- 1 - ! "# $% "" &'( )* "" + &'( ) * ! !" # $ % & # ! '(( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )* # '+( ' '', $ % *- *- '& * * ,%&* * # ' # ' # ( ! *# ! + ) * * # '+( . $ % & / - 3 - ! ', ! ', # * # # ' ! '( '', ' $ % *- & * * ,%&* # # ' # ( *# ! * # 0 # - 4 - % 12324352667829:3*4;3< ==2763>462?:8?2;25<498 ,%& 9> <12 9<9; 2145623 5< %>9; 319;< 12;2487><2; ;2>2;;2? <9 73 @<12 5<A& 7;432 9:< 9> <12 B:?CD28< 78? 7E7;? ?7<2? =7332? FG ' ??4<49876 2849; 4H46 #:?C2 78? 9<9; 554?28< 674D3 ;4F:876' 4B7G7=:;7489( ;42>>75<3C4H48C;432<9>4648C9><12327==2763 7;2<17<98<12?252732?'14H7?73:<7;E73 =;9522?48C 98 D9<9;5G562 F27;48C ;2C43<;7<498 9'' '/ >;9D 9:B2 <9 767DF964 <9 7<<28? 7 D7;;47C2 52;2D98G128<12GE2;2827;<127554?28<3=9< F:357D2>;9D148?34?27<<17<<4D2982 7B7B4359H2;G ;4?2; 57D2 >;9D E;98C 34?2 48 7 ;731 78? 82C64C28< D7882;>;9DF2148?78??7312?<9<12D9<9;5G5629><12 ?252732? :2 <9 E1451 <12 ?252732? >266 ?9E8 98 <12 ;97?78?7<<17<<4D2<12F:3;789H2;<12F9?G9> <12 ?252732? 78? 73 7 ;23:6< <12 14H7?73 ?42? 98 <12 - 5 - 3=9< 12 =2<4<4982;3 7;2 <12 62C76 ;2=;2328<7<4H23 9> <12 ?252732?'14H7?73 >462? 5674D =2<4<498 :8?2; 25<498 (( 9><12 5<322I48C59D=2837<498987559:8<9><12?27<1 9>14H7?7348<12;97?<;7>>457554?28< 12 ;4F:876 433:2? 89<452 <9<129E82; 9> <12 7B7B 4359H2;G D9<9;5G562 23=4<2 32;H452 9> 89<452 12 ;2D7482?:8;2=;2328<2?78?E73=6752?2J=7;<2 12 83:;7852 9D=78G >462? 3<7<2D28< 9> 9FB25<4983 ?28G48C <12 7H2;D28<3 D7?2 48 <12 5674D =2<4<49878? 598<28?2? <17<<12 7554?28<955:;;2??:2 <9 <12;73178?82C64C28<?;4H48C9><12?;4H2;9><12 F:3 2852 <12 83:;7852 9D=78G 43 89< 647F62 <9 =7G <12 59D=2837<498 7D9:8< 2852 4< =;7G2? <9 ?43D433 <125674D=2<4<4987C7483<<12 83:;78529D=78G + 12 7639 >462? 3<7<2D28< 9> 9FB25<4983 ?28G48C <12 7H2;D28<3 D7?2 48 <12 5674D =2<4<498 78? 598<28?2?<17<<127662C2?7554?28<<99I=6752?:2<9;731 78? 82C64C28< ;4?48C 9> <12 ;4?2; 9> <12 7B7B 4359H2;G - 6 - D9<9;5G562 12 83:;7852 9D=78G 43 647F62 <9 =7G <12 59D=2837<498 7D9:8< 2852 4< =;7G2? <9 ?43D433 <12 5674D=2<4<4987C7483< ( 12 ;4F:876 98 <12 F7343 9> =627?48C3 9> <12 =7;<423>;7D2?<12;262H78<433:2378?7??4<49876433:23 , 12 =2<4<4982;3 48 9;?2; <9 3:F3<78<47<2 <124; 57322J7D482?=2<4<4982;973 78?2J7D482?982 E4<823373 78?C9<D7;I2??95:D28<373J3 <9 8;2F:<<76<129>>452;9><12 83:;78529D=78G E732J7D482?7378?C9<D7;I2??95:D28<373 J3<9 12 ;4F:876 7><2; ;259;?48C <12 2H4?2852 127;48C F9<1 34?23 78? 98 733233D28< 9> H2;F76 78? ?95:D28<7;G 2H4?2852 7669E2? <12 5674D =2<4<498 48 =7;< E4<1593<378?7E7;?2?59D=2837<4989>3'<9 =2<4<4982; 9 78? 3+' <9 =2<4<4982; 9 7698C E4<148<2;23<7<<12;7<29>/K=2;788:D>;9D<12?7<29> =2<4<498 <466 4<3 59D=62<2 ;2764L7<498 12;4F:876 ?4;25<2? - 7 - <12 83:;78529D=78G<9=7G<1259D=2837<4987D9:8< 78? ;259H2; <12 37D2 >;9D <12 9E82; 9> <12 7B7B 4359H2;GD9<9;5G562 / 12 =2<4<4982;3 F248C ?4337<43>42? E4<1 <12 M:78<:D 9> 59D=2837<498 7E7;?2? FG <12 ;4F:876 >462? 7==276 48 * 9(,/ 78? <12 83:;7852 9D=78G 7CC;42H2? FG <12 M:78<:D 9> 647F464<G >462? 7==27648* 9(/ 27;? <12 627;82? 59:8326 >9; <12 83:;7852 9D=78G627;82?59:8326>9;<12=2<4<4982;378?627;82? 59:8326>9;<12 27;82? 59:8326 >9; <12 83:;7852 9D=78G 3:FD4<3<17<<12;2E73 59D=934<2 82C64C285298<12=7;< 9><12?;4H2;9><12F:378?<12;4?2;9><12 7B7B 4359H2;G D9<9;5G562 :< <12 ;4F:876 173 89< 7==9;<4982? 78? >73<282?<12 647F464<G 98 2 7639 3:FD4<3 <17< <12 ;4?2; 9> <12 D9<9;5G562 E73 89< =93323348C H764? 78? 2>>25<4H2 ?;4H48C 6452852 73 98 <12 - 8 - ?7<2 9> <12 7554?28< 78? <12;2>9;2 <12;2 43 H4967<498 9> =9645G598?4<49832852123:FD4<3<17<<12;4F:876173 59DD4<<2?782;;9;48>73<2848C<1228<4;2647F464<G98<12 83:;78529D=78G8<1232C;9:8?312=;7G3<97669E <127==276>462?FG<12 83:;78529D=78G78?<9?43D433 <127==276>462?FG<12=2<4<4982;3 627;82? 59:8326 >9; <12 3:FD4<3 <17< <12 B:?CD28< 78? 7E7;? =7332? FG <12 ;4F:876 43 B:3< 78? =;9=2; 78? ?9 89< 5766 >9; 78G 48<2;>2;2852 9> <143 9:;< 8 <143 C;9:8? 12 =;7G3 <9 ?43D433<127==276>462?FG<12 83:;78529D=78G73E266 73<127==276>462?FG<12=2<4<4982;3 27;82?59:8326>9;<12=2<4<4982;33:FD4<3<17< <1259D=2837<4987E7;?2?FG<12;4F:8764398<1269E2; 34?2285298<143C;9:8?12=;7G3<97669E<127==276 >462?FG<12=2<4<4982;378?<9?43D433<127==276>462?FG <12 83:;78529D=78G - 9 - 2;:32? <12 ;259;?3 78? 59834?2;2? <12 3:FD43349839>627;82?59:8326>9;<12=7;<423 + 12 =948< <17< 7;4323 >9; 59834?2;7<498 9> <143 9:;<43E4<1;2C7;?<9M:78<:D9>647F464<G78?M:78<:D9> 59D=2837<498 ( 12;24389?43=:<2;2C7;?48C<12955:;;28529> <12 7554?28< 78? <12 ?27<1 9> 14H7?73 48 <12 374? ;97? <;7>>45 7554?28< 8 9;?2; <9 23<7F6431 <17< <12 7554?28< 955:;;2? ?:2 <9 <12 ;731 78? 82C64C28< ?;4H48C 9> <12 ?;4H2; 9> <12 F:3 73 E266 73 <12 ;4?2; 9> <12 D9<9;5G562 <12 =2<4<4982;3 17H2 =;9?:52? <12 517;C2 3122< E1451 43 D7;I2? 73 J ( 12 517;C2 3122< =;9?:52?FG<12=2<4<4982;343487;7<14678C:7C278?4<3 8C6431 <;78367<2? 59=G 43 D7;I2?73 J (%7& =2;:376 9>J (%7&?43569323<17<<127554?28<955:;;2??:2<9<12 ;73178?82C64C28<;4?48C9><12D9<9;5G56273E26673<12 ?;4H2;9><12F:32852<12;4F:876E73B:3<4>42? - 10 - 48;259;?48C4<3>48?48C98433:2948<127>>4;D7<4H2 5985:;E4<1<12>48?48C9><12;4F:87698433:29 , 839>7; 73 647F464<G 43 59852;82? <19:C1 <12 83:;78529D=78G173<7I283=254>45?2>2852<17<<12;2 E73 59D=934<2 82C64C2852 98<12 =7;< 9> <12;4?2; 9> <12 D9<9;5G56278?<12?;4H2;9><12F:3<12;4F:876 ?4?89<59834?2;<12374?73=25<78?59DD4<<2?782;;9;48 >73<2848C<1228<4;2647F464<G98<12 83:;78529D=78G 17H2=2;:32?<128C6431H2;34989>517;C23122<D7;I2? 73 J (%7& E1451 ?43569323 <17< F9<1 <12 ;4?2; 9> <12 D9<9;5G562 78? <12 ?;4H2; 9> <12 F:3 17H2 598<;4F:<2? <9 <12 57:32 9> <12 7554?28< 12 ;4F:876 E4<19:< 59834?2;48C <12 374? 73=25< 173 59DD4<<2? 78 2;;9; 48 >73<2848C <12 28<4;2 647F464<G 98 <12 83:;7852 9D=78G 12;2>9;2 733233 <12 647F464<G 48 <12 ;7<49 9> (++>4J48C(+K647F464<G98<12 83:;78529D=78G78? +K647F464<G98<1219:C1<12627;82?59:8326 >9;<12 83:;78529D=78G598<28?2?<17<<12;4?2;9><12 9>>28?48C D9<9;5G562 E73 89< =93323348C H764? 78? - 11 - 2>>25<4H2 ?;4H48C 6452852 73 98 <12 ?7<2 9> <12 7554?28< 7?D4<<2?6G <12 H214562 E73 483:;2? E4<1 <12 83:;7852 9D=78G 2852 <12 83:;7852 9D=78G 43 647F62 <9 48?2D84>G <12 9E82; 9> <12 9>>28?48C D9<9;5G562 7C7483< <14;? =7;<G 12;2>9;2 <12 ;4F:876 E73 B:3<4>42? 48 ?4;25<48C<12 83:;78529D=78G<9=7G<1259D=2837<498 7<<12>4;3<483<785278?;259H2;<1237D2>;9D<129E82; 9><129>>28?48CD9<9;5G562 8 H42E 9> <12 7F9H2 ?435:33498 783E2; <12 =948<E4<1;2C7;?<9647F464<G7559;?48C6G / 839>7; 73 M:78<:D 9> 59D=2837<498 43 59852;82? 4< 43 598<28?2? FG <12 =2<4<4982;3 <17< <12 ?252732?'14H7?73 E73 7C2? 7F9:< , G27;3 73 9> <12 ?7<2 9> <12 7554?28< 78? 12 E73 ?948C 7C;45:6<:;76 E9;I 78? 27;848C 3' =2; D98<1 9 3:F3<78<47<2 <12 37D2 <12 =2<4<4982;3 17H2 89< =;9?:52? 78G 4859D2 =;99> 8 <12 7F32852 9> =;99> 9> 4859D2 <12 89<49876 4859D2 173 <9 F2 <7I28 73 =2; <12 3512?:62 89<4>42? FG - 12 - 4852<127554?28<439><12G27;<1289<49876 4859D243<7I287<3('=2;D98<19<127>9;2374? 7D9:8<73<12?252732?E737C2?,G27;3+K9><12 374? 7D9:8< 173 <9 F2 7??2? 98 7559:8< 9> >:<:;2 =;93=25<348H42E9><1267E674??9E8FG<12983<4<:<498 2851 9> <12 98AF62 :=;2D2 9:;< 48 <12 5732 9> !" # $ %&"'&;2=9;<2?48()%**)1:3 <12 D98<16G 4859D2 59D23 <9 3,+' :< 9> E1451 59834?2;48C <17< <12;2 7;2 <E9 ?2=28?28<3 ?22D 4< 7==;9=;47<2 <9 ?2?:5< ;? 9> <12 374? 4859D2 <9E7;?3 =2;39876 2J=28323 9> <12 ?252732? 78? <12;2>9;2 <12 D98<16G 4859D2 9> <12 ?252732? 59D23 <9 3+' 7I48C48<97559:8<<127C29><12?252732?E1451E73, G27;3 7< <12 <4D2 9> 7554?28< D:6<4=642; 9> 173 <9 F2 7?9=<2? 73 =2; <12 B:?CD28< 9> <12 980F62 :=;2D2 9:;< 48 <12 5732 9> % + # ,& - ;2=9;<2?48./%12;2>9;2 - 13 - <12 =2<4<4982;3 7;2 28<4<62? <9 7 3:D 9> 3,' %3+'JJ&987559:8<9>69339>?2=28?285G *:;<12; 48 H42E 9> <12 67E 674? ?9E8 FG <12 98AF62 :=;2D2 9:;< 48 <12 5732 9> 0 1 !" # ( &&(2'&;2=9;<2?48.3/3% 2751=2<4<4982;4328<4<62?<973:D9>3'<9E7;?3 6933 9> 59839;<4:D 12 =2<4<4982;3 7;2 <E9 48 8:DF2; 12852<1259D=2837<498<9E7;?369339>59839;<4:DE9:6? F23/('%J& 87??4<498<12=2<4<4982;3 7;2 28<4<62? 7 3:D 9> 3' <9E7;?3 >:82;76 2J=28323 78? 7 3:D 9> 3' <9E7;?3 6933 9> 23<7<2 1:3 48 766 <12 =2<4<4982;3 7;2 28<4<62? <9 7 <9<76 59D=2837<498 9> 3/' 73 7C7483< 3' %3' N 3+'& 7E7;?2? FG <12 ;4F:876 12 =2<4<4982;3 28<4<62? >9; 78 2817852? 59D=2837<4989>3' - 14 - 8 H42E 9> <12 7F9H2 ?435:33498 =;9522? <9 =733<12>9669E48C 9<1<127==27637;2 44 124D=:C82?B:?CD28<78?7E7;??7<2? =7332? FG <12 ' ??4<49876 2849;4H46#:?C278? ' 4B7G7=:; 489(43D9?4>42? 444 12 =2<4<4982;3 7;2 28<4<62? <9 2817852? 59D=2837<4989>3'7698CE4<1 48<2;23<7<<12;7<29>(K=2;788:D>;9D <12 ?7<2 9> 5674D =2<4<498 <466 <12 ?7<2 9> ;2764L7<498 4H 12 83:;7852 9D=78G 43 ?4;25<2? <9 ?2=934<(+K9><1259D=2837<4987D9:8< E4<1755;:2?48<2;23<78?;259H2;<12374? 7D9:8< >;9D <12 9E82; 9> <12 9>>28?48C D9<9;5G562 78? <12 43 ?4;25<2? <9 ?2=934<+K9><1259D=2837<4987D9:8< E4<1 755;:2? 48<2;23< F2>9;2 <12 ;4F:876 E4<148 24C1< E22I3 >;9D <12 ?7<2 9> <12 ;2524=<9>52;<4>42?59=G9><143B:?CD28< - 15 - H 12 7D9:8< 48 ?2=934< 43 9;?2;2? <9 F2 <;783D4<<2?<9<12;4F:876 H4 122C43<;G 43 ?4;25<2? <9 328?F75I <12 ;259;?3<9<12;4F:876 ,) & ( % 43<969 <