- 1 - !" ! #"$! #"$" %"!! & !" " " !" # $ % & & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & '(!!! " & ) !" * + !" + ' !" # & & '(!!! # & $ & " , -&& & , % & & & ./ & & & 0 "*!"!" "!!.*. & "!" + &- - 3 - & 1- 1- & $ 1- % 234 56789:;8 ;9838367 34 <3=9> ;?@A37B 829 6C?8 86 37383@8956789:;8;?6599>37B4@B@3748829?94;67>9784<6? >346D9>39759 6< 829 6?>9? >@89> "*!"!" ;@449> DA =9@?79> 37B=9 -C>B9 6< 8234 6C?8 37 ?38 9838367 6"!!.*."!" " 29;?@A9?46CB28378294@3>E?38;9838367E@4 86344C9@E?386<:@7>@:C4>3?95837B829?94;67>978486 56743>9? 829 ?9;?94978@8367 6< 829 ;98383679?4 >@89> !*!"!" F3>9 779GC?9' @7> 56749HC978=A 37383@89 @5HC3438367 ;?6599>37B4 37 ?94;958 6< 829 =@7> 6< 829 ;98383679?4 @I37B 7689 6< 829 ;?@A9? @4 E9== @4 829 >65C:978 @8 779GC?9' @7> @=46 829 4CD:344367 :@>9 DA 829 =9@?79> 3B2 6C?8 6F9?7:978 =9@>9? 82@8 - 4 - ?9@467@D=9 83:9 :@A D9 B?@789> 86 56743>9? @7> ;@44 @;;?6;?3@89 6?>9?4 =9@?79> 37B=9 -C>B9 >3?9589> 829 ?94;67>9784 86 @>>?944 829 B?39F@7594 6< 829 ;98383679?4 @7> 86 56743>9? 8293? ?9;?94978@8367 >@89> !*!"!" @8 779GC?9'@7>86;@44@;;?6;?3@896?>9?437@556?>@759 E382=@EE38237@;9?36>6<43GE99I4294@3>6?>9?2@4 768 D997 56:;=39> E382 E38237 829 483;C=@89> ;9?36> @7> 2975956789:;8;?6599>37B42@4D99737383@89> * 7;C?4C@7596<82956789:;8;?6599>37B4829 ?94;67>9784 2@F9 <3=9> @ 56C789? @<<3>@F38 >@89> " ! "!" @7> 779GC?94' 86 ( @=67B E382 6?@= 4CD:344367 48@837B 82@8 829?9 E@4 9G3489759 6< @ J5@?8 ?6@>K37829=@7>6<56:;=@37@784@7>67=A378294@3>5@?8 ?6@>829?6@>34<6?:9>65C:9784@?9@=46;?6>C59>37 4C;;6?86<8294@3>5678978367 2956C749=@;;9@?37B<6?82956:;=@37@782@4 <3=9> 234 ?9;=A 67 !*!."!" ;=@537B 67 ?956?> 779GC?94' @7> 39 56;A 6< 829 97>6?49:978 @7> - 5 - 56;A6<82956::C735@8367=9889?779GC?9'@7>29759 4@:934768@559;89> B@37 829 8@89 <3=9> @ D9889? @<<3>@F38 @=67B E382 >65C:9784 67 !."!" 4CD:38837B 82@8 829 5@?8 ?6@>34 37 9G3489759 @7> 29759 829 56:;=@37@784 @?9 768 97838=9><6?56:;974@8367 ( 7 ?9;=A 829 56:;=@37@7804 56C749= 2@4 <3=9> @ :9:6 >@89> !."!" @=67B E382 829 F3==@B9 :@; E29?937 38 34 5@89B6?35@==A :9783679> 82@8 76 5@?8 ?6@> 9G348437 C?F9A 64(.@7>/*@7>8294@:934376829? 4C?F9A7C:D9?4E2352@?9@>L@597886829=@7>37 C?F9A 64( @7>/ / 7 F39E 6< 829 4@:9 829 =9@?79> >>38367@= >F65@89 979?@= :@>9 829 4CD:344367 82@8 829A @?9 B637B 86 567>C58 @ L6378 4C?F9A @7> ;=@59 829 :@89?3@= D9<6?982346C?8678234>@A6>@A2@F37B567>C589>829 L6378 4C?F9A 829A 2@F9 <3=9> @ <?942 @<<3>@F38 @>:38837B 82@8 829 ?6@> 34 <6?:9> 37 829 =@7> 6< 829 56:;=@37@784 - 6 - 438C@89> 37 C?F9A 64(. @7> /* @7> 5@?8 ?6@> 34 37 9G3489759 37 C?F9A 764( @7> / 234 >65C:978 34 344C9>DA829 C?F9A6?>@89>"!."!" 23=9 <3=37B 8234 @<<3>@F38 38 34 48@89> 37 ;@?@B?@;2 6/82@8829L63784C?F9A5=9@?=A>345=649482@8 829 ?6@> 2@4 D997 >9F3@89> <?6: 829 5@?8 ?6@> @7> 829 4@:9 34 @8 @ F9?A =944 >348@759 D98E997 829 5@?8 ?6@> 426E767829:@;@7>8299G34837B8@??6@><6?E2352@ 4:@== ?9@=3B7:978 34 ?9HC3?9> 8 34 @=46 48@89> 37 829 @<<3>@F38 82@8 37 F39E 6< 829 >3?9583674 6< 8234 6C?8 829 ;2A435@= ;644944367 6< 829 ?6@> E3== D9 ?9@=3B79> @556?>37B=A ?C7737B 82?6CB2 829 5@?8 ?6@> @7> 829 ;6449443676<@7A;6?83676<82956:;=@37@7840=@7>E3==D9 ?9=9@49> @7> 829A E6C=> ?9486?9 829 48@8C4 HC6 @789 37 ?94;9586<829=@7>6<82956:;=@37@784 . 29 =9@?79> 56C749= @;;9@?37B <6? 829 56:;=@37@784 4CD:384 82@8 829 :@89?3@= 5=9@?=A >345=6494 82@8829?6@>2@4D997<6?:9>37829=@7>6<56:;=@37@784 @7>C83=3M9>46829A2@F986;@A829>@:@B94<6?C4@B96< - 7 - =@7>E3826C8<6==6E37B>C9;?659446<=@E29L63784C?F9A 3849=< >345=6494 82@8 E3826C8 <6==6E37B @7A ;?659>C?9 829 ?6@> 2@4 D997 <6?:9> 37 829 56:;=@37@7840 =@7> @7> 29759829?934@<6?593782956789783676<82956C749=<6? 56:;=@37@784 ! 7F39E6<829:@89?3@=;=@59>67?956?>@7>829 4CD:34436746<829?94;9583F956C749=3834F9?A5=9@?82@8 829?6@>2@4D997<6?:9>37829=@7>6<82956:;=@37@784 @7>8294@:92@4D997C49>DA829 8@89<6?829B979?@= ;CD=35 6E 829 @<<3>@F38 <3=9> >345=6494 82@8 829A @?9 B637B86?9486?9829;?6;9?8A6<82956:;=@37@7848648@8C4 HC6@789E38237@;9?36>6<679:6782@7>@=46B637B86 56743>9? 829 >@:@B94 3< ;@?835C=@?4 @?9 <C?73429>DA 829 56:;=@37@784 46 @4 86 @44944 829 4@:9 375=C>37B 829 >@:@B9@7>=6446<5?6;4>C?37B8294@3>;9?36> 29 =9@?79> 56C749= <6? 829 56:;=@37@78 @=46 4CD:38482@8829>98@3=4E3==D9<C?73429><6?82E38286829 8@89 29 =9@?79> >>38367@= 6F9?7:978 >F65@89 @4 E9== @4 829 =9@?79> >>38367@= >F65@89 979?@= 4CD:38 - 8 - 82@8 829A @?9 B637B 86 56:;=989 8234 ;?65944 E38237 @ ;9?36>6<679:6782 " 556?>37B=A 829 ?94;67>9784 @?9 >3?9589> 86 ?9486?9 829 ;?6;9?8A 6< 829 56:;=@37@784 86 48@8C4 HC6 @789 E38237 679 :6782 @7> 4@:9 426C=> D9 <6? 829 ;C?;6496<5C=83F@83676<829=@7>@438E@49@?=39?D9<6?9 <6?:@83676<829?6@>834:@>95=9@?82@88294@:942@== D9>679@882956486<8296<<353@=4E26E9?9?94;6743D=9 <6?<6?:@83676<829?6@>E3826C8<6==6E37B>C9;?659446< =@E 37 F39E 6< 829 53?5C=@? 6< 829 6F9?7:978 D9@?37B 76 @@" "!( >@89> "*!."!( @7> @=46 37383@89 @;;?6;?3@89 ;?6599>37B4 @B@3748 9??9> 6<<353@=4 E2656::3889>8234:348@I96<<6?:37B@?6@>37829=@7> D9=67B37B 86 829 56:;=@37@784 ?9;6?8 ?9B@?>37B 829 4@:9 42@== D9 4CD:3889> D9<6?9 8234 6C?8 E38237 82?99 :67824 <?6: 829 >@89 6< ?9593;8 6< @ 56;A 6< 8234 6?>9? 37>35@837B829>95343678@I97@B@37488294@3>6<<353@=429 4@:9 42@== D9 ;=@59> D9<6?9 8234 6C?8 67 6? D9<6?9 ' - 9 - * 7 829 D@434 6< 829 @<<3>@F38 <3=9> @7> 829 4CD:3443674 :@>9DA=9@?79>@7>=9@?79>679 :678204 83:9 34 B?@789> 86 5@??A 6C8 829 4@3> ;?65944 < 829 4@:9 34 768 56:;=39> E382 E38237 @ ;9?36> 6< 679 :6782 <?6: 829 >@89 6< ?9593;8 6< 59?83<39> 56;A 6< 8234 6?>9? 829 56:;=@37@784 @?9 @8 =3D9?8A 86 ?9F3F9 8234 56789:;8;9838367 382 829 @D6F9 6D49?F@83674 829 56789:;8 ;?6599>37B4345=649><6?;?94978 348 8234 56789:;8 ;9838367 67 !!"!"( <6? 56743>9?@83676<@583678@I97?9;6?886D9<3=9>D9<6?9829 6C?8@4;9?829@<6?94@3>>3?958367 () *!+ $ (), *"+ $ - 348 6 = 6