- 1 - !" #$ !! %&' () !! * %&' ( ) !"" " "# $% $ &# '$" $ (( $)* $ &(*+ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (( ! " " , &( " *& " """ - ) . *" -- -' *( ) $% $ &# '$" $ !"" " $)* $ #&& (*) &(*+ (( ! " " "# &. " - 3 - *& " "" - ) " . * -- # " " -' "" - $ $ / -## $ " $/ -## 012134413523613672789:;<:=<0123>1?;@9>18< 38@ 3A36@ ) 43221@ 78 :. * BC <01187:67D75-;@9138@3@9767 3E<297D7896721<:=75789:=<0121344135236132 ;8@16$ 8 )% 3< 3B:;< %$ 4> <01 41<7<7:816 2<38@789:8<011F<61>151=<27@1:=<01>;@6:3@8136:5@ B;2 2<38@ 78 3@9767 :A8 3< <03< <7>1 <01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51B13678961972<63<7:8:#&& (*)E3>178 3632038@81957918<>3881638@@3201@<:<0141<7<7:816 2 3 612;5< := A07E0 <01 41<7<7:816 2;2<3781@ 9671D:;2 - 4 - 78?;671218E1<0141<7<7:816=751@3E537>41<7<7:8;8@16 1E<7:8 %% := <01 :<:6 107E512 E< 211G789 E:>41823<7:8 @;1 <: <01 78?;6712 2;2<3781@ 78 <01 6:3@ <63==7E3EE7@18< & 01 8:<7E1 A32 722;1@ <: <01 :A816 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 1247<1 216D7E1 := 8:<7E1 01 61>3781@ ;861461218<1@38@A32453E1@ ) 01 782;638E1 E:>438C =751@ <01 2<3<1>18< := :B?1E<7:82 @18C789 <01 3D16>18<2 >3@1 78 <01 E537> 41<7<7:838@E:8<18<1@<03<<01@67D16:=:==18@789D107E51 A328:<4:221227893D357@38@1==1E<7D1@67D78957E18E132 :8 <01 @3<1 := <01 3EE7@18< 0161 72 3 B613E0 := 4:57EC E:8@7<7:8218E1<01782;638E1E:>438C728:<573B51<: 43C<01E:>41823<7:83>:;8<32E537>1@BC<0141<7<7:816 78<01E537>41<7<7:8 ( 01 67B;835 B321@ :8 <01 4513@7892 := <01 436<712=63>1@<01722;1238@61E:6@1@<011D7@18E101 41<7<7:816 <: 2;B2<38<73<1 072 E321 1F3>781@ 07>215= 32 - 5 - " 1F3>781@ :81 A7<8122 32 " 38@ >36G1@ <18 @:E;>18<2 32 F2" <: " 8 61B;<<35 <01 :==7E16 := <01 782;638E1 E:>438C 1F3>781@ 32 38@ >36G1@ <A:@:E;>18<232F2 38@ % 01 67B;835 3=<16 322122789 <01 D16B35 38@ @:E;>18<36C 1D7@18E1 355:A1@ <01 E537> 41<7<7:8 78 436< 38@3A36@1@E:>41823<7:8:= 2.* A7<078<1612< 3<<0163<1:=%H416388;>=6:><01@3<1:=41<7<7:8<755 61357I3<7:8 38@ 015@ <03< <01 6124:8@18<2 361 ?:78<5C 38@ 21D16355C 573B51 <: 43C <01 E:>41823<7:8 3>:;8< <: <01 41<7<7:816 38@@761E<1@<01 782;638E1E:>438C <: @14:27< <01E:>41823<7:83>:;8< * 01 782;638E1 E:>438C 399671D1@ BC <01 ?;@9>18< 38@ 3A36@ @3<1@ ) 43221@ 78 :. * =751@ 344135 78 :&&( . E0355189789 <01 573B757<C 38@ <01 41<7<7:816 B1789 @7223<72=71@A7<0<01J;38<;>:=E:>41823<7:83A36@1@BC <0167B;835=751@34413578 :&* . - 6 - 136@ 513681@ E:;8215 =:6 <01 782;638E1 E:>438C38@<01513681@E:;8215=:6<0141<7<7:816 . 13681@ E:;8215 =:6 <01 782;638E1 E:>438C 2;B>7<2 <03< <01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 A32 8:< 4:22122789 3 D357@ 38@ 1==1E<7D1 @67D789 57E18E1 32 := <01 @3<1:=3EE7@18<01:A81603@18<6;2<1@<01>:<:6ECE51 <: 38 ;83;<0:67I1@ 4162:8 A0: @7@ 8:< 4:22122 3 D357@ 38@ 1==1E<7D1 @67D789 57E18E1 32 := <01 @3<1 := 3EE7@18< 0161 A32 3 B613E0 := 4:57EC E:8@7<7:82 18E1 201 2;B>7<2<03<<0167B;835E:>>7<<1@78166:678=32<18789 <01573B757<C:8<01782;638E1E:>438C38@463C2<:355:A <01344135=751@BC<01782;638E1E:>438C38@@72>722<01 344135=751@BC<0141<7<7:816 513681@ E:;8215 =:6 <01 41<7<7:816 2;B>7<2 <03< <01 <01 E:>41823<7:8 3A36@1@ BC <01 67B;83572:8<015:A1627@118E1:8<012196:;8@201 463C2 <: @72>722 <01 344135 =751@ BC <01 782;638E1 - 7 - E:>438C 38@ 463C2 <: 355:A <01 344135 =751@ BC <01 41<7<7:816 03D1416;21@<0161E:6@238@E:827@161@<01 2;B>7227:82>3@1BC<01513681@E:;8215=:6<01436<712 014:78<2<03<36721=:6E:827@163<7:8361A7<061936@<: 573B757<C38@J;38<;>:=E:>41823<7:8 0161728:@724;<17861936@<:<01:EE;6618E1 :=3EE7@18<38@78?;67122;2<3781@BC<0141<7<7:81678<01 6:3@ <63==7E 3EE7@18< 8 :6@16 <: 2;B2<38<73<1 <01 E:8<18<7:8:=<0141<7<7:816<03<<013EE7@18<:EE;661@@;1 <:632038@81957918<67@789BC<0167@16:=<01>:<:6ECE51 <01 41<7<7:816 032 46:@;E1@ <01 E036912011< >36G1@ 32 F"& A07E0 @72E5:212 <03<<01 3EE7@18<:EE;661@@;1 <: 6320 38@ 81957918< 67@789 BC <01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 01 67B;835 A32 ?;2<7=71@ 78 61E:6@789 3 =78@789 <03< <01 3EE7@18<:EE;661@@;1<:632038@81957918<67@789BC<01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 @: 8:< =78@ 38C 166:6 78 <01 - 8 - =78@78961E:6@1@BC<0167B;8357861936@<:<01632038@ 81957918<67@789BC<0167@16:=<01>:<:6ECE51 +,-./01,0-203045 & 01 782;638E1 E:>438C =751@ <01 2<3<1>18< := :B?1E<7:82E:8<18@789<03<<0167@16:=<01>:<:6ECE51A32 8:<4:22122789 3 D357@ 38@ 1==1E<7D1 @67D789 57E18E1 32:8 <01 @3<1 := <01 3EE7@18< @>7<<1@5C <01 41<7<7:816 032 3663C1@ <01 :A816 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 32 6124:8@18<: B1=:61<0167B;835018:<7E1A32216D1@<:<01:A816 :=<01>:<:6ECE511247<1216D7E1:=8:<7E1<01:A816:= <01 >:<:6ECE51 61>3781@ ;861461218<1@ 38@ A32 453E1@ 01 782;638E1 E:>438C 1F3>781@ 7<2 :==7E16 32 38@ 78 072 1F3>783<7:878E071= 01 032 @14:21@ <03<<0167@16:=<01:==18@789D107E51A328:<4:22122789 3 D357@ 38@ 1==1E<7D1 @67D789 57E18E1 32 :8 <01 @3<1 := 78E7@18<01:A816@7@8:<46:@;E138C@67D78957E18E1:= <01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 01 B;6@18 72 :8 <01 782;638E1 E:>438C <: 46:D1 <03< <01 67@16 := <01 - 9 - >:<:6ECE51 A32 8:< 46:E122789 3 D357@ 38@ 1==1E<7D1 @67D78957E18E132:=<01@3<1:=3EE7@18<01782;638E1 E:>438C 032 8:< 46:@;E1@ 38C 61E:6@2 <: 12<3B5720 <03< <01 782;638E1 E:>438C 032 <3G18 <01 2<142 BC 722;789 3 8:<7E1 <: <01 :A816 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 E355789 ;4:8 <01 :A816 <: =;68720 <01 @67D789 57E18E1 := <01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 38@ 352: 032 8:< <3G1838C 2<142 <: 1F3>781 <01 <: @1>:82<63<1 <03< <01 67@16 := <01 >:<:6ECE51 A328:<4:221227893D357@38@1==1E<7D1@67D78957E18E132 :8<01@3<1:=3EE7@18<01782;638E1E:>438C=3751@<: @72E03691 <01 B;6@18 453E1@ :8 7< 01 67B;835 A32 ?;2<7=71@7823@@5789<01573B757<C?:78<5C38@21D16355C:8<01 :A81638@<01782;638E1E:>438C ) 01513681@E:;8215=:6<01782;638E1E:>438C 2;B>7<2 <03< <01 782;638E1 E:>438C >3C B1 @761E<1@ <: 43C 38@ 61E:D16 <01 3>:;8< =6:> <01 :A816 := <01 :==18@789D107E5123<<01E:2<:=6141<7<7:8<01B;6@18 72:8<01782;638E1E:>438C<:46:D1<03<<0167@16:=<01 >:<:6ECE51 A32 8:< 4:22122789 3 D357@ 38@ 1==1E<7D1 - 10 - @67D78957E18E101782;638E1E:>438C032=3751@<:46:D1 <01B;6@18453E1@:87<8D71A:=<013B:D1@72E;227:8 382A161@<01573B757<C3EE:6@7895C +,-./01,67-147889+1:-401 ( 01 41<7<7:816 A32 391@ 3B:;< % C1362 32 :8 <01@3<1:=3EE7@18<38@E:8<18@1@<03<<0141<7<7:816A32 38 3967E;5<;672< 38@ 1368789 >:61 <038 2( 416 >:8<0 8 :6@16 <: 2;B2<38<73<1 <01 E:8<18<7:8 := <01 41<7<7:816010328:<46:@;E1@38C78E:>146::=8<01 3B218E1 := 78E:>1 46::= <01 8:<7:835 78E:>1 032 <: B1 <3G1832416<012E01@;518:<7=71@BC<01#3683<3G3<3<1 1935 16D7E12 ;<0:67<C 01 3EE7@18< 72 := <01 C136 %18E1<072:;6<<3G12<0183<7:83578E:>1:=<01 41<7<7:816 3< 2*( 01 41<7<7:816 <: 46:D1 <01 @723B757<C1F3>781@<01@:E<:632"A0:032:4781@ <03<<0141<7<7:8160322;==161@@723B757<C<:<011F<18<:= H<:<01A0:51B:@CA016178<0167B;8353221221@<01 - 11 - @723B757<C3<(H01@723B757<C3221221@BC<0167B;83572 ?;2<38@46:41638@@:8:<E355=:638C78<16=1618E1 % :827@16789 <01 1D7@18E1 := " 38@ <01 >1@7E3561E:6@2<072:;6<613221221@<01E:>41823<7:8 ;8@16<01=:55:A789013@2$ :>41823<7:83A36@1@78 2 "36<7E;5362 54;+ .0271-3 54;0: 7.4 "37838@2;==167892 ( :22:=3>187<7127857=1 ( :22:=78E:>1@;6789<01 537@;44167:@*(F& %( ::@38@8:;6720>18< ( :8D1C38E1E036912 ( 1@7E351F418212 ).*& ).*& :22:==;<;6178E:>1 *( F F (H F .K)*( .* )*( :<35 %.71/+/4' "*"*( "*"( " "<*( 1;-1=+/254;0:7.4 " "<*( - 12 - * 0;2 <01 41<7<7:816 72 18<7<51@ =:6 <:<35 E:>41823<7:8 := 2&*& 32 393782< 2.* 01 41<7<7:816 72 18<7<51@ =:6 18038E1@ E:>41823<7:8 := 2(*& 8 D71A := <01 3B:D1 @72E;227:8 46:E11@ <: 4322<01=:55:A789$ 7 01344135=751@BC<01782;638E1E:>438C 78 :&&( .72@72>7221@ 77 01 344135 =751@ BC <01 41<7<7:816 78 :&* .72355:A1@78436< 777 01 7>4;981@ ?;@9>18< 38@ 3A36@ 43221@ BC <01 67B;835 72 >:@7=71@ 01 41<7<7:816 72 18<7<51@ <: 38 18038E1@ E:>41823<7:8:= 2(*& 783@@7<7:8 <: <01 E:>41823<7:8 3A36@1@ BC <01 67B;83535:89A7<078<1612<3<<0163<1:= %H 416 388;> =6:> <01 @3<1 := 41<7<7:8 <75561357I3<7:8:=<013>:;8< - 13 - 7D 01 782;638E1 E:>438C 72 @761E<1@ <: @14:27< <01 18<761 E:>41823<7:8 3>:;8< A7<0 3EE6;1@ 78<1612< A7<078 1790< A11G2 =6:> @3<1 := <01 61E174< := E16<7=71@ E:4C :=<072?;@9>18< D 01 3>:;8< 78 @14:27< 38@ 6735 :;6< 61E:6@2B1<6382>7<<1@<:<0167B;835 /( %' $ " 72<:$5:$% $