92 ?3:.?7 ;.;3 .1 783 :9003;@3?0 /; 783 5>00>079/;349;6/;A>?/30!00><8 /7<9;53:?30>=34 7897 783?3 /0 ;. ;3@2/@3;<3 .; 783 :9?7 .1 783 4?/C3? .1 783 5>0! 83 4?/C3? .1 783 5>0 079734 7897 783 9<</43;7 .<<>??34 .;26 4>3 7. 783 ;3@2/@3;<3 .1 783 =.7.?<6<2/07 5>7 19203 <903 /0 ?3@/073?34 9@9/;07 783 4?/C3?.17835>0!30:.;43;7.!B90;.789C/;@C92/4 4?/C/;@ 2/<3;03 9;4 9<</43;7 .<<>??34 .;26 4>3 7. 8/0 ;3@2/@3;<3! %! G! 929?6 02/: /0 ;.7 9; 9>783;7/<9734 4.<>=3;7 900><8 ;.7/.;92/;<.=3/07.53<.;0/43?34! 83 4.<7.? 90030034 783 8/@83? :3?<3;79@3 .1 4/095/2/76 9;4 /7 ;3340 7. 53 ?34><34! 0 :3? G!) .>;4 <3?7/1/<973:37/7/.;3?0>079/;341?9<7>?3.1?/@87=/408917 13=>? 9;4 2.B3? 3;4 7/5/9 9;4 1?9<7>?3 .1 2.B3? 3;4 .1 ?/@87?94/>0!83:37/7/.;3?0>079/;341?9<7>?3/;A>?/3090 :3? B.>;4 <3?7/1/<973 9;4 90 :3? 783 4/0<89?@3 <9?4! - 7 - ;43?G! 4/0<89?@3<9?4 830>079/;34'?9<7>?3.1783 =/408917 .1 783 ?/@87 13=>? 9;4 1?9<7>?3 .1 783 2.B3? 3;4 .1 783 ?/@87 ?94/>0! 4.<7.? 90030034 783 4/095/2/76 9;4 /00>34 G! 4/095/2/76 <3?7/1/<973! 83 4.<7.?1>?783?0797347897783D;33A./;7=.C3=3;709?3 ?307?/<734 9;D23 =.C3=3;70 9?3 ?307?/<734 4/11/<>276 /; 0H>977/;@ 9;4 <?.0023@@34! 20. 13=>? ?/@870/43B/78 /=:29;7 /; 0/73 1?9<7>?3 2.B3? ?4 7/5/9 9;4 1/5>29 =9223;3.>0 :?303;7! 3 90030034 783 7.792 :860/<92 /=:9/?=3;790&E 5>77837?/5>;92890<.;0/43?34783 4/095/2/7690+&E! ! 39?;34 <.>;032 1.? 783 /;0>?9;<3 <.=:9;6 07973478977834/095/2/76<.;0/43?34567837?/5>;92/0.; 7838/@83?0/439;4;33407.53?34><34!83?390 783 <29/=9;7 ?3H>30734 7. 3;89;<3 783 09=3 7. &E 90 9003003456783.<7.?! ?4.1783&E<.=307.%E 78/0<.>?71/;40/7?390.;95237.<.;0/43?7834/095/2/7690 %E! - 8 - ,!839@3.1783:37/7/.;3?/0)&!3B90B.?D/;@ 90 9; 323<7?/</9; 9;4 1>?783? 079734 7897 83 B90 920. 39?;/;@ 0!) && &&& :!9! 1?.= 9@?/<>27>?3! 3 1/234 0929?6 02/: >;43? G! 9;4 <.;7?9<7 .1 23<7?/<92 .;7?9<7.?09;4<.123<7?/<92.;7?9<7.?/<3;03>;43? G! !83?/5>;92<.;0/43?/;@7833;7/?33C/43;<39;4 .783? 4.<>=3;70 890 79D3; 8/0 /;<.=3 90 0! &&& :3? =.;78! 8/0 .>?7 1/;40 ;. ?390.; 7. /;73?13?3B/78 783 09/4 .?43?! 3;<3 2.00 .1 1>7>?3 39?;/;@ <9:9</76 <.=307.0! &&&G G)G%EI+,)*-' 83 7?/5>;92 @?9;734 +,,' 1.? =34/<92 3G:3;0309;4/7;3340;./;73?13?3;<3!3B90/;:97/3;7 1.? + 4960 90 :3? G! 7. G!&! .;0/43?/;@ 783 ;97>?3 .1 /;A>?/30 :3?/.4 .1 8.0:/792/097/.; 9;4 .783? ?323C9;7 19<70 78/0 <.>?7 1/;40 /7?390.;9523 7. @?9;79; 9=.>;7 .1 +- 1.? :9/; 9;4 0>113?/;@ +, 1.? 2.00 .1 9=3;/7/30 +' 1.? 7?9;0:.?797/.; 3G7?9 ;.>?/08=3;7 9;4 9773;49;7 <89?@30! 83 :37/7/.;3? =/@87 ;.7 89C3 9773;434 9;6 .783?B.?D97239071.?9:3?/.4.1+=.;780!83?31.?3 - 9 - &&&G+ I +' >;43? 783 8394 2.00 .1 39?;/;@4>?/;@29/4>::3?/.4! &!8>0/;922 <.=:.;3;709B9?4345678/0<.>?7 9?390532.B 3;<3 783 9::3229;7<29/=9;7 /0 3;7/7234 1.? 7.792 <.=:3;097/.; .1 +) -' 92.;@ B/78 /;73?307 97 783?973.1)E:!9! /;07394.10!+ &% +&& 90@?9;734 567837?/5>;92! 9?7/<>29?0 =.>;7 /;0! .00 .1 1>7>?3 39?;/;@ <9:9</76 ,)*- 34/<923G:3;030 ,, 9/;9;40>113?/;@ - .00.19=3;/7/30 , ?9;0:.?797/.; 3G7?9 ;.>?/08=3;7 9;4 9773;49;7<89?@30 .00.1/;<.=34>?/;@29/4 >::3?/.4 ./0 ) - - 10 - ! ;783?30>27 7831.22.B/;@.?43?/0:90034 /! .789::39209?3 /;:9?7! //! 83 A>4@=3;7 9;4 9B9?4 /; .! & 49734!& ! & :90034 56 783 3;/.? /C/2 *>4@3 ( 8/779:>? /0=.4/1/34! ///! 83 <29/=9;7 /0 3;7/7234 7. 9 0>= .1 +) -' 92.;@ B/78 /;73?30797 )E :!9! 1?.=7834973.1:37/7/.;7/227834973 .1 ?392/F97/.; /;07394 .1 0!+ &% +&& @?9;734567837?/5>;92! /C! 83/;0>?9;<3<.=:9;643:.0/734&E.1 783 <.=:3;097/.; 531.?3 783 7?/5>;92! 836 9?3 4/?3<734 7. 43:.0/7 783 5929;<3 9=.>;792.;@B/78/;73?3079<<?>34.;783 09=3 B/78/;.;3=.;781?.=7834973.1 78/0.?43?.;0><843:.0/70! - 11 - C! ; 0><8 43:.0/7 <29/=9;70 9?3:3?=/7734 7.B/784?9B7833;7/?39=.>;792.;@B/78 /;73?3079<<?>34.;78309=3! +1' %$& # /07.!2.!+)