- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " # $ %&'''($ ! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) **% %$)$)$ %(+($') ! " * ), $%" )'$)')& # ** $-!$#*" * " " -$&)'$- '$'&)'$ * * " . $ $ /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 ) 4=90>>/0?=9;=?/2<@34/A?0=7083050=89334/ B6257/83 082 0C012 203/2 '$'&)'$ >099/2 <@ 34/ 22=3=:80?/8=:1=D=?625/0820?0<6105=E;:1 94:13 F1=<680?GH =8 " :-$&)'$& 9//I=85 /8408A/7/83:;A:7>/8903=:8 - 3 - 4/ ;0A39 :; 34/ A09/ 01/ 3403 :8 $-$')'$J C4/834/A?0=7083C09>1:A//2=85=807:3:1A@A?/</01=85 1/5=93103=:8 :%) %(+-7/3C=34080AA=2/8326/3: 1094 082 8/5?=5/83 21=D=85 <@ 34/ 21=D/1 :; 01 </01=85 :%')%'($+ C4=A4 A07/ ;1:7 :>>:9=3/ 2=1/A3=:8 =8 4=54 9>//2 1/96?3=85 =8 =8B61=/9 3: 34/ A?0=7083 *:1 C4=A4 4/ C09 31/03/2 09 =8>03=/83 =8 34/ 4:9>=30? ;:1 9/D/10?20@9082682/15:8/9615/1=/9/8A/4/;=?/20 A?0=7 >/3=3=:8 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? A?0=7=85 A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9$+))J''%A:83/82=8534034/C0905/2J@/019 03 34/ 3=7/ :; 0AA=2/83 C:1I=85 09 0<:61 082 /018=85 9$)'''% >/1 7:834 4/ 1=<680? A:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ 703/1=0? 0D0=?0<?/ :8 1/A:12 0C012/2 0 967 :; 9(')''%C=34=83/1/93 03 34/103/:; JK >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=L03=:8 082 2=1/A3/2 1/9>:82/83 :) % 896108A/ :7>08@ 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ A:7>/8903=:807:6830?:85C=34=83/1/93 & 551=/D/2<@34/90=2B6257/83:;34/1=<680? 34/=8B61/2%A?0=7083409>1/;/11/234=90>>/0?=8C4=A4=3 - 4 - =9A:83/82/2340334:6544/C09/018=85 9$)'''%>/1 7:834 <63 34/ 1=<680? 409 /11/2 =8 A:89=2/1=85 34/ =8A:7/09 9-(''%>/17:8343=9;6134/1A:83/82/2 340334/1=<680?4098:30C012/208@07:683;:1;6361/ 7/2=A0? /M>/89/9 082 C403/D/1 0C012/2 ;:1 >0=8 082 96;;/1=85082?:99:;07/8=3=/9=9:834/?:C/19=2/3469 1/N6/93/2;:1/8408A/7/83:;A:7>/8903=:8 ( 8 96>>:13 :; 4=9 A?0=7 4/ 5:3 /M07=8/2 3C: :A3:19 09 9) 082 ) 099/99/2 34/ C4:?/ <:2@ 2=90<=?=3@03'K082099/99/203)$K J 9 >/1 34/ /D=2/8A/ :; 34/ A?0=7083 409 96930=8/2;10A361/:;8090?<:8/ 3:1=543082A41:8=A 14=8=3=9 7=?2 <=?03/10? 70M=??01@ 082 9>4/8:=2 9=869=3=9 682=9>?0A/2;10A361/:;?/;38090?<:8/082;10A361/:;3=> :;1=5438090?<:8/C=343=8@;1057/839=89:;33=996/082 /D=2/8A/:;:?2;10A361/:;2=930?/82:;?/;3102=69082:?2 ;10A361/:;93@?:=2>1:A/99:;?/;36?808 MJ%:682 /13=;=A03/34/05/:;A?0=7083=994:C809J@/019 =996/2 M$)=8C4=A4=3=99303/2340334/1/=93106703: - 5 - 34/ ;0A/ ?/02=85 ;10A361/ :; 8090? <:8/ A069=85 8090? :<9316A3=:8 A:7>?/3/ ?:99 :; 9/8903=:8 :; 97/?? 082 /M3/180? 2/;:17=3@ :; 8:9/ / 0?9: 9303/2 3403 34/1/ =9 682=9>?0A/2;10A361/:;?/;38090?<:8/082;10A361/:;3=> :;1=5438090?<:8/C=343=8@;1057/839=89:;33=996/ =996/2 M$)O=90<=?=3@/13=;=A03/=8C4=A4=3=99303/2 )K2=90<=?=3@3:?/;36>>/1?=7<A069=85>0=80822=;;=A6?3@ 3: ?=;3 C/=5439 082 C:1I 082 1/931=A3=:8 :; ?/;3 C1=3 7:D/7/839 4/8A/ 099/99/2 2=90<=?=3@ 03 )$K 3: 34/ C4:?/ <:2@ 4/1/;:1/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 30I/)(K09;68A3=:80?2=90<=?=3@ - 4:654 34/ A?0=7083 9303/2 3403 4/ C09 /018=85 9$)'''% >/1 7:834 <63 8:3 >1:26A/2 08@ 2:A67/83 3: >1:D/ 34/ 907/ 9 34/ 0AA=2/83 =9 :; 34/ @/01)'$J09>/134/A4013=996/2<@34/018030I0303/ /50? /1D=A/9 634:1=3@ 34=9 :613 2//79 =3 0>>1:>1=03/ 3:1/099/9934/ =8A:7/ :; 34/ A?0=7083 03 9+-('% >/1 7:834334/3=7/:;0AA=2/8334/A?0=7083C0905/2J @/019 082 0>>1:>1=03/ 76?3=>?=/1 0>>?=A0<?/ 3: 4=9 05/ - 6 - 51:6>=9F$(GAA:12=85?@34/A?0=7083=9/83=3?/2;:1?:99 :;;6361//018=8509682/1 9+-('%M$)M$(M)(KP 9-('% + 4/ A?0=7083 C09 31/03/2 09 =8>03=/83 ;:1 9/D/10?20@9682/1C/839615/1=/90820?9:3::I;:??:C6> 31/037/83 4/1/;:1/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 510830807:683:; 9-('''%;:1>0=808296;;/1=85082 9&''''% ;:1 31089>:1303=:8 /M310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083A4015/94/0>>/??0837=5438:340D/033/82/2 08@C:1I03?/093;:1341//7:83494/8A/4/=9/83=3?/2;:1 9('''% ;:1 ?:99 :; =8A:7/ 261=85 ?0=2 6> >/1=:2 :C/D/1 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9$$))''% 0C012/2<@ 34/1=<680?;:17/2=A0?/M>/89/9082 9&''''%;:1?:99 :;07/8=3=/98//298:=83/1;/1/8A/ 4/ A:7>/8903=:8 0C012/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? =9 7:2=;=/209682/1 - 7 - ? : /029 C012<@34/ 1=<680? C012<@34=9 :613 $ 0=8 082 96;;/1=85 9(''''% 9-('''% ) /2=A0? M>/89/9 9$$))''% 9$$))''% :99 :; ;6361/ /018=85A0>0A=3@ 9)-''''% 9-('% & 1089>:1303=:8 /M310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083 A4015/9 9$&(''% 9&''''% ( :99 :; 07/8=3=/9 9&''''% 9&''''% J :99 :; =8A:7/ 261=85 ?0=2 6> >/1=:2 9))(''% 9('''% :30? 9(')''% 9J(('% 4/1/C=??<//8408A/7/83:; 9$+J-('% $' 834/1/96?334/;:??:C=85:12/1=9>099/2 !=# >>/0?=90??:C/2=8>013 - 8 - !==# 4/ A?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 34/ /8408A/2 A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9$+J-('% C=34 =83/1/93 03 JK >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:83=??34/203/:;1/0?=L03=:8 !===# /9>:82/83 :) O 896108A/ :7>08@ =9 2=1/A3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ 0;:1/90=2 A:7>/8903=:807:6830?:85C=34=83/1/93C=34=8 :8/7:834;1:734/203/:;34=9B6257/83 !=D# 8 96A4 2/>:9=3 34/ A?0=7083 =9 >/17=33/23:C=34210C34//83=1/07:6830?:85 C=34=83/1/930AA16/2:8=3 *+, &% ( $ =93 :$? :&)