- 1 - !" # $% & & ## '&( )* ## ) * ! " # $%& $ ' ! " ! $%' $ # ( " ) $' *+,-+-./0+121-+1-.3+- '4%'''252,678+ 2913 +/02,-+,3 2/(32.1+ 31+.3+-./81/251+/02,-+,3 ,2.,-' Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ # & ! " ) $ $ " ) $ $ &:! # # ! ( " $ ;$ $<#%( # (= & ! #" (= " '4%''' '= ( ' ! # ( ! ! ;# " ! <#! ''4 ! ! # <# ! ("' <# ;# - 3 - ) * # " $% $ ' " $%( $ # ( " $' $ # & " $ $ ! " $ $ - 4 - % " $% $ " $& $ & ! ## ! ( " $ ;$ $<#%( # (= & ! "( ! # ( ! ! ;# " ! <#! ''4 ! ! # <# ! &"' <# ;# !6 ! ! <#! # $ - 5 - !$ >!<# ! % 23? .00+.8/ .1+ 5@8+- 7A 3?+ .00+88.,3B 21021.3@2, C?.88+,D@,D 3?+ 8@.7@8@3A @, 3?+ C2**2, E9-D*+,3 -.3+- '' 0.//+- @, ! 2("' .,- ! 2&"'7A18+,@21 @F@8<9-D+: <!:! B @E.A.091. ' ?+ 71@+5 5.C3/ 8+.-@,D 32 5@8@,D 25 3?+ C8.@* 0+3@3@2,/ .1+ 3?.3 2, '4' .3 .7293 ($( 0* 3?+ -+C+./+-B1@/?.@8 .3?2- .,- -+C+./+-B1.F@,- .3?2- G+1+*2F@,D2,*2321CAC8+7+.1@,D 2B'BB44''.,- -+C+./+-B1@/?.@8G./1@-@,D3?+/.@-*2321CAC8+.,-G?+, 3?+A G+1+ 012C++-@,D 32G.1-/ 213@ 512* @E.A.091. .3 3?.3 3@*+ 79/ 7+.1@,D 2B'4"B'4' C.*+ 512* 2002/@3+ /@-+ @, . ?@D? /0++- .,- @, . 1./? .,- ,+D8@D+,3*.,,+1.,--./?+-323?+*2321CAC8+.,-./. 1+/983 723? 1@/?.@8 .,- 1.F@,- -@+- 2, 3?+ /023 ?+ 8+D.81+01+/+,3.3@F+/25723?-+C+./+-0+1/2,/?.F+5@8+- - 6 - C8.@* 0+3@3@2,/ ?+ 1@79,.8 .//+//+-3?+ C2*0+,/.3@2, .,- 0.//+- 3?+ .G.1- ?28-@,D 3?.3 .CC@-+,3 ?./ 7++, C.9/+--9+32/28+,+D8@D+,C+2,3?+0.13253?+-1@F+125 3?+ 79/ .,- /.--8+- 8@.7@8@3A 32 0.A 3?+ +,3@1+ C2*0+,/.3@2, 2, 3?+ .00+88.,3/B 21021.3@2, +@,D .DD1@+F+- 7A 3?+ /.*+ 3?+ .00+88.,3/B 21021.3@2, 5@8+- 3?+ .00+.8/ C?.88+,D@,D @3/ 8@.7@8@3A 32 0.A 3?+ +,3@1+ C2*0+,/.3@2, 2, 3?+ D129,- 3?.3 3?+ 1@-+1 25 3?+ *2321CAC8+.8/2C2,31@793+-323?+.CC@-+,3 ( +.1- 8+.1,+- C29,/+8 521 3?+ .00+88.,3/B 21021.3@2, .,- 8+.1,+- C29,/+8 521 1+/02,-+,3/B C8.@*.,3/ & +.1,+- C29,/+8 521 3?+ .00+88.,3/B 21021.3@2, G298- C2,3+,- 3?.3 3?+ .CC@-+,3 2CC911+- 2, 3?+ G12,D /@-+253?+12.-.,-3?+1+@/-.*.D+323?+8+53/@-+253?+ 79/ 3?.3 @3/+85 @,-@C.3+ 3?.3 3?+ .CC@-+,3 2CC911+- -9+ 32 ,+D8@D+,C+2,3?+0.13253?+1@-+1253?+*2321CAC8+.8/2 - 7 - +.1,+- C29,/+8 521 3?+ 1+/02,-+,3/BC8.@*.,3/ G298- C2,3+,- 3?.3 3?+ C?.1D+B/?++3 ?./ 7++, 5@8+- 2,8A .D.@,/33?+-1@F+1253?+79/3?.3@3/+85@,-@C.3+3?.3-9+32 3?+ ,+D8@D+,C+ 25 3?+ -1@F+1 25 3?+ 79/ 3?+ .CC@-+,3 2CC911+- .,- 3?+1+ @/ ,2 .,A C2,31@793@2, 2, 3?+ 0.13 25 3?+1@-+1253?+*2321CAC8+ % .F@,D ?+.1- 8+.1,+- C29,/+8/ 3?+ 2913 ?./ 0+19/+- 3?+ @*09D,+- E9-D*+,3 .,- 3?+ 1@.8 2913 +C21-/ H @/ 3?+ C+13@5@+- C20A 25 3?+ C?.1D+B/?++3 .,-@3@/5@8+-.D.@,/33?+-1@F+1253?+79/?+-+C+./+-B 1@-+1253?+*2321CAC8+?./,237++,.11.A+-./.CC9/+-@, 3?+C?.1D+B/?++3F+,3?+C20A25G?@C?@/.3H @/.8/21+D@/3+1+-.D.@,/33?+-1@F+1253?+79/?+-1@F+1 25 3?+ 79/ ?./ ,23 C?.88+,D+- 3?+ C?.1D+B/?++3 !+1+8A 7+C.9/+3?+-1@F+1253?+79/?./5@8+-.C2*08.@,3323?+ 3?+C20A25G?@C?@/.3H@3C.,,237+/.@-3?.3 3?+1+ @/ ,+D8@D+,C+ 2, 3?+ 0.13 25 3?+ 1@-+1 25 3?+ *2321CAC8+ .8/2 / 3?+ C?.1D+B/?++3 ?./ ,23 7++, - 8 - C?.88+,D+- 7A 3?+ -1@F+1 25 3?+ 79/ C2,/@-+1@,D 3?+ /.@- ./0+C33?+1@79,.8?./1@D?38A/.--8+-3?+8@.7@8@3A320.A 3?++,3@1+C2*0+,/.3@2,.*29,32,3?+ 21021.3@2, , F@+G 25 3?+ .72F+ 723? .00+.8/ .1+ -@/*@//+- ?+ .*29,3 @, -+02/@3 @5 .,A @/ 21-+1+- 32 7+ 31.,/*@33+-323?+C2,C+1,+-1@79,.8 +) ' & &( % # $ $( 3=I