- 1 - ! " # $!%!&!! !!&& '() * ! " # $ % & ' && ! '! ! () !% % " # !* ! ! ! % &$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %('#%$ $ ! %) $ & ! !' + & )! %! + &, , - % ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 ! 3<8/==./><8:<>.1/4/<78223./?/019:23.0<;57/> <7 9 ! %) 1/2.1 ! !' =/88.1 ;@ 23. 11<2<97/> .7<90 <A<> 51. /71 /2 <1/0 #:90 83902 B23. 0<;57/>C$ ' ==.>>/72 ?/8 /4.1 ! @./08 19<74;58<7.88 6.2 ?<23 /7 /DD<1.72 97 ! '! %) . :<>.1 / D>/<6 =.2<2<97 D>/<6<74 D96=.78/2<97 9: 8%! ?<23 <72.0.82 3. 0<;57/> D978<1.0<74 .72<0. 6/2.0</> 97 0.D901 40/72.1 /7 - 3 - /69572 9: 8)! ?<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: )E =.0 /7756:0961/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>0./><F/2<97 440<.A.1 ;@ 23. 8/<1 /69572 3. =0.:.00.1 /7 /==./>/716/<7>@D972.72.123/23.:<>.1G )991<D.78. D.02<:<D/2. /71 82/2.1 3<8 <7D96. /8 8 =.0 69723 5223.0<;57/>3/82/H.76./4.0<7D96.9:8% =.0 697238=.0G I?9571D.02<:<D/2.3.8582/<7.1:0/D250. 9: >.:2 23<43 :0/D250. 9: >.:2 2<;</ /71 :<;5>/ 65>2<=>. :/D</> /;0/8<97;>57220/56/97>.:2:90.3./1/71?29>.:2:90./06 ?3<D3 /0. 40<.A958 <7 7/250. /71 23. /69572 40/72.1 571.0 >9889:/6.7<2<.8/71>9889::5250.<7D96.6./4.023.0.:90. 0.J5.82.1:90.73/7D.6.72 3. 19D290 3/8 <885.1 1<8/;<><2@ D.02<:<D/2. 571.0 G .82/2.123/223.0.<86/>57<2.1:0/D250.9:1<82/>2<;</ 9>179757<971<82/>:<;5>/<6=>/72<78<259>157<2.1:0/D250.9: :.650?<23<6=>/72<78<259>157<2.1:0/D250.9:9>.D0/7973./1 /717.DH9:0/1<58/719>157<2.1:0/D250.9:0<4320/1<58?<23 <6=>/72<78<25/71/88.88.123.1<8/;<><2@/8E3.0<;57/> 0<432>@ D978<1.0.1 % '01 9: E /71 2/H.7 23. 1<8/;<><2@ /8 - 4 - %)E 3.7D. 23<8 9502 :<718 79 0./8978 29 <72.0:.0. ?<23 23. 8/<1901.0 39543 23. /==.>>/72 3/8 82/2.1 23/2 3. ?/8 ./07<74 8 =.0 69723 3. 3/8 792 =0915D.1 /7@ <7D96. =099: .0. :<><74 9: 991 <D.78. <8 792 85::<D<.72 29 /88.883<8<7D96./88 /7123.0.<879<7D96.=099: 8 3. 6.2 ?<23 /7 /DD<1.72 97 ! '! %) /8 =.0 23. 45<1.><7.89:23./07/2/H/.4/>.0A<D.852390<2@23<89502 :<7180./897/;>.292/H.<7D96./8 8%'! DD901<74>@ 23.>9889::5250.<7D96.D96.829, %'! G%!G%G%)EK!!) ( . ?/8 398=<2/><F.1 :90 !! 1/@8 3. 0<;57/> 40/72.18'!)) 29?/0186.1<D/>.G=.78.8/71<27..18 79<72.0:.0.7D. 978<1.0<74 23. 7/250. 9: <7L50<.8 /71 =.0<91 9: 398=<2/><F/2<97 23<8 9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 40/72 /7 /695729:8 :90=/<7/7185::.0<748! :90 >988 9: /6.7<2<.8 8' :90 20/78=902/2<97 .G20/ 7950<836.72/71/22.71/72D3/04.8 - 5 - ) 3. /==.>>/72 6<432 792 3/A. ?90H.1 /2>./82 :90 =.0<91 9: 230.. 697238 15. 29 <7L50<.8 8582/<7.1 <7 23. /DD<1.7223.0.:90.8')( #%'! G'$<829;.40/72.1 571.023.3./1>9889:<7D96.150<74>/<15==.0<91 % 7/>>23.292/>D96=.78/2<97D96.829% ) ?<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: E =.0 /7756 :096 23. 1/2. 9: =.2<2<972<>>0./><F/2<97 3./6957240/72.1;@23.0<;57/><8691<:<.1/8571.0, +,-. /01231. %9889:<7D96. !!) ! /<7/7185::.0<74 '9889:/6.7<2<.8 ! .1<D/>.G=.78.8 '!)) 0/78=902/2<97 .G20/ 7950<836.72 /71/22.71/72D3/04.8 ' 9889:./07<74150<7423.>/<15= =.0<91:90697238 ')( 2,4 " 5 DD901<74>@ 23. /==.>>/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 / 292/> D96=.78/2<97 9: ." 5 /8 /4/<782 8)! 3. D>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 /7 .73/7D.1 D96=.78/2<97 9: . 5 %% 723.0.85>223.:9>>9?<74901.0<8=/88.1, - 6 - <$ 3./==./><8 <<$ 3. 0.8=971.72 <7850/7D. 96=/7@ />0./1@ 1.=98<2.1 23. /?/01.1 /69572 ;@ 23. 0<;57/> 23.0.:90.0.8=971.729!<81<0.D2.1291.=98<2/7 .73/7D.1 D96=.78/2<97 9: 8%%) ?<23 <72.0.82/223.0/2.9:E?<23<7%69723:09623. 1/2.9:23<8901.0 <<<$ 7 85D3 1.=98<2 23. /==.>>/72 <8 =.06<22.1 29 ?<2310/? 23. .72<0. /69572 />974 ?<23 <72.0.82 /DD05.197<2 .-5 '&!! ) % <829,%>9,