Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43501 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. SURESH S/O BABURAO BIRADAR SINCE DECEASED BY LRS 1(A) SHANTABAI W/O BABURAO AND ANR
MFA/203828/2024 · 2025-09-23
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43501 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43501 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$ % %
""
&%' (
! "! #
# $% $ # $ &' ($$
)
# $
& $
# $ &' ($$
)) Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
'+#')! * !,
)! * *
%! *
*
&
)))- & &
*
---#)-
*
* & (
*
*
&
$
$ . &
$ /012/ 3/45 "667"8 45 845379 :0; "9<45540= >43/ 3/7 ?0=57=30:87";=79?01=578:0;@03/5497543453"A7=16:0; :4="8945605"8
- 3 -
/45"667"845:4879@B"66788"=3'=51;"=?70<6"=B ?/"887=24=23/7C1"=31<0:?0<67=5"340=">";9794=3/7 D192<7=3 "=9 ">";9 9"379 )))- 6"5579 4=
0---#)-@B3/77=40;4E48&1927F&
*F
7<@7;
0:
/"8A4:0;5/0;3G3/7;4@1="8! ) /7@;47::"?3587"94=230:484=20:?8"4<6734340=
";7"51=97;$ /"33/7?8"4<"=3>"56;0?7794=20=/45<030;?B?87 @7";4=2 0'+#'H :;0< /"8A4 30 1=D4' 0= ) "3 "@013 +$ "< >/7= /7 ;7"?/79 =7";
4E7A"="=9 /0>A " <030;?B?87 @7";4=2 0'+#' ) >"5 ;4997= @B 435 ;497; 4= " ;"5/ "=9 =728427=3 <"==7;?"<7:;0<0660543794;7?340="=99"5/79"2"4=53 3/7<030;?B?870:3/7?8"4<"=31730>/4?/3/7?8"4<"=3 5153"4=79 57E7;7 4=D1;475 "=9 /7 300A 3;7"3<7=3 4= 05643"8 /7 ?8"4<"=3 :4879 ?8"4< 6734340= /7;4@1="8
"5575579 3/7 ?0<67=5"340= "=9 6"5579 3/7 4<612=79 D192<7=3 74=2 "22;47E79 @B 3/7 5"<7 3/7 "66788"=3' =51;"=?7 0<6"=B ?/"887=24=2 C1"=31< /"5 :4879 3/7
- 4 -
6;757=3 "667"8 1;4=2 3/7 67=97=?B 0: 3/45 "667"8 ;7560=97=3 0'?8"4<"=3 9479 0= H))- "=9 /45 872"8;76;757=3"34E7/"5@77=@;012/30=;7?0;9
7";9 87";=79 ?01=578 :0; 3/7
"66788"=3' =51;"=?7 0<6"=B "=9 87";=79 ?01=578 :0; ;7560=97=3
0"!'?8"4<"=3
- 7";=79 ?01=578 :0;
"66788"=3'=51;"=?7 0<6"=B >0189 ?0=37=9 3/"3
"5 3/7 ?8"4< :0; ?0<67=5"340=/"5@77=">";979:0;3/74=D1;B4=E47>0:
97"3/ 0: 3/7 4=D1;79 3/7 872"8 ;76;757=3"34E7 45 =03 7=34387930">";9"<01=3?0=37=94=23/"3?"1579479>43/ 3/767;50=7:1;3/7;?0=37=9793/"3>/7=3/7945"@4843B 4587553/"=I3/7;4@1="8/"57;;794=">";94=2:131;7 6;0567?35/70?30;/"553"379945"@4843B"3)HI303/7 >/087@09B"=9/745=03"3;7"37990?30;"=93/7;4@1="8 /"5 7;;79 4= 3"A4=2 3/7 945"@4843B "3 I /7 ?0<67=5"340= ">";979 :0; 6"4= "=9 51::7;4=2, :131;7 <794?"8 7J67=575, 8055 0: "<7=43475 ";7 0= /42/7; 5497
- 5 -
7=?7577A5:0;;791?4=23/75"<743/3/757/76;"B79 30"880>3/7"667"8
7";=79 ?01=578 :0; ;7560=97=3
0"!' ?8"4<"=3>0189?0=37=93/"33/7?8"4<"=3>"5"84E7"50= 3/79"370:3/7D192<7=36"5579@B3/7;4@1="8/7872"8 /74; 45 7=343879 0=8B 30 51?/ ?0<67=5"340= >/4?/ :0;<5 6";3 0: 3/7 753"37 0: 3/7 97?7"579 = 3/"3 /7 68"?75 ;784"=?70=3/797?4540=0:3/70=.@8767J01;34=3/7 ?"57 0:
! ;760;3794="#""$% &'& 7:1;3/7;51@<4353/"33/7?0<67=5"340=">";979@B3/7 ;4@1="80="8803/7;/7"9545D153"=96;067;43/3/757 /76;"B7930945<4553/7"667"8
H
"E4=2 /7";9 87";=79 ?01=5785 3/45 01;3 /"5 67;1579 3/7 4<612=79 D192<7=3 "=9 03/7; <"37;4"85 68"?790=;7?0;9
- 6 -
% /7 9"37 0: "??497=3 45 ) /7 ;4@1="8 6"5579 3/7 4<612=79 D192<7=3 "=9 ">";9 0= )))- "=9 3/7 =51;"=?7 0<6"=B /"5 :4879 3/7 6;757=3 "667"8 0= )))- /7 ?8"4<"=3 47 ;7560=97=3 0 9479 0= H))- /7 ?8"4<"=3 9479
":37;6"554=20:3/7D192<7=3@B3/7;4@1="8"=9@7:0;7 :484=20:3/7"667"8@B3/7=51;"=?70<6"=B50=3/7 9"370:D192<7=30:3/7;4@1="83/7?8"4<"=3>"5"84E7 /7 ">";9 "<01=3 45 "??;7340= 30 3/7 753"37 0: 3/7 ?8"4<"=3
/70=.@8767J01;34=3/7?"570:
516;"! /"5 0@57;E79 "3 6";"2;"6/ 05 30"=9+3/15$
! " #
$
%
$
- 7 -
& $
$
%
$
'
!
(
! #
! ! ! )
! ! * % "
$
! $
! ! - 8 -
+
+$
$
$
$
,
%
+ $
+
- % . /
0- % $ *12
3# 4
+
5
! ! % 6' $ ! $
#
'
!$
$ +
1 %
$ 7
8 9
'
$#7 $
- 9 -
! '
+
! #
7
9! +
5
! : (
! '
! 4
' ' &
'
$
)
+
7 # ;! - 10 -
9
# ,
!$
5
0
(
7 .9
7$
. . &
7 <
. = $ 1-2 1 ;4> ?**$
:
-@#
A / #
4
;
B
7 #
7
) 8
. ' 6
B
7 9
! ># $
+
5
0- %
3
%
! $
- 11 -
! $
$
+
"
$
A /
#( $
! (
>$
5
? ' &! C >
># 7 9
#
$%9 *2 &C> 1 . > #
6 . &
$ ** #7 2 . 2 '8
"
8
- 12 -
;! > #
$
*)
! ' >#
+
$
$ $
$ A , $
+
!$ ( 5
+ = E47> 0: 3/7 "@0E7 97?4540= 0: 3/7 0=.@87 67J 01;3 3/7 872"8 ;76;757=3"34E7 0: 3/7 ?8"4<"=3 47 ;7560=97=3 0"!
45 7=343879 30 ?0<67=5"340= "<01=3 7J?76330>";956"4="=951::7;4=2
/7"??497=3/"53"A7=68"?74=3/7B7";)
"=9 "5 67; ?/";3 =0340="8 4=?0<7 45 5%#' "=9 3/7 ;4@1="8 /"5 3"A7= 3/7 5"49 4=?0<7 "=9 "850 "668479 <18346847;"5GK"53/7"270:3/7?8"4<"=3>"5)-B7";5
"50=3/79"370:3/7"??497=3/70?30;>/07J"<4=79
- 13 -
3/7 4=D1;79 ) /"5 455179 J'945"@4843B ?7;34:4?"37 53"34=23/"33/7?8"4<"=3/"55153"4=79)HI0:945"@4843B30 3/7 >/087 @09B E7= 3/012/ ) 45 =03 3/7 3;7"379 90?30; 3/7 ;4@1="8 /"5 7;;79 4= 3"A4=2 3/7 945"@4843B "3 I/7?8"4<"=3/"55153"4=79:;"?31;70:;42/3:7<1;
0=5497;4=2 3/7 J'945"@4843B ?7;34:4?"37 455179 @B )'0?30; 945"@4843B 30 @7 3"A7= "5 I "5 "2"4=53 I3"A7=@B3/7;4@1="8/7;4@1="8/"53"A7=:131;7 6;0567?35 5 945"@4843B 45 8755 3/"= I 3/7 :131;7 6;0567?35 ";7 =03 ;7C14;79 30 @7 3"A7= = E47> 0: 3/7
"@0E73/7?8"4<"=3457=3438793080550::131;74=?0<7"5 1=97;$ 5%#'J)JJIL)*+,,-
/7 ;4@1="8 /"5 ;42/38B 3"A7= 3/7 <794?"8 7J67=575 "5 5H-#' /7 ;4@1="8 /"5 ">";979 :131;7 <794?"8 7J67=575 0: 5#' 0= 3/7 2;01=9 3/"34<68"=35";7:4J79"=9:0;;7<0E"80:3/75"<7:131;7 <794?"8 7J67=575 ";7 ;7C14;79 30 @7 ">";979 /7 5"49 :131;7 <794?"8 7J67=575 ">";979 ";7 0= /42/7; 5497"=9
- 14 -
;7"50="@87 7J67=575 :0; ;7<0E"@87 0: 4<68"=35 >0189 @7 )-/7;7:0;73/7?8"4<"=3457=34387930:131;7 <794?"87J67=5750:)-
) 17 30 3/7 4=D1;475 5153"4=793/7 ?8"4<"=3 >"5
"9<43379 4= 05643"8 :0; 54J 9"B5 "=9 /7 >"5 "9E4579 :0; ;7530=5497;4=23/75"<73/7?8"4<"=3457=343879:0;8055 0:4=?0<791;4=28"491667;409:0;3/;77<0=3/54="51< 0: ) *- 5%#' J ! "5 "2"4=53 5-#'
"5">";979@B3/7;4@1="8
/7;4@1="8/"5">";97980550:"<7=434754=" 51<0:5#'43450=/42/7;5497"=93/7?8"4<"=3 457=3438793080550:"<7=434754="51<0:)-
- 6";3 :0;< 8055 0: "<7=43475 3/7 ;4@1="8 /"5
">";979
" 51< 0: 5#' 30>";95 8055 0: 7J67?3"340=0:84:7"=947=0330@7">";979576";"378B"5 80550:"<7=4347545">";979
- 15 -
/7 ?8"4<"=3 >"5 "9<43379 4= 05643"8 :0; 54J 9"B5 3/7;7:0;7 /7 45 7=343879 30 ?0<67=5"340= 30>";95 ?0=E7B"=?7"=9"337=9"=3?/";275:00994734="51<0: ),-
H = E47> 0: 97"3/ 0: 3/7 ?8"4<"=3 3/7;7 45 =0 =77930">";9?0<67=5"340=:0;6"4="=951::7;4=2>/4?/ /"5 @77= ">";979 @B 3/7 ;4@1="8 4= " 51< 0: 5#'
% =E47>0:3/7"@0E73/7?8"4<"=3457=34387930 303"8?0<67=5"340="51=97;$ . /01) 2345 06071/1895:/ 7;8340. 2345 06071/189 5:;)375
0550::131;74=?0<7 5H-+-#' 5+HH#' ) 794?"87J67=575 '''' 5H-#'
0550:4=?0<791;4=2 8"491667;409 '''' 5)#' - *131;7<794?"87J67=575 5#' 5#'
0550:"<7=43475 5#' 5#' H 337=9"=3"=9 ?0=E7B"=?7?/";275 73? 5+-+#' 5H#' %
"4="=951::7;4=2 5#' ''''
0550:7J67?3"340=0:84:7 5#' ''''
50. )*+- )
*+
- /13<5;4 )+
*+-
- 16 -
=3/7;751833/7"667"89757;E7530@7"880>79 4='6";37=?73/7:0880>4=2$
4! /7"667"845"880>794='6";3
44! /7D192<7=3"=9">";99"379)))- 6"55794= 0---#)-@B3/77=40;
4E48 &1927 F &
* F
7<@7; 0: /"8A445<094:479"51=97;$
"!
/7 ?8"4<"=3 45 7=343879 30 303"8 ?0<67=5"340= 0: )
*+
-
"2"4=535-+#'"5">";979@B 3/7;4@1="8"80=2>43/4=37;753"33/7 ;"37 0: HI 6" :;0< 3/7 9"37 0: 6734340=3488;7"84M"340= @! /7=51;"=?70<6"=B4594;7?37930 9760543 3/7 5"49 ">";9 "<01=3 "80=2 >43/ 4=37;753 4: 43 45 =03 "8;7"9B 976054379, 4: "=B 7J?755 "<01=3 45
- 17 -
976054379 3/7 =51;"=?7 0<6"=B 45 7=34387930;7:1=90:3/75"<7
?! /7 7=34;7 ">";9 "<01=3 "80=2 >43/ 4=37;753 45 0;97;79 30 @7 ;787"579 4= :"E01;0:;7560=97=3 0"!'?8"4<"=3 47 872"8 ;76;757=3"34E7 0: ?8"4<"=3' 1;75/5#0"@1;"04;"9";":37;917 497=34:4?"340=#E7;4:4?"340=
9! /7 "<01=3 4= 9760543 4: "=B 45 0;97;79 30 @7 3;"=5<43379 30 3/7 ?0=?7;=79;4@1="8
1- & % %' $
$ $) 3,A