Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43487 (KAR)

SMT CHAYA W/O RAMACHANDRA KALEL AND ORS v. SRI ANIL S/O BABAN BAAD AND ANR

MFA/200824/2021 · 2025-09-12

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "!# $%!!&!& !!## '( ) ! " "" ! # $% "" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ " " &! ' ( "" )# $ # * # # # # # $ " + "&' " " " " " " " # &''' (" )# # " % , - 3 - '-' "* % % ')* % " % " '-' '' " # % " " " ' % + % % .# % /01 233425 01 60547 8974: 4;<0=9 ')* =6 </4 >35=?441=>34912<0=9 ;<@?</4;520>29<13:2?09A<= 14<21074</4B87A>49<72<47'-' ''32114709 = '@?</4 770<0=925490=:0C0587A4297 =>>0110=94:6=:>35=?441=>34912<0=90B2?238: /4 62;<1 =6 23345529<1;520>29<1D ;214 @46=:4 </4 =>>0110=94: E4:4 </2< </4? 2:4 </4 E064 ;/057:49 - 4 - 297</432:49<1=6</474;421472>2;/297:22545/4 74;42147 2>2;/297:2 E21 ;==504 E=:F09A 09 2 18A2: ;2945297129709</4C4/0;54E/0;/E21<:2913=:<09A18A2: ;294 <= </4 18A2: 62;<=:? 8974: :413=9749< = 09 /01 30;FG83 C4/0;54 @42:09A =G!- 297 /4 E21 3207 >=9</5?E2A41=61 '''G@?:413=9749<=/2<=9 ' '</474;421472>2;/297:2E21E=:F09A212 ;==504 8974: :413=9749< = 09 /01 30;FG83 C4/0;54 @42:09A =G!- 297 09 </4 >=:909A /4 E21 3:=;44709A<=E2:7118A2:;29452971<=2<<497</418A2: ;294 ;8<<09A E=:F <=E2:71 2/==7 6:=> 2H>0 2A2: 29A=52/0543:=;44709A1=2<2@=8<'G'2>E/49 </4 C4/0;54 ;2>4 942: 2/==7 C0552A4 </4 7:0C4: =6 </4 1207 C4/0;54 7:=C40< 09 2:21/ 29794A50A49<>2994: 297 784 <=/0A/ 13447 </4C4/0;54 B8>347 297</474;42147 2>2;/297:2E/=E2110<<09A09</4:42:107464557=E9 =9</4:=27297181<2094714C4:2509B8:041=9/01/427297 =</4:C0<2532:<1297/418;;8>@47<=</409B8:04109</4 /=130<25 /4 74;42147 2>2;/297:2 181<20947 09B8:041 - 5 - 78:09A </4 ;=8:14 =6 4>35=?>49< 297 /4 7047 /4 29A=52 "=50;4 :4A01<4:47 </4 ;:0>0925 ;214 2A2091< </4 7:0C4: =6 </4 30;FG83 C4/0;54 09 :0>4 = ' 413=9749< = 01 </4 7:0C4: 297 =E94: =6 </4 30;FG83 @42:09A =G!- 297 :413=9749< = 01 </4 0918:4: =6 </4 1207 C4/0;54 /4 54A25 /40:1 =6 74;42147 2>2;/297:2605472;520>34<0<0=98974:4;<0=9=6</4 >35=?441 =>34912<0=9 ;< - 1<2<09A </2< :413=9749< =1 297 2:4 502@54 <= 32? </4 ;=>34912<0=9 413=9749< = 4C49 26<4: 14:C0;4 =6 9=<0;4 :4>209472@149<297/4/21@449352;47 413=9749< =0918:29;4 ;=>329? 23342:47 297 60547 E:0<<49 1<2<4>49< 297 <2F49 83 74649;4 </2< </4:4 01 9= 4>35=?4: 297 4>35=?44 :452<0=91/03 @4<E449 </4 74;42147 2>2;/297:2 297 :413=9749< = 297 /4 E219=<E=:F09A212;==5048974:/0>=9</42554A4772<4 - 6 - =62;;0749</40918:29;4;=>329?/21251=<2F49=</4: 74649;41 ! 520>29<=/21@4494H2>094721"297 A=< >2:F47 H1" <= /4 =660;4: =6 :413=9749< = /21@4494H2>094721297A=<>2:F47H1297 9 </4 @2101 =6 </4 1207 3542709A1 </4 =>>0110=94:/216:2>47</46=55=E09A011841 ! "# $ # # # " # % !$# " $ # - 7 - & " '" $ # " ( ) /4=>>0110=94:26<4:/42:09A</42:A8>49<1 =9 @=</ 10741 297 291E4:09A 01184 =1 297 09 </4 94A2<0C4 297 01184 =1 297 7= 9=< 18:C0C4 6=: ;=91074:2<0=9 701>01147 </4 ;520> 34<0<0=9 /4 1207 B87A>49< 01 ;/25549A47 @? </4 ;520>29<1 09 </4 3:4149< 233425 074 =:74: 72<47 '-'! </4 233425 E21 27>0<<47<=;=91074:</46=55=E09A18@1<29<025I841<0=9=6 52E * +# " ,# #" ) - 8 - - 42:7 542:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 23345529<1 297 542:947;=891456=::413=9749<= ' 42:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 23345529<1 E=857 ;=9<497</2<</44C0749;4=6"09</4;21401</2<</4 74;42147 E21 ;==504 E=:F09A 8974: :413=9749< = 09 </4 30;F C29 297 E21 3:=;44709A 09 </4 30;FG83 C29297 </4 1207 C4/0;54 E21 @409A 8147 6=: <:2913=:<09A </4 ;==504129718A2:;294/4:4E214>35=?4:2974>35=?44 :452<0=91/03 @4<E449 :413=9749< = 297 </4 74;42147 418@>0<1</2<</44C0749;4=6"41<2@501/47</2<</4 74;42147E21E=:F>298974::413=9749<=09/0130;FG 83C29297</42;;0749</21<2F49352;478:09A</4;=8:14 =6 </4 4>35=?>49< 4 18@>0<1 </2< :413=9749< = :4>20947E/0;/0970;2<41</2<</4:452<0=91/03=6 4>35=?4:2974>35=?44019=<0970138<4 4 18@>0<1 </2< </4 =>>0110=94: /?3=</4<0;255?=@14:C41</2<</474;42147144>1<=@429 8928</=:0J47 321149A4: 09 2 30;FG83 C4/0;54 297 /4 E21 - 9 - 9=<2;==5042974::4709/=5709A</2<</4:4019=4>35=?4: 297 4>35=?44 :452<0=91/03 @4<E449 </4 74;42147 297 :413=9749<= 42:947;=891456=::413=9749<=0918:29;4 ;=>329? E=857 ;=9<497 </2< </4 74;42147 E21 29 8928</=:0J47 321149A4: <:2C4509A 09 2 30;FG83 C4/0;54 =6 :413=9749< = 297 </4:4 E21 9= :452<0=91/03 =6 4>35=?4: 297 E=:F>29 @4<E449 </4 74;42147 297 :413=9749< = =91074:09A </4 1207 2134;< </4 =>>0110=94: /21 :0A/<5? 291E4:47 01184 =1 297 09 </494A2<0C4297701>01147</4;520>34<0<0=9 2C09A /42:7 </4 542:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 32:<041 </01 =8:< 34:8147 </4 0>38A947 B87A>49< 297 :025=8:<:4;=:71 934:8125=6</4;520>34<0<0=90<01134;060;255? >49<0=947 09 32:2A:23/ = </2< </4 74;42147 E21 E=:F09A212;==5048974::413=9749<=09/0130;FG83 C4/0;54 @42:09A G!- =9 </4 72<4 =6 </4 2;;0749< - 10 - 04 =9 ' ' " 01 </4 E064 =6 74;42147 2>2;/297:2 /21 1<2<47 </4 12>4 09 /4: ;/046G 4H2>092<0=99</4;:=11G4H2>092<0=91/4/21291E4:47 <=</4=8:<I841<0=9</2<=9</472<4=6</42;;0749</4: /81@297 E21 E=:F09A 21 2 ;54294: 09 </4 30;FG83 C29 /4:4 E21 9= @2101 6=: =@14:C2<0=9 =6 </4 =>>0110=94: </2< </4 74;42147 E21 29 28</=:0J47 321149A4: 297 /4 E219=<2;==50409</430;FG83C29H01</4;=3?=6 </40918:29;43=50;?E/4:409</41207C4/0;5401746094721 K==71 2::?09A 4/0;54D /4 542:947 =>>0110=94: /21 =@14:C47</2<818255?18A2:;2941/255@45=2747092<:8;F =:092<:2;<=:297<:=554?297</4:4@?;2::047<=</418A2: 62;<=:? 297 E/054 =@14:C09A </4 12>4 0A9=:47 </2< </4 30;FG83C2901251=A==71;2::?09AC4/0;5429718A2:;294 ;29@45=2747090</4=>>0110=94:/21251=0A9=:47</4 2134;<</2<:413=9749<=4>35=?4::4>20947 297</2<0<14561/=E1</2</4/219=<7490474>35=?4:297 E=:F>29:452<0=91/03C4906</474;42147;=91074:47<= @4 2 ;54294: 21 743=147 @? " /4 @4;=>41 2 - 11 - E=:F>298974::413=9749<=09/01C4/0;54/4:46=:4 </4609709A=6</4=>>0110=94:</2<</4:4019=4>35=?4: 297 4>35=?44 :452<0=91/03 @4<E449 :413=9749< = 297 </4 74;42147 01 9=< 3:=34: 297 ;=::4;< 9 C04E =6 </4 12>4 </4 18@1<29<025 I841<0=9 =6 52E 01 291E4:47 09 </4 94A2<0C4 ! 9C04E=6</42@=C4</4>2<<4::4I80:41<=@4 :4>0<<47 <= </4 =>>0110=94: 6=: A0C09A 609709A =9 01184 =12972976=:7013=125=6</4;520>34<0<0=926:41/ 49;4</46=55=E09A )2* /401;455294=81%0:1< 3342501255=E47 )@* /4B87A>49<72<47'-' ''321147@?</4 770<0=925 490=: 0C05 87A4 297 </4 =>>0110=94: 6=: >35=?441 =>34912<0=9 0B2?238:09 = '0114<21074 - 12 - );* /4 >2<<4: 01 :4>29747 <= </4 =>>0110=94: 6=:A0C09A609709A=901184=12972976=: 7013=125=6</4;520>34<0<0=926:41/ )7* /4 23345529<1 297 :413=9749< = 1/255 23342:@46=:4</4=>>0110=94:=9'-''! E0</=8<29<0;032<09A29?=8:<9=<0;4 !*+ '!&!&( % " 01<=5=