Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43541 (KAR)

VEERESH KUMAR S/O MALLIKARJUN D v. B.NALLA REDDY AND ANR

MFA/200680/2020 · 2025-10-14

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' () $$ *+ *%&' ( ) !" # $$ %& $ ' & & &( ) * $$ & &! +( !" * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & , #$ %& * - ! $)' * *,%' * $ ) $$ & ) , ! $ ,& & * & $ $ *+( * ) * & , $$& * & # $$ %& ' & " ( !" - 3 - & & & &( ) * $$ &! ( !" #$ %& $ * - " **' * *,%' * $ ) , ! $ , & & $$ * ) .& $ # /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9=8<:3434/ 0>>/0?9 4/ 0>>/0? =8 * : ! <@ 34/ A?0=7083 082 34/ 0>>/0? =8 * : ", <@ 34/ 896108A/ :7>08@ 01/ 050=893 34/ 907/ B6257/83 082 0C012 203/2 , ! >099/2 <@ 34/ $1=8A=>0? =931=A3 082 /99=:89 625/ 082 0=A461 D;:1 94:13 E1=<680?FG=8 : , - 4 - 4/;0A39:;34/A09/01/3403A?0=70837/3C=34 08 0AA=2/83 :8 " C4/8 4/ C09 1/3618=85 :8 0 7:3:1A@A?/ </01=85 : "! 09 0 >=??=:8 1=2/1 26/ 3: 1094 082 8/5?=5/83 21=H=85 <@ 34/ 21=H/1 :; >/ $099/85/1 63: &/01=85 : &! 1/96?3=85 =8 =8B61=/9 3: 34/ A?0=7083 *:1 C4=A4 4/ C09 31/03/2 09 =8>03=/83 =8 34/ 4:9>=30? ;1:7 " 3: , 082682/15:8/9615/1@082=7>?0839C/1/=89/13/2=84=9 1=543 ;/761 082 2=9A4015/2 ;1:7 34/ 4:9>=30? C=34 08 02H=9/3:30I/A:7>?/3/</21/93;:19=J7:8340823:30I/ ;:??:C 6> 31/037/83 /8A/ 4/ ;=?/2 0 A?0=7 >/3=3=:8 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? A?0=7=85 A:7>/8903=:8 ;1:7 34/ 1/9>:82/839A:83/82=8534034/C0905/2@/0190334/ 3=7/:;0AA=2/83082C099362@=85=8"34/7/93/1 093/1 :; :77/1A/ =8 6?<0150 8=H/19=3@ $ /831/ 0=A461 082?:934=9:8/0A02/7=A@/01:;/26A03=:808296;;/1/2 2=90<=?=3@ 4/ 1=<680? A:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ 703/1=0?9 0H0=?0<?/:81/A:124020C012/20967:;9 C=34=83/1/9303K>/108867;1:734/203/:;>/3=3=:83=?? - 5 - 1/0?=L03=:80822=1/A3/21/9>:82/83896108A/:7>08@3: >0@34/A:7>/8903=:8 " 551=/H/2 <@ 34/ 90=2 B6257/83 34/ =8B61/2 A?0=7083 409 >1/;/11/2 34/ 0>>/0? ;:1 /8408A/7/83 :; A:7>/8903=:8 =8 C4=A4 =3 =9 A:83/82/2 3403 34:654 34/ A?0=7083C09/018=859 >/17:83434/1=<680? 40930I/834/907/039 C=34:6308@<09=93=9 ;6134/1A:83/82/2340334/A:7>/8903=:80C012/2<@34/ 1=<680? 682/1 0?? 4/02=859 01/ :8 34/ ?/99/1 9=2/ C4=A4 1/M6=1/ =83/1;/1/8A/ <@ 34=9 :613 3 =9 0?9: A:83/82/2 340326/3:0AA=2/830?=8B61=/9A?0=70832=28:3033/824=9 "34/7/93/1 093/1:;:77/1A //J07=8/2 34/:A3:109$)C4:099/99/234/2=90<=?=3@03"K 3:34/C4:?/<:2@<6334/1=<680?/11:8/:69?@30I/834/ ;68A3=:80? 2=90<=?=3@ 03 K 34/1/;:1/ 1/M6/93/2 ;:1 /8408A/7/83 &/=85 0551=/H/2 <@ 34/ 907/ B6257/83 082 0C012 34/ 896108A/ :7>08@ >1/;/11/2 34/ 0>>/0? A:83/82=85340334/=8961/2:C8/1:;34/90=2 >/ 63: - 6 - 409H=:?03/234/>:?=A@3/179082A:82=3=:89<@8:340H=85 H0?=2 * 082 $ 09 :8 34/ 203/ :; 34/ 0AA=2/83 =8 A:8310H/83=:83:34/>1:H=9=:89:;34/ A3/8A/=3 =9A:83/82/2340334/896108A/:7>08@=98:3?=0<?/3: >0@ 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 09 :12/1/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? 8 96>>:13 :; 4=9 A:83/83=:8 ?/018/2 A:689/? ;:1 34/ 896108A/ :7>08@ 409 1/?=/2 :8 34/ 2/A=9=:8 :; >/J :613 =8 34/ A09/ :; !"! # 9>/1):682/13=;=A03/J$A?0=7083409 96930=8/2 A:77=863/2 ;10A361/ 2=930? 1=543 ;/761 082 ?03/10?A:82:@?/;10A361/1=543>1:J=70?3=<=0082<:3434/ =8B61=/9 01/ 51=/H:69 =8 80361/ 3 =9 :<9/1H/2 =8 34/ =9A4015/ 012 3403 34/ A?0=7083 682/1C/83 %' * :; ;10A361/%'2=930?;/761;=J03=:8C=342=930?;/761?:AI=85 >?03/ :8 , 082 %' ?=0A A1/93 <:8/ 510;3 :8 $) 409 =996/2 =90<=?=3@ /13=;=A03/09 >/1 J$ 0AA:12=85 3: C4=A4 34/ A?0=7083 96;;/1/2 "K - 7 - 2=90<=?=3@3:C4:?/<:2@3=9;6134/1A:83/82/2340334/ A?0=7083409?:93:8/0A02/7=A@/0126/3:34/0AA=2/830? =8B61=/9 , 4:654 34/ A?0=7083 A:83/82/2 3403 K 2=90<=?=3@ 099/99/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? =9 :8 34/ ?:C/1 9=2/ 9=8A/ =3 C09 9303/2 3403 ;10A361/C09 68=3/234/ 1=<680? 409 30I/8 7:1/ 3408 12 :; "K 099/99/2 <@ 34/ :A3:1 C4=A4 =9 B693 082 >1:>/1 082 =3 8//29 8: =83/1;/1/8A/ ! $/3=3=:8/19303/234034/C09C:1I=85=8 /2=A0? 4:>082/018=859 >/17:834<634/4098:3 ;=?/2 08@ =8A:7/ >1::; 9 34/ 0AA=2/83 =9 :; 34/ @/01 ,09>/134/A4013=996/2<@34/018030I0303//50? /1H=A/9 634:1=3@ 34=9 :613 2//79 =3 0>>1:>1=03/ 3: 1/099/99 34/ =8A:7/ :; 34/ A?0=7083 03 9!, >/1 7:834 27=33/2?@ A?0=7083 C09 05/2 @/019 03 34/ 3=7/ :; 0AA=2/8308234/ 0>>1:>1=03/ 76?3=>?=/1 0>>?=A0<?/ 3: 4=9 05/ 51:6> =9 E!F AA:12=85?@ 34/ A?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2;:1?:99:;;6361//018=85A0>0A=3@09682/1 - 8 - 9!, JJ!J KN9! 4/ A?0=7083 C09 027=33/2 =8 34/ 4:9>=30? ;:1 20@9 082 682/1C/83 9615/1=/9 082 30I/8 ;:??:C 6> 31/037/83 4/1/;:1/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 0C012 08 07:683 :; 9, ;:1 >0=8 082 96;;/1=85- 9 ;:1 ?:99 :; 07/8=3=/9- 082 9 ;:1 31089>:1303=:8033/82083082/J3108:61=947/83A4015/9 ::I=85 3: 34/ 80361/ 082 9/1=:698/99 :; =8B61=/9 34/ A?0=70837=543 8:340H/033/82/2 08@ C:1I 03?/093 ;:1" 7:8349 4/8A/ 4/ =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 9 ;:1 ?:99 :; =8A:7/261=85?0=26>>/1=:2:C/H/134/A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9" 0C012/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? ;:1 7/2=A0? /J>/89/9 0 967 :; 9 ;:1 ;6361/ 7/2=A0? /J>/89/90829 ;:1?:99 :;/26A03=:88//298: =83/1;/1/8A/ 4/ A:7>/8903=:8 0C012/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? =9 7:2=;=/209682/1 - 9 - ? : /029 C012<@34/ 1=<680? C012<@34=9 :613 $0=8 082 96;;/1=85 9" 9, /2=A0? J>/89/9 9" 9" :99 :; ;6361/ /018=85A0>0A=3@ 9 9! " 1089>:1303=:8 /J310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083 A4015/9 9 9 :99 :; 07/8=3=/9 9 9 :99 :; =8A:7/ 261=85 ?0=2 6> >/1=:2 9! 9 , :99 :; /26A03=:8 9 9 ! *6361/ 7/2=A0? /J>/89/9 9 9 :30? 9 9" 4/1/C=??<//8408A/7/83:;9" - 10 - 4/896108A/:7>08@A:83/82/2340334/1/=9 H=:?03=:8 :; 34/ 3/179 082 A:82=3=:89 :; 34/ $:?=A@ 082 4/8A/ 34/ 896108A/ :7>08@ =9 8:3 ?=0<?/ 3: >0@ 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 3: 34/ A?0=7083 8 96>>:13 :; =39 A:83/83=:8 =3 1/?=/2 :8 34/ 2/A=9=:8 :; 34/ >/J :613 =8 34/A09/:;$% &'(")&*+,-1/;/11/296>10 834/A09/034082=3=9 A?/01?@2/7:893103/2 ;1:7 34/ 703/1=0?9 <1:6543 :8 1/A:12 3403 34/ H/4=A?/ 03 34/3=7/ :; 34/ 0AA=2/83 2=2 8:3 40H/ 0 H0?=2 >/17=3 082 *=38/99 /13=;=A03/ 09 A:83/82/2 <@ 34/ 896108A/ :7>08@ /8A/ 1/?@=85 :8 34/ 0<:H/ A=303=:8 34/ 1/9>:82/83 : O 896108A/ :7>08@ =9 2=1/A3/2 3: >0@ 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 3: 34/ A?0=7083 03 34/ ;=193 =89308A/ 082 34/1/0;3/1 1/A:H/1 34/ 907/ ;1:7 34/ :C8/1:;34/H/4=A?/ 834/1/96?334/;:??:C=85:12/1=9>099/2 %=' &:34 34/ 0>>/0?9 01/ ()) ./ &* 0( ' - 11 - %==' 4/ A?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 34/ /8408A/2 A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9" C=34 =83/1/93 03 K >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:83=??34/203/:;1/0?=L03=:8 %===' 4/ 896108A/ :7>08@ =9 2=1/A3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ /83=1/ A:7>/8903=:8 07:683 0?:85 C=34 =83/1/93 C=34=8 :8/ 7:834 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; 34=9 B6257/83 082 =9 03 ?=</13@ 3: 1/A:H/134/907/;1:71/9>:82/83: %=H' 4/930363:1@07:683:;9 2/>:9=3/2 <@ 34/ 896108A/ :7>08@ =9 3: </ 310897=33/23:34/1=<680? %H' 8 96A4 2/>:9=3 34/ A?0=7083 =9 >/17=33/23:C=34210C34//83=1/07:6830?:85 C=34=83/1/930AA16/2:8=3 ,-( %$' # & =93:?:"