Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43500 (KAR)

SURYAKANT AND ANR v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/200320/2025 · 2025-09-23

Jyoti Mulimani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $" % %!"" &' ( ! " # $ %%&!'!() %%&!'!() %% &!'!() ( %% & &!'!() Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! % %%% %% &!'!() &!'!() " # $ % * % % % % +, -./0./1.2345678294-1:8;81.1.468-/6<-./2:/- /4 /246= >.1: -./22.?/-@56 /:5?/- 94- 1:8 -87;46<8617:/08/;;8/-8<.6;8-746 :83/;1.468<-.181.1.46.79.28<788?.6=94224>.6= -82.897 /$ 4.7758/-.1498-1.4-/-.4-<.-831.4614A5/7: 1:8 4-<8- </18< ))*)( ;/778< BC 1:8 9.-71 -87;46<861.6%.28 4&))(&!0.<8 668D5-8& /6< 1:8 4-<8- </18< )!)( ;/778< BC 1:8 78346< -87;46<861 .6 %.28 - 3 - 4&))(&!*E&' 0.<8 668D5-8&/7.228=/2/6</-B.1-/-C B$ 7758/-.149/6</F57<.-831.6=-87;46<8617 1414899831F51/1.46861-.87.61:86/F8491:8 ;81.1.468-7 B/78< 46 1:8 +, %4-F .7758< BC 1:8 /6< -/61 4FF.1188 </18< )!))! /6< !)!))!0.<8668D5-87&/6< :8;81.1.46/08-F8617/-8/756<8- 1.77/.<1:/11:8;81.1.468-7/-81:8/B7425184>68-749 2/6< B8/-.6= C 4'( F8/75-.6= )( 3-87 ' 561/7 49 :/F7:/6/=/- .22/=8 /25? /6< .71-.31 .</- :8C >8-8 .7758< >.1: +, %4-F /=50/2. :.1 .6 %.28 4& *)))!&) </18< )!))! /6< .6 %.28 4& !E))!&) </18< !)!))! /6< -834=6.G.6= 56/51:4-.G8< 3521.0/1.46.6-87;83149408-6F8612/6<1.771/18<1:/11:8 2/6<.6C 4'(>/74-.=.6/22CF8/75-.6=3-87)561/7 >/7 /-/F;4? 408-6F861 /6< /6< 1:8 ;81.1.468-7 >8-8 56/51:4-.G8< 3521.0/14-7 /6< B/78< 46 1:8 /;;2.3/1.46 F/<8 1:8 /25?/ /6< -/61 4FF.1188 >/7 ;28/78< 14 346<531 75-08C .<861.9C.6= 1:8 ;4-1.46 49 2/6< .6 C 4'( 56<8- 1:8 - 4 - 3521.0/1.46491:8;81.1.468-7BC<-/>.6=;/63:/6/F/>:8-8BC 1:8;4-1.46492/6<.6C 4'(.6;477877.46/6<3521.0/1.4649 1:8;81.1.468-7>/7<52C.<861.9.8<.69/04-491:8;81.1.468-714 /68D186149)(3-87'561/7 5-75/61 14 38-1.9.3/18 49 -8=.71-/1.46 1:8 ;81.1.468-7 F/<8/;;2.3/1.46141:8/:7.2</-14.634-;4-/181:8.-6/F87.6 1:8 B/78<46>:.3:/683877/-C-8;4-1>/73/228<94-1:8 7.D1: -87;46<861 14 .<861.9C 1:8 2/6< .6 3521.0/1.46 49 1:8 ;81.1.468-7:87.D1:-87;46<86175BF.118</<81/.28<-8;4-146 E)')E >.1: / 34;C 49 ;/63:/6/F/ 38-1.9C.6= 1:8 9/31 -8=/-<.6=1:8;477877.46/6<3521.0/1.46491:8;81.1.468-7/6< -834FF86<.6=94-899831.6=-808658861-.87.61:8.-6/F8:8 7.D1: -87;46<861 .6 .17 -8;4-1 -898--8< 14 861-.87 .6 425F6 4491:8 -898--.6=141:8861-.87.61:86/F849%4-871 8;/-1F861/6<1:8-894-81:8/:7.2</-/918-.775.6=641.3814 1:89.91:-87;46<861;/778</64-<8-46)))(-8@831.6= 1:8/;;2.3/1.46491:8;81.1.468-7==-.808<BC1:87/.<4-<8- 1:8 ;81.1.468-7 /;;-4/3:8< 1:8 77.71/61 4FF.77.468- :8 ;-4388<.6=7 >8-8 <52C 34618718< BC 1:8 9.91: -87;46<861 /51:4-.1C 32/.F.6= 1:/1 1:8 75B@831 2/6< .7 / 41.9.8< %4-871 - 5 - /6<0.<8 4</18<)EEE!.7758<56<8-831.46 E49C<8-/B/<%4-87131!!%/72.>:.3:>/7;5B2.7:8<.6 1:8499.3./2/G8118</18<*E!!/6<1:8-894-8745=:114 346186<1:/1+,%4-F.7758<.69/04-491:8;81.1.468-7BC1:8 /:7.2</-.7>.1:451@5-.7<.31.46/6<745=:194-<.7F.77/2491:8 /;;8/2 :8 77.71/61 4FF.77.468- B/78<46 1:8 3461861.467 -/.78<BC1:89.91:-87;46<861>.1:451/;;-83./1.6=1:8-834-<7 ;8-1/.6.6= 14 1:8 75B@831 2/6< 3/638228< 1:8 =-/61 F/<8 .6 9/04-491:8;81.1.468-70.<834FF464-<8-</18<)!)( 7/=/.6711:87/.<4-<8-1:8;81.1.468-79.28<-80.7.46;81.1.46 B894-8 1:8 8;51C 4FF.77.468- :8 8;51C 4FF.77.468- 0.<8 4-<8- </18< ))*)( -8@8318< 1:8 80.7.46 81.1.46 6<8- 1:878 3.-35F71/6387 1:8 ;81.1.468-7 /-8 B894-8 1:.7 45-1 ( 456782 94- 1:8 -87;831.08 ;/-1.87 5-=8< 7808-/2 3461861.467 -=.6= 7808-/2 3461861.467 3456782 94- 1:8 ;81.1.468- ;2/38<-82./638461:8<83.7.46.6 .6 4)))E) <.7;478< 4946()) - 6 - :8 71/18F861 49 4B@831.467 .7 9.28< BC 1:8 408-6F861 -=.6=7808-/23461861.4671:8408-6F861;2/38<-82./63846 1:894224>.6=<83.7.467 $ % H *)E&*)EE $ % H #$ *EE % EE $ % H)! *!( 8/-< 1:8 /-=5F8617 /6< ;8-578< 1:8 -.1 ;/;8-7 >.1: 3/-8 ! :8 9/317 /-8 7599.3.8612C 7/.< /6< <4 641 -8A5.-8 -8.18-/1.46:8.7758-8042087/-456<1:88D8-3.78491:8;4>8- BC 1:8 77.71/61 4FF.77.468- 56<8- 1:8 ;-40.7.467 49 1:8 /-6/1/?//6<80865831E(599.38.11464181:/11:8 2/6< .6 C 4'( F8/75-.6= 3-87 ) 561/7 7.15/18< /1 :/F7:/6/=/- .22/=8 >/7 / 408-6F861 /-/F;:4? /6< /6< 1:8 7/F8 >/7 56<8- 3521.0/1.46 49 56/51:4-.G8< ;8-7467 - 7 - 6<8- / 41.9.3/1.46 4 E </18< E)EE 1:8 /:/7.2</-.7758</8-1.9.3/1849/=50/2.:.1.69/04-491:8 ;81.1.468-7 :8408-6F861:/79.28<4B@831.46/6<95-6.7:8</1-58 34;C 49 1:8 <435F861 /1 668D5-8& 14 346186< 1:/1 1:8 75B@831 2/6< .7 / 94-871 2/6< 8-578< 1:8 7/F8 >.1: 51F471 3/-861:87/.<<435F8611:894-871B243?49:/F7:88-6/=/- 7.15/18< .6 /6=8 .</- /25A/ .</- .71-.31 .</- .0.7.46 .</- 3467.71.6= 49 141/2 /-8/ 49 ( 3-87 E 561/7 /6< .6325<.6= 1:8 0.22/=87 49 :/F7:88-6/=/- >/7 <832/-8< /7 / ;-418318< 94-871 1:-45=: 5-/2 834671-531.46 8;/-1F861 41.9.3/1.46 4</18<)EE!!.7758<56<8-831.46E 491:8C<8-/B/<%4-87131!!%#49!!%$;5B2.7:8< .61:8499.3./2/G8118 4""D""</18<*E!!-8/<.6= 49668D5-8&7:4>71:/11:80.22/=8749:/F7:88-6/=/->/7 <832/-8</7/-418318<%4-871 1.7;.041/21464181:/11:875B@8312/6<>/74-.=.6/22C/ /-/F;:4? 408-6F861 2/6< /6< 1:8 /25?/ /6< -/61 4FF.1188:/<<.-8318<1:8/25?/5-08C4-14346<53175-08C 491:82/6<918-1:875-08C/6<<-/>.6=491:8;/63:/6/F/.1 - 8 - >/7.<861.9.8<1:/11:8;81.1.468-7>8-8.63521.0/1.46491:82/6< 14 /6 8D1861 49 )( 3-87 ' 561/7 /7 .7 80.<861 9-4F 1:8 ;-4388<.6=7 </18< ))EE( %5-1:8-F4-8 / -834FF86</1.46>/7F/<8148618-1:86/F8491:8;81.1.468-7 .6 1:8 7.638 1:8C >8-8 3521.0/1.6= 1:8 2/6< 4>808- >.1:4511/?.6=.6143467.<8-/1.46491:8-8280/61F/18-./271:8 77.71/614FF.77.468-6522.9.8<1:8%4-F 81 F8 3467.<8- >:81:8- 1:8 77.71/61 4FF.77.468-3452<:/086522.9.8<1:8%4-F/918-/2/;7849 /2F4716.681886C8/-7:8/67>8-.764:8-8/746.77.F;28 :82/>.7>822781128<1:/11:8;4>8-F571B88D8-3.78<>.1:.6 /-8/746/B281.F861:8;-878613/781:8-8.7/6.64-<.6/18 <82/C 6 FC 0.8> 1:8 ;-4388<.6=7 /-8 328/-2C B/--8< BC 2/3:87%5-1:8-F4-81:8408-6F8613452<641:/088D8-3.78< ;4>8- 14 3/6382 1:8 =-/617 46 1:8 =-456< 1:/1 1:8-8 .7 / 0.42/1.4649528)'&491:8 /-6/1/?//6<8086585287 45678294-1:8-87;831.08;/-1.87;2/38<-82./638461:8 <83.7.467 -898--8< 14 75;-/ <4 641 1:.6? 1:/1 1:8 2/> .7 .6 <45B1/3:<83.7.4615-6746.174>69/317:8;-878613/78.7 /27418718<.61:82.=:1491:8/94-87/.<<83.7.467 - 9 - %4-1:8-8/746771/18</B4081:84-<8-491:877.71/61 4FF.77.468- /6< 1:8 8;51C 4FF.77.468- /-8 2./B28 14 B8 781/7.<8334-<.6=2C.1.7781/7.<8 * :8 -.1 49 8-1.4-/-. .7 4-<8-8< :8 -<8- </18< 4-<8-</18<)!)(;/778<BC1:877.71/614FF.77.468- %.28 4&))(&!*E&' 0.<8 668D5-8& /6< 1:8 4-<8- </18< ))*)( ;/778< BC 1:8 8;51C 4FF.77.468- .6 %.28 4&))(&! 0.<8 668D5-8&/-8A5/7:8< ' 87521/612C1:8-.181.1.46.7 83/578 49 1:8 <.7;47/2 49 1:8 -.1 81.1.46 ;86<.6= .618-243514-C /;;2.3/1.467 .9 /6C /-8 <.7;478< 49 /6< 1:8 .618-.F<.-831.46.9/6C71/6<7<.73:/-=8< )' &%!""( % .71 42 4'