- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ "" %&' ( ! ! "! ! #$%& ' ( ) "! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! #$%& " ! "" #$%& ' ( "* &$ ) " " ()" " +$ " #, $ " - " . . " $ (. ") /01 233425 01 60547 89 :/4 2334552;:1 < =520>2;:1 144?0;@ 6AB 4;/2;=4>4;: A6 =A>34;12:0A; 2B010;@ AC: A6 DC7@>4;: 2;7 2E2B7 72:47 +$ 0; A$ 321147 89 775 4;0AB 0F05 C7@4 2;7 - 3 - A:AB ==074;: 520>1 B08C;25 A, 0D2923CB2 (6AB 1/AB:G:/4B08C;25H) /4 72:4 A6 2==074;: 0;FA5F4>4;: A6 F4/0=54 742:/A674=42147 2;@23322;092F2B1A251A:/45028050:9 :A329:/4=A>34;12:0A;2B4251A;A:0;7013C:4/4A;59 7013C:4010;B4134=:A60;274IC2:4=A>34;12:0A; 42B7 B0 2;@2;2@AC72 0B272B 542B;47 =AC;145 6AB :/4 2334552;:1 2;7 B0 2;DC;2:/ 2552992 /4::9542B;47=AC;1456ABB413A;74;:AA:0=4A6:/01 233425 01 70134;147 E0:/ 0; B4134=: A6 B413A;74;: A AB74B72:47&$ B0 2;@2;2@AC72 0B272B F4/4>4;:59 1C8>0::47 :/2: :/4 B08C;25 /21 :2?4; :/4 0;=A>4 2: 1%# 34B >A;:/ E/4B421 :/4 0;=A>4 0; :4B>1 A6 /2B: 3B432B47 89 :/4 !2B;2:2?2 :2:4 4@25 4BF0=41 C:/AB0:9 6AB :/4 942B 01 1$#3> A 251A :/4 B08C;25 747C=:47 $J 0;1:427 A6 B7 :AE2B71 34B1A;25 4K34;141 "CB:/4B /4 /21 1C8>0::47 :/2: :/4 - 4 - B08C;25 /21 620547 :A 2E2B7 233BA3B02:4 =A>34;12:0A; C;74B :/4 =A;F4;:0A;25 /4271 2;7 251A 620547 :A 2E2B7 41=252:0A;A6JA;:/4=A>34;12:472E2B747C;74B:/4 =A;F4;:0A;25/42710;F04EA652E52077AE;89:/4A;H854 34K ACB: 2;7 1AC@/: :A 4;/2;=4 :/4 =A>34;12:0A; 2==AB70;@59 $ 46C:0;@ :/4 1C8>0110A; A6 542B;47 =AC;145 6AB :/4 2334552;:1 B0 2;DC;2:/ 2552992 /4::9 E0:/ 255 F4/4>4;=4 1C8>0::47 :/2: :/4 B08C;25 =A;1074B0;@ :/4 2@4A674=4214704%$942B13BA34B59:2?4;:/40;=A>4 2:1%#34B>A;:/21/401;A:2;42B;0;@>4>84B E0:/B464B4;=4:A/012@42;7747C=:0A;A6$J013BA34B 6AB:/4B421A;:/2:255:/4=/057B4;4K=43:E0642B4>2DAB 2;72334552;:A010;AF4B;>4;:14BF0=411C=/:/4 2>AC;:A6=A>34;12:0A;2E2B747C;74B:/4/427G5A11A6 7434;74;=9H 0;=5C70;@ :/4 =A;F4;:0A;25 /4271 01 DC1: 2;7 3BA34B==AB70;@591AC@/::A701>011:/4233425 - 5 - & 2F0;@ /42B7 :/4 542B;47 =AC;145 6AB :/4 32B:041 34BC147 :/4 4;:0B4 233425 3234B1 :/4 A;59 3A0;: :/2:2B0146ABACB=A;1074B2:0A;01 /4:/4B:/4=A>34;12:0A;2E2B74789:/4 B08C;2501DC1:2;73BA34B06:/42;1E4B01 A:/4BE014 E/4:/4B :/4 2;9 0;:4B64B4;=4 01 =25547 6AB 2: :/4 /2;71 A6 :/01 ACB: 6AB 4;/2;=4>4;:L CB2;1E4B:A:/428AF43A0;:6AB=A;1074B2:0A; 0132B:590;2660B>2:0F46AB:/46A55AE0;@ % :01;A:0;7013C:4:/2:74=42147E212@47%$ 942B1 2: :/4 :0>4 A6 2==074;: 2;7 21 34B :/4 2334552;:1 74=42147 E21 /254 2;7 /425:/9 2;7 E21 EAB?0;@ 21 2; 2@B0=C5:CB01:1CBF0F4789/01E0642;7:EA=/057B4;/AC@/ :/4 2334552;: A1 2;7 2B4 >2DAB1 2;7 42B;0;@ 0; :4B>1A6:/4DC7@>4;:A6A;H85434KACB:0;:/4=214A6 - 6 - 4F4; :/4 42B;0;@ >2BB047 >2DAB 1A;1 2B4 251A 62551 E0:/0; :/4 7460;0:0A; A6 7434;74;: 2;7 2B4 4;:0:5476AB=A>34;12:0A;32B:6BA>:/2:0;:/4 ;702; 62>059191:4>:/442B;0;@1A6:/4>4>84B10;:/462>059 01 =A;1074B47 21 62>059 0;=A>4 ; F04E A6 742:/ A6 /C182;7 A6 2334552;: A 2;7 62:/4B A6 2334552;: A1 2;72;7:/4B4015A110;:/462>0590;=A>4E/0=//21@A: 1A>4 842B0;@ 0; :/4 1A=025 1:2:C1 /4 B08C;25 :2?0;@ ;A:4A6:/462=::/2:74=42147E21%$942B12::/4:0>4A6 2==074;: E/054 701=C110;@ A; :/4 3A0;: A6 0;=A>4 251A 701=C1147 B4@2B70;@ :/4 0;=A>4 60K47 89 :/4 !2B;2:2?2 4@25 4BF0=41 C:/AB0:9 6AB :/4 942B 8C: /2F0;@ B4@2B7 :A :/4 2@4 2;7 2FA=2:0A; A6 74=42147 3BA34B59 =A;1074B47 :/4 0;=A>4 A6 74=42147 2: 1%# 34B >A;:/ 4 60;7 ;A 0;60B>0:9 0; :/4 0;=A>4 :2?4; 89 :/4 B08C;25/44BBAB=A>>0::4789:/4B08C;2501:/2:0:/21 747C=:47$JE/0=/01;A:0;2==AB72;=4E0:/52E2134B DC7@>4;:A6A;H85434K0;:/4=214A6 1 (2020) 11 SCC 356 - 7 - /4233BA3B02:4747C=:0A;EAC5784B7:AE2B7134B1A;25 4K34;141 A6 74=42147 E/A E21 >2BB047 1CBF0F47 89 /01 E064 2;7 :EA =/057B4; :/AC@/ :/4 =/057B4; 2B4 >2DAB 2;7 42B;0;@ 0; :4B>1 A6 :/4 52E 5207 7AE; 0; :/49 2B4 251A B4IC0B47 :A 84 =25=C52:47 E/054 747C=:0;@ :AE2B71 34B1A;25 4K34;141 ; :/4 =214 A; /2;7 :/4B4 2B4 :/B44 =520>2;:1* :/4 747C=:0A; AC@/: :A /2F4 844; B71A251A:/4B08C;25/21;A:3BA34B59=A;1074B47:/4 =214A6:/42334552;:1E/0542E2B70;@=A>34;12:0A;C;74B :/4=A;F4;:0A;25/4271 + /4 B08C;25 /21 620547 :A 2E2B7 233BA3B02:4 =A>34;12:0A;C;74B:/4605025=A;1AB:0C>0;F04EA6:/452E 52077AE;89:/4A;H85434KACB:0;:/4=214A6 ! " 21 E455 21 =A;1074B0;@ J 41=252:0A; A; :/4 =A>34;12:0A;2E2B747C;74B=A;F4;:0A;25/42710;:4B>1 A6 :/4 52E 5207 7AE; 89 :/4 34K ACB: 0; :/4 =214 A6 2"#$%&"'%" - 8 - ( 2;7 ) ! * "AB :/4 6AB4@A0;@ B421A;1 :/4 =A>34;12:0A; 2E2B747 89 :/4 B08C;25 B4IC0B41 B4#=A;1074B2:0A; 2;7 B4#74:4B>0;2:0A;;B4#74:4B>0;2:0A;:/4=A>34;12:0A; C;74B:/4/427G5A11A67434;74;=9HEAB?1AC:216A55AE1 (1%KK$KM1#) /4 B08C;25 /21 =A>>0::47 4BBAB 0; ;A: 2E2B70;@ =A>34;12:0A; C;74B :/4 =A;F4;:0A;25 /4271 /4B46AB42134B:/4DC7@>4;:A6:/4A;H85434KACB:0; :/4 =2141 A6 2;7 0; :/4 =214 A6 + :/4 =520>2;:1 840;@ E064 2;7 =/057B4; A6 74=42147 2B4 4;:0:547 :A 1# 42=/ C;74B :/4 /427 GA11 6 3AC125 (,"#$'-$..%# *,"#""-"'.' 5 ()& &% - 9 - A;1AB:0C>2;7"05025A;1AB:0C>H2?0;@0;:A=A;1074B2:0A; :/4 12>4 :/4 =520>2;:1 2B4 4;:0:547 6AB 2 1C> A6 1# (1# K ) :AE2B71 G5A11 A6 13AC125 =A;1AB:0C>2;7605025=A;1AB:0C>H "CB:/4B 2 =A>34;12:0A; A6 1$# 42=/ 01 2E2B747C;74B:/4/427GA1161:2:4H;7G"C;4B25;7 B2;13AB:2:0A;HB4134=:0F459 "CB:/4B0;F04EA6:/4DC7@>4;:A6:/4A;H854 34K ACB: 0; :/4 =214 A6 ,- ) ! .:/4B41/255842;4;/2;=4>4;:A6JA;:/4 =A;F4;:0A;25 /4271 6AB 4F4B9 :/B44 942B1 6BA> ; :/4 =214 A; /2;7 :/4 2==074;: A==CBB47 0; /4B46AB4:/4=520>2;:12B44;:0:5476ABJ41=252:0A;A6 :/B44 942B1 =A>354:47 04 6AB A;4 :4B> 21 :/4 &() & - 10 - =A;F4;:0A;25 /4271 04 1$# (1 N $N$M1$KJ) /C10;255:/42334552;:1=520>2;:12B44;:0:547 6AB4;/2;=47=A>34;12:0A;216A55AE1 )*+,-./)0,*120 .301 A11A6 434;74;=9 1 # A11A61:2:4 1 $# A11A6"C;4B25K34;141 1 $# A11 A6 A;1AB:0C> 2;7 "05025 A;1AB:0C> (1K) 1 # J 41=252:0A; 6AB :/B44 942B1 C;74B=A;F4;:0A;25/4271 O1N$N$K J(942B1)P 1 $# 1 %$# $ /4 :A:25 =A>34;12:0A; B4#74:4B>0;47 89 :/01 ACB:EAB?1AC::A1%$#212@20;1:1+# 2E2B747 89 :/4 B08C;25 25A;@ E0:/ 0;:4B41: 2: &J 34B 2;;C>6BA>:/472:4A66050;@A6:/434:0:0A;:055B4250Q2:0A; - 11 - & "AB :/4 6AB4@A0;@ B421A;1 :/01 ACB: 3BA=4471 :A3211:/46A55AE0;@ 0) /423342501445)+0"*61* 00) /4 DC7@>4;: 2;7 2E2B7 321147 89 :/4 B08C;25 72:47 +$ 0; A$ 321147 89 :/4 770:0A;25 4;0AB 0F05 C7@4 2;7 A, 2: 0D2923CB201>A706047* 000) /4 2334552;:1 < =520>2;:1 2B4 4;:0:547 6AB :A:25 =A>34;12:0A; A6 1%$# 21 2@20;1: 1+# 2E2B747 89 :/4 B08C;25 25A;@ E0:/ 0;:4B41: 2: &J 34B 2;;C>6BA>:/472:4A66050;@A6:/434:0:0A; :055B4250Q2:0A;* 0F) /4B413A;74;:A< ;1CB2;=4=A>32;9 21 34B :/4 70B4=:0A; A6 B08C;25 845AE 3B0>2B059 743A10: :/4 4;:0B4 =A>34;12:0A; 25A;@E0:/0;:4B41:846AB4:/4B08C;256BA> :/4 72:4 A6 34:0:0A; :055 B4250Q2:0A; E0:/0; 0K E44?1 6BA> :/4 72:4 A6 B4=403: A6 2 =A39A6:/01AB74B* - 12 - F) /4B413A;74;:A< ;1CB2;=4=A>32;9 01 2: 5084B:9 :A B4=AF4B :/4 =A>34;12:0A; 2>AC;: 6BA> :/4 AE;4B A6 :/4 F4/0=54 0; :4B>1A6:/4AB74B32114789:/4B08C;25* F0) /4 233AB:0A;>4;: 7018CB14>4;: 2;7 B454214 1/255 84 21 34B :/4 AB74B A6 :/4 B08C;25* F00) AAB74B21:A=A1: +7 %" ' $ +7 %' $ 01:A 5A