- 1 - ! "# $ % & && '#( ) !! " # $ ! % !! & % ' !(! " # ) &!!(( ! % $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !*&#!$ % % (!(( ' +*(( % , , - % ! ./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 9.3 :41/;1<9 1=1/<09 9.3 >6=;3<9 1<6 1?1@6 61936 (!(( 210036 /< A+*(( 78 9.3 66/9/A<14 3</A@ /B/4 >6=3 1<6 ' 19 /C1812>@1 #5A@ 0.A@9 D9.3 9@/7><14E$ 033F/<= 3<.1<:3;3<9A59.3:A;23<019/A< .3 :41/;1<9 ;39 ?/9. 1::/63<9 A< (!(!(( ?./43 .3 ?10 2@A:336/<= A< 9.3 ;A9A@:8:43 1<6 0>091/<36 =@/3BA>0 /<C>@/30 3 5/436 :41/; 239/9/A< 033F/<= :A;23<019/A< A5 0!((((( 14A<= ?/9. /<93@309 19 9.3 @193 A5 !G 23@ 1<<>; .3 9@/7><14 1593@ :A<0/63@/<= 9.3 3<9/@33B/63<:3A<@3:A@61?1@63610>;A50!(+ 14A<= ?/9. /<93@309 19 9.3 @193 A5 G 23@ 1<<>; 5@A; 9.3 - 3 - 6193A5239/9/A<9/449.36193A5@314/H19/A<==@/3B36789.3 01/6>6=;3<91<61?1@69.3:41/;1<92@353@@369.32@303<9 122314033F/<=3<.1<:3;3<9A59.3:A;23<019/A< & 31@<36 :A><034 5A@ 9.3 :41/;1<9 0>7;/90 9.19 9.3 :41/;1<9 0>091/<36 .316 /<C>@8 5@1:9>@3 A5 4359 6/0914 53;>@435A@95@1:9>@31I/441?/9.<10147A<3 3?10 16;/9936 /< 9.3 A02/914 A< (!(!(( 1<6 6/0:.1@=36 A< ((!(( .3 A:9A@ 10030036 9.3 6/017/4/98 19 ( G 9A 9.3 4359 4A?3@ 4/;7 1<6 9.3 9@/7><14 .10 91F3< A<48 *G 6/017/4/98 >@9.3@ .3 0>7;/90 9.19 9.3 1;A><90 =@1<936 ><63@ 9.3 A9.3@ .3160 1@3 140A A< 4A?3@ 0/63 1<6 .3<:3 @3J>30909A3<.1<:39.3:A;23<019/A< .3 :41/;1<9 ?10 1=36 &( 831@0 1<6 ?10 6A/<= 1=@/:>49>@3<9.3:41/;239/9/A</9?100919369.19.3?10 31@</<= 1 0>; A5 0(((( 23@ ;A<9. 7>9 .3 .10 <A9 2@A6>:36 1<8 /<:A;3 2@AA5 .3 9@/7><14 :A<0/63@/<= 9.3 :.1@9 2@321@36 78 9.3 1@<191F1 9193 3=14 3@B/:30 >9.A@/98 .10 91F3< 9.3 /<:A;3 A5 9.3 :41/;1<9 19 0!&*( 5A@ 9.3 831@ (( 3<:3 9.3 9@/7><14 .10 - 4 - @/=.948 91F3< 9.3 /<:A;3 A5 9.3 :41/;1<9 1<6 /9 <3360 <A /<93@53@3<:3 % 9.3 A:9A@ 10030036 6/017/4/98 ><63@ I!(6/0174/98:3@9/5/:1931<6100300369.36/017/4/9819( G023@9.36/017/4/98:3@9/5/:1939.3:41/;1<90>091/<36 .316 /<C>@8 5@1:9>@3 A5 4359 6/0914 53;>@ 435A@9 5@1:9>@3 1I/441 ?/9. <1014 7A<3 3<:3 9./0 A>@9 5/<60 /9 @310A<17439A91F39.36/017/4/9819!(G.34A00A55>9>@3 31@</<=:121:/9810><63@, 0!&*('!'!'!(GK0*(( .39@/7><14.101?1@63610>;A50!((++ 9A?1@60 ;36/:14 3I23<030 3<:3 9.3 01;3 <3360 <A /<93@53@3<:3 A<0/63@/<= 9.3 <19>@3 A5 /<C>@/30 23@/A6 A5 .A02/914/H19/A<1<6A9.3@@343B1<951:9A@09./0A>@95/<60/9 @310A<17439A1?1@610>;A50((((9A?1@6021/<1<6 0>553@/<=0 0((( 9A?1@60 4A00 A5 1;3</9/30 1<6 0&(((( 9A?1@60 9@1<02A@919/A< 3I9@1 <A>@/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1@=30 .3 :41/;1<9 ;/=.9 .1B3 <A9 1993<636 1<8A9.3@?A@F5A@19431095A>@;A<9.0 3<:3.3/03<9/943 9A10>;A50(((#0!&*(';A<9.0$><63@9.3 - 5 - .316A54A00A5/<:A;36>@/<=41/6>223@/A6 3<:39.39A914 :A;23<019/A</010><63@, * +,-./01+2.,342 0523 ! A00A531@</<=:121:/98 0*(( 36/:143I23<030 0!((++ & 1/<1<60>553@/<= 0(((( A00A51;3</9/30 0((( @1<02A@919/A< 3I9@1 <A>@/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1@=30 0&(((( A00 A5 /<:A;3 6>@/<= 41/6 >2 23@/A6 0((( 3,* .6 7 31@<36 :A><034 5A@ 9.3 <0>@1<:3 :A;21<8 0>7;/909.199.31;A><91?1@636789.39@/7><14.10733< 14@3168632A0/936735A@39.39@/7><1414A<=?/9./<93@309 * /<:39.3@/63@A59.3;A9A@:8:43/0<A9.1B/<= 9.3 9@/7><14 .10 A@63@36 5A@ 218 1<6 @3:AB3@8 1=1/<09 <0>@1<:3 :A;21<8 1<6 9.3 B/3? 91F3< 78 9.3 9@/7><14 /0 :A@@3:91<6<3360<A/<93@53@3<:3 ::A@6/<=489.35A44A?/<=A@63@, #/$ .3122314/0144A?36/<21@9) - 6 - #//$ .3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 9A 9A914 :A;23<019/A<A50*++14A<=?/9./<93@309 199.3@193A5 G23@1<<>;5@A;9.36193239/9/A< 9/449.36193A5@314/H19/A<101=1/<090!(+ 1?1@636789.39@/7><14) #///$ .3 <0>@1<:3 :A;21<8 /0 6/@3:936 9A 632A0/9 9.3 3<.1<:36 :A;23<019/A< A5 0!& *(14A<=?/9./<93@309?/9./<A<3;A<9. 5@A;9.36193A59./0A@63@) #/B$ < 0>:. 632A0/9 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 23@;/9936 9A ?/9.6@1? 9.3 1;A><9 14A<= ?/9. /<93@3091::@>36A</9 #B$ .3 <0>@1<:3:A;21<8 /019 4/73@98 9A @3:AB3@ 9.3 :A;23<019/A< 5@A; 9.3 A?<3@ A5 9.3 B3./:43 .-7 '& ( % /09 A,!4 A,*