- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( ! " #$ $ % $ $ ! ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ' ' ( $ ) '' ! " #$ $' ( &* ! ! &!& % '( ( #% ( ' ' ' $ $'( ' &+!&!& $ ' ' $ ' +&&!&! ' ( ' ' ,$' # -./ 011203 ./ 4.325 67 8-2 .9:;<25 =30.>098 0?0.9/88-2:;5?>2980950@0<550825&+ ! &!&10//25 67 8-2 55.8.A903 29.A< .B.3 ;5?2 095 '2>62< ' .:0701;<0 C4A< /-A<8 D <.6;903EF .9 ' A +&&!&!/22G.9?29-09=2>298A4=A>129/08.A9 - 3 - & -2 .9:;<25 =30.>098 0?25 ! 720</ >28 @.8- 09 0==.5298 A9 ! ! &!&! 095 /;/80.925 ?<.2BA;/ .9:;<.2/ 2 4.325 0 =30.> 128.8.A9 624A<2 8-2 <.6;903 /22G.9? =A>129/08.A9 A4 / !!!!!! -2 <.6;903 0482< =A9/.52<.9? 8-2 298.<2 2B.529=2 A9 <2=A<5 0@0<525 8-2=A>129/08.A9A4 / !!@.8-.982<2/808 H12< 099;> 4<A> 8-2 5082 A4 128.8.A9 8.33 <203.I08.A9 095 5.<2=825<2/1A95298A &9/;<09=2A>10978A521A/.8 8-2=A>129/08.A9088-24.</8.9/809=2<2/2<B.9?3.62<878A <2=AB2< 8-2 /0>2 4<A> <2/1A95298 A .9 0==A<509=2 @.8-30@ ??<.2B25 67 8-2 /0.5 0@0<5 8-2 011233098 =30.>098-0/1<242<<258-./011203>0.937=A98295.9?8-08 8-2=30.>098/;/80.9254<0=8;<2A4<.?-88.6.00954.6;30095 A8-2< .9:;<.2/ .9 8-2 0==.5298 095 8-A;?- -2 /1298 -;?2 0>A;98 4A< 8<208>298 -2 /;442<25 H 12<>09298 5./06.3.87 0/ 12< J K ./06.3.87 2<8.4.=082 6;8 8-2 <.6;903=A9/.52<258-25./06.3.87A93708H8A8-2@-A32 6A57 8./03/A=A98295258-08=30.>098@0/5A.9?AA3.2 - 4 - @A<G09520<9.9? / &!!!!12<>A98-6;88-2 <.6;903 @.8-A;8 =A9/.52<.9? 8-2 /0>2 -0/ 0@0<525 >20?<2 =A>129/08.A9 ;952< 033 -205/ 29=2 <2L;2/825 4A< 29-09=.9?8-2=A>129/08.A9.9-./40BA;< 20<5 8-2 320<925 =A;9/23/ A9 6A8- 8-2 /.52/ 09512<;/258-2>082<.030B0.30632A9<2=A<5 5>.8825378-2=30.>098./0?25!720</088-2 8.>2A40==.5298095@A<G.9?0/AA3.26;89A81<A5;=25 1<AA4A4.9=A>28A/-A@8-08-2@0/20<9.9? / &!!!! 12<>A98- /8-20==.5298-0/A==;<<25A9! ! &!&! 8-2 <.6;903 -0/ <.?-837 80G29 8-2 9A8.A903 .9=A>2A4 8-2 =30.>098 08 / ! 0/ 12< 8-2 ?;.523.92/ .//;25 67 8-2M0<9080G080822?032<B.=2/;8-A<.87@-.=-9225/ 9A.982<42<29=2 -2 5A=;>298/ /-A@ 8-08 8-2 =30.>098 /;/80.9254<0=8;<2A4<.?-88.6.00954.6;30095;952<?A92 /;<?2<7 4A< 8-2 /0>2 2 @0/ 05>.8825 .9 AB2<9>298 A/1.8034<A>! ! &!&!8A! ! &!&!09503/A05>.8825 - 5 - .9 1<.B082 -A/1.803 4<A> ! ! &!&! 8A & ! &!&! ./06.3.87 2<8.4.=082 .//;25 67 & A=8A< /-A@/ 8-08 8-2=30.>098-0//;442<25 8AH5./06.3.878A8-2<.?-8 3A@2< 3.>6 -2<24A<2 8-./ A;<8 4.95/ .8 :;/8 095 <20/A906328A80G2!H4;9=8.A9035./06.3.87 ==A<5.9?37 8-2=30.>098./298.83254A<3A//A44;8;<220<9.9?0/;952< / !J&JJ!HN / &!!! -2=30.>098@0/05>.8825.98-2-A/1.8034A< 507/ A9/.52<.9?8-212<.A5A4-A/1.803.I08.A9908;<2A4 .9:;<.2/ 095 A8-2< <232B098 40=8A</ 8-./ A;<8 4.95/ .8 <20/A906328A?<098090>A;98A4 / !!!!4A<10.9095 /;442<.9? / &!!! 4A< 3A// A4 0>29.8.2/ 095 / !!!! 4A< 8<09/1A<808.A9 2J8<0 9A;<./->298 095 088295098=-0<?2/ ;28A8-2.9:;<.2/-2>.?-89A8-0B2 08829525 097 @A<G 08320/8 4A< 0 12<.A5 A4 >A98-/ 095 8-2 <.6;903-0/<.?-8370@0<5258-<22>A98-/.9=A>2 / &! 4A< 3A// A4 .9=A>2 5;<.9? 30.5 ;1 12<.A5 A@2B2< 8-2 =A>129/08.A9 A4 / & 0@0<525 67 8-2 <.6;9034A<>25.=032J129/2/9225/9A.982<42<29=2 - 6 - -2 =A>129/08.A9 0@0<525 67 8-2 <.6;903 ./ >A5.4.250/;952< 3 A 205/ @0<5678-2 <.6;903 @0<5678-./ A;<8 0.9 095 /;442<.9? / !!!! / !!!! & '25.=03 J129/2/ / & / & A// A4 4;8;<2 20<9.9?=010=.87 / !! / &!!! <09/1A<808.A9 2J8<0 9A;<./->298 095 088295098 =-0<?2/ / +!!! / !!!! A// A4 0>29.8.2/ / !!!! / &!!! A// A4 .9=A>2 5;<.9? 30.5 ;1 12<.A5 / &! / &! A803 / / + -2<2@.336229-09=2>298A4 / !&&!! - 7 - + 2/1A95298 A & K 9/;<09=2 A>1097 -0/ 03<2057 521A/.825 8-2 =A>129/08.A9 0>A;98 0@0<525 67 8-2 <.6;903 ! 98-2<2/;388-24A33A@.9?A<52<./10//25 #.% 11203./ #..% -2 =30.>098 ./ 298.8325 4A< 8-2 29-09=25 =A>129/08.A9 A4 / !&&!! @.8- .982<2/8 08 H 12< 099;> 4<A> 8-2 5082 A4 128.8.A98.338-25082A4<203.I08.A9 #...% 2/1A95298A ./3.06328A1078-2 29-09=25=A>129/08.A903A9?@.8-.982<2/8 #.B% 2/1A95298 A & K 9/;<09=2 A>1097 ./ 5.<2=825 8A 521A/.8 8-2 04A<2/0.5 =A>129/08.A90>A;9803A9?@.8-.982<2/8@.8-.9 A92>A98-4<A>8-25082A48-./:;5?>298 #B% <.6;903 03<2057 5.<2=825 8-2 9/;<09=2 A>1097 4A< 107 095 <2=AB2< - 8 - -29=28-270<2083.62<878A<2=AB2<8-2/0>2 4<A>8-2A@92<A48-2B2-.=32 #B.% 9 /;=- 521A/.8 8-2 =30.>098 ./ 12<>.88258A@.8-5<0@8-2298.<20>A;9803A9? @.8-.982<2/80==<;25A9.8 )*+ %$' # $ ./8A 3A