Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43515 (KAR)
SHARANAMMA W/O SHIVAPPA v. SMT.GANGABAI W/O HANMANTH
RSA/7308/2009 · 2025-10-17
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43515 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43515 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!!"
# $%$$
!&& '&( )
!" #"! $$
% &' #"! $$
&
( %
$!'! Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&! #
$! &
&
&
&
&
&
(
"& ) *+
" ) *+
&, -. *+
&# -. *+
&! -. *+
- 3 -
"
*+
! " *+
/ )
! )
)
)
)
)
)*
%
%
% %
% %
%
%
- 4 -
)
)
)
)
)
)*
)
)
)
'
&
&! %
&
&
'
*+
$!'!&
'
'
%
%$!'
&
0
/
)
*) ) )* 1
"! ) ) ) **
1 % *) )
1 &
- 5 -
*
* % % ,',
!* % *
&, #* ,,! * *2
*
** %
2 %
%!$ )2 %
345 56789: ;<<6;= >? @36 :6A69:;9@5 ;BBC46D6: >? @36EF:BG69@;9::67C66:;@6:&,<;556:49 8#8A,,!89@36A4=68A@36
$::4@489;=4D4=%F:B6 )C9 ;=;>FC;B4 -36C649;A@6C C6A6CC6: @8 ;5 H@36 C4;= 8FC@(A8C>C6D4@?.789A4CG6:>?@36EF:BG69@;9:8C:6C :;@6:,',<;556:498!8A89@36A4=6 8A
::4@489;= 45@C47@ %F:B6 ;=;>FC;B4 -36C649;A@6C C6A6CC6:@8;5H@36*4C5@<<6==;@68FC@(A8C>C6D4@?. - 6 -
36 5F>E67@ G;@@6C 8A @36 5F4@ ;C6 @36 4GG8D;>=6 <C8<6C@465 9;G6=?1 =;9:5 >6;C49B )4 ?88""! G6;5FC49B ;7C65 &! BF9@;51 )44 ?8"" G6;5FC49B ;7C65 ;9: &' BF9@;51 ;9:
)444 38F56 <C8<6C@? >6;C49B 85$& ;9: $" ;== 54@F;@6: ;@ 8>>FC$ 4==;B6 AI;=<FC ;=FJ ;=;>FC;B4 45@C47@ -36C649;A@6C C6A6CC6: @8 ;5 H@36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465(. & 36 7;56 8A @36 <=;49@4AA 45 @3;@ 896 FC;<<;
K;5 @36 78GG89<C8<854@F5 ;4:FC;<<;3;: @K8 5895 9;G6=? C;<<; ;9: 6D;<<;
C;<<; 45 3F5>;9: 8A :6A69:;9@ 8 ;9: @36 A;@36C 8A @36 <=;49@4AA ;9:
:6A69:;9@ 85 ;9: & ;9: BC;9:A;@36C 8A :6A69:;9@ 85"@8#6D;<<;@3656789:5898AFC;<<;<;556: ;K;?K4@38F@=6;D49B>6349:;9?364C53;@@3669@4C65F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 K6C6 5F7766:6: >? C;<<; K38 C6G;496: ;>58=F@6 8K96C 49 <855655489 @36C68A @4== 345 :6G45689,,!<89345:6G456@365F4@5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 :6D8=D6: F<89 345 K4A6 $ @36 :6A69:;9@ 8
- 7 -
;9:734=:C6946<=;49@4AA;9::6A69:;9@85;9:&3;@ ;A@6C @36 :6;@3 8A @364C A;@36C
C;<<; <=;49@4AA ;9: 36C ;98@36C545@6C3;:6L<C6556:@364CK4==49B9655@83;D6@36 5F4@5736:F=6<C8<6C@465<;C@4@4896:K3473K;5;D84:6:>? :6A69:;9@ 8 F>56MF69@=? <=;49@4AA =6;C9@ @3;@ @36 9;G65 8A :6A69:;9@ 85" @8 # K38 ;C6 @36 734=:C69 8A :6A69:;9@ 8 3;D6 >669 GF@;@6: 49 @36 C6D69F6 C678C:53;@89D6C4A47;@4898A@36GF@;@489C678C:5536 =6;C9@@3;@9;G68A:6A69:;9@8"3;:>669GF@;@6:49 C6D69F6C678C:5;5A;C>;7J;549@36?6;C,##:FC49B@36 =4A6@4G68A
C;<<;
" 3;@ :6A69:;9@ 8" >649B ; 8D6C9G69@ 56CD;9@ K4@38F@ 3;D49B ;9? 49:6<69:69@ C4B3@ @4@=6 8C 49@6C65@ 8D6C @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 K4@3 ;9 49@69@489 8A :6<C4D49B @36 <=;49@4AA ;9: ;=58 @;J49B ;:D;9@;B6 8A4==4@6C;7?
8A
C;<<; 3;: 7C6;@6: ; B4A@ :66:
:;@6: ,# 36 5;4: :87FG69@ 45 D84: ;9: 98@ >49:49B 89 @36 <=;49@4AA 3;@ @36 38F56 <C8<6C@? >6;C49B 8$" K;5 5@4== 5@;9:49B 49 @36 9;G6 8A <;@6C9;= F97=6
- 8 -
6D;<<; ;9: @36 38F56 >6;C49B 8$& 5@88: 49 @36 9;G6 8A @364C A;@36C
C;<<; 3;@ @36 C6MF65@ 8A @36 <=;49@4AAA8C<;C@4@4898A@36<C8<6C@465K;5C6AF56::FC49B @36A4C5@K66J8A ;C73,,!B4D49BC456@8@367;F568A ;7@489@8@365F4@
! 6A69:;9@ 8 <;556:
;K;? :FC49B @36 <69:697? 8A @36 5F4@ 6A69:;9@ 8& ;=58 <;556: ;K;? =6;D49B>6349:@36=6B;=C6<C6569@;@4D656A69:;9@85
" @8 # A4=6: KC4@@69 5@;@6G69@ :69?49B @36 <=;49@ ;D6CG69@5;9:789@69:6:@3;@FC;<<;K;5@3678GG89 <C8<854@F5 ;9: 8K96C 49 <855655489 8A 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 K38 3;: @K8 5895 >? 9;G6
C;<<; ;9:
6D;<<; K38 5F7766:6: @8 @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 F<89 @36 :6G456 8A FC;<<; 3;@ :FC49B @36 =4A6@4G6 8A 6D;<<; 36 ;=89B K4@3 345 >C8@36C
C;<<; 3;: 6L67F@6:
C6B45@6C6: :66: 8A B4A@ 89 ,# 789D6?49B 4@6G 85;9:8A@365F4@5736:F=6<C8<6C@465>?K;?8AB4A@ 49A;D8FC8A:6A69:;9@8"3;@6D;<<;K383;:3;=A 53;C6494@6G85;9:8A5F4@5736:F=6<C8<6C@4653;:
- 9 -
E8496: 6L67F@489 8A @36 5;4: :66: 8A B4A@ ;5 ; 789569@49B K4@9655 3F5 F<89 @36 6L67F@489 8A @36 :66: 8A B4A@ >? C;<<;;=89B K4@3 6D;<<;;5 @36 789569@49BK4@9655 @8 @365;4::87FG69@4@6G85;9:8A@365F4@5736:F=6 <C8<6C@4655@88:789D6?6:49@369;G68A:6A69:;9@8" 6A69:;9@ 8" K;5 <=;76: 49 <855655489 8A 4@6G 85 ;9: 8A @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 ;9: 36 3;5 G;:6 4G<C8D6G69@>?;D;4=49BA49;974;=;5545@;97655F73@36 7=;4G8A@36<=;49@4AAA8C<;C@4@489K;5:6946:
! @45 789@69@6: @3;@ @36 <=;49@4AA;9: :6A69:;9@ 85 ;9: & K6C6 G;CC46: ;9: K6C6 C654:49B 49 @364C C65<67@4D6 G;C4@;= 38F565 K34=6 :6A69:;9@ 8" K;5 =88J49B ;A@6C @36;AA;4C5 8A @3669@4C6 A;G4=? 497=F:49B @36 K6== >649B 8A
C;<<; ;9: 6D;<<; 3;@ 4@ K;5 49 78954:6C;@489 8A @345 56CD476 C69:6C6: >? @36 :6A69:;9@ 8"6D;<<;3;:6L67F@6:@36:66:8AB4A@49345A;D8FC 55F73363;:>678G6;>58=F@68K96C8A4@6G85;9:
8A @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 ;9: 789@49F6: @8 >6 49 <855655489;9:69E8?G69@8A@365;G6697658FB3@A8C :45G455;=8A@365F4@
- 10 -
;56: 89 @36 ;A8C65;4: <=6;:49B5 @36 C4;= 8FC@AC;G6:@36A8==8K49B455F65
!"!#$" % &'(
( &'($
)
"!"!#$"
&'(
* )
*
+ &'($
* )
*
,
*
$
*
- . # =;49@4AA 6L;G496: 36C56=A ;5 $ ;9: @K8 K4@965565 >? 9;G6 ;==49;@3 ;9: 3;9:;<<; ;5 5$ ;9:&C65<67@4D6=?;9:6L34>4@6:56D69:87FG69@5G;CJ6:
- 11 -
;5 L5$ @8 $# 6A69:;9@ 8" 6L;G496: 34G56=A ;5
$ ;9: @3C66 K4@965565 >?
9;G6 3;9J6C;<<; ;99;5;>;9:4::;C;G;5 5$@8";9:6L34>4@6:, :87FG69@5G;CJ6:;5L5$@8$,
' 9 ;<<C674;@489 8A 6D4:6976 @36 C4;= 8FC@ ;95K6C6: 455F6 85 @8 & ;9: # 49 @36 ;AA4CG;@4D6 ;9:
455F6 85" ! ;9: 49 @36 96B;@4D6 8956MF69@=? :67C66:@365F4@;5F9:6C 36<=;49@4AA4569@4@=6:A8C<;C@4@489;9:56<;C;@6 <855655489 8A 36C &C: 53;C6 49 @36 5F4@ <C8<6C@465
4G4=;C=? :6A69:;9@ 85 ;9: :6A69:;9@ 8&); @8&)
;C6;=5869@4@=6:A8C&C:53;C6 6;7349@365F4@<C8<6C@465
@45AFC@36C:67=;C6:@3;@@36C6B45@6C6::66:8A B4A@ :;@6: ,# 6L67F@6: >? C;<<; 49 A;D8FC 8A :6A69:;9@ 8" ;5 9F== ;9: D84: ;9: 98@>49:49B89@36<=;49@4AA
, 649B ;BBC46D6: :6A69:;9@ 85 " @8 # <C6A6CC6:C6BF=;C;<<6;=498!8A>6A8C6@36 *4C5@ <<6==;@6 8FC@ 9 78954:6C;@489 8A @36 BC8F9:5 FCB6: @36 *4C5@ <<6==;@6 8FC@ AC;G6: @36 A8==8K49B <849@5A8C4@578954:6C;@489
- 12 -
/
*
/*
)
0%'1! %
1
&'(
)
) 2 &' &' & 324 *
5
&'
*
*
/*
6
)
) 5) . 9 C6$;<<C674;@489 8A @36 6D4:6976 @36 *4C5@ <<6==;@6 8FC@ ;95K6C6: @36 5;G6 49 @36 96B;@4D6 8956MF69@=? :45G4556: @36 ;<<6;= 789A4CG49B @36 EF:BG69@;9::67C66<;556:>?@36C4;=8FC@
649B ;BBC46D6: :6A69:;9@ 85 " @8 # ;C6 >6A8C6@3458FC@
345 8FC@ >? 8C:6C :;@6: ' 3;: AC;G6:@36A8==8K49B5F>5@;9@4;=MF65@4898A=;K /* ) )
)
) 7 &'8' 9! 8' 7*
32"":52!(-(. - 13 -
& 36C6;A@6C 89 36;C49B @36 =6;C96: 78F956= A8C @36 <;C@465 89 ! AC;G6: A8==8K49B ;::4@489;= 5F>5@;9@4;=MF65@48958A=;K ;
<
5
/
&'($
6
1 =
"'"'#$"%
;
<
5
/
* *
&'(
*
1=
"'"'#$". " 4976@365F>5@;9@4;=MF65@4898A=;KAC;G6:89 ':898@;C45649@36=4B3@8A@36EF:BG69@8A@36 89(>=6 <6L 8FC@ 49 @36 7;56 8A
@365;G64598@;:D6C@6:@8
! C4 ;?;J =6;C96: 78F956= A8C @36 ;<<6==;9@5;:D6C@49B@8@36;::4@489;=5F>5@;9@4;=MF65@489 8A=;K8) 5F>G4@@6:
>""#4
- 14 -
! 3;@ @36 C4;= 8FC@ ;9: @36 *4C5@ <<6==;@6 8FC@3;D6BC855=?6CC6:49:67=4949B@8;776<@C6B45@6C6: 66:8A4A@:;@6:,#49@6CG58AK3473:6A69:;9@ 8";7MF4C6:C4B3@@4@=6;9:49@6C65@8D6C4@6G85;9: 8A@365F4@5736:F=6<C8<6C@465365;4::87FG69@K;5 6L67F@6: >? C;<<; @8 K3473 6D;<<; 3;: E8496: ;5 789569@49B K4@9655 3;@ 4@6G 85 ;9: 8A @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6<C8<6C@4658C4B49;==?>6=89B6:@8FC;<<;K3473 6D69 8@36CK456 K;5 @8 :6D8=D6 6MF;==? F<89
C;<<; ;9:
6D;<<; 49 6MF;= <C8<8C@489 6;73 >649B 69@4@=6: A8C ' ;7C65 BF9@;5 3F5
C;<<; ;9: 6D;<<; >649B @36 8K96C58A';7C65BF9@;58A=;9:6;73A8CG49B<;C@8A 4@6G 85 ;9: 8A @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 3;: 789D6?6:@365;G6;>58=F@6=?49A;D8FC8A:6A69:;9@8" 49@6CG58A@36:66:8AB4A@ !3;@5889;A@6C@366L67F@4898A:66:8AB4A@ @369;G68A:6A69:;9@8"K;5GF@;@6:49@36C6D69F6 C678C:5 ;9: 345 9;G6 3;5 >669 C6A=67@6: 49 @36 C6D69F6 C678C:56D6C54976,##3;@
C;<<;K38:46:49@36?6;C
- 15 -
,,!3;:98@8>E67@6:8C:45<F@6:@366L67F@4898A:66: 8AB4A@;9:5F>56MF69@69@C?8A9;G68A:6A69:;9@8"49 @36C6D69F6C678C:5:FC49B345=4A6@4G6=6;C=?@36:66:8A B4A@;@@;496:A49;=4@? !&=;49@4AA3;D49BA4=6:@365F4@49@36?6;C,,! K347345;A@6C=;<568A!?6;C578F=:98@3;D6G;49@;496:
@36 5F4@ ;5 @36 5;G6 45 38<6=655=? >;CC6: >?
=4G4@;@489 3;@@36C4;=8FC@;9:@36*4C5@<<6==;@68FC@3;D6=85@ 54B3@8A@345;5<67@8AG;@@6C
!" 5 C6B;C:5 ;::4@489;= 5F>5@;9@4;= MF65@489 8A =;K8) 36C6A6C5@8C@47=6,8A@364G4@;@4897@@8 789@69:@3;@5F4@4A;9?8FB3@@83;D6>669A4=6:K4@349; <6C48:8A?6;C5AC8G@36:;@68A:6A69:;9@8">649B <F@49<8556554898A4@6G85;9:8A@365F4@5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465 =;49@4AA :65<4@6 3;D49B J98K=6:B6 8A @36 ;A8C65;4:@C;95;7@4893;D49B98@@;J69;7@4894565@8<<6:
AC8G A4=49B @36 5F4@ 6 C6=465 F<89 @36 EF:BG69@ 49 @36
- 16 -
7;56 8A 49 EF5@4A47;@4898A345789@69@489K4@3C6B;C:@85F4@98@>649B G;49@;49;>=649@36=4B3@8A:6=;?49A4=49B@365;G66976 365F>G4@5@3;@5F>5@;9@4;=MF65@4898A=;K>6;95K6C6:49 A;D8FC8A@36;<<6==;9@5:45G45549B@365F4@
7 =6;C96: 78F956= C4 G>6J;C ;<<6;C49B A8C @36 <=;49@4AAC65<89:69@ 85)7 )6 )A 5F>G4@5 3;@:66:8AB4A@45C6MF4C6:@8>66L67F@6:;5 <C8D4:6: F9:6C 67@489 & 8A @36 C;95A6C 8A C8<6C@? 7@''K3473G;9:;@656L67F@4898A@365;G6K4@3;@ =6;5@ @K8 ;@@65@6: K4@965565 67@489 ' 8A @36 D4:6976 7@'#4G<8565;C4B8C8A6L;G4949B;@=6;5@8968A@36 ;@@65@49B K4@965565 @8 @36 5;4: :87FG69@ 3;@ @36C6 45 @8@;=989$78G<=4;9768A67@489'8A@36D4:69767@49 @3;@A4C5@=?:6A69:;9@8"3;598@<C8:F76:@368C4B49;= :66: 8A B4A@ 56789:=? 36 3;5 98@ 6L;G496: ;9? 8A @36 ;@@65@49BK4@965565
"4?3
7@A-
- 17 -
3;@ 49 @36 ;>56976 8A :6A69:;9@ 8" <C8D49B @36 6L67F@489 8A @36 :66: 8A B4A@ 49 @36 G;996C J98K9 @8 =;K @36 5;4: :87FG69@ @36C6A8C6 7;998@ >6 78954:6C6: ;5 3;D49B >669 <C8D6: A8C @36 <FC<856 8A :6@6CG49;@4898AC4B3@58A@36<;C@465 & 3;@ ;5 C6B;C:5 @36 MF65@489 8A =4G4@;@489 8C4B49;==? <=;49@4AA 3;: A4=6: 5F4@ A8C <;C@4@489 54G<=474@8C 3;@ 49 C65<8956 @8 @36 49@6C4G ;<<=47;@489 A4=6: >? @36 <=;49@4AA :6A69:;9@ 8" 3;: 78G6 F< K4@3 @36 @368C? 8A C;<<; ;9:6D;<<;6L67F@49B :66: 8A B4A@ 49 345 A;D8FC 8954:6C49B @36 ;D6CG69@5 G;:6 49 @36 5;4: ;<<=47;@489 <=;49@4AA 3;: 58FB3@ A8C ;G69:G69@ 8A @36 <=;49@ >? 4978C<8C;@49B@36;::4@489;=<C;?6C8AC6=46A8A:67=;C;@489 K4@3 C6B;C: @8 D;=4:4@? 8C 8@36CK456 8A @36 :66: 8A B4A@ :;@6:,#365;4:;G69:G69@K;5K4@349@4G6 3;@ @36 D6C? <C6G456 89 K3473 @36 C6=46A 8A :67=;C;@489 K4@3C6B;C:@8D;=4:4@?8A@36:66:8AB4A@4558FB3@45@3;@ @36 5;4: :87FG69@ K;5 ; <C8:F7@ 8A AC;F: ;9:
G45C6<C6569@;@489
@45@3656@@=6:<854@4898A=;K@3;@@36 =4G4@;@489 49 C65<67@ 8A A;7@5 49D8=D49B 6=6G69@ 8A AC;F:
- 18 -
K8F=: ;C456 ;9: 78GG6976 89=? AC8G @36 :;@6 8A J98K=6:B6;9:98@AC8G@36:;@689K3473@36:87FG69@ 78G65 49@8 6L45@6976 3;@ 49 @36 495@;9@ 7;56 @36 6L45@69768A@36:87FG69@7;G6@8@36J98K=6:B68A@36 <=;49@4AA 89=? K369 @36 :6A69:;9@5 3;: A4=6: 8>E67@489 @8 @3649@6C4G;<<=47;@4894==@369536K;598@;K;C68A@36 6L67F@4898A5F73:87FG69@
" 5 C6B;C:5 @36 C6D69F6 69@C465 ;AA67@49B @36 9;G68A:6A69:;9@8"49@36?6;C,##365F>G4@5@3;@ @365;G6K8F=:964@36C7C6;@6;9?C4B3@@4@=68C49@6C65@49 A;D8FC 8A @36 <;C@? 98C :865 4@ 6L@49BF453 C4B3@ @4@=6 ;9: 49@6C65@3;@49@36495@;9@7;56@36<=;49@4AAK;5G;CC46:
;9: 5@;?49B 56<;C;@6=? 36 3;: C6MF65@6: A8C @36 <;C@4@4898A5F4@5736:F=6<C8<6C@46589=?F<89@36:6G456 8A 36C A;@36C 49 @36 ?6;C ,,! 4976 36C C6MF65@ K;5 C6AF56:5889@36C6;A@6C5363;5;<<C8;736:@368FC@>? A4=49B 5F4@ 49 @36 ?6;C ,,!
;9: 6D69 @36 ;G69:G69@ @8 @36<=;49@K;558FB3@K4@349;<6C48:8A&?6;C5AC8G@36 :;@6 8A J98K=6:B6 5 5F73 36 5F>G4@5 @3;@ @36 <=6; 8A =4G4@;@48978F=:98@;C45649@36495@;9@7;56
- 19 -
! :D6C@49B @8 @36 EF:BG69@ C6=46: F<89 >? =6;C96:78F956=A8C@36;<<6==;9@549@367;568A
365F>G4@5@3;@@36A;7@5;9:74C7FG5@;97658A@36 5;4:7;56;C6:4AA6C69@;9::45@497@AC8G@36896;@3;9:
9 @36 7;56 8A
@36 :45<F@6 K;5 C;456: >? @36 D6C? 6L67F@;9@ 8A @36 :66: 8A B4A@ 36C6A8C6 36 3;:
J98K=6:B6 8A @36 6L67F@489 8A @36 B4A@ K3473 45 98@ @36 7;56;@3;9:6976365F>G4@5@3;@@365;4:EF:BG69@45 98@;<<=47;>=6@8@36A;7@58A@36495@;9@7;5665F>G4@5 @3;@=4G4@;@48953;==>6C67J896:@;J49B49@878954:6C;@489 @36 G;E8C N 5F>5@;9@4D6 C6=46A 58FB3@ A8C D69 ;<<=?49B @365;4:<C4974<=6@36<C6569@5F4@A4=6:>?@36<=;49@4AA45 D6C?GF73G;49@;49;>=6;9:36976566J5A8C;95K6C49B8A @365F>5@;9@4;=MF65@48958A=;K49@3696B;@4D6;9:566J5 A8C:45G455;=8A@36;<<6;=
# 6;C:6CF56:@36C678C:5
- 20 -
' 36C6 45 98 :45<F@6 K4@3 C6B;C: @8 C6=;@489534< 8A @36 <;C@465 58 ;=58 K4@3 C6B;C: @8 FC;<<; >649B @36 <C8<854@F5 ;9: @36 8K96C 49 <855655489 8A @36 5F4@ 5736:F=6 <C8<6C@465
9 @36 98CG;= 74C7FG5@;9765 F<89 @36:6G4568AFC;<<;@365F4@5736:F=6<C8<6C@465K8F=:
3;D6 :6D8=D6: F<89 345 @K8 5895 9;G6=? C;<<; ;9:
6D;<<; 6;73 >649B 69@4@=6: A8C 6MF;= 53;C6 @36C649 6D;<<;;:G4@@6:=?<;556:;K;?455F6=655=6;D49B>6349:
345 >C8@36C
C;<<; ;5 345 7=;55$
364C @8 5F7766: @8 345 69@4C665@;@6
, 6A69:;9@ 8" 45 @36 BC;9:589 8A
C;<<; 778C:49B @8 :6A69:;9@ 8" C;<<;
<FC<8C@6:=? 6L67F@6:;9:C6B45@6C6:@36:66:8AB4A@89,#@8 K3473 6D;<<; 3;: E8496: ;5 ;9 ;@@65@49B K4@9655 5 5F73 :6A69:;9@ 8" 7=;4G5 36 3;D49B >678G6 @36 ;>58=F@6 8K96C @8 @36 69@4C6 6L@69@ 8A @36 =;9: >649B @6G58;9:8A@365F4@<C8<6C@465
- 21 -
67@489 & 8A @36 C;95A6C 8A C8<6C@? 7@ ''<C8D4:49BA8C@C;95A6C8A4GG8D;>=6<C8<6C@?@3C8FB3 B4A@C6;:5;5F9:6C$
<
*B
**
* * ))
' <
*B
*
* * ' 4
**
*) *
'. 3F5 @C;95A6C 8A 4GG8D;>=6 <C8<6C@? 49 @6CG5 8A B4A@ 89=? 7;9 >6 6AA67@6: @3C8FB3 ; C6B45@6C6: 495@CFG69@54B96:>?8C89>63;=A8A:898C;@@65@6:>?;@ =6;5@@K8K4@965565
67@489 ' 8A @36
9:4;9 D4:6976 7@ '# <C8D4:49B A8C <C88A 8A 6L67F@489 8A:87FG69@ C6MF4C6: >? =;K@8>6;@@65@6:C6;:5;5F9:6C$
- 22 -
!'!" #
$ %&%
!* 6
) ' )
%
) /
' C7 ) % *
) )
2
5#"->,#"- % )*
% 'D.
& 6;C96: 78F956= A8C @36 ;<<6==;9@ ;@ @345 EF97@FC6 5F>G4@5 @3;@ 54976 @36 ;@@65@49B K4@965565 K6C6 98G8C6@36?78F=:98@>66L;G496:
" 67@489 , 8A @36
9:4;9 D4:6976 7@ '# C6;:5;5F9:6C$ '"
( '!
) *
% E
:
*
*
) )
%
*
) '. - 23 -
! 6CF5;= 8A @36 ;A8C65;4: <C8D45489 49:47;@6 @3;@ 4A;9?8A@36;@@65@49BK4@965565K6C698@;D;4=;>=6A8C@36 C6;589 8A @36? 98@ >649B ;=4D6 8C 8@36CK456 49 @6CG5 8A 67@489,8A@36
9:4;9D4:69767@4@GF5@>6<C8D6: @3;@@36;@@65@;@4898A8968A@36;@@65@49BK4@965565K;5 49 345 3;9:KC4@49B >? <C8:F749B 8C 6L;G4949B 5F73 K4@965565 K38 K6C6 ;7MF;49@6: K4@3 @36 3;9:KC4@49B 8A 5F73;@@65@49BK4@9655
:G4@@6:=? @36 8C4B49;= 8A @36 D6C? B4A@ :66:
L :;@6: ,# 3;5 98@ >669 <C8:F76: >? :6A69:;9@8"36C678C:5C6D6;=6:@3;@;=6@@6CL' 3;:>669;::C6556:@8@36>;9JK36C6@36:6A69:;9@8" 3;: <FC<8C@6:=? ;D;4=6: @36 =8;9 36 L 45 C6MF65@49B A8C <C8:F7@489 8A @36 :87FG69@ L76<@ @3;@ @36C6566G5@8>698;@@6G<@8C6AA8C@G;:6>?:6A69:;9@ 8"@8567FC6;9:<C8:F76@365;4::87FG69@36=6;5@ 78F=: 3;D6 >669 :896 K;5 @8 6L;G496 @36 >;9J ;F@38C4@465K34733;598@>669:896
- 24 -
# 4976@36G;9:;@8C?C6MF4C6G69@8A67@489' ;9: 67@489 , 8A @36
9:4;9 D4:6976 7@ 3;5 98@>669 78G<=46:K4@3;5C4B3@=?789@69@6:>?@36=6;C96:78F956= A8C @36 <=;49@4AA @36 C4;= 8FC@ ;9: @36 *4C5@ <<6==;@6 8FC@3;D678GG4@@6:986CC8C49:67=4949B@8;776<@@36 7;56 8A @36 :6A69:;9@ 8" 8A 36 3;D49B >678G6 @36 8K96C 8A @36
@6G5 8 ;9:
@6G 8 8A @36 5F4@ <C8<6C@465 49 @6CG5 8A @36 :66: 8A B4A@ L :;@6: ,#4976@366L67F@4898A@365;4::87FG69@45 98@<C8D6:49@36G;996CJ98K9@8=;K:6A69:;9@58
" @8 # 7;998@ 7=;4G @8 3;D6 ;7MF4C6: C4B3@ @4@=6 ;9:
49@6C65@ 8D6C
@6G5 8 ;9: 8A @36 5F4@ <C8<6C@465 F>5@;9@4;=MF65@4898A=;K845;95K6C6:;778C:49B=? ' 5 C6B;C:5 @36 455F6 8A =4G4@;@489 @38FB3 @36 ;A8C65;4: :66: 8A B4A@ 455@;@6: @83;D6 >669 6L67F@6: 49 @36 ?6;C ,# @36 <=;49@4AA 7=;4G6: @8 3;D6 =6;C9@ ;>8F@ @366L45@69768A5F73:87FG69@89=?K369@36:6A69:;9@ 8"A4=6:5@;@6G69@8A8>E67@489@8@3649@6C4G;<<=47;@489 A4=6:>?@36<=;49@4AA49@365F4@8@349B3;5>669>C8FB3@
- 25 -
89C678C:>?@36:6A69:;9@5@8C6>F@@365;4:789@69@4895 8A<=;49@4AA38FB3C6A6C69764558FB3@@8>6G;:6@8@36 C6D69F6 69@C465 >F@ C6D69F6 69@C465 <FC<8C@6: @8 3;D6 G;:649@36?6;C,##@365;G6458A98;D;4=49@36=4B3@ 8A 56@@=6: <854@489 8A =;K 9;G6=? ;:D6C56 69@C465 49 @36 C6D69F6C678C:578F=:98@@;J6;K;?@365F>5@;9@4D6C4B3@ 8A@36<;C@465896@36=655@367;568A@36<=;49@4AA45@3;@ @36 :66: 8A B4A@ 3;: 78G6 49@8 6L45@6976 >? G6;95 8A 6L6C@489 8A AC;F: ;9: G45C6<C6569@;@489 89
C;<<; K38 K;5<FC<8C@6:=?;94==4@6C;@6
, 9@36;>569768A;9?;776<@;>=6=6B;=6D4:6976 >C8FB3@ 89 C678C: >? :6A69:;9@ 8" @8 :45>6=46D6 @36 D6C548958A@36<=;49@4AA@3458FC@:898@566@365F4@8A @36<=;49@4AA>649B>;CC6:>?=4G4@;@489
& 6=4;976 <=;76: 89 >? @36 =6;C96: 78F956= A8C @36;<<6==;9@89@36EF:BG69@8A@3689(>=6<6L8FC@ 49@367;568AA2* 458A98;D;4=36C6=6D;9@ ;C;8"C6=46:F<89>?=6;C96:78F956=A8C@36;<<6==;9@ C6;:5;5F9:6C$
- 26 -
;
>0%
7!
) ,'"+'#+#' 2 *
)
%
* *
'&
2*
* )
) * * >0%
7!' A /
* /
) /
' ;
) ) >0%
7!' F
% )
' 4
) *
'; #+# )
* %
* 5
+# ; 4 >7 !8G 3
*
5 #,'A)
)
'"$'#-"
'' %
% ,'"+'#+# >0%
7' ;
)
*
' ;
)
*
)
'. & 6CF5;=8AK3473K8F=:49:47;@6@3;@49@36A;7@5 8A @36 5;4: 7;56 @36 <;C@465 3;: 49:66: 789@65@6: @36 C6D69F6 69@C465 ;9: @36 5;G6 3;: >669 96B;@6:
9 @36 495@;9@ 7;56 @36C6 K;5 98 5F73 789@65@ @8 @36 C6D69F6
- 27 -
69@C465 654:65 @36 <C4974<=65 @3;@ :87FG69@ >649B C6B45@6C6:45;98@476@8K8C=:;@=;CB6G;?98@;<<=?49 @36 A;7@5 8A @36 7;56 49;5GF73 ;5 A4C5@=? @36 <=;49@4AA25 789@69@48945@3;@@365;4::87FG69@45;<C8:F7@8AAC;F: 6789:=?4@45@36:;@68A;7MF4C49B@36J98K=6:B6;9:98@ @36 :;@6 8A 6L67F@489 ;9: C6B45@C;@489 K3473 G;@@6C5 ;5 36=:>?@36<6L8FC@49@367;568A%)%
" )* + % + %
& 9 @36 495@;9@ 7;56 @38FB3 8C4B49;==? 5F4@ K;5 A4=6:566J49B<;C@4@4894@4589=?K369@36:6A69:;9@8" 56@ F< <=6; 8A 36 3;D49B 8>@;496: :66: 8A B4A@ 49 345 8>E67@489 @8 49@6C4G ;<<=47;@489 A4=6: >? @36 <=;49@4AA ;G69:G69@4978C<8C;@49B@36;::4@489;=<C;?6C8AC6=46A8A :67=;C;@4893;5>66958FB3@8@349B456=474@6:C6B;C:49B @36 <=;49@4AA 3;D49B 3;: 6;C=46C J98K=6:B6
9 ;9? 6D69@ @3458FC@K34=6;::C65549B@365F>5@;9@4;=MF65@4898A=;K 83;D49B78G6@87897=F5489@3;@:6A69:;9@8"98@ 3;D49B<C8D6:@36B4A@G6C6C6B45@C;@4898A@36:87FG69@ 458A9878956MF69765
3 )"(4?3
4("+
- 28 -
&& *8C @36 ;A8C65;4: C6;5895 ;9: ;9;=?545 5F>5@;9@4;= MF65@4895 8A =;K ;95K6C6: ;778C:49B=? @36 ;<<6;=A;4=5778C:49B=?@36A8==8K49B
! 36;<<6;=45 36 EF:BG69@ ;9: :67C66 <;556: >? @36 C4;= 8FC@ ;9: @36 *4C5@ <<6==;@6 8FC@ ;C6 36C6>? 789A4CG6:
*+ '$$( %! %% 45@8=8&