- 1 - ! "!# #! $ %!#!! $ %! ! !## &'( ) ! "#$%% & ' ( % $$ )*+ ,+ !-"#%% ' +,.# ,$.*.( Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %,.,% + + "#%% & ' / ## % ( %.'%( %)## #. *%% % - %$).$ ,*0 *. , %0 ! 1 1 - 3 - % ' 1( 234 566758 34 9387: ;< =27 >853?5@= AB74=3C@3@D =27 AB5@=B? C9 >C?67@45=3C@ 5E5F:7: ;< =27 ::3=3C@58 7@3CF 3G38 B:D7 5@: 5@: 3:5F '9CF 42CF= HF3;B@58I(65447:3@C*%% %:5=7:#. 27 95>=B58 ?5=F3J C9 =27 >547 C9 >853?5@= ;79CF7 =27 =F3;B@58 =25= C@ $ 3@ ;7=E77@ * 6? C@ 3:5F,B?@5;5: FC5: 5@ 5>>3:7@= E54 =5K7@ 685>7 :B7 =C F542 5@: @7D83D7@= F3:3@D C9 ?C=CF><>87 C+,.# ,$.*. 5@: =27 >853? C9 >853?5@= ;79CF7 =27 F3;B@58 =25= 54 5 F74B8= C9 =27 5>>3:7@= >853?5@= 25: 4B4=53@7: DF37GCB4 3@LBF374 853?5@= E54 5D7: 5;CB= $ <75F45@:ECFK3@D3@53397C?65@<+C85F5@:75F@3@D 4% ,67F?C@=2 . @ 4B66CF= C9 234 >547 >853?5@= 7J5?3@7: =27 C>=CF , 5@: =27 C>=CF 5447447: =27 :345;383=< C9 %0 5@: 344B7: =27 :345;383=< >7F=393>5=7 B7 =C =27 5>>3:7@==27>853?5@=4B4=53@7:=F5B?5=3>;F53@3@LBF<5@: - 4 - 8C4= >C@4>3CB4@744 4>5@ C9 ;F53@ F7G7587: 85FD7 27?CFF25D7 3@ ,;5458 D5@D83C@ E3=2 ;F53@ 7:7?5 5@: ?3:83@7 4239= 5@: 9F5>=BF7 C9 85=7F E588 C9 F3D2= CF;3= 27 4>5@C9;F53@F7G7587:3@>F75473@7:7?5?38:83@74239= 5@: E3=2 4B;,954>3@7 27F@35=3C@ 5@: :7=7F3CF5=3C@ C9 >C@:3=3C@ >83@3>588< @ % 5@ 7?7FD7@>< ,43:7 :7,>C?6F7443G7 >F5@3C=C?< E54 :C@7 7 25: 763876=3> 93=4 8C44 C9 4623@>=7F >C@=FC8 275F= 5@: 5F7 27?365F7434 :BF3@D 6C4= C67F5=3G7 67F3C: 9CF E23>2 =F5>27C=C?<E54:C@7C@.27>853?5@==CCK =F75=?7@= 3@ 5=2BF 7BFC8CD< 83@3> <:7F5;5: C@ ## 7 254 :35D@C47: =C ;7 4B997F3@D 9FC? 6C4= ;F53@ 3@LBF< 4654=3> F3D2= 43:7 27?3687D35 5@: 7638764< E3=2 8C44 C9 4623@>=7F >C@=FC8 34 4677>2 34 B@>875F 5@: 3@5B:3;87 :759@744 3@ F3D2= 75F E75K@744 3@ F3D2= B667F 5@:8CE7F83?;4C>C@=FC8CG7FBF3@5=3C@5@::797>5=3C@ @5;87 =C 2C8: =27 C;L7>= E3=2 F3D2= 25@: CF 839= E73D2= B@5;87 =C E58K 5@: @77:4 4B66CF= 9CF FCB=3@7 62<43>58 5>=3G3=374 83K7 =C387= ;5=23@D :F7443@D >C?;3@D 977:3@D - 5 - 7=>5@:C@7J5?3@5=3C@279CB@:48CEB@:7F4=5@:3@D5@: 5@4E7F3@D =27 FCB=3@7 AB74=3C@4 5?@7435 C9 5>>3:7@= 7G7@= F3D2= B667F 5@: 8CE7F 83?;4 4654=3>3=< C9 ?CG7?7@=4 5= LC3@=4 2<67F F7987J35 3@,>CCF:3@5=3C@ C9 93@D7F ?CG7?7@=4 6CE7F , 3@ 588 DFCB6 C9 ?B4>874 4BDD74=3@DB667F?C=CF@7BFC@8743C@5@:65F58<434CE >853?5@=E54B@:7F=27>B4=C:<C9234?C=27F $ 27 >853? 67=3=3C@ E54 F7434=7: ;< F746C@:7@= C ;< :7@<3@D =27 3@>C?7 C>>BFF7@>7 C9 5>>3:7@= @5=BF7 C9 3@LBF374 5@: :345;383=< 5@: =27 5?CB@= 467@= =CE5F:4 ?7:3>58 7J67@474 BF=27F 3= 34 5887D7: =25= =27 F3:7FC9=27?C=CF><>87E3=2CB=2C8:3@DG583:5@:7997>=3G7 :F3G3@D 83>7@>7 =C :F3G7 =27 65F=3>B85F =<67 C9 G723>87 5887D7: =C 25G7 ;77@ 3@GC8G7: 3@ =27 453: 5>>3:7@= 5@: =27F7 34 @C F7D34=F5=3C@ >7F=393>5=7 67F?3= 5@: 93=@744 9CF =273@4BF7:G723>87 @ CF:7F =C 4B;4=5@=35=7 =27 @5=BF7 C9 3@LBF374 5@:584C=C6FCG7=27>853??5:7;<=273@LBF7:5427E54 @C= 3@ 5 6C43=3C@ =C 4675K 234 @7J= 9F37@: ?C=27F E54 - 6 - F76F747@=7: 5@: 7J5?3@7: 54 ,% 5@: 6FC:B>7: :C>B?7@=454J4%=C%273@LBF7:584CDC=7J5?3@7: =27 C>=CF 54 27 F746C@:7@=,3@4BF5@>7 >C?65@< 2547J5?3@7:3=4C993>35854,%5@:254@C=?5FK7:5@< :C>B?7@=C@=273F;72589 * 5G3@D =5K7@ @C=7 C9 588 =2747 ?5=7F3584 5G5385;87 C@ F7>CF: 3= 34 >C@=7@:7: =25= =27 F3;B@58 >C??3==7: 5@ 7FFCF 3@ =5K3@D =27 :345;383=< C9 0 54 5D53@4= =27 7G3:7@>7 C9 %0 5@: 5E5F:3@D 87447F >C?67@45=3C@C94%$).$ , 27 ?53@ >C@=7@=3C@ C9 =27 >CB@478 56675F3@D 9CF =27 5667885@= ;79CF7 =234 >CBF= 34 =25= =27 =F3;B@58 >C??3==7:5@7FFCF3@F7:B>3@D=27:345;383=<C909FC? %05@:CBD2==C25G7=5K7@9B@>=3C@58:345;383=<C9%0 43@>7273425G3@D@C>C@=FC8CG7F=272589C9=27;C:<3@ F7467>=C9=27F3D2=6CF=3C@5@:584C=27B667F5@:8CE7F 83?;47@>73=F7AB3F743@=7F97F7@>7C9=234CBF= - 7 - # =27 >CB@478 56675F3@D 9CF =27 3@4BF5@>7 >C?65@< ECB8: >C@=7@: =25= =2CBD2 C>=CF 34 @C= 5 =F75=7: C>=CF ;B= 5447447: %0 C9 :345;383=< 5@: @C=%05@:=F3;B@58F3D2=8<=5K7@0C9=27:345;383=< 5@: @C= >C??3==7: 5@< 7FFCF 5@: 3= :C74@I= F7AB3F74 5@< 3@=7F97F7@>77@>756675834835;87=C;7:34?3447: ) 5G3@D275F:=275667885@=>CB@4785@:584C=27 >CB@478 56675F3@D 9CF =27 F746C@:7@=4 =27 6C3@= =25= ECB8:5F3479CF>C@43:7F5=3C@C9=234>CBF=5F7, 3( 27=27F =27 =F3;B@58 >C??3==7: 5@ 7FFCF 3@ 93J3@D =27 :345;383=< C9 0 5@: E27=27F 3= F7AB3F743@=7F97F7@>7C9=234CBF=3@5E5F:3@D LB4=>C?67@45=3C@M 33( 25=CF:7FM % 5G3@D275F:=27875F@7:>CB@47856675F3@D9CF =27 5667885@= 5@: 584C >C@43:7F3@D =27 ?5=7F358 5G5385;87 C@ F7>CF: 65F=3>B85F8< =27 7G3:7@>7 C9 3= 34 G7F< >875F=25=272545447447:=27:345;383=<C9%0:B7=C=27 3@LBF374 4B4=53@7: ;< >853?5@= 27 =F3;B@58 584C =5K7@ - 8 - @C=7C9@5=BF7C93@LBF3743@65F5DF562C%3@:7=5385@: 3=345>875F>547C965F58<434C@C@743:7C9=27;C:<C9=27 >853?5@= 5@: 27 34 B@5;87 =C :34>25FD7 5@< :B=374 27 7G3:7@>7 C9 C>=CF 34 G7F< >875F =25= =27 4677>2 C9 =27 >853?5@= 34 B@>875F 5@: 3@5B:3;87 =27F7 34 5 :759@744 3@ F3D2=43:775F5@:E75K@7443@F3D2=B667F5@:8CE7F83?; @C >C@=FC8 CG7F BF3@5=3C@ 5@: :797>5=3C@ B@5;87 =C 2C8: =27 C;L7>= E3=2 F3D2= 25@: CF 839= E73D2= 5@: B@5;87 =C E58K 27 @77:4 =27 4B66CF= 9CF 62<43>58 5>=3G3=374 9CF 588 :5<=C:5<5>=3G3=374 %% 27@ 4B>2 ;73@D =27 >547 =27 =F3;B@58 8C4= 43D2=C9=2745?73@>C@43:7F3@D=277G3:7@>7;B=F7:B>7: =27 :345;383=< =C 0 E3=2CB= 5443D@3@D 5@< F754C@4 3@ >C?3@D=C4B>25>C@>8B43C@5@:=27C@I;8767JCBF=3@ =27>547C9 % 3=4789 =5K7@ *)0 C9 :345;383=< >C@43:7F3@D=279B@>=3C@58:345;383=<54%05@:27@>73= 34 5 >875F >547 C9 :345;383=< C9 %0 27@ =27F7 34 @C 1 (2022) 15 SCC 620 - 9 - >C@=FC8 CG7F =27 B667F 5@: 8CE7F 83?;4 5@: 7G7@ 39 C@7 43:7 ;C:< 34:C 4C?75>=67F?3=4 =27 45?7>5@@C=;7 5 DFCB@: =C F7544744 =27 :345;383=< =C =27 0 27F79CF7 =234 >CBF= 254 =C =5K7 @C=7 C9 =27 9B@>=3C@58 :345;383=< C9 %0 % CE >C?3@D =C =27 5467>=C9=275>>3:7@==25= E54=5K7@685>73@=27<75F=F3;B@58254=5K7@=27 3@>C?7 54 4% , 5@: CBD2= =C 25G7 =5K7@ 4%. , 27 =F3;B@58 584C >C??3==7: 5@ 7FFCF 3@ @C= >C@43:7F3@D =27 9B=BF7 6FC467>=4 5@: =27 6F3@>36874 853: :CE@3@=2759CF7453::7>343C@E27F73@3=34G7F<>875F=25= E2387 =5K3@D %0 C9 :345;383=< 584C =C 5:: $0 9B=BF7 6FC467>=4 =27F7=C 43@>7 27 34 5D7: $ <75F4 5@: =27 ?C@=28< 8C44 C9 75F@3@D =C ;7 AB5@=3937: 3@>8B:3@D 234 3@>C?7 54 E788 54 9B=BF7 6FC467>=4 5@: 584C =27 F787G5@= ?B8=36837F %. CE >C?3@D =C =27 >C@>8B43C@ C9 %0 C9 :345;383=< =CE5F:4 8C44 C9 75F@3@D C9 3@LBF7: 5@: 584C >C@43:7F3@D $0 C9 9B=BF7 6FC467>=4 54 E788 54 =27 - 10 - F787G5@= ?B8=36837F C9 H%#I 3= >C?74 =C 4$%# , '%.N$0O%) , J %J%#J%0( =CE5F:4 H8C44 C9 9B=BF775F@3@D>565>3=<I %$ 27=F3;B@585E5F:7:5@5?CB@=C94 , =CE5F:4 653@ 5@: 4B997F3@D 5@: 25G3@D =5K7@ @C=7 C9 =27 @5=BF7 C9 3@LBF374 5@: :345;383=< 3@4=75: C9 4 , 3= 7@25@>7:=C4 , % CE>C?3@D=C=27>C?67@45=3C@=CE5F:49CC: 5@:@CBF342?7@==273@LBF7:4B4=53@7:?B8=36879F5>=BF74 5@: 275: 3@LBF< 5G3@D =5K7@ @C=7 C9 =27 453: 95>= 3@>8B:3@D =27 9CC: >C@G7<5@>7 5@: >25FD74 F3;B@58 5E5F:7:5@5?CB@=C94% ,5@:45?7347@25@>7: =C4 ,27?7:3>587J67@474C94)*$ ,34 F7=53@7:543=34;547:C@=27:C>B?7@=5F<7G3:7@>7 %* CE 25G3@D =5K7@ @C=7 C9 =27 @5=BF7 C9 =27 3@LBF374 4B4=53@7: ;< =27 3@LBF7: 54 27 F7AB3F74 =27 =F75=?7@= =2FCBD2CB= 234 8397 27 C@I;87 67J CBF= 3@ =27:7>343C@F797FF7:4B6F5584C7@25@>7:=2745?79FC? - 11 - 4% ,=C4. ,54:34>B447:3@65F5DF562 C) 5@: 27@>7 3= 34 566FC6F35=7 =C 5E5F: 5@ 5?CB@= C9 4. , =CE5F:4 9B=BF7 ?7:3>58 7J67@474 43@>7 3@LBF7: ?B4= =5K7 =27 =F75=?7@= =2FCBD2CB= 234 8397 >C@43:7F3@D=27@5=BF7C93@LBF374 % 27F3;B@585E5F:7:5@5?CB@=C94 , =CE5F:4 H8C44 C9 3@>C?7 :BF3@D =F75=?7@= 67F3C:I 45?7 >5@@C=;7>C@43:7F7:E27@=234CBF=254=5K7@%0C9 :345;383=<=27AB74=3C@C95E5F:3@D5@<4B>2>C?67@45=3C@ :BF3@D=2767F3C:C9=F75=?7@=:C74@1=5F347 %# CE>C?3@D=C=275467>=C98C44C95?7@3=37434 >C@>7F@7: =27 F3;B@58 5E5F:7: 5@ 5?CB@= C9 4 ,25G3@D=5K7@@C=7C9@5=BF7C93@LBF37454=27 3@LBF7: 4B4=53@7:3@LBF3745= =27 5D7 C9$ <75F4 5@: =27 45?7584C=C;7=5K7@@C=7C9E23875E5F:3@D=278C44C9 5?7@3=374 =27 5E5F: 5?CB@= C9 4 , 34 G7F< ?75D7F =234 CBF= 254 =C =5K7 @C=7 C9 8C44 C9 5?7@3=374 E27@=273@LBF7:25:4B4=53@7:=273@LBF3745==275D7C9 - 12 - $ 3= 34 566FC6F35=7 =C 5E5F: C9 4 , =CE5F:4 H8C44C95?7@3=374I %) CE >C?3@D =C =27 5467>= C9 >C?67@45=3C@ =CE5F:4 5==7@:5@= >25FD7434 >C@>7F@7: E27@ =234 CBF= >C?74=C=27>C@>8B43C@=25=3=345%0C9:345;383=<5@: 584C =27 C>=CF E2C 254 ;77@ 7J5?3@7: 54 >5=7DCF3>588< :76C47: ;79CF7 =27 F3;B@58 =25= 3@LBF7: 34 B@5;87 =C 5==7@: 234 :5< =C :5< 5>=3G3=374 5@: 62<43>58 5>=3G3=374584C>5@@C=;7:C@75@:E27@27343@@77:C95@ 54434=5@>7 C9 5 67F4C@ =27 6F3@>36874 853: :CE@ 3@ I4 >547 '4B6F5( 3@ 65F5DF562 @C# :34>B447: 3@ :7=5383@5>547C9*)0C9:345;383=<E27F73@584C=5K7@=27 :345;383=< C9 %0 2387 F75447443@D =27 ?5=7F358 5G5385;87 C@ F7>CF: 7G7@ =27 C@I;87 67J CBF= 584C :34>B447:=27:7>343C@C9 =25==CC 3@5>547C9?3@CF;B=27F7345>547C9=273@LBF7:345D7: 5;CB=$<75F45@:27@77:45@5==7@:5@==2FCBD2CB=234 8397 5@: =27 C@I;87 67J CBF= 3@ I4 >547 2 (2020) 4 SCC 413 - 13 - '4B6F5(254=5K7@=27>C@47FG5=3G774=3?5=7C94 , 67F ?C@=2 56675F4 =C ;7 =27 ;5F7 ?3@3?B? 5@: 25G3@D 5:C6=7:=27?B8=36837FC9H%#I5@5::3=3C@58>C?67@45=3C@ CF:7F7:5=4%# ,5@:3@=234>547584CE75:C6= =27 G7F< 45?7 6F3@>3687 853: :CE@ ;< =27 67J CBF= 3@ I4 >547 '4B6F5( 5@: 5E5F:7: 5@ 5?CB@= C9 4%# ,=CE5F:4H5==7@:5@=>25FD74I 27 3@LBF7: 25: 4B4=53@7: =27 3@LBF374 5= =27 5D7C9$<75F45@:>C@93@7:=C;7:5@::B7=C=27@5=BF7 C93@LBF374=27F734@C>25@>74C9?5FF35D73@9B=BF727@ 4B>2;73@D=27>547=234CBF=ECB8:584C=C=5K7@C=7C9 =27 8C44 C9 ?5FF35D7 6FC467>=4 25G3@D =5K7@ @C=7 C9 =27 6F3@>36874 853: :CE@ ;< =27 C@I;87 67J CBF= 3@ I4 >547 '4B6F5( 5@ 5?CB@= C9 4. , 34 5E5F:7: =CE5F:48C44C9?5FF35D76FC467>=45@:584C=27:7>343C@3@ =27 >547 C9 ! .=2767JCBF==CE5F:4H8C44C9?5FF35D76FC467>=4I 584C 5E5F:7: 5@ 5?CB@= C9 4. , 5@: 27@>7 E7 3 2022 SCC Online SC 1488 - 14 - 5E5F: 5@ 5?CB@= C9 4. , =CE5F:4 H8C44 C9 ?5FF35D76FC467>=4I % 7 25G7 >C@43:7F7: =27 ?5=7F358 5G5385;87 C@ F7>CF:5@:F7G343=7:3@5E5F:3@D=27>C?67@45=3C@=25=34 LB4= 5@: F754C@5;87 >C?67@45=3C@ 5@: 27@>7 5@4E7F7: =27 6C3@= C% 54 5993F?5=3G7 27 F75447447: >C?67@45=3C@34549C88CE4, % C44C99B=BF775F@3@D>565>3=< 4$%# , 53@5@:4B997F3@D 4 , . CC:5@:@CBF342?7@= 4 , $ 7:3>587J67@474 4)*$ , B=BF7?7:3>587J67@474 4. , * C44C95?7@3=374 4 , ==7@:5@=>25FD74 4%# , # 5FF35D76FC467>=4 4. , *+, - . @G37EC9=27:34>B443C@4?5:75;CG7E76544 =279C88CE3@D 3( 6675834588CE7: 33( 27 LB:D?7@= 5@: 5E5F: :5=7: #. 65447: 3@ C*%% % ;< =27 CBF= C9 - 15 - =27 ::3=3C@58 7@3CF 3G38 B:D7 5@: 3:5F34?C:3937: 333( 27 3@LBF7: 34 7@=3=87: 9CF >C?67@45=3C@ C9 4%$$ , 54 5D53@4= 4%$).$ , 5E5F:7:;<=27F3;B@5858C@DE3=23@=7F74=5= =27F5=7C9*067F5@@B? 3G( 27 7@25@>7: >C?67@45=3C@ 34 65<5;87 ;< @4BF7F3@73D2=E77K4E3=23@=7F74= G( B= C9 =27 >C?67@45=3C@ 5?CB@= )0 E3=2 6FC6CF=3C@5=7 3@=7F74= ?B4= ;7 K76= 3@ 93J7: :76C43= 5@: =27 45?7 34 F7@7E5;87 67F3C:3>588< 5B=C?5=3>588< E3=2CB= 5@< 9BF=27F CF:7F49FC?=27F3;B@58 G3( 27 ?C=27F C9 =27 3@LBF7: 34 7@=3=87: =C E3=2:F5E =27 3@=7F74= AB5F=7F8< =CE5F:4 =F75=?7@= 5@: C=27F ?53@=7@5@>7 C9 =27 3@LBF7: G33( 27 F7?53@3@D %0 E3=2 6FC6CF=3C@5=7 3@=7F74= 34 65<5;87 =C =27 5>>CB@= C9 =27 ?C=27FC9=273@LBF7::3F7>=8<;<C;=53@3@D=27 ;5@K 5>>CB@= 5@: =27 67=3=3C@7F >CB@478 34 :3F7>=7:=C9BF@342=27;5@K5>>CB@=9CF=2E3=2 =CF3;B@58 - 16 - G333( 27 ;5@K 34 584C :3F7>=7: @C= =C 6FCG3:7 5@< 8C5@ E3=2CB= CF:7F C9 =27 F3;B@58 C@ =27 :76C43=7:5?CB@=C9=273@LBF7: !/. &#!!( % !/. &( % 4@ 34=C%8C.