- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $ %$& '()*+$'' , ! " " " # $ % && ' " ( " " &!! ) " # $ %& '&( && ! *# '(!&'(+! '(& & ! , $+ $ $ & ! & ! " $--$ $$ , & ! !! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & # ! & & ! !! & # ! & , && ! ! . #! '&. ( /0 122033145 60748 5/0 9:;23174145 74 :$--$ $$:45/0<730:<5/0301=40>&=74972137?73 @>80 14> ! "1316@=187 7A 7;2@84748 5/0 B@>8;045 >150>$+ $ $>7A;7AA7485/09:;23174514>19C@755748 5/0 =0A2:4>045199@A0> <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 # :< 5/0 08:571630 4A5=@;045A 95 '<:= A/:=5 D 95E( $ /091A0:<5/09:;23174145746=70<7A5/155/0 199@A0>607481:?0=4;045A0=?145F:=G748745/0&:A5 <<790 =0C@0A50> 5/0 9:;23174145 <:= /14> 3:14 :< A /0 199@A0> 1AA@=0> 5: =021H 5/0 A1;0 F75/74 $ ;:45/A 99:=>7483H 5/0 9:;23174145 /1> 3045 - 3 - A 5: 5/0 199@A0> /04 5/0 9:;23174145 74A7A50> <:= =021H;045 :< 5/0 3:14 1;:@45 5/0 199@A0> 7AA@0> 5/0 9/0C@0 1A 20= I& :4 - $$ $$ <:= A /04 5/0 9/0C@0 F1A 2=0A0450> <:= 0491A/;045 5/0 A1;0 F1A >7A/:4:@=0> 1A 5/0=0 F1A 74A@<<797045 <@4> 74 5/0 199:@45 :< 5/0 199@A0> 0813 4:5790 F1A 7AA@0> 6H 5/0 9:;23174145 5: 5/0 199@A0> 74<:=;74816:@5>7A/:4:@=:<5/09/0C@014>9133748@2:4 /7; 5: =021H 5/0 9/0C@0 1;:@45 4A2750 :< A0=?790 :< 4:57905/0199@A0>/1A4:5=0217>5/09/0C@01;:@4514> 5/0=06H 9:;;7550> 5/0:<<0490 2@47A/1630@4>0= 0957:4 #:<5/0 95 99:=>7483H5/09:;23174145<730>5/0 2=7?150 9:;231745 74 &:$#$ $$ 14> =0C@0A50> 5/0 =713 :@=5 5: 51G0 9:847J1490 14> 74757150 30813 1957:4 18174A55/0199@A0> /0 =713 :@=5 5::G 9:847J1490 :< 5/0 :<<0490 14>=087A50=0>:$--$ $$/0199@A0>12201=0> 60<:=0 5/0 =713 :@=5 2301>0> 4:5 8@735H 14> 9317;0> 5: 60 5=70> /0 9:;23174145 0I1;740> /0=A03< 1A & 14> - 4 - 8:5;1=G0>IA&5:&-74A@22:=5:</0=9:450457:4/0 199@A0>>0470>1335/0749=7;7415748;150=713A1?1731630:4 =09:=>14>0I1;740>/7;A03<1A /0 =713 :@=5 1<50= 51G748 745: 9:4A7>0=157:4 1335/0A0;150=713A:4=09:=>91;05:5/09:493@A7:45/15 5/09:;23174145/1A4:52=:?0>5/0304>748:<5/01;:@45 14> 0I7A50490 :< 308133H 04<:=901630 >065 99:=>7483H 21AA0> 5/0 7;2@840> B@>8;045 19C@755748 5/0 199@A0> 0748 188=70?0> 6H 5/0 A1;0 5/0 9:;23174145 7A 60<:=0 5/7A:@=5 01=> =7 145:A/ "@;1= 1=1>7 301=40> 9:@4A03<:=5/01220331450A2:4>0455/:@8/A0=?0>F75/ 5/0 4:5790 /1A =0;1740> @4=02=0A0450> &0=@A0> 5/0 ;150=713A:4=09:=> - 4?70F:<5/0A@6;7AA7:4A;1>06H5/0301=40> 9:@4A03<:=5/01220331455/02:7455/15F:@3>1=7A0<:=;H 9:4A7>0=157:47A - 5 - H 14AF0= 5:5/0 16:?0 2:745 7A 745/0 . <<7=;157?0E <:=5/0<:33:F748 * 57A5/09:450457:4:<5/09:;231741455/155/0 199@A0>607485/0:?0=4;045A0=?145F:=G748745/0&:A5 <<790 /1A 1?1730> 1 3:14 :< A :F1=>A =021H;045:<5/0A1;0/0/1>7AA@0>5/09/0C@0I& /04 5/0 9/0C@0 F1A 2=0A0450> <:= 0491A/;045 5/0 A1;0 F1A >7A/:4:@=0> 1A 5/0=0 F1A 74A@<<797045 <@4> 74 5/0199:@45:<5/0199@A0>?045/:@8/308134:5790F1A 7AA@0>5:5/0199@A0>5/0A1;0F1A=05@=40>@4A0=?0>1A D1>>=0AA00 4:5 <:@4>E :F0?0= 199@A0> /1A 4:5 =0217> 5/0 1;:@45 14> 5/0=06H /0 /1A 9:;;7550> 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630@4>0=0957:4#:<5/0 95 - 6 - # : 2=:?0 /0= 9:450457:4 5/0 9:;23174145 0I1;740> /0=A03< 1A & 14> =0750=150> /0= 9:450457:4A 1A 51G04 74 5/0 9:;231745 14> 8:5 ;1=G0> IA& 5: &- I& 7A 5/0 9/0C@0 >150> - $$ $$ <:= A I&$ 7A 5/0 =05@=4 ;0;: 7AA@0> 6H 5/0 141=1 14G 74<:=;748 16:@5 >7A/:4:@= :< 5/0 9/0C@0 I& 7A 5/0 9:2H :< 5/0 30813 4:5790 I& 7A 5/0 2:A513 =090725 14> I& 7A 5/0 2:A513 04?03:20 =05@=40> 5: 5/0 A04>0= 1A D1>>=0AA00 4:5 <:@4>E /0 9:;23174145 F1A 9=:AA 0I1;740>6H5/0301=40>9:@4A03<:=5/0199@A0>@=748 9=:AA0I1;74157:4 5/0 199@A0> 12201=A 5: /1?0 51G04 1 >0<0490 :< 5:513 >04713 AA@1490 :< 9/0C@0 14> 5/0 A78415@=0 <:@4> :4 5/0 9/0C@0 F0=0 >0470> ?173748 :< 3:14F1A13A:>0470>5/0=5/145/154:A2097<79>0<0490 F1A51G04 + /0 199@A0> A50220> 745: 5/0 F7540AA 6:I 14> >02:A0> 1A A515748 5/15 /0 40?0= ;05 5/0 9:;231741454:=6:==:F0>14H1;:@450/1A4:57AA@0> 5/0 9/0C@0 74 C@0A57:4 F75/ /7A A78415@=0 450=0A57483H - 7 - 5/0=07A4:=0<0=04905:5/09/0C@0I&14>4:A2097<79 >0<0490 F1A 51G04 16:@5 5/0 A1;0 @=748 9=:AA 0I1;74157:4 F7540AA 1>;7550> 5/15 /0 /1> 4:5 <730> 14H 9:;231745 18174A5 5/0 9:;23174145 13308748 <73748 :< 5/0 <13A0 9:;231745 <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 #:<5/0 95 5 7A 20=574045 5: 4:50 5/15 0?04 5/:@8/ 5/0 199@A0> 0I1;740> /7;A03< 0I9025 >04713 :< 5/0 9:450457:4A51G046H5/09:;231741455/0=07A4:>0<0490 6H5/0199@A0>57A9:4504>0>5/15I&F1A4:57AA@0> 5: 5/0 9:;23174145 6H 5/0 199@A0> @5 I& 7A 5/0 9/0C@0F/0=05/041;0:<5/0199@A0>7A2=7450>14>/0 /1A A7840> 5/0 A1;0 99:=>748 5: 5/0 9:;23174145 A78415@=0<:@4>:4I&7A5/15:<5/0199@A0>/0=07A 4: A2097<79 >04713 5: 5/7A <195 6H 5/0 199@A0> I9025 A1H7485/15/0/1A4:57AA@0>5/09/0C@074<1?:@=:<5/0 9:;23174145 /0 199@A0> /1A 4:5 0I231740> 1A 5: /:F 5/09/0C@091;0745:5/02:AA0AA7:4:<5/09:;231741457< 15 133 /0 /1A 4:5 7AA@0> 5/0 A1;0 4 9:;21=7A:4 5/0 - 8 - A78415@=0 <:@4> :4 I& ;159/0A F75/ 5/0 A78415@=0 :< 5/0 199@A0> 1A A7840> 74 5/0 >02:A757:4 74 5/0 ?1G1315/41;1 14>13A: 74 5/0 2301=09:=>0>6H 5/0=713 :@=5 4 20=@A13 :< I& >: 4:5 <74> 14H =01A:4 5: =0B0955/09317;:<5/09:;231741455/155/09/0C@0I& 603:48A 5: 5/0 199@A0> 14> 75 601=A /7A A78415@=0 5/09:;23174145/1AA/:F45/155/09/0C@0603:48A 5:5/0199@A0>14>A7840>6H/7; 5 7A 20=574045 5: 4:50 5/15 5/0 9:;23174145 <730>14122379157:4@4>0=0957:4+:<=&60<:=05/0 =713 :@=5 2=1H748 5: A@;;:4 5/0 14G :<<79713 5: 2=:>@90=0C@7=0>21=579@31=A 16:@55/0 9/0C@0I& 6@5 5/0 A17> 122379157:4 F1A =0B0950> 6H 5/0 =713 :@=5 6H :6A0=?7485/155/06@=>047A:45/0199@A0>5:=06@55/0 308132=:A09@57:414>5/0=0<:=05/09:;23174145400>4:5 /1?0 5: A@;;:4 5/0 14G :<<79713 A00G748 A@9/ 21=579@31=A :F0?0= 3150= 5/0 =713 :@=5 91;0 5: 5/0 9:493@A7:4 5/15 5/0 9:;23174145 /1A 4:5 2=:?0> /0= <741497139121975H14>304>748:<5/01;:@45 - 9 - $ /04 5/0 199@A0> /1A 4:5 51G04 14H A2097<79 >0<04904:=2=:61637J0>5/0613>>0<04905/155/09/0C@0 I&F1A40?0=7AA@0>6H/7;5:5/09:;231741455/15 5::F/045/0=713:@=5=0B095A5/0122379157:4<730>6H5/0 9:;23174145 @4>0= 0957:4 + :< =& 14> <@=5/0= :4 20=@A13:<I&75 >7A93:A0A5/155/09/0C@0 603:48A 5: 5/0 199@A0> 14> 75 601=A /7A A78415@=0 5/0 7475713 6@=>04 :4 5/0 9:;23174145 805A >7A9/1=80> /0 2=0A@;257:4 @4>0= 0957:4A # 14> + :< 95 1=7A0A/06@=>04A/7<5A:45/0199@A0>5:=06@55/030813 2=0A@;257:4 0=0 >04713 :< 7AA@1490 :< 9/0C@0 F733 4:5 =06@5 5/0 2=0A@;257:4 /0 30813 2=0A@;257:4 @4>0= 0957:4 + :< 5/0 95 7493@>0A 0I7A50490 :< 308133H 04<:=901630>065/02=0A@;257:4@4>0=0957:4#:< 5/0 95 =17A0A 2=0A@;257:4 =081=>748 5/0 9:4A7>0=157:4 :< >150 14> 57;0 :< 1990251490 :< 5/0 408:57163074A5=@;045/0199@A0>/1A4:5=06@550>5/0 308132=0A@;257:4A4>0=A@9/97=9@;A51490A/07A371630 <:=9:4?7957:4 - 10 - /0 30813 4:5790 I& 7A 1>>=0AA0> 5: 5/0 199@A0> F/79/ 7A =05@=40> 1A 5/0 1>>=0AA00 4:5 <:@4> /01>>=0AA:<5/0199@A0>;0457:40>745/0308134:5790 I&14>5/004?03:2I&7A5/0A1;01A;0457:40> 74 5/0 2=7?150 9:;231745 4>0= A@9/ 97=9@;A51490A 5/0 4:5790 7A >00;0> 5: /1?0 6004 A0=?0> :4 5/0 199@A0> 4>0=5/0A097=9@;A51490A1;:<5/0:2747:45/155/0 9:;23174145 7A A@990AA<@3 74 2=:?748 5/0 8@735 :< 5/0 199@A0> 60H:4> =01A:41630 >:@65 14> 5/0=0<:=0 5/0 199@A0>7A371630<:=9:4?7957:4 /1?08:405/=:@8/5/07;2@840>B@>8;045:< 19C@75513 21AA0> 6H 5/0 =713 :@=5 5 /1A 2=:900>0> 5: 19C@755/0199@A0>A:303H:45/08=:@4>5/155/0199@A0> 613>3H>0470>7AA@1490:<5/09/0C@0I&14>/03>5/15 5/09:;23174145/1A4:52=:?0>5/0304>748:<5/01;:@45 784:=748 5/0 A05530> 2:A757:4 :< 31F 14> 5/0 30813 2=0A@;257:4@4>0=0957:4A#14>+:<5/0 95 /0=0<:=0 1; :< 5/0 :2747:4 5/15 5/0 7;2@840> - 11 - B@>8;045:<19C@7551321AA0>6H5/0=713:@=57A3716305: 60A051A7>0 01=> 301=40> 9:@4A03 <:= 5/0 122033145 =081=>748A0450490 -4?70F:<5/016:?014AF0=5/016:?02:745 745/0D1<<7=;157?0E14>2=:900>5:21AA5/0<:33:F748 '7( /0=7;7413 220137A '77( /0 7;2@840> B@>8;045 >150> $+ $ $ 21AA0> 74 :$--$ $$ 6H 5/0 &=74972137?73@>8014>!15"1316@=187 7A '777( /0 =0A2:4>045 K 199@A0> 7A 9:4?7950> <:= 5/0:<<04902@47A/1630@4>0=0957:4#:< 5/008:5716304A5=@;045A 95## '7?( /0 =0A2:4>045 K 199@A0> 7A A0450490> 5: @4>0=8: A7;230 7;2=7A:4;045 <:= 1 20=7:> - 12 - :< A7I ;:45/A 14> 5: 21H <740 :< A$ 74 >0<1@35 5: 21H <740 5: @4>0=8: <@=5/0= A7;230 7;2=7A:4;045 <:= 5F:;:45/A '?( 421H;045:<<7401;:@45141;:@45:< A+ 5:60217>5:5/09:;23174145 1A9:;204A157:4 087A5=H 7A >7=0950> 5: A04> 619G 5/0 =713 :@=5 =09:=>A 13:48 F75/ 5/0 9:2H :< 5/0 B@>8;045 <:= 74<:=;157:4 14> 400><@3 1957:4 70 <:= 7AA@1490 :< 5/0 9:4?7957:4F1==14518174A55/0199@A0> -( $!!' # " 7A5:3:# &"