- 1 - ! "!#$ %#!&!&"## '(!) ! " # ! $ %&' ( ) ' *& & ( (' (' (' ' # " ' ( ! ' ( ** ( Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ** ' ' $ % & '& ) ' + * ""# "",*' * & * ' + * ' -. ' /0&1234 567894: ;6/ 314 <43030684/9 28= /02::0>2/?78 217>2/ ;6/ 314 /49<68=4839 12@4 2<<42/4=08<4/968 " 1452<30684=+/03430306809;0:4=944>08A2+/036; 4/306/2/036B72913146/=4/=234= " "<2994=CD314 94568=/49<68=48308*0:4 6( E " "!"," , 28= *0:4 6( E " "!",#,E @0=4 884F7/49 28= ! 14<43030682@4/G48392/42978=4/ - 3 - 3 09 920= 3123 314 :28= C42/08A D 6, 6; 7:328<7/ (0::2A4 H29 6@4/8G483 :28= 28= 314 <43030684/9 28= 31/44 6314/9H4/47827316/0I4=:D57:30@2308A314920=:28=908543140/ ;6/4;2314/9825567836;083/6=7530686;2G48=4=</6@0966; 7:4 6; 314 &2/8232>2 28= 4@4874 53 28= 68 314 =0/4530689 09974= CD 314 2190:=2/ 56854/84= 314 <43030684/9 ;0:4= 2<<:0523068 ;6/ /4A7:2/0I23068 6; 3140/ 7827316/0I4= 57:30@23068 14 2190:=2/ =0/4534= 314 (0::2A4 556783283 28= 4@4874 89<4536/ 36 97CG03 /4<6/3 2C673 314 7827316/0I4= 57:30@23068 CD 314 <43030684/9 14 4@4874 7316/03049 97CG0334=2=4320:4=/4<6/32:68AH0317/@4D9>4351G2<28= /456GG48=4= ;6/ /4A7:2/0I23068 6; 7827316/0I4= 57:30@23068 142190:=2/97CG0334=2:4334/36314310/=/49<68=483H0312 /4B7493 36 09974 86 6C?453068 54/30;05234 ;6/ 314 <7/<694 6; A43308A /4A7:2/0I4= 314 7827316/0I4= 57:30@23068 CD 314 <43030684/928=3H66314/968 EE144A0682:*6/493 ;;054/6;314310/=/49<68=4836;;05497CG0334=2:4334/36314 2190:=2/<73308A3140/866C?45306836/4A7:2/0I47827316/0I4= 57:30@23068 28= 314/4CD 09974= *6/G08 ;2@6/6; 314<4/9689 H1612@47827316/0I4=:D57:30@234=3142;6/4920=:28=C42/08A - 4 - D 6, 9037234= 23 7:328<7/ (0::2A4 2:7> 28= 093/053 0=2/68 EE 30993234=31233142190:=2/6;;05468A43308A56G<:434= 2::314;6/G2:03049/4A7:2/0I4=3147827316/0I4=57:30@2306828= 314/4CD =0/4534= 314 <43030684/9 36 =4<6903 314 7<943 </054 2G67836;9#/49<4530@4:D363146@4/8G483/4297/D 29 <4/ 12::28 =234= E"EE 28= ! "EE @0=4 884F7/49* 28= * 14 2190:=2/ 2;34/ 56G<:43068 6; 314 2C6@4920=;6/G2:030496/=4/4=;6/099728546;*6/G08;2@6/ 6; 314 <43030684/9 A43308A /4A7:2/0I4= 314 7827316/0I4= 57:30@2306868:28=C42/08AD 6,G4297/08A36284F34836; 5/49" 7832908;2@6/6;<43030684/ 629<4/*6/G =234=E"EE28=2556/=08A:D08;2@6/6;<43030684/ 6"36 284F34836; 5/49!78329=234=!"EE 3 09 568348=4= 3123 314 <43030684/9 2/4 08 25372: <699499068 28= 57:30@23068 6; 314 2;6/4920= 4F3483 6; :28= 16H4@4/ 314 ;67/31 /49<68=483 68 A43308A 97/@4D 28= =4G2/523068</6544=4=082::63308A84H97/@4D87GC4/968314 82G46;<43030684/929D 6,%6:=)28=D 6"E%)3628 4F34836; 5/49" 7832968 314 82G46;<43030684/ 6 - 5 - 28= 5/49 ! 78329 68 314 82G4 6; <43030684/ 6" 08 D 6, %6:=) 28= D 6! %84H) C631 9037234= 23 7:328<7/ (0::2A4 0854 314 =234 6; /4A7:2/0I23068 6; 7827316/0I4= 57:30@23068 28= 09972854 6; *6/G 68 314 G7323068928530684=CD314;67/31/49<68=4836831482G46; 314 <43030684/9 3140/ 82G49 2/4 5683087679:D 2<<42/08A 08 2:: 314/4@4874483/04936H1051G6/43128"D42/912@4<2994= '6H4@4/ 314 99093283 6GG0990684/ 2;34/ 2 :2<94 6; 2:G693 " D42/9 @0=4 6/=4/ =234= " " 52854::4= 314 *6/G 09974=08;2@6/6;314<43030684/9932308A312331497C?453:28=09 2 *6/493 :28= 28= 863 2 /4@4874 :28= 28= 314/4 09 2 5683/2@483068 6; </6@090689 4530689 E %) 28= %)%;) 6; &2/8232>2 28=4@4874 53E#H7:4 %)28=%") 6;&2/8232>2 28=4@48747:49E##28==0/4534=36/497G4 314 :28= 08 314 82G4 6; 6@4/8G483 ;/44 ;/6G 2:: 4857GC/285498=4/3149450/57G9328549314<43030684/92/4 C4;6/4310967/3 67894: ;6/ 314 /49<4530@4 <2/3049 7/A4= 94@4/2: 56834830689 - 6 - /A08A 94@4/2: 56834830689 567894: ;6/ 314 <43030684/ 97CG0393123314+/034303068G2DC42::6H4= 14 93234G483 6; 6C?4530689 09 863 ;0:4= CD 314 6@4/8G483 /A08A 94@4/2: 56834830689 314 6@4/8G483 <:254=/4:0285468314;6::6H08A=45090689 ) * & & ' ( ( + ' J ( ,! E,! EE# ") ( ' ( * ' J +%( ) ,EE# * ""EE# !) ( ' ( * 'J" " , '42/= 314 2/A7G4839 28= <4/794= 314 +/03 <2<4/9 H031 52/4 14 ;2539 2/4 97;;050483:D 920= 28= =6 863 /4B70/4 /4034/230681409974/4@6:@492/678=3144F4/50946;314<6H4/ CD 314 99093283 6GG0990684/ 78=4/ 314 </6@090689 6; 314 &2/8232>2 28= 4@4874 53 E# 7;;054 03 36 8634 3123 - 7 - 78=4/ 2 630;0523068 6 ! E =234= E !EE 314 21290:=2/09974=24/30;052346;2A7@2:0103 3092/A74=68C412:;6;3146@4/8G4833123314:28=08 B749306809:299-.28=-.7857:30@2C:4:28=28=3142190:=2/ @0=4:4334/, E,E3/289;4//4=28=128=4=6@4/314:28=36 314*6/4934<2/3G4833092/A74=68C412:;6;314<43030684/9 3123 314 :28= 08 D 6, 09 840314/ 2 8630;04= 86/ 2 /494/@4= ;6/493 78=4/ 453068 6; 314 *6/493 53 86/ 09 03 2 =44G4= ;6/493 68 0893/753068 97CG039 3123 630;0523068 78=4/ 4530680986309974=08/49<4536;:28=99037234=237:328<7/ %)(0::2A4 A/423=42:6;2/A7G483092==/4994=2C67394530686; 314*6/493 5314>4D29<45396;3142/A7G4832/44F2G084= 453068 6; 314 *6/493 53 =42:9 H031 8630;0523068 CD 314 A6@4/8G48328=03/42=929;6::6H9 453068 630;0523068CD6@4/8G483J%)+1484@4/03 129C448=450=4=36568930373428D:28=2/494/@4=;6/493314 32346@4/8G483912::0997428630;0523068 %2) =45:2/08A 3123 03 129 C448=450=4= 365689303734 9751:28=2/494/@4=;6/493K - 8 - %C) 9<450;D08A 29 842/:D 29 <6990C:4 314 903723068 28=:0G0396;9751:28=K28= %5) 2<<608308A 28 6;;054/ %14/4082;34/ 52::4= 314 L*6/493 433:4G483 ;;054/M) 36 08B70/4 0836 28= =434/G084 314 4F0934854 8237/4 28= 4F3483 6; 28D /0A139 5:20G4= CD 6/ 2::4A4= 36 4F093 08 ;2@67/ 6; 28D <4/968 08 6/ 6@4/ 28D :28= 56G</094= H03108 9751 :0G039 6/ 08 6/ 6@4/ 28D ;6/493 </6=754 28= 36 =42: H031 314 92G4 29 </6@0=4=08310912<34/ %") 14 6;;054/ 2<<60834= 78=4/ 5:2794 %5) 6; 97C 9453068 %) 912:: C4 2 <4/968 863 16:=08A 28D ;6/493 6;;054 4F54<3 3123 6; *6/493 433:4G483 ;;054/KC732*6/493;;054/G2DC42<<60834=CD 314 3234 6@4/8G483 36 /4</49483 03 08 314 08B70/D 78=4/ 3109 12<34/ CD 314 *6/493 433:4G483;;054/ 14 6@4/8G483 129 <:254= /4:02854 68 2 93234G483 916H08A 314 /4G20808A -. 28= -. :299 :28= %6@4/8G483 28=) 3/289;4//4= 36 314 *6/493 4<2/3G483 6; 2:7>2 0=2/ - 9 - 90A84= CD 314 2190:=2/ 68 , E,E 36 568348= 3123 314 ;6/493 :28= 567:= 863 12@4 C448 A/2834= 36 314 <43030684/9 2A7@2:0103567:=86312@4C44809974=08/49<4536;2;6/493 :28=1456834830686;3146@4/8G483312303.92;6/493:28= 528863C497932084=290309<0@632:3686343123314*6/493 53 129 56G4 0836 ;6/54 08 E#! 16H4@4/ 08 314 2C94854 6; 2 8630;0523068 78=4/ 453068 6; 314 &2/8232>2 *6/493 53 314 2190:=2/ 2<<42/9 36 12@4 </4<2/4= 2 93234G483 3123 314 97C?453 :28= 129 C448 3/289;4//4= 36 314 *6/493 4<2/3G483 44=:499 36 92D 314 *6/493 53 G28=2349 09972854 6; 2 630;052306878=4/453068 92:/42=D8634=2C6@4314/409 86 630;0523068 78=4/ 453068 6; 314 &2/8232>2 *6/493 53 E#! 6/46@4/ 314 *6/493 4<2/3G483 0394:; 129 A0@48 6 C?453068 4/30;05234 36 A/283 314 :28= 08 ;2@6/ 6; 314 C484;0502/049 @0=4 :4334/ =234= EE 14/4;6/4 314 5683483068 6; 314 6@4/8G483 3123 03 09 2 ;6/493 :28= G793 8454992/0:D;20: # 4F3 :43 G4 56890=4/ H14314/ 314 99093283 6GG0990684/567:=12@487::0;04=314*6/G2;34/2:2<946; 2:G693 3H483D;0@4 D42/9 14 289H4/ 09 86 14 /42968 09 - 10 - 90G<:4 14 :2H 09 H4:: 9433:4= 3123 314 <6H4/ G793 C4 4F4/5094=H031082/429682C:430G48314</494835294314/4 0928086/=08234=4:2D8GD@04H314</6544=08A92/45:42/:D C2//4=CD:25149*7/314/G6/43146@4/8G483567:=86312@4 4F4/5094=<6H4/3652854:314A/283968314A/678=3123314/4 09 2 @06:23068 6; 7:4 6; 314 &2/8232>2 28= 4@4874 7:49 67894:;6/314/49<4530@4<2/3049<:254=/4:0285468314 =45090689 /4;4//4= 36 97</2 =6 863 3108> 3123 314 :2H 09 08 =67C3251=450906837/89680396H8;253914</49483529409 2:9634934=08314:0A136;3142;6/4920==45090689 *6/314/42968993234=2C6@43146/=4/6;314 99093283 6GG0990684/ 09 :02C:4 36 C4 943 290=4 556/=08A:D 03 09 943 290=4 , 14 +/03 6; 4/306/2/0 09 6/=4/4= 14 /=4/ =234= " " <2994= CD 314 99093283 6GG0990684/ 08 *0:4 6( E " "!",", 28= 08 *0:4 6( E " "!",#,E @0=4 884F7/49 28= 2/4B72914= - 11 - 497:3283:D314+/03430306809 452794 6; 314 =09<692: 6; 314 +/03 4303068 <48=08A 0834/:65736/D 2<<:05230689 0; 28D 2/4 =09<694= 6; 28= 314 0834/0G=0/4530680;28D9328=9=09512/A4= !*( '&"##) & & 093 6: 6!,