- 1 - !!" #!!$"% & ' %"("($%% )%* !" #$ %$ & ! " " $ "!' %$ '!('!' & ' !" $ !" !" #$ % ) & Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) $ ''( )$ ! *+,-+$,.+/012345/61*.7585.+.+135*,39*+,/7,* ,1 ,/13: ;+.7 *+,//+<,*=23 ,72<,* 61* .75 *54813953.47,-5,885,*59+385*413 ' 75 0,8.+1359 )*+. $5.+.+13 +4 6+/59 455<+3: .75 61//1;+3:*5/+564 ,& 1 +4425 , ;*+. 16 5*.+1*,*+ 1* , 9+*50.+13 .1 >2,47.751*95*9,.59'(!?'!' 8,4459@A.75 6+*4. *54813953. ,2.71*+.A +3 -+95 335B2*5 @& 1 +4425 , ;*+. 16 ,39,C24 9+*50.+3: *54813953.4",39 .1*54.1*5.753,C516.75 85.+.+135* +3 *54850. 16 /,39 +3 A1'! ' C5,42*+3: ! 0*54 4+.2,.59 ,. ,C,3<5*+ +//,:5,/2<,,39+4.*+0.+9,* - 3 - 75471*.6,0.4,*5.7545 .+44,+9.7,..7585.+.+135*D46,.75**=23 1,C@,33, ;,4 +44259 ;+.7 , 5*.+6+0,.5 16 *,3. 16 ,:2-,/+ 7+. 2395* 2/5 'E 16 ,*3,.,<, ,39 *,3. 2/54 +3 *54850. 16 /,39 +3 A1'! ' %1/9 A1'! ' ,& C5,42*+3: ! 0*54 4+.2,.59 ,.,C,3<5*++//,:5,/2<,39+4.*+0.+9,*-+951*95*9,.59 !?!?"E(E.+44.,.59.7,..75.753582.A1CC+44+135*+3 +/5 1 "!!" 9,.59 'E!("E! 0,305//59 .75 5*.+6+0,.5 16 *,3. +44259 +3 6,-1* 16 .75 85.+.+135*D4 6,.75* 75 4,C5 ;,4 >254.+1359 @561*5 .7+4 12*. +3 )$1"?( "E!,39.754,C5;,4,//1;59,39.751*95* 16.75582.A1CC+44+135*;,445.,4+95,39.75C,..5*;,4 *5C,395961**50134+95*,.+13.1.75,74+/9,*+9,*-+951*95* 9,.59 ""!"EE $2*42,3. .1 ;7+07 8*10559+3:4 ;5*5 013920.59@A.75,74+/9,*,6.5*71/9+3:,481.+34850.+13,39 8*1055959.18,44,31*95*13"?"'"EE.1*5:*,3..75/,39 C5,42*+3: ! 0*54 +3 A1'! ' +4 4+.2,.59 ,. ,C,3<5*+ +//,:5$2*42,3..1.751*95*16.75,74+/9,*.753,C516.75 85.+.+135* ;,4 92/A *553.5*59 +3 .75 5-5325 501*94 +3 1/2C34 E ,39 "' @,459 13 4200544+13 ,4 7+4 6,.75* 9+59 13 - 4 - "!"EE",39.75*561*556650.59C2.,.+13+31*C1"',39 .753,C516.7585.+.+135*;,4*56/50.59+3.75*5-5325*501*94 .+//'!"E'! 4 .7+3:4 4.119 .724 .75 85.+.+135* *505+-59 , 31.+05 6*1C .75 166+05 16 .75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* @,459 13 .75 /5..5* +44259 @A .75 612*.7 *54813953. 9,.59 "!?'!'' 0/,+C+3: .7,. .75 1-5*3C53. 16 ,*3,.,<, -+95 1.+6+0,.+13 9,.59 '(!?"EE" 950/,*59 .75 42@=50. /,39 ,4 1*54. ,39 2395*50.+13 16.751*54.0."E?5305.7544+4.,3. 1CC+44+135*412:7..1+3>2+*5,@12..75:*,3.1*95*C,95+3 6,-1*16.7585.+.+135*D46,.75*,/13:;+.71.75*:*,3.55475 44+4.,3.1CC+44+135*-+951*95*9,.59"?"''!''45.,4+95 .751*95*16*5:*,3.4,:,+34..754,+91*95*.7585.+.+135* 6+/59 , *5-+4+13 @561*5 .75 582.A 1CC+44+135* 75 582.A 1CC+44+135* -+95 1*95* 9,.59 ''!?'!' *5=50.59 .75 5-+4+13 $5.+.+13 ::*+5-59 @A .75 1*95* 16 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* .75 85.+.+135* 8*565**59 , )*+. $5.+.+13 +3 1'!'E '!',39.7+412*.7,9:*,3.59,3+3.5*+C1*95* 13 !"''!' ,39 4.,A59 .75 1*95* 8,4459 @A .75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* - 5 - 4.75 C,..5* 4.119 .724 .75 6+*4. *54813953. ,2.71*+.A +4425931.+05.1.7585.+.+135*13! ! '!' 9+*50.+3:7+C.1 ,885,* @561*5 .75 ,2.71*+.A 13 "'! '!' ,. "'!8C 75 85.+.+135*,885,*59@561*5.756+*4.*54813953.,3942@C+..59 *5/5-,3. *501*94 ,@12. .75 :*,3. C,95 +3 6,-1* 16 7+4 6,.75* ,39,/4162*3+4759,018A16.75+3.5*+C1*95*:*,3.59@A.7+4 12*. +3 )$1'!'E '!' 1;5-5* .75 6+*4. *54813953. -+95 1*95* 9,.59 '(!?'!' 75/9 .7,. .75 85.+.+135* +4 31. 53.+./59 .1 ,3A *5:2/,*+F,.+13 395* .7545 0+*02C4.,3054 .75 85.+.+135*+4@561*5.7+412*. 12345/ 61* .75 *54850.+-5 8,*.+54 2*:59 45-5*,/ 013.53.+1345,*9.75,*:2C53.4,3985*2459.75)*+.8,85*4 ;+.70,*5 75 6,0.4 ,*5 4266+0+53./A 4,+9 ,39 91 31. *5>2+*5 *5+.5*,.+1375+4425*5-1/-54,*1239.751*95*8,4459@A.75 1345*-,.1* 16 1*54.4 266+05 +. .1 31.5 .7,. .75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* -+95 1*95* 9,.59 "?"''!'' 7,9 45. ,4+95 .75 *5:*,3. 1*95* 2@45>253. .1 .75 1*95* 16 .75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* .75 1345*-,.1* 16 1*54.4 8,4459 .75 1*95* 71/9+3:.7,..7585.+.+135*+431.53.+./5961**5:2/,*+F,.+1375 - 6 - 85.+.+135* 7,4 >254.+1359 .75 1*95* 16 .75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* +3 )$1'!'E '!' ,39 .7+4 12*. 7,4 >2,4759.751*95*16.7544+4.,3.1CC+44+135* 751*95*16.751345*-,.1*161*54.4+462*3+4759,/13: ;+.7.75)*+.$5.+.+13,39.754,C5+4C,*<59,4335B2*5 85*24,/ 16 .75 4,C5 *56/50.4 .7,. .75 1345*-,.1* 16 1*54.4 8/,0+3: *5/+,305 13 , 1.+6+0,.+13 9,.59 '(!?"EE" 0130/2959 .7,..7585.+.+135*+431.53.+./5961**5:2/,*+F,.+13.+48+-1.,/ .1 31.5 .7,. .75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* ,/41 7,9 8/,059 *5/+,305 13 .75 4,+9 1.+6+0,.+13 ,39 45.,4+95 .75 1*95* 16 *5:*,3.,39.7+412*.+3)$1'!'E '!'7,4950/+359.1 ,0058..75013.53.+1316.751-5*3C53.4.751*95*16.75 44+4.,3. 1CC+44+135* +4 >2,4759 .75 01345>253.+,/ 1*95* 8,4459 @A .75 1345*-,.1* 16 1*54.4 +4 /+,@/5 .1 @5>2,4759 001*9+3:/A+.+4>2,4759 ? 75 )*+. 16 5*.+1*,*+ +4 1*95*59 75 *95* 9,.59 '(!?'!' 8,4459 @A .75 1345*-,.1* 16 1*54. +3 -+95 335B2*5 +4 >2,4759 - 7 - ( 542/.,3./A.75)*+.$5.+.+13+4 50,245 16 .75 9+4814,/ 16 .75 )*+. $5.+.+13 8539+3: +3.5*/102.1*A ,88/+0,.+134 +6 ,3A ,*5 9+481459 16 ,39 .75 +3.5*+C9+*50.+13+6,3A4.,3949+407,*:59 "+, )($%%* (! +4.1"/1'(