Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43504 (KAR)
THE MANAGER v. RAMESH AND ANR
MFA/202787/2024 · 2025-10-14
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43504 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43504 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #
$!%!&!! !!&&
'() *
! "
#
$ #
%&
& ' # $ '
#&
()
%&
! "
#*!"
+" &&,#&&&
'
' -"
'
$ &&&%
&&,#&&&
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
' $
' (
'
$
. . / '
%
0+12340+15670839:1;7-;349<209 & 40 =>+<7+83 4+9 :<>02 340 =>+<7 ?03<3<;8 <8 ;&&,#&&&-0:;10340
22<3<;8+>08<;1<@<>'6250+82 ' ;613 <2+1 !:;1 94;13 A340 31<-68+>B" 900C<85 =;7?089+3<;8 ;: 9&# +>;85 D<34 <8301093 +3 340 1+30;:&E?01+8867;834051;68234+340703D<34+ 1;+231+::<=+==<2083;8&&+9+1096>3409693+<802 51<0@;69<8F61<094031<-68+>;8=;89<201+3<;8;:340083<10 0@<208=0;810=;12+D+1202+967;: 9,#+>;85 D<34 E <8301093 :1;7 340 2+30 ;: ?03<3<;8 3<>> 10+><G+3<;8 0<85 +551<0@02 -H 340 9+<2 ;1201 340 8961+8=0 =;7?+8H 4+9 ?10:01102 34<9 +??0+> ;8 340 51;682 ;: I6+8367 ;:
=;7?089+3<;8 +82 7+<8>H =;8308202 34+3 ?01=083+50 ;: ?017+80832<9+-<><3H;:3401<543>;D01><7-D+9+9909902-H
- 3 -
;=3;1 +9 ,E -63 340 31<-68+> D4<>0 3+C<85 #12 ;: <3 7083<;802 <3 +9 %E <8930+2 ;: &E 3; 340 D4;>0 -;2H 4010:;1010I60939:;17;2<:<=+3<;8;:340;1201
40 ?03<3<;801 703 D<34 +8 +==<2083 ;8 &&0D+9+502+-;63&H0+19+9;83402+30;: +==<2083+82D+92;<85>+-;61D;1C+8293+30234+340D+9 0+18<85 9# ?01 2+H -63 40 4+9 8;3 :<>02 +8H <8=;70 ?1;;:4031<-68+>4+93+C088;3<;8+><8=;70+3 9%# 9 40 703 D<34 340 +==<2083 ;8 && +9 ?01 340 56<20><809 ;: 340 +18+3+C+ 3+30 05+> 01@<=09 634;1<3H 340<8=;70;:340?03<3<;801:;1340H0+1&&<93;-03+C08 +3 9%&# <8930+2 ;: 9%# 8 ?0169+> ;: 340 10=;12 94;D9 34+3 $& +9909902 340 2<9+-<><3H+9 ,E 9?01J%+82#12;:<3=;7093;&E;340>;99;:
:63610 <8=;70 <9 9%&# K & K * K &E L 9%# 0 D+9 4;9?<3+><G02 :;1 2+H9 40 ?03<3<;8019693+<802340:;>>;D<85<8F61<09. !<" +<89D0>><85+82;?08:1+=3610;:1<543:0761M !<<" +<8+829D0>><85<81<543>05M
- 4 -
!<<<" -1+9<;8&K=7+821<543:1;83+>+10+M !<@" >DK=7;@011<5433;0
63;:340+:;109+<2<8F61<093D;+1051<0@;69<8F61<09 0 7<543 4+@0 8;3 +3308202 +8H ;3401 D;1C :;1 +-;63 :;61 7;834908=034<9;613:<829<310+9;8+->03;51+83>;99;: <8=;70 261<85 340 >+<2 6? ?01<;2 :;1 :;61 7;8349 <0 9%&# K % 7;8349 D4<=4 =;709 3; 9*# 40 +7;683 51+8302 68201 340 40+2 ;: +33082+83 =4+1509 <9 9# +82 340 +7;683 51+8302 68201 340 40+2 ;:
702<=+>0J?08909<0 9%*#+9?01340702<=+>-<>>9 D4<=4800298;<8301:0108=04<9;613:<829<310+9;8+->03;
+D+12 + 967 ;: 9# 68201 340 40+2 ;: ?+<8 +82 96::01<85 + 967 ;: 9# 3;D+129 >;99 ;: +708<3<09 +82 + 967 ;: 9# 3;D+129 31+89?;13+3<;8 0J31+ 8;61<947083 +82 +33082+83 =4+150 08=0 340 3;3+> =;7?089+3<;8+D+1202-H34<9;613<9+968201. !+ ,-./012,3/-453 1634
;99;::63610<8=;70 9%# & ;99;:<8=;70261<85>+<26? ?01<;2 9*#
02<=+>0J?08909 9%*# % +<8+8296::01<859 9#
;99;:+708<3<09 9#
- 5 -
1+89?;13+3<;8 0J31+ 8;61<947083 +82 +33082+83 =4+1509 9# * 33082+83=4+1509 9#
4-+ /778
% 08=0 <8 @<0D ;: 340 +-;@0 340 =;7?089+3<;8 +D+1202 -H 340 31<-68+> <8 + 967 ;: 9,# <9 1026=02 3; 9,,*# +>;85 D<34 <8301093 +3 340 1+30 ;: E<8301093:1;73402+30;:?03<3<;83<>>10+><G+3<;8
==;12<85>H340:;>>;D<85;1201.
!<" 40+??0+><9+>>;D02<8?+13M
!<<" 40 =;7?089+3<;8 +D+1202 -H 340 31<-68+> <8 + 967 ;: 9,# <9 1026=02 3; 9,,*#+>;85D<34<8301093+33401+30;:E <8301093:1;73402+30;:?03<3<;83<>>10+><G+3<;8M
!<<<" 40 +??0>>+83 8961+8=0 =;7?+8H <9 2<10=302 3; 20?;9<3 340 =;7?089+3<;8 +7;683 ;: 9,,*#+>;85D<34<8301093+33401+30;:E ?01+8867D<34<8;807;834:1;73402+30;:34<9 ;1201M
- 6 -
!<@" 09?;82083 ; <9 ?017<3302 3;
D<3421+D 340 083<10 +7;683 +>;85 D<34 <8301093 +==160234010;8
!.8 '&!! ) %
<93;.>;. . '