Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43552 (KAR)
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA v. ANIL KUMAR
WP/202256/2025 · 2025-09-12
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43552 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43552 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#$ %
&%'
&%' %
( )
!"# $
"
! %& $
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
'
! "$
# (
$#
#
#
)"
%
*
(&"&
+ $
#
&
,
*
#
-
-
.! .! &
*
-
.! $
/012/ 3/45 673389 45 :4538; <09 =98:464>79? /8794>2 @43/3/8A0>58>30<B03/3/8:879>8;A01>58:<093/8=793485 37C8>1=<09<4>7:;45=057:
/45 @943 =834340> 45 <4:8; B? 3/8 3738 A7::4>2 4> D185340> 3/8 09;89 ;738; % 4> ==:4A7340> 0(&"& =7558;
B? 3/8 79>737C7 3738 ;64>4539734E894B1>7:7:7B19724 <095/093,3/894B1>7:*$ @/898B? 3/8 7==:4A7340> <4:8; B? 7==:4A7>3"985=0>;8>3
0 /8984> /8984>7<389 98<8998; 75 ,=94E738 985=0>;8>3*$ A0685 30 B8 7::0@8; 58334>2 754;8 3/8 46=12>8; 09;89 B8794>2 0"""( ;738; F& =7558;
B? 985=0>;8>3
0 >>8G198 4>50<79 75 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 45 A0>A89>8; 7>; <193/89 ;498A34>2 3/8 0E89>68>3305833:87::3/8A0>58D18>347:60>8379?B8>8<435
%
<09 @/4A/ 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 45 8>343:8; 4> :7@ 297>34>2 3/98860>3/5346830A06=:?@43/3/809;89
& 948< 013:4>8 0< <7A35 :87;4>2 30 <4:4>2 0< 3/8 =9858>3=834340>798751>;89- #/4:8 3/8 7==:4A7>3 @09C4>2 75 4::728 AA01>37>3 73 7579C7:E4::728/8@7524E8>7;;4340>7:A/7928758E8>18 >5=8A3098E7;192737:1C4>3/8?879%53/8673389 5300; 3/15 0> 3/8 A06=:74>3 0< 0>8 7>167>20@;7 3/8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 0:4A8 74A/19 /7; 7;;98558; 7 :83389 303/87/754:;798E7;19270>%&7>;5012/3<09 4><0967340>98279;4>23/8A06=:74>35=893/8A06=:74>7>3 /8/7567;87>7==:4A7340><0998:87580<A06=8>57340><09 A90= :055 ;18 30 /87E? 974>5 @/4A/ 3/8 574; 7987 /7;
@43>8558; ;194>2 3/8 60>3/ 0< 12153 % /8 =94E738 985=0>;8>37<3894>E853427340><01>;3/733/8:0550<A90=@75 30 3/8 8G38>3 0< %H 7>; @43/ H 75 =89 3/8 214;8:4>85 45518; B? 3/8 0E89>68>3 AA09;4>2:? /8 /75 <09@79;8; 3/898=093303/8A0>A89>8;75/4:;793/733/8A06=:74>7>345 >03 8>343:8; <09 7>? A06=8>57340> <09 A90= :07> /45 45
7AA09;4>2303/8A06=:74>7>37601>3530;898:4A340>0<;13? 0>3/8=7930<3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3@/4A/67;8/4630<4:8 7A06=:74>3B8<0983/80:4A879>737C70C7?1C37
% > 3/8 B7545 0< :83389 98A84E8; B? 3/8 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 74A/19 3/8 7/754:;79 <0968; 7 06643388 <09 3/8 =19=058 0< 4>5=8A340> 4> 09;89 30 75A89374>3/8:055A7158;303/8A90=4>985=8A30<3/88>3498 E4::728/806643388<4:8;43598=0930>&F%303/8 7/754:;79@/8984>3/8A90=:05551<<898;7567>?75B? <796895 /75 B88> 8>A:058; 53734>2 3/8 8G38>3 0< :055 0< A90=5/8A06=:74>7>3>768:?7>167>20@;7@755/0@> 73:
0303/8574;98=093 >3/8B75450<3/898=093 ;738;
51B64338;
B? 3/8 06643388 3/8 7/754:;79 8E7;1927 0> F 45518; 7> 8>;095868>3 30 3/8 A06=:74>7>37>167>20@;7 7>; 03/89 <796895 53734>2 3/73 0> 3/8 B7545 0< 3/8 98=093 3/8 :055 0< A90=51<<898;@75:8553/7>H7>;4>389650<0E89>68>3 49A1:79 B8794>2
0&&"&
;738; & <796895@/0/7E851<<898;7>?A90=:055@/4A/45B8:0@H
798 >03 8>343:8; <09 3/8 A06=8>57340> 5 51A/ 45518; 8>;095868>3 53734>2 3/73 3/8 <796895 4>A:1;4>2 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 798 >03 8>343:8; <09 A06=8>57340> /8 A0>A89>8; 7/754:;79 8E7;1927 <09@79;8; 3/8 574; 98=093 30 3/8 1=894>38>;8>3 0< 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 74A/19
1B58D18>3 30 3/8 98A84=3 0< 98=093 <906 3/8 7/754:;79 8E7;1927 3/8 1=894>38>;8>3 0< 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 74A/19 <09@79;8; 3/8 5768 30 3/8 82453979% 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 8>27:191 @43/ 7 A0E894>2 :83389 ;738; % 98D18534>2 30 A:058 3/8 A06=:74>385=4383/8574;98=093:8338951=97B?3/8 1=894>38>;8>30<0:4A879>737C70C7?1C3774A/193/8 =834340>89 /8984> @43/013 A0>54;894>2 3/8 ;0A168>35 8>391538;3/86733893079>737C70C7?1C3730/0:;8>D149?
7274>53 3/8 7/754:;79 75 @8:: 75 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 1B58D18>3 30 8>3915368>3 0< 8>D149? 3/8 >D149? <<4A89 45518; 934A:85 0< A/79285 53734>2 46=137340> 0< A/79285 30 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 75 @8:: 75 30 3/8 7/754:;79
(
8E7;19277>;58>30B589E7340>>03830<4:83/8490BI8A340>5 /8 48 3/8 7/754:;79 /75 51B64338; 98=:? 53734>2 3/734>389650<3/80E89>68>349A1:7954>A83/8A90=:055 51<<898; @75 B8:0@ H /8 /75 <4:8; 98=093 53734>2 3/73 <796895 798 >03 8>343:8; <09 7>? A90= :055 A06=8>57340> 0@8E89 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /75 >03 <4:8;
7>? 98=:?"0BI8A340>5 /8 8>D149? 0<<4A89 /8:; 3/73 3/8 A/79285 7274>53 J94 /4E75/797>7==7 45 >03 =90E8; 7>;
98A0668>;8; 30 8G0>89738 /46 7>; /8:; 3/73 A/79285 7274>53 "=94E738 985=0>;8>3 45 =90E8; 7>; 51B64338;
98=093 ;738; (F /8 0>*B:8 =70C7?1C7 0> (F<09@79;8;3/898=0937:0>2@43/98A0668>;7340> 30 3/8 3738 0E89>68>3 98A0668>;4>2 <09 46=054340> 0< @43//0:;4>20<<0197>>17:4>A9868>35=7?7B:8303/8=94E738 985=0>;8>3 /8984> @43/ A161:734E8 8<<8A3 7>; 7:50 <09 ;8<8994>23/8=9060340>B?<019?8795@/8>8E89/8B8A0685 ;18<09=9060340>
/8 =834340>89 51B58D18>3 30 3/8 98A84=3 0< 98A0668>;7340> 7>; 8>D149? 98=093 45518; 58A0>; 5/0@
A7158 >034A8 ;738; 30 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /8=94E738985=0>;8>30>51B64338;/4598=:?30 3/88>D149?98=09375@8::7598A0668>;7340>7>;5012/330 8G0>89738/46<9063/8A/792850@8E893/8=834340>89B? 09;89 ;738; F&
>>8G198 30 3/8 7==:4A7340> =90A88;8; 30 4><:4A3 3/8 =1>45/68>3 4> 38965 0< 98A0668>;7340> /0:;4>2 3/73 ;85=438 58A0>; 5/0@ A7158 >034A8 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /75 >03 51B64338; /45 98=:? 3/73 7601>35 30 7 ;8868; 7AA8=37>A8 0< 8>D149? 98=093 75 @8::7598A0668>;7340>B?3/80>*B:8=70C7?1C37
( 7::4>2 3/8 09;89 0< =1>45/68>3 75 @8:: 75 8>D149?98=0937>;98A0668>;7340>3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3 7==907A/8;3/894B1>7:4>==:4A7340>
0(&"&
/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 B8<098 3/8 94B1>7: /7;
A0>38>;8;3/73/8/75>03A0664338;7>?;898:4A340>0<;13? /898=093/8/7551B64338;454>389650<3/80E89>68>3 49A1:79 @/4A/ =985A94B85 3/73 3/8 <796895 798 >03 8>343:8; <09A06=8>57340>4<3/8A90=:055515374>8;B?3/8645B8:0@
F
H /8 :055 515374>8;
B? 3/8 A06=:74>7>3
7>167>20@;7@75303/88G38>30<%H@/4A/@75B8:0@ 3/8 =89A8>3728 <4G8; B? 3/8 0E89>68>3 4> 3/8 49A1:79 53738; 75 51A/ 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 @75 >03 8>343:8; <09 7>? A06=8>57340> 193/89 /8 /75 1928; B8<098 3/8 94B1>7: 3/73 3/8 1=894>38>;8>3 0< 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C3774A/19@90387:8338951B58D18>3303/898A84=3 0<A06=:74>3303/87/754:;798E7;1927<094><0967340>0> 51A/ 98=093 /8 7/754:;79 8E7;1927 51B58D18>3 30 98A84=3 0< :83389 7==04>38; 7 06643388 30 4>5=8A3 7>; 51B64398=093@/4A/7AA09;4>2:?51B64338;798=093@/8984> 3/8294A1:3198 <<4A89743776=79C78>;978E7;1927 4::728 AA01>37>3 7579C7: 8E8>18 >5=8A309 7>;
554537>3 498A309 0< 294A1:3198 8E7;1927 @898 3/8 686B8955=893/898=0933/8A90=:055515374>8;B?3/8 7>167>20@;7 @75 30 3/8 8G38>3 0< &H /8 7/754:;79 51B58D18>3303/898A84=30<98=093B?3/80664338845518;
7> 8>;095868>3 ;738; F 53734>2 3/73 3/8 :055 51<<898;B?3/8A06=:74>7>3@75B8:0@H7>;/8@75>03
8>343:8; 30 B8 A0>54;898; <09 =7?68>3 0< A06=8>57340> 4> 389650<0E89>68>349A1:7953738;
F /8987<389 3/8 7/754:;79 8E7;1927 <09@79;8; 3/898=09375@8::753/88>;095868>3303/81=894>38>;8>3 0<0:4A879>737C70C7?1C3774A/19/81=894>38>;8>3 0< 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 74A/19 51B58D18>3 30 3/8 98A84=3 0< 3/8 98=093 75 @8:: 75 8>;095868>3 45518; B? 3/8 7/754:;798E7;1927<09@79;8;3/85768303/882453979 >D149485% 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 0> % 98A0668>;4>230A:0583/87==:4A7340>753/87==:4A7>3@75 >03 8>343:8; <09 7>? A06=8>57340> 4> 38965 0< 3/8 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 53738; 4> 3/8 8>;095868>3 45518; B? 3/8 7/754:;79 8E7;1927 0> 3/8 B7545 0< 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 53738; 85=438 574; 98=093 B?
3/8 0:4A8 79>737C70C7?1C373/80E89>68>3=90A88;8;308>39153 3/86733893079>737C70C7?1C3730/0:;8>D149? /8 8>D149? 0<<4A89 /8:; 3/8 8>D149? 45518; 3/8 934A:85 0< A/79285 @43/013 3/898 B84>2 7>? 51B537>347:
8E4;8>A8 <09 3/8 574; 934A:85 0< A/79285 7>; A0>A:1;8; 3/8 8>D149? /0:;4>2 3/73 3/8 A/79285 B? 3/8 ;8=79368>3";45A4=:4>79? 713/0943? 7274>53 45 >03 =90E8; 0@8E89 50<79 75 48 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /8984> /75 B88> =90E8; 7>; 51B64338; 3/8 98=093 30 3/8 0>*B:8 =70C7?1C37
/8 0>*B:8 =70C7?1C37 <09@79;8; 3/8 5768 7:0>2 @43/ 98A0668>;7340> 98A0668>;4>2 <09 =1>45/68>3 53738; 3/8984>
/8 0E89>68>3 51B58D18>3 30 98A84=3 0< 98=093 7>;
98A0668>;7340> 45518; 58A0>; 5/0@ A7158 >034A8 /8 =94E738985=0>;8>3/7537C8>75=8A4<4AA0>38>340>B8<0983/8 94B1>7:3/733/012/>034A8@75;738;3/85768 @75 589E8; 0> /46 0> 7>; 4668;4738:? 3/8987<389/8/7551B64338;/4598=:?@43/4>;7?5<9063/8 ;7380<98A84=30<A0=?0<>034A88/75=90;1A8;3/8A0=? 0< 3/8 58A0>; 5/0@ A7158 >034A8 >>G198 30 3/8 7==:4A7340> @/8984> 43 45 A:879:? 53738; 3/73 3/8 >034A8 @75 589E8;0>/460>551A//8/75<4:8;/4598=:? @43/4> ;7?5 48 0> F 85=438 3/8 98=:? 3/8
09;89 46=12>8; @/4A/ A768 30 B8 =7558; 0> F& 53734>23/73=94E738985=0>;8>3/75>03<4:8;7>?98=:?@/4A/ 7601>35 30 ;8868; 7AA8=37>A8 0< 98=093 75 @8:: 75 98A0668>;7340> B? 3/8 0>*B:8 =70C7?1C37 8 /75 <193/89 51B64338; 3/73 3/898 45 >0 ;898:4A340> 0< ;13? 73394B137B:8 30 /46 54>A8 /8 /75 ;45A/7928; 3/8 ;13485 4> 38965 0< 3/8 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 53738; @/4A/ =985A94B85 4> 7>? A758 @/898E89 3/898 45 A90= :055 B8:0@ H3/8<796895798>038>343:8;<09A06=8>57340>
> 3/8 A758 0> /7>; 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 515374>8;
A90=:055303/88G38>30<%H5=8906643388<0968;B? 7/754:;79 43 @75 &H /8 934A:85 0< A/79285 45518;
@43/013 3/898 B84>2 7>? B7545 7>; 6738947:5 7E74:7B:8 0> 98A09;30A0>38>;3/733/89845;898:4A340>0<;13?;85=4383/8 <7A3 3/73 3/8 A90= :055 @75 %H 7AA09;4>2 30 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 7>; &H 75 =89 3/8 06643388 7==04>38;
193/89/8/7551B64338;3/733/809;8946=12>8;4><:4A34>2 3/8 =1>45/68>3 45 7274>53 3/8 <7A35 8E4;8>A8 7>; 3/8
&
6738947:57>;51<<895<906=89E89543?7>;98D1498;30B8583 754;8
/012/ 3/8 =834340>89 7==8798; B8<098 3/8 94B1>7:/0@8E89>03A/058>30<4:898=:?5373868>3B13/75 097::? 0==058; 3/8 A:746 0< 3/8 7==:4A7>3 @/4A/ 45 A:879:? 98<:8A38;4>=797
0%0<3/809;89=7558;B?3/894B1>7:
& /8 A01>58: 7==8794>2 <09 3/8 82453979 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 985=0>;8>3 0 /8984> <4:8;
5373868>3 0< 0BI8A340>5 30 3/8 7==:4A7340> A0>38>;4>2 3/73 3/87==:4A7340>45>03674>374>7B:87>;3/898798>06894354> 3/8 7==:4A7340> 7>; 3/8 A0>;1A3 0< 3/8 7==:4A7>3"=94E738 985=0>;8>3 ;458>343:85 /46 <906 588C4>2 7>? 98:48< 7>; 5012/330;4564553/87==:4A7340>
% /8 94B1>7: /7E4>2 <01>; 3/73 3/8 0E89>68>3 ;85=43898A84=30<98=:?303/858A0>;5/0@A7158>034A80> FB13=7558;3/809;890>F&487<389 60983/7>?87560>3/5 B1353738;7554G60>3/54>3/8 I1;268>3$ 0B589E4>2 3/73 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /75 >03
%
<4:8; 7>? 98=:?
30 3/8 58A0>; 5/0@ A7158 >034A8 @/4A/ 7601>3530;8868;7AA8=37>A80<3/898=09375@8::753/8 98A0668>;7340> 7>; =90A88;8; 30 =755 3/8 09;89 @/4A/ 45 >03515374>7B:84>:7@
/8 94B1>7: 73 =797297=/
0F /75 A0>54;898;
3/8 6738947: 7E74:7B:8 B8<098 43 3/73 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /8984> 51B64338; /45 98=093 53734>2 3/73 3/8 A90= :055 515374>8; B? 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 @75 30 3/8 8G38>3 0< %H @/4A/@75B8:0@H75/75B88><4G8;B?3/80E89>68>3 4> 435 49A1:79 53738; 7>; 3/8 06643388 @/4A/ @75 7==04>38;51B58D18>3303/898=0930<3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3 0> 3/8 :83389 0< 1=894>38>;8>3 0< 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 74A/19 30 @/4A/ 294A1:3198 <<4A89 743/7 76=79C7 8>;97 @75 7 686B89 7>; 3/8 574; 06643388 51B64338;798=093/0:;4>23/733/8A90=:05545&H@/4A/45 <79 B8:0@ 3/8 =89A8>3728 51B64338;
B? 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /8 94B1>7: /75 A:879:? 0B589E8; 3/73 3/8 294A1:3198 <<4A89457>8G=8934>7558554>23/8:055A7158; ;1830>73197:A7:7643485@/0/757558558;3/8:055A7158;
30 &H @/4A/ 45 :855 3/7> 3/8 =89A8>3728 24E8> B? 3/8 7==:4A7>37>;<193/890B589E8;3/733/88E8>18>5=8A30945 >038G=893A06=798;303/8294A1:3198 <<4A89/894B1>7: <193/89/8:;3/733/88>D149?0<<4A895@7?8;B?G3/8 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 @/4A/ 57?5 98279;4>2 =7?68>3 0< 7601>3<09A90=:055=897A98733/897380<5%"4>3/8 8E8>33/8A90=:0554560983/7>H/0@8E893/88>D149? 0<<4A89/75<74:8;30A0>54;893/733/8A90=:0554>3/8A7580> /7>; 45 %H 7>; 75 =89 3/8 67/7K79 98=093 0< 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3" 7==:4A7>3 B8<098 3/8 94B1>7: 7>; &H 75 =89 3/8 06643388 /8 8>D149? 0<<4A89 /75 >03 =90=89:? 7==98A4738; 3/8 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 =90;1A8; B8<098 /46 <09 7@79;4>2 A06=8>57340> 193/89 3/73 3/8 8>D149? 0<<4A89 ;8:4B89738; 6053 0> 3/8 7@79; 0< A06=8>57340> =985A94B8; B13>037338>;8;303/894;893/7343A01:;B8=74;0>:?@/8> 3/8:0554560983/7>H7E4>2A0>54;898;8>34986738947:
7E74:7B:8 0> 98A09; 3/8 94B1>7: /8:; 3/73 3/8 =834340>89 @43/013 7==:4A7340> 0< 64>; 7>; @43/013 8G764>4>2 3/8 6738947:5 =:7A8; B8<098 43 /75 68A/7>4A7::? =7558; 3/8
46=12>8; 09;89 5 51A/ B03/ 48 98=093 0< 3/8 >D149? <<4A8975@8::753/8=8>7:3?09;8951<<895<906=89E89543? 7>;@43/013B84>27>?8E4;8>A87>;7AA09;4>2:?583754;83/8 09;89 46=12>8; >>8G198 ;738; F& 7>;
;498A38; 3/8 =834340>89 30 5833:8 7:: 3/8 A0>58D18>347: 60>8379?B8>8<4357==:4A7B:8303/87==:4A7>34>389650<:7@ @43/4>3/98860>3/5<9063/8;7380<98A84=30<A0=?0<3/8 09;89 =7558; B? 3/8 94B1>7: 3 45 3/45 09;89 45 A7::8; 4> D185340>4>3/8=9858>3@943=834340>
879;944I7?C1679:879>8;;;4340>7:;E0A738 8>897:7==8794>20>B8/7:<0<3/8=834340>897:0>2@43/63 7?7 :879>8; 42/ 0193 0E89>68>3 :87;89 <09 3/8 0E89>68>37>;94!/15798:879>8;A01>58:7==8794>2 <093/8A7E87309"985=0>;8>3
0
( 94 4I7?C1679 5398558; 61A/ 0> 3/8 =04>3 3/73 @/73 /75 B88> A0>54;898; B? 3/8 =834340>89 45 >03 3/8 =89A8>3728 0< A90= :055 43 45 3/8 ;898:4A340> 0< ;13? 0> 3/8 =793 0< =94E738 985=0>;8>3 30 755453 3/8 <796895 @/0 /7E8
(
51<<898; :055 0< 3/849 A90= 7>; 4> 28334>2 A06=8>57340> 75 =90E4;8;1>;893/80E89>68>349A1:79@/4A/45679C8;75 GB8<0983/8>D149? <<4A897>;3/8<79689/75:053/45 A90= ;18 30 /87E?
974> <7:: <09 @/4A/ /8 45 8>343:8; <09 A06=8>57340>75=8949A1:79/87==:4A7>3/75>037554538; /464>28334>23/8A06=8>57340>4>389650<:7@/45453/8 ;898:4A340>0<;13?0>3/8=7930<3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3<09 @/4A/ 3/8 934A:85 0< A/79285 @898 45518; /8 934A:85 0< A/79285 7>; 46=137340> 0< A/79285 798 E89? A:879 3/73 3/8 7==:4A7>3 /75 5/0@> ;898:4A340> @/4:8 ;45A/7924>2 /45 ;13? 30@79;53/8<79689@/0/757==907A/8;/46<09:827:/8:= <093/8:055/8/75515374>8;303/8A90=;1830/87E?974> 7>;<:00; @/4A/3/8 8>3498 74A/19 ;45394A3@43>8558; ;194>2 3/8 60>3/ 0< 12153 % /45 /75 B88> =90=89:? A0>54;898;B?3/8>D149? <<4A8975@8::753/80>B*8:=7 0C7?1C37 @/4:8 <09@79;4>2 3/8 98=093 30 3/8 0E89>68>3 7:0>2 @43/ 98A0668>;7340> /8 0E89>68>3 7<389 98A84=3 0<3/898=09375@8::7598A0668>;7340>45518;58A0>;5/0@ A7158 >034A8 @/4A/ /75 >03 B88> 7>5@898; B? 3/8 =94E738
985=0>;8>3 /8 0E89>68>3 37C4>2 >038 0< 7:: 3/8 574;
6738947:5 0> 98A09; 7>; 4> 3/8 7B58>A8 0< 98=:? /75 =90A88;8; 30 /0:; 3/73 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 4>;498A3:? 7AA8=38;3/88>D149?98=09375@8::753/898A0668>;7340> 7>;0>3/8B75450<6738947:0>98A09;=:7A8;B8<09843/8:;
3/73 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /75 A0664338; ;898:4A340> 0< ;13? 7>; =7558; 3/8 46=12>8; 09;89 0< =1>45/68>3 @/4A/ 012/3>0330/7E8B88>4>389<898;@43/B?3/894B1>7:/8 94B1>7:/75>03737::A0>54;898;3/86738947:5=:7A8;B8<098 43 3 45 3/8 A758 0< ;898:4A340> 0< ;13? 0> 3/8 =793 0< 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 @75 4> D185340> 7>; >03 3/8 =89A8>3728 0<A90=:055/894B1>7:5@7?8;B?3/8=89A8>37280<:055 73 %H 75 =89 3/8 67/7K79 51B64338; B? 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>37>;&H75=893/80664338898=09351B64338; 4>389650<3/8;498A340>50<3/87/754:;795=89G 3/8 <79689 45 8>343:8; <09 A06=8>57340> 73 3/8 9738 0< 5%" =89 7A98 <09 3/8 :055 0< A90= /45 8G/4B43 @75 @43//8:;B?3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3B8<0983/894B1>7:/8 94B1>7:012/330/7E8A7::8;<093/88>349898A09;5<9063/8
F
=834340>8975@8::753/879>737C70C7?1C370@8E893/8 94B1>7: ;85=438 >034A4>2 3/8 574; G @/4A/ 45 7 0E89>68>349A1:794>3/88>D149?98=093=90A88;8;30/0:;
3/73 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /75 >03 A0664338; ;898:4A340> 0< ;13?7>;583754;809;89@/4A/45 >03515374>7B:84>:7@75 51A/ 5012/3 30 7::0@ 3/8 =834340> 583 754;8 3/8 09;89 0< 94B1>7: 9853098 7>; A0><496 3/8 09;89 =7558; B? 3/8 =834340>89 4><:4A34>2 3/8 =1>45/68>3 75 =89 >>8G198 ;738;F&
8<134>2 3/8 51B645540>5 0< :879>8; ;;4340>7:
;E0A738 8>897: 94 ! /15798 984389738; 3/8 5768 A0>38>340>5 1928; B8<098 3/8 94B1>7: 53734>2 3/73 3/898 45 >0;898:4A340>0<;13?0>3/8=7930<3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3 7>;4>E48@0<3/80E89>68>349A1:7954>A8A90=:055@75 <01>; %H @/4A/ 45 B8:0@ H 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 45 >03 8>343:8; <09 7>? A06=8>57340> 3 45 >03 3/8 A06=8>57340> 53738;733/897380<5%"=897A984530B8A0>54;898;
75 A0>38>;8; B? :879>8; ;;4340>7: ;E0A738 8>897: /8 <79689 45 8>343:8; <09 3/8 574; 7601>3 0>:? @/8> 3/8 A90=
:055515374>8;45H7>;7B0E875=890E89>68>349A1:79 51=97 > 3/8 A758 0> /7>; 3/8 A90= :055 515374>8; 75 =89 3/867/7K7951B64338;B?=94E738985=0>;8>345%H7>;75 =89 3/8 06643388 98=093 45 &H @/4A/ 45 <79 B8:0@ 3/8 98=09351B64338;B?3/8=94E738985=0>;8>3/4575=8A30< 3/8 673389 /75 B88> 64558; B? >D149?
<<4A89 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 75 @8:: 75 3/8 =834340>89 @/4:8 4><:4A34>2 3/8 =1>45/68>3/4575=8A30<3/86733890>98A09;A0>54;898; B?3/894B1>7:7==90=94738:?7>;B?@8::98750>8;09;893/8 94B1>7: 7::0@8; 3/8 7==:4A7340> 58334>2 754;8 3/8 09;89 @/4A/;085>03A7::<097>?4>389<898>A8733/8/7>;50<3/45 01937>;7AA09;4>2:?5012/330;4564553/8@943=834340> F 7E4>2/879;3/8:879>8;A01>58:<093/8=793485 =89158; 3/8 8>3498 @943 =834340> =7=895 3/8 0>:? =04>3 3/73 @01:;79458<09019A0>54;897340>45- L#/83/89 3/8 94B1>7: 45 I1534<48; 4> 7::0@4>2 3/8 7==:4A7340> 3/898B? 58334>2 754;8 3/8 09;89 46=12>8; 7>; =7554>2 A0>58D18>347:;498A340>5M
197>5@89303/87B0E8=04>3<09A0>54;897340>45 4>,7<<496734E8*<093/8<0::0@4>2
345>034>;45=1383/73;1830/87E?974><7::3/8 A06=:74>7>3 >768:? 7>167>201;7 /75 51<<898; :055 0< A90= 7>; /8 /75 67;8 7> 7==:4A7340> <09 A06=8>57340> 4> 38965 0< 3/8 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 > E48@ 0< 3/8 7==:4A7340> 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 A0>;1A38; 67/7K79 7>;
51B64338; 98=093 3/73 3/8 A90= :055 515374>8; B? 3/8 574;
A06=:74>7>3 @75 73 %H @/4A/ 45 <79 B8:0@ H 75 =89 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 53738; 7>; 98A0668>;8; 3/8 5768 30 3/8 7/754:;79 85=438 3/8 574; 67/7K79 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 7==907A/8; 3/8 1=894>38>;8>3 0< 0:4A8 79>737C70C7?1C370:4A874A/19A06=:74>4>27274>533/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 0< ;898:4A340> 0< ;13? @/4A/ 67;8 3/8 0:4A879>737C70C7?1C3774A/1930@94387:83389303/8 7/754:;79 30 588C 4><0967340> 0> 3/8 574; 75=8A3 0< 3/8 673389 0> 3/8 B7545 0< 3/8 7::827340>5 67;8 B? 574;
7>167>20@;7 7/754:;798E7;19274>=19517>A80<3/8
:83389 7==04>38; 7 06643388 30 4>5=8A3 3/8 673389 7>;
51B643 98=093 /8 06643388 51B64338; 435 98=093 /0:;4>2 3/733/8A90=:055515374>8;&HB?3/8A06=:74>7>375=89 3/898=09373>>8G198&@/4A/45<79B8:0@3/7>3/80>8 53738;B?3/8=94E738985=0>;8>348303/88G38>30<%H <389 98A84=3 0< 3/8 5768 3/8 0:4A8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37 74A/19 <09@79;8; 3/8 5768 30 3/8 0E89>68>3 75 @8:: 75 3/879>737C70C7?1C37@43/7=90=057:30A:0583/8A75875 3/8 A06=:74>7>3 45 >03 8>343:8; <09 7>? A06=8>57340> 4> 38965 0< 3/8 0E89>68>3 49A1:79 53738; 0@8E89 ;85=438 3/8 574; 4><0967340> 3/8 0E89>68>3 =90A88;8; 30 8>391533/8673389303/879>737C70C7?1C37@/4A/4>319> 7==04>38;3/882453979>D14948579>737C70C7?1C3775 >D149? <<4A89 7>; =90A88;8; 30 45518 934A:85 0< A/79285 7>;0B589E7340>>03830@/4A/3/87/754:;79 98=:48;
/0@8E89 3/898 45 >0 98=:? B? 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 1B58D18>3 30 3/8 98A84=3 0< 0BI8A340>5"98=:? 3/8 >D149? <<4A89=90A88;8;@43/3/88>D149?7>;/8:;3/733/8A/79285 7274>53 45 >03 =90E8; 7>; A/79285 :8E8:8; B? 3/8
&
;45A4=:4>79? 713/0943? 7274>53 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 /75 B88> =90E8; 7>; 51B64338; 3/8 98=093 30 3/8 79>737C7 0C7?1C37/879>737C70C7?1C374>319><09@79;8;3/8 98=093 7:0>2 @43/ 98A0668>;7340> 0< =1>45/68>3 53738; 4> 3/8 574; 98A0668>;7340> /8 0E89>68>3 51B58D18>3 30 3/8 98A84=3 0< 98=093 7>; 98A0668>;7340> 45518; 58A0>; 5/0@A7158>034A830@/4A/3/8=94E738985=0>;8>398=:48;
5 A01:; B8 588> <906 3/8 98A09; 58A0>; 5/0@ A7158 >034A8 @75 589E8; 0> 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 0> AA09;4>2:? /8 /75 51B64338; /45 98=:?
0> F /8 =1>45/68>3 09;89 A768 30 B8 =7558; 0> F&487<38960983/7>?879560>3/50@8E89 3/8=834340>89/7553738;3/733/8=94E738985=0>;8>3/75>03 51B64338;/4598=:?3/450B589E7340>4>3/83883/0<98A09;5 451>515374>7B:8
& /894B1>7:7<389A0>54;894>23/88>34986738947:
=:7A8; B8<098 43 /75 /8:; 3/73 @/8> 3/8 A90= :055 45 B8:0@ H75=893/8214;8:4>85<4G8;B?3/80E89>68>349A1:79 3/8 <79689 45 >03 8>343:8; <09 A90= A06=8>57340> 7>; <01>;
%
3/73 3/898 45 >0 <71:3 A0664338; B? 3/8 =94E738 985=0>;8>3 @/4:8;45A/7924>2/45;13?@/4A/7AA09;4>2303/8=834340>89 75@8::753/879>737C70C7?1C377601>3530;898:4A340>0< ;13? /8 94B1>7: /7E4>2 <01>; 3/73 3/898 45 >0 51A/ ;898:4A340>0<;13?7553728;B?3/8>D149? <<4A8975@8::75 3/8 0E89>68>3 =90A88;8; 30 7::0@ 3/8 7==:4A7340> 58334>2 754;8 3/8 09;89 46=12>8; 98750>4>2 =7934A1:79:? 73 =797 05F7>;0<3/809;89#8<4>;>04><496434854>3/809;89 =7558; B? 3/8 94B1>7: /8 94B1>7: 7<389 A0>54;894>2 3/8 8>34986738947:/75/8:;3/733/89845>0;898:4A340>0<;13?75 7::828;7274>533/8=94E738985=0>;8>3 % 09 3/8 <09204>2 98750>5 3/8 =04>3 97458; <09 A0>54;897340> 45 7>5@898; 7AA09;4>2:? 7>; @8 =90A88; 30 =7553/8<0::0@4>2-
4$ /8 @943 =834340>
689435 7>; 7AA09;4>2:?;4564558; 44$ > 38965 0< 3/8 ;498A340> 45518; B? 3/8 94B1>7: 3/8 =834340>89"3738 0E89>68>3
5833:8 7:: 3/8 A0>58D18>347:
60>4309? B8>8<435 =7?7B:8 30 3/8 7==:4A7>3 @43/4> 7 =8940; 0< 3@0 60>3/5 <906 3/8 ;738 0< 98A84=30<A0=?0<3/4509;89 444$ 009;897530A053
+,
( ) '
+,
(%) '
-!