- 1 - ! "#$## #% &'(&)*+,&** - !"##$ % & ' ( $" !""# % & ( ) * ) & ( $* & ( $$ ) ###" ! $" #* + ) * ) ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) , , - &, - ( ./0123456/78/94:4562/3434564:;<3./100=:/7>.5 18/0569403/7?583./5??/60/2=64:.1;@/=67/8/03456* 5? 3./ /A5341;@/ 6:38=B/63: 03 &?58 :.583 C 03D( 167 .1: 65> 0.1@@/6A/7 3./ E=7AB/63 5? 0569403456 167587/85?:/63/60/21::/7;<3./841@5=83;/?58/3./ 22/@@13/5=834684B461@ 22/1@ 5$" #*=846A3./ 2/67/60< 5? 3./ 122/1@ 3./ 2/343456/8: 100=:/7 ./8/46 .19/ ?4@/7 16 122@4013456 =67/8 /03456 * 5? 8 ://F46A @/19/ 35 2857=0/ 1 052< 5? 8/A4:3/8/7 1@/ //7 713/7##*16705B2@1463?4@/7;<3./48:56!46!@1>! 8 8E=6 1.17=8 1A146:3 3./ 2/343456/8: ./8/46 167 3./ 587/8 :.//3 46 2@ 5 # .5:2431@ ;4@@: 5@40/ 8/2583:16725:31@10F65>@/7A/B/63: - 3 - ./ A4:3 5? 3./28/:/63122@4013456 ?4@/7 ;< 3./ 2/343456/8:4:3.133./<463/67352857=0/0/83146177434561@ 750=B/63: 167 1@:5 /G1B46/ 3.8// 177434561@ >436/::/: 7=846A 3./ 2/67/60< 5? 3./ 122/1@ ./ :147 8/H=/:3 4: B17/>43.16463/6345635:=;:3163413/3./487/?/60/3.13 1: 56 3./ 713/ >./6 G" I @/A1@ 65340/ >1: 4::=/7 ;< 3./ 05B2@146163 3./ 2/343456/8: >/8/ 653 8/:4746A 13 3./ 1778/:: B/63456/7 46 3./ :147 65340/ 3 4: 3./48 :2/04?40 0563/63456 3.13 :460/ 3./ :313=358< 65340/ 0563/B2@13/7 =67/8/03456*5?3./ 03>1:6537=@<:/89/7=256 3./B133./480588/031778/::3./8/4:656!05B2@4160/5? 3./ B1671358< 8/H=48/B/63 5? 4::=160/ 167 :/8940/ 5? :313=358<65340/3./8/;<94341346A3./285:/0=345643:/@? * ./@/186/7 22/@@13/5=831?3/81??58746A16 522583=643<5?./1846A35;53.:47/:.1:8/E/03/73./:147 122@4013456 ./ 5=83 .1: 8/0587/7 1 ?46746A 3.13 3./ 28525:/7 >436/:: 8 8E=6 1.17=8 >.5 4: 656/ 53./8 3.163./:56!46!@1>5?3./2/343456/8:4:17B433/7@<.1946A :/9/81@ 74:2=3/: 167 2/6746A @434A13456: >43. 3./B 167 - 4 - 3./8/?58/ .4: 3/:34B56< >5=@7 653 :/89/ 16< =:/?=@ 2=825:/46/@=0471346A3./1@@/A/7656!:/8940/5?65340/ : 8/A187:3./8/H=/:335:=BB563>525@40/056:31;@/:?58 3./2=825:/5?285946A3./1778/::5?3./2/343456/8:3./ 22/@@13/ 5=83 .1: 5;:/89/7 3.13 /9/6 3./48 /947/60/ >5=@7 653 147 3./ 2/343456/8: 46 /:31;@4:.46A 3./ ?103 5? 656!:/8940/167056:/H=/63@<3./:1478/H=/:3>1:1@:5 7/0@46/7 6 3./:/ A85=67: 3./ 122@4013456 ?4@/7 =67/8 /03456 * 5? 3./ 57/ 5? 84B461@ 850/7=8/ * &J8K( 01B/ 35 ;/ 8/E/03/7 AA84/9/7 ;< 3./ :147 587/83./2/343456/8:.19/1228510./73.4:5=83;<>1< 5?3./28/:/632/343456 $ .19/./1873./@/186/705=6:/@122/1846A?58 3./ 2/343456/8: 13 @/6A3. 167 .19/ 018/?=@@< 2/8=:/7 3./ 4B2=A6/7587/821::/7;<3./@/186/7 22/@@13/5=831: >/@@1:3./8/0587:B17/1914@1;@/ " ./@/186/705=6:/@?583./2/343456/8:.1:1@:5 2@10/7568/05871052<5?3./E=7AB/638/67/8/7;<3./ - 5 - @/186/71A4:3813/46 5$# #1671052<5?3./ /G1B4613456!46!0.4/? 3/67/8/7 ;< 3./ ?48:3 2/343456/8 84 16A12217=846A3./05=8:/5?3841@ 0@5:/:08=346<5?3./:147/G1B4613456!46!0.4/? 8/9/1@: 3.13 3./ /6348/ 7/?/60/ 5? 3./ 2/343456/8: 46 3./ 2850//746A:=67/8/03456*5?3./ 038/:3:563./48 1::/834563.133./0./H=/:46H=/:3456>/8/6/9/84::=/7 35 3./ 05B2@146163 ;=3 >/8/ 1@@/A/7@< 5;3146/7 ;< 05/80456167=67=/46?@=/60/;<3./48:56!46!@1>8 8E=6 1.17=8 >43. >.5B 3./< 18/ 17B433/7@< 13 @5AA/8./17: 167 4695@9/7 46 :/9/81@ 0494@ 167 084B461@ @434A13456: 3 4: ?=83./8://63.13132181A812.!5?3./7/25:434563./8/4: 1;84/?167A/6/81@7/641@353.//??/033.133./:313=358< 65340/>1:6/9/8:/89/7=2563./2/343456/8:5>/9/81 8/1746A5? 3./3/:34B56< 46 43: /6348/3< 4674013/:3.13 3./ 28460421@ 7/?/60/ 31F/6 ;< 3./ 2/343456/8: ;/?58/ 3./ @/186/7 1A4:3813/ >1: 3.13 3./8/ /G4:3/7 65 @/A1@@< /6?580/1;@/ 7/;358@41;4@43< 46 ?195=8 5? 3./05B2@146163 - 6 - 167 056:/H=/63@< 3./ 05B2@1463 >1: @41;@/ 35 ;/ 74:B4::/7 3 4: 2/8346/63 35 653/ 3.13 3.5=A. 3./ 2/343456/8: .19/ B17/ 1 91A=/ 167 ;1@7 7/641@ 5? 3./ :/8940/ 5? 65340/ 3./< .19/ 653 2857=0/7 16< 08/74;@/ B13/841@ ;/?58/ 3./ 841@ 5=83 58 3./ 22/@@13/ 5=83 35 7/B56:3813/3.133./<>/8/6538/:4746A133./1778/::35 >.40. 3./ :313=358< 65340/ 167 05B2@1463 >/8/ :/63 G0/23 ?58 3./ :/@?!:/8946A :313/B/63 3.13 3./< >/8/ 653 8/:4746A 13 3./ 8/@/9163 25463 5? 34B/ 46 3./ 1778/:: B/63456/7 46 G" 167 3./ 284913/ 05B2@1463 65 0563/B25816/5=: 750=B/63 :=0. 1:1 0.16A/!5?!1778/:: 4634B13456 2855? 5? 8/:47/60/ /@:/>./8/ 58 16< :=2258346A8/0587.1:;//62857=0/735:=;:3163413/3./48 0@14B.=:12183?85B1B/8/7/641@3./8/4:65B13/841@ 2@10/7 56 8/0587 35 :.5> 3.13 3./ 1778/:: =:/7 ;< 3./ 05B2@146163 >1: 460588/03 58 3.13 3./ 2/343456/8: >/8/ 28/E=740/7;<1@@/A/7656!:/8940/ - 7 - .4: 5=83 .1: 5? @13/ 5;:/89/7 1 8/0=8846A 2133/86 >./8/46 100=:/7 2/8:56: 1?3/8 :=??/846A 0569403456=67/8/03456*5?3./ 038/:58335?4@46A 122@4013456: =67/8 /03456 * 5? 3./ 8 ;/?58/ 3./ 22/@@13/ 5=83 1: 1 74@1358< 310340 35 285@56A 3./ 2850//746A: ./ 46:3163 01:/ =6?583=613/@< 122/18: 35 ;/56/:=0.133/B23?3./2/343456/8:>/8/A/6=46/@<653 8/:4746A133./1778/:::.5>6463./:313=358<65340/167 05B2@14633./?48:3167613=81@:3/2/G2/03/75?3./B>1: 35 2@10/ 56 8/0587 3./48 103=1@ 58 ?58>18746A 1778/:: ;< 2857=046A:=2258346A750=B/63:0563/B25816/5=:353./ 8/@/91632/845734::4A64?4016335653/3.133./2/343456/8: .19/ 653 0563/67/7 3.13 3./ 1778/:: B/63456/7 46 3./ @/A1@ 65340/ 58 05B2@1463 4: 653 3./48 2/8B16/63 1778/:: ./48 2@/1746A: 18/ 056:240=5=:@< :4@/63 56 3.4: 08=041@ 1:2/03 6 3./ 1;:/60/ 5? 16< 05A/63 2855? 58 ;561 ?47/ /G2@16134563./0563/634563.133./8/>1:657=/:/8940/ 5?65340/8/B146:=6:=;:3163413/7 - 8 - 1946A 8/A187 35 3./:/ 0480=B:3160/: 3.4: 5=83 ?467: 65 46?48B43< 488/A=@1843< 58 4@@/A1@43< 46 3./ 4B2=A6/7 587/8 21::/7 ;< 3./ @/186/7 22/@@13/ 5=83 8/E/0346A3./122@4013456=67/8/03456*5?3./8 ./587/8=67/80.1@@/6A/4:>/@@!8/1:56/716701@@:?5865 463/8?/8/60/ 46 /G/804:/ 5? :=2/894:58< E=84:7403456 0058746A@<3./2/343456:3167:74:B4::/7 .+ &##* $ 4:3 5,@ 5, ,