- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( ! !"#$ % & ' ! "#$ ( ! "#$ % & ( ) ( ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( *&' ( ++# + + ( , # -./0-1-23455647237231689.:48;2332.<=21->.<36<1.9 ?.1-328631-634;62314@6</59.:-64:2<0 64:81-64:0/;6<13.9?.1-32863 * -23 455647 23 92768 4042<31 1-6 A/80;6<1 4<8 4=4:8 84168++#543368?B1-6./:1.96<2.:2C27/8064<8 "/886?2-472< .+ + <6 434C4:4A44068$B64:3;61=21-4<4>>286<1 .< ++D++ 4<8 8268 23 54:6<13 92768 >742; 561212.< >742;2<0 >.;56<3412.< .9 3D++++ " =21- 2<16:631 41 1-6 :416.9#E56:4<</;-61:2?/<47 >.<3286:682<1-66<12:6 - 3 - 6C286<>6.<:6>.:84<80:4<1683+++++ "=21-2<16:63141 1-6 :416 .9 DE 56: 4<</; 9:.; 1-6 8416 .9 561212.< 1277 :64723412.< 00:26C68?B1-634284=4:81-23455647235:696::68 2< =-2>- 21 23 >.<16<868 1-41 2<3/992>26<1 4;./<1 =43 0:4<168 ?B 1-6 1:2?/<47 9.: 7.33 .9 8656<86<>B -6 86>64368 =43 -6752<0 -23 ;.1-6: 2< 36772<0 ;27@ 1. 56.576 -6:69.:6 :6F/631689.:6<-4<>6;6<1.9>.;56<3412.< $ -6 561212.<6:">742;4<13 -4C6 314168 1-41 1-6 86>64368=4364:<2<03*+++ "56:;.<1-?/11-6B-4C6<.1 927684<B8.>/;6<131.5:.C6-232<>.;631-686>64368;61 =21-1-64>>286<1.<++D++-232<>.;6231.?614@6<43 3++ " 56: ;.<1- 43 56: 1-6 0/28672<63 .9 1-6 4:<414@4 1416 6047 6:C2>63 /1-.:21B -6 86>64368 23 6<121768 9.: +E 1.=4:83 9/1/:6 5:.356>13 43 56: 1-6 >21412.< .9 .<G?76 56H ./:1 2< 3 56: 1-6 0/28672<63 .9 1-6 .<G?76 56H ./:12< 29 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 4 - 1-6 86>64368 =43 /<;4::268 +E .9 -23 2<>.;6 23 1. ?6 868/>168 1.=4:83 -23 56:3.<47 6H56<363 -6 406 .9 1-6 86>64368 23 $ B64:3 4<8 1-6 45572>4?76 ;/7125726: 23 # -/31-6>.;56<3412.<1.=4:837.33.98656<86<>B>.;631. 3#*$++ "&++ "I+E"+EHH#' .<3.:12/;231.?60:4<1684356:1-60/28672<63.9 1-6 .<G?76 /5:6;6 ./:1 2< 1-6 >4363 .9 ! " #$ # % & 4<8 ' " ()*( + >>.:82<07B 21 23 A/31 4<8 :643.<4?76 1. 4=4:8 3++++ " 64>- &26 3#++++ "' 1.=4:83 7.33 .9 >.<3.:12/; 1. 1-6 >742;4<13 -6 >742;4<13 4:6 473. 6<121768 9.: 4< 4;./<1 .9 3*++++ "/<86:1-6>.<C6<12.<47-64834356:1-6>21412.<2< 1-6 >436 .9 -/3 1-6 1.147 >.;56<3412.< >.;63 1. 3D$++ " 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 5 - # 1 23 3/?;21168 1-41 1-6 :635.<86<1 ."2<3/:4<>6 >.;54<B -43 47:648B 865.32168 3+++++ " ?69.:6 1-6 1:2?/<47-6:69.:6:635.<86<1 .231.?682:6>1681.865.321 1-6 6<-4<>68 >.;56<3412.< .9 3$++ " =21- 2<16:631 41 1-6:416.9$E D < 1-6 :63/71 1-6 455647 23 477.=68 2< 54:1 -6 561212.<6:">742;4<13 4:6 6<121768 9.: 1-6 1.147 >.;56<3412.< .9 3D$++ "=21-2<16:631411-6:416.9$E635.<86<1 . J 2<3/:4<>6 >.;54<B 23 82:6>168 1. 865.321 1-6 6<-4<>68 >.;56<3412.<.93$++ "=21-2<16:631411-6:416.9$E =21-2<.<6;.<1-9:.;1-68416.91-23.:86: <3/>-865.321 1-6 561212.<6:3 4:6 56:;21168 1. =21-8:4= 1-6 6<12:6 4;./<1 47.<0=21-2<16:6314>>:/68.<216F/477B + < C26= .9 1-6 .:86: 84168 +++ 543368 .< . +* 1-6 >742;4<13 4:6 <.1 6<121768 9.: 2<16:631 9.: 1-68674B6856:2.8.984B32<9272<01-6455647 38 " %$' # 231 .7 .D