- 1 - !" #$%$$ $&& '( ')&*+ '** , !"" # $%% &" '( ! ! $%% !%!# & " ) ! " ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "%$" ) !" ! $* # " $ )+, # $ " $ # ! $ % ' " $ $ " & " -!""" %$ -!"""# ./ 011/22034 5/637 4./ 0889:/; 63 12 0:/ <=> >34./?62/>?4./2/0@3/;;;646>302 /::6>3: 9;7/ $0:4 @08A 1/8602 >9@4 B 6C0D019@0 ?>@ :.>@4 E@602 >9@4F# 6: 6G1973637 4./ C9;7G/34 >? 8>3H6846>3 03; >@;/@ >? :/34/38/ ;04/; 8>3H684637 .6G ?>@ 4./ >??/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846>3 - 3 - )) >? 4./ 3;603 /302 >;/ ?>@ :.>@4 -4./ -# 03; /846>3 , # >? @>4/846>3 >? .62;@/3 ?@>G /I902 ??/38/: 84 ?>@ :.>@4 E4./ 84F# 03; :/34/38637 .6G 4> 93;/@7> :6G12/ 6G1@6:>3G/34 ?>@ 0 1/@6>; >? G>34.: 03; 10D 0 ?63/ >? : ?>@ 4./ >??/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846>3 )) >? 03; 4> 93;/@7> D/0@: >? 6G1@6:>3G/34 03; 4> 10D ?63/ >? : ?>@4./>??/38/1936:.052/93;/@/846>3, # >?4./84 J64.;/?0924:/34/38/: !@6/? ?084: >? 4./ 80:/ 0: G0;/ >94 5D 4./ 1@>:/8946>30@/4.04 &)5/6374./G>4./@>?4./H6846G 2>;7/; 4./ ?6@:4 63?>@G046>3 07063:4 93A3>J3 1/@:>3 ?>@ .0H6378>GG644/;:/I9020::0924>3./@;097.4/@07/; D/0@: ./ $ 80G/ 4> 5/ @/76:4/@/; 03; 4./ 63H/:467046>3 J0: 93;/@40A/3 9@637 63H/:467046>3 0889:/; J0: 011@/./3;/; 03; /:4 ;/346?68046>3 0@0;/ J0:./2; J./@/H6846G6;/346?6/;4./0889:/;./H6846G J0: :95C/84/; 4> G/;6802 /I0G63046>3 03; 0?4/@ 8>G12/4637 4./ 63H/:467046>3 8.0@7/:.//4 80G/ 4> 5/ - 4 - ?62/; /0@3/; "076:4@04/ 4>>A 8>736K038/ >? 4./ >??/38/ 03;@/76:4/@/;4./:1/860280:/889:/;011/0@/;5/?>@/ 4./@602>9@4 12/0;/;3>479624D03;8206G/;4>5/4@6/; ) @>:/8946>3 /I0G63/; 63 022 &: 4> + 7>4 G0@A/;I:4>03;1@>;98/;"4>63:911>@4 >?64:8>34/346>3./0889:/;.0:;/36/;022638@6G6304637 G04/@602: 0H062052/ >3 @/8>@; 63 .6: :404/G/34 93;/@ /846>3 )) >? @ 594 .0: 3>4 2/; 03D /H6;/38/ 63 :911>@4 >? .6: ;/?/38/ / 7>4 G0@A/; I ;9@637 8@>::/I0G63046>3 >? &) ./ @602 >9@4 0?4/@ 40A637 634> 8>3:6;/@046>3 022 4./:/ G04/@602: >3 @/8>@; 80G/ 4> 4./ 8>3829:6>3 4.04 4./ 1@>:/8946>3 6: :988/::?92 63 1@>H6374./79624>?4./0889:/;?>@4./>??/38/1936:.052/ 93;/@/846>3))>?03;/846>3, #>?84 03;088>@;6372D ./J0::/34/38/;0::404/;05>H/!/637 077@6/H/;5D4./:0G/ 4./0889:/;6:5/?>@/4.6:>9@4 , /0@;@6"0G0;019@ 2/0@3/;8>93:/2?>@ 4./011/2203403;@60G0;0@.0.059;;63 2/0@3/;67. - 5 - >9@4 >H/@3G/34 2/0;/@ @/:1>3;/34 > B 404/ /:1>3;/34 > 6: :/@H/; 594 93@/1@/:/34/; /@9:/; 4./G04/@602:>3@/8>@; 3 H6/J >? 4./ @6H02 8>34/346>3: 9@7/; 5D 2/0@3/;8>93:/2?>@5>4.4./10@46/: 4./1>6344.04J>92; 0@6:/?>@GD8>3:6;/@046>36: "D03:J/@4>4./05>H/1>6346:634./EF?>@ 4./?>22>J637 &) 6: 4./ G>4./@ >? 4./ H6846G 76@2 J.> 2>;7/;4./?6@:463?>@G046>307063:493A3>J31/@:>3 0:0 @/:924 $80G/ 4> 5/@/76:4/@/; 4 6: 4./ 8>34/346>3>? 4./ 63?>@G034 4.04 >3 , J./3 4./ H6846G 76@2 07/; D/0@: J0: 7@0K637 80442/ 0889:/; 80G/ >3 0 G>4>@8D82/ 0::0924/; ./@ H>29340@62D 809:/; .9@4 03; - 6 - 8>GG644/; 077@0H04/; 1/3/4@046H/ :/I902 0::0924 >3 ./@ ./ H6846G 76@2 80G/ 03; 63?>@G/;@/70@;6374./ 6386;/34 4>./@G>4./@03;:./6349@32>;7/;4./?6@:463?>@G046>3 ./H6846G76@2J0:6GG/;604/2D40A/34>4./.>:1640203; :95C/84/; 4> G/;6802 /I0G63046>3 9@637 63H/:467046>3 0889:/; J0: 011@/./3;/; 3 4./ 4/:4 6;/346?68046>3 10@0;/ H6846G .0: 6;/346?6/; 4./ 0889:/; 03; 4./@/0?4/@ 8.0@7/:.//480G/4>5/?62/;07063:44./0889:/; + ./H6846G6:/I0G63/;0:&./.0:?922D :911>@4/; 4./ 80:/ >? 4./ 1@>:/8946>3 @/70@;637 8>GG6::6>3 >? 4./ >??/38/ 5D 4./ 0889:/; 5D 8>34/3;637 4.04 :./.0;6;/346?6/;4./0889:/;J.62/8>GG6446374./ >??/38/ H/3 4.>97. 4./ H6846G J0: 8@>::/I0G63/; 3>4.637.0:5//3/26864/;4>;6:5/26/H/./@H/@:6>3./ 63?>@G0345/6374./G>4./@>?4./H6846GJ0:/I0G63/;0: &)&,6:D>937/@5@>4./@>?4./H6846G03;./.0: 02:>;/1>:/;63:911>@4>?4./80:/>?4./1@>:/8946>3 - 7 - &+ 6: 4./ ;>84>@ J.> /I0G63/; 4./ H6846G 03; 6::9/; I : 1/@ I 4./ H6846G J0: /I0G63/;>34./H/@D:0G/;04/6/ , 03;0: G03D0:?6H/63C9@6/:J/@/?>93;>3./@5>;D./@/J0: 4/3;/@3/::>H/@2>J/@05;>G/3*8>349:/;05@0:6>3:>H/@ ?@>34 >? @67.4 :6;/ >? 3/8A* 05@0:6>3: >H/@ 508A >? @67.4 :6;/>?8./:4*8>349:/;05@0:6>3:>H/@633/@0:1/84>?2/?4 5944>8A* 8>349:/; 05@0:6>3: >H/@ >94 0:1/84 >? 2/?4 5944>8A* 8>349:/; 05@0:6>3: >H/@ >94 0:1/84 >? @67.4 5944>8A224./63C9@6/:J/@/?@/:.03;@/; L I6:4./?6302>1636>376H/35D4./"/;6802 ??68/@B&+0?4/@8>3:6;/@6374./$@/1>@4 088>@;637 4> J.68. 4./@/ J/@/ :673: >? @/8/34 1/3/4@046>3 >3 7/3640260>?4./H6846G634./?>@G>?7/36402J>93;:&+ ?922D:911>@4/;4./80:/>?4./1@>:/8946>3J64.@/70@;4> 6::9038/ >? I: 03; 0?4/@ /I0G63046>3 >? 4./ H6846G &+ 6: 4./ 0.:62;0@ J.> 8>3;984/; 4/:4 6;/346?68046>3 10@0;/ 03; .0: 02:> :911>@4/; 4./ 80:/ >? 4./1@>:/8946>303;6::9/;4./@/1>@40:1/@IL - 8 - 224./:/G04/@602:>3@/8>@;1@>H/4./79624>? 4./0889:/;?>@4./>??/38/1936:.052/93;/@/846>3)) >?03;93;/@/846>3, #>?4./845/D>3; 022 @/0:>3052/ ;>954 ./ 0889:/; .0: 3>4 40A/3 03D :1/86?68 ;/?/38/ 3;/@ :98. 86@89G:4038/: ./ 6: 26052/ ?>@8>3H6846>3 .0H/7>3/4.@>97.4./6G1973/;C9;7G/34>? 8>3H6846>303;>@;/@>?:/34/38/10::/;5D4./@602>9@4 4 .0: 40A/3 634> 8>3:6;/@046>3 022 4./:/ G04/@602: >3 @/8>@;03;80G/4>4./@67.48>3829:6>3;>3>4?63;03D @/0:>3 4> 634/@?/@/ J64. 4./ :0G/ 03; 088>@;6372D 03:J/@ 4./ 05>H/ 1>634 63 4./ 03; 1@>8//; 4> 10::4./?>22>J637 ./8@6G6302011/026: -+ '$$* % ! 6:4>2>) %