- 1 - !" #$ %!&!'!! !!'' ($) *+ !!'' , ($) * + ! " #$$ % # & # # #' $& #( ! " #$' ) $ *% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' # +"% ' $ # # ' &# * + ,$ $& # $ (( ,* + $& # " * # #% ! " #$ % # & # # ! " #$$' ) $ + ( - *% - 3 - ' ' # +"% ' $ * # &# * +$ (( $ $&#,$$& # ' &#*$# .&# # & /010 2330241 250 67408 2927:1; ;/0 <=89>0:; 2:8 2?258 82;08 + 321108 @A ;/0 0>@05 ,$$7<2A23=527:$B((B6 /0 C427>2:; 2908 A0251 >0; ?7;/ 2: 2CC780:; B: D 2:8 1=1;27:08 9570EB=1 7:<=501 /0506B50 1/0 67408 2 C427> 30;7;7B: @06B50 ;/0 57@=:24 C427>7:9CB>30:12;7B:B61-( + /057@=:24CB:178057:9;/00:;7500E780:C0B: 50CB58 952:;08 CB>30:12;7B: B6 1 ?7;/ 7:;0501;2;(F3265B>;/082;0B630;7;7B:;7445024712;7B: - 4 - 2:8 8750C;08 5013B:80:; B:1=52:C0 B>32:A ;B 803B17;;/012>0 - 99570E08@A;/01278<=89>0:;2:82?258;/0 7:<=508 C427>2:; /21 350605508 ' B --D - 2:8 ;/0 :1=52:C0 B>32:A /21 67408 ' B -+ - 8713=;7:9;/0G=2:;=> /0C427>2:;7:/05233024CB:;0:808;/2;21 305;/0?B=:8C05;767C2;02;H -E0576708@A 5;/B32087C =590B: * 1/0 1=1;27:08 652C;=50 B6 - 95280 471;0171 ?7;/C258CB:;=17B:7:<=5A;B6B50/028406;I:00 406; 2:I40 2:8 652C;=50 B6 406; 409 ?/7C/ 250 9570EB=1 7: :2;=502:8130:;/=902>B=:;;B?2581>087C240H30:101 /0 =:805?0:; 1=5905701 @=; :B 2>B=:; 71 2?25808 6B5 6=;=50>087C240H30:1012:8241B6B54B11B62>0:7;7012:8 871679=52;7B: '=5;/05 ;/0 7:;0501; 71 ;B @0 2?25808 2; F 32 /0506B50 50G=01;08 6B5 0:/2:C0>0:; B6 ;/0 CB>30:12;7B: - 5 - ( /0 :1=52:C0 B>32:A 7: 7;1 233024 CB:;0:808;/2;;/08BC;B521101108;/08712@747;A2;+F @=;;/057@=:24/21?5B:94A;2I0:21- F/057@=:24 055087:952:;7:9>B50CB>30:12;7B:?7;/B=;6B44B?7:9;/0 9=78047:01B6;/0B:J@4030HB=5;7: ! "# $%& '$( ( ! /0 2>B=:; 2?25808 ;B?2581 >087C24 0H30:101 71 0HC0117E0 2:8 ;/=1 50G=01;08 6B5 508=C;7B:B6;/0CB>30:12;7B: 0258;/0259=>0:;1B6@B;/17801 1 305 ;/0 8712@747;A C05;767C2;0 711=08 =:805 H;/0C427>2:;/211=1;27:08%652C;=50B6;7@722:8 67@=42 406; 409 2:8 % - 5280 471;/0171 ?7;/ CB:;=17B: /0 ?21 B3052;08 ?7;/ 652C;=50 ;7@72 ?7;/ 2742:8-528071;/017180CB>350117B:B6137:24 CB582:8137:241;2@747K2;7B:2:8871C/25908B: D 2:8 2927: 6B5 ;/0 10CB:8 ;7>0 1/0 ?21 28>7;;08 B: 2:8871C/25908B:- 6B550>BE24B6 1 AIR 2014 SC 736 - 6 - 7>342:;/050?21327:2:847>37:97:406;4092:8;/05071 + F>BE0>0:;501;57C;7B:2;406;I:00<B7:;2:82;2:I40 <B7:; /050 71 >24=:7;08 652C;=50 B6 ;7@72 2:8 67@=42 2:8 137:246=17B:B6-0E04?7;/8090:052;7E0C/2:9017: C05E7C24137:02:8;/=1;/08BC;B521101108;/08712@747;A 2;+ F;B;/0406;4B?0547>@( F;B;/0579/;=330547>@ 2:8 +F ;B ;/0 ?/B40 @B8A ; ?21 B@105E08 @A ;/0 57@=:247:;/07>3=9:08<=89>0:;;/2;;/0C427>2:;?21 7:7;7244A 28>7;;08 7: ;/0 # 2:8 1/0 /21 50927:08 CB:1C7B=1:01126;05+82A1 3052;7B:?21CB:8=C;08;B ;/0:0CI?7;/@B:09526;7:92:81;004342;0?2167H082:8 2:B;/05B3052;7B:?21CB:8=C;08;B;/0652C;=50B6;/0406; 409@04B?I:00@A7:105;7:9;/01;004342;0?7;/1C50?/0 C2;/0;05 ?21 7:105;08 ;B 3211 ;/0 =57:0 2:8 7; ?21 50>BE0826;05;?B>B:;/1B6;/0871C/2590/00:92908 357E2;0E0/7C406B5;52:13B5;2;7B:;B;/0/B137;24;744:B? ;/05071BBK7:9B6;/03=165B>;/0406;409?/0507:1;004 342;0 71 7:105;08 /0 8BC;B5 21101108 ;/0 ?/B40 @B8A 8712@747;A 2; +F CB:178057:9 ;/0 2@BE0 7:<=5701 - 7 - /0506B50 ;/71 B=5; 67:81 7; 5021B:2@40 ;B ;2I0 ;/0 8712@747;A2;+F7:1;028B6- F;2I0:@A;/057@=:241 ;/0 C427>2:; /21 627408 ;B 35B8=C0 ;/0 7:CB>0 35BB6 ;/0 57@=:24 /21 579/;4A ;2I0: /71 :B;7B:24 7:CB>0 2; 1+ 305 >B:;/ 21 305 ;/0 9=78047:01 B6 ;/0 25:2;2I2;2;0092405E7C01=;/B57;A21;/02CC780:; 71 B6 ;/0 A025 D 2:8 7; :0081 :B 7:;056050:C0 /0 57@=:24 /21 CB:1780508 ;/0 290 B6 ;/0 C427>2:; 21 A0251 +>B:;/1-82A12:8;/0506B50;/0>=4;734705?21 579/;4A ;2I0: 21 LJ /=1 ;/0 4B11 B6 6=;=50 025:7:91 ?B=48@0 1+ HHH+FM D /0 57@=:24 /21 2?25808 2: 2>B=:; B6 1+D- ;B?2581>087C240H30:1012:87;:0081:B; 7:;056050:C0 /0 C427>2:; ?21 28>7;;08 7: ;/0 /B137;24 6B5 ++82A12:8=:805?0:;;?B1=59057012:8;/057@=:24/21 2?25808 2: 2>B=:; B6 1 6B5 327: 2:8 - 8 - 1=66057:9 2:8 1 6B5 4B11 B6 2>0:7;701 ?/7C/ :0081 :B 7:;056050:C0'=5;/05 ;/057@=:24 /21 2?25808 2: 2>B=:; B6 1 6B5 6BB8 :B=571/>0:; 2:8 130C724 870; B?0E05 CB:178057:9 ;/0 3057B8 B6 /B137;24712;7B: ;/71 B=5; 67:81 7; 5021B:2@40 ;B 952:; 2: 2>B=:; B6 1 6B5 ;52:13B5;2;7B: 0H;52 :B=571/>0:;2:82;;0:82:;C/25901 /0C427>2:;>79/;:B;/2E02;;0:8082:A?B5I 2; 4021; 6B5 2 3057B8 B6 6B=5 >B:;/1 8=0 ;B ;/0 7:<=5701 1=1;27:08 /0506B50 ;/71 B=5; 67:81 7; 5021B:2@40 ;B 952:;2:2>B=:;B61+ "1+ H-%6B54B11B6 7:CB>08=57:94278=33057B8 /0C427>2:;?212908A0251:E70?B6;/0 7:<=57011=1;27:08@A/05/05>255729035B130C;1?B=48@0 2660C;08/0506B50;/71B=5;67:817;5021B:2@40;B952:; 2: 2>B=:; B6 1+ ;B?2581 4B11 B6 >2557290 35B130C;1 - 9 - + 0:C0;/0C427>2:;710:;7;4086B5;/0>B876708 CB>30:12;7B:=:8058766050:;/028121@04B? 27:2:81=66057:9 1 087C240H30:101 1+D- B11B66=;=50025:7:91 1 B11B67:CB>08=57:94278=33057B8 1+ 52:13B5;2;7B: 0H;52 :B=571/>0:; 2:82;;0:82:;C/25901 1 B11B62>0:7;701 1 B11B6>255729035B130C;1 1+ -./ 0* /=1;/0C427>2:;710:;7;4086B5;B;24CB>30:12;7B: B61D -- ?7;/7:;0501;2;(F3052::=>65B>;/0 82;0B630;7;7B:;7445024712;7B: - :;/0501=4;;/06B44B?7:9B580571321108 "7% B;/'B --D -67408@A;/0C427>2:; 2:8'B -+ -67408@A;/0:1=52:C0B>32:A 250244B?087:325; "77% /0 C427>2:; 71 0:;7;408 6B5 ;B;24 CB>30:12;7B: B61D -- ?7;/7:;0501;2;(F3052::=>65B>;/0 82;0B630;7;7B:;744;/082;0B65024712;7B:B?0E0521305 B5805 82;08 - ;/0 C427>2:; 71 :B; 0:;7;408 6B5 - 10 - 7:;0501; 6B5 ;/0 8042A08 3057B8 B6 D 82A1 7: 6747:9 ;/0 233024 "777% ; 71 1;2;08 ;/2; ;/0 :1=52:C0 B>32:A /21 245028A 803B17;08 F B6 ;/0 2>B=:; 2?25808 @A ;/0 57@=:24 /0506B50 ;/0A 250 8750C;08 ;B 803B17; ;/0 @242:C02>B=:;24B:9?7;/7:;0501;?7;/7:B:0>B:;/65B> ;/082;0B6;/71<=89>0:; "7E% : 1=C/ 803B17; ;/0 C427>2:; 71 305>7;;08 ;B ?7;/852? ;/0 0:;750 2?258 2>B=:; 24B:9 ?7;/ 7:;0501; 2CC5=08B:7; 01* ('!! ) & 71;B4B-