Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43485 (KAR)
KARNATAKA STATE INDUSTRIAL v. M/S SRI S.B.DALL INDUSTRIES AND ORS
MFA/201019/2016 · 2025-10-23
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43485 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43485 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$ "
#$ !$%! ""
& ' (
! " #
$%
% &
! '
%()'$&
)! (
' *+% * '*
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
,*%
*)! (
-
' * % * '* ,*%
*)! (
' *(% * '* ,*% )+! ! ' *+% * '* ,%
*)! (
' * % * '* ,*%
*)! ( #
$%
(. '
!) !( (! ! . '
!! !( ( (
&
- 3 -
-($& %
('(
! -( ! %
('( % % , %
%
*
* /
/ %
%
$ $*/
& 01234453612716589:85;5<=1>:-($&>7=05=3=5 1:3:<136 >;4>;3=1>:2 <= !! $05;51:37=5; ;575;;58 => 32 ? <=@ 7>; 20>;=& <03665:A1:A =05 >;85; 83=58 ! -( ! 432258 BC =05 881=1>:36 12=;1<= 98A5 363B9;3A11:1D1612<5663:5>92>('( E05;5BC=05 45=1=1>: 71658 BC =05 3445663:=F3;:3=3G3 =3=5 :892=;136 :D52=H5:= >7
5D56>4H5:= >;4>;3=1>: 1H1=58 $05;51:37=5; ;575;;58 => 32 ?>;4>;3=1>:@ 7>; 20>;=& 9:85;
5<=1>: -!$!&$33& E32 812H12258 32 B51:A B3;;58 BC 61H1=3=1>:
- 4 -
( ;157 73<=2 >7 =05 <325 3;5 =03= =05 45=1=1>:5;'3445663:=12=05>;4>;3=1>:524>:85:=>!12 3;5A12=5;5843;=:5;201471;H3:8;524>:85:=:>2(=> 3;5 1=2 43;=:5;2 524>:85:= >!
B>;;>E58 3 6>3: >7 2-+ 'F 7;>H =05 3445663:=F>;4>;3=1>: 7>; =05 49;4>25 >7 52=3B61201:A 3:8 ;9::1:A 3 366 4;><5221:A 2H366 2<365 1:892=;C 524>:85:= :>( 2=>>8 32 3 A93;3:=>;3:8<;53=58321H465H>;=A3A5BC854>21=1:A366 =1=65 85582 1: ;5245<= >7 =05 1HH>D3B65 4;>45;=152 852<;1B581:<058965F1H163;6C;524>:85:=>2-3:8 2=>>8 32 A93;3:=>;2 3:8 H>;=A3A58 =051; ;5245<=1D5 1HH>D3B65 4;>45;=152 BC 854>21=1:A =05 =1=65 85582 32 20>E: 1: <058965 3:8 1:<5 =05 ;524>:85:=2 857396=58 1: ;543CH5:= >7 =05 6>3: =05 45=1=1>:5;'3445663:= 1:D>G58 4;><5581:A2 9:85; =05 <= - 7=5; 25661:A =05 4;>45;=152 3==3<058 9:85; =05 <=7>;=05B363:<53H>9:==053445663:=05;51:71658 345=1=1>:9:85;5<=1>:2-!3:8-(>7=05<=B57>;5
- 5 -
=05 881=1>:36 12=;1<= 98A5 363B9;3A1 1: 1D16 12<5663:5>92 >('( 05 2318 45=1=1>: <3H5 => B5 812H12258 32 B51:A B3;;58 BC 61H1=3=1>: 51:A 3AA;15D58 BC=052318>;85;=053445663:=0324;575;;58=054;525:= 344536B57>;5=012>9;=
;1 3;5:8;3
588C 653;:58 <>9:256 34453;1:A 7>; =05 3445663:= 05;51: 71658 3 45=1=1>: 9:85;
5<=1>:2-!3:8-(>7=05<=B57>;5=05 881=1>:36
12=;1<= 98A5 363B9;3A1 1: 1D16 12<5663:5>92 >('( 05 2318 45=1=1>: <3H5 => B5 812H12258 32 B51:AB3;;58BC61H1=3=1>:0545;1>8>761H1=3=1>:12=>B5 <>9:=587;>H=0583=5>:E01<0=053225=2>7=05<>H43:C E5;52>68
53;:58 <>9:256 7>; =05 3445663:= 79;=05;
<>:=5:858 =03= =05 3225=2 >7 =05 ;524>:85:=F43;=:5;2014 71;HE5;52>689:85;32365855883=58( )( 012 8><9H5:= E32 :>= 3D3163B65 B57>;5 =05 ;136 >9;= 05 ;136 >9;= E;>:A6C <>:2185;58 ( )( =05 83=5 >:
- 6 -
E01<0 4>225221>: E32 =3G5: BC =05 >;4>;3=1>: 32 =05 83=5 7>; <>9:=1:A 61H1=3=1>: 05 ;136 >9;= =;53=58 =05 83=5>7=3G1:A4>225221>:>7=05H>;=A3A583225=232=05 83=5>723653:8>:=03=B3212812H12258=0534461<3=1>:
>: =05 A;>9:8 =03= 1= E32 B3;;58 BC 61H1=3=1>: 05 2365 8558032B55:4;>89<5836>:AE1=0=0534461<3=1>:7>;=05 71;2= =1H5 B57>;5 =012 >9;= 2 45; =05 2365 8558 =05 3225=2>7=05;524>:85:=F71;HE5;52>68>:( )(
05>:@B6545I>9;=1:=05<325>7
!" ! !
! # 0320568=03==0545;1>8>761H1=3=1>:>7=0;55C53;2=>7165 3:34461<3=1>:9:85;5<=1>:-!>7=05<=<>HH5:<52 7;>H =05 83=5 >: E01<0 =05 3225=2 >7 =05 <>H43:C 3;5 2>68 : =05 <325 1: 03:8 =05 ;136 >9;= 032 E;>:A6C <>:2=;958 ( )( =05 83=5 >: E01<0 =05 4>225221>: >7=05H>;=A3A584;>45;=CE32=3G5:32=0583=5>72365 >;=0571;2==1H5=0523658558032B55:4;>89<58B57>;5 =012 >9;= 7 =05 83=5 H5:=1>:58 1: =05 2365 8558 12
- 7 -
<>:2185;58 =05 34461<3=1>: H3C 7366 E1=01: =05 45;1>8 >7 61H1=3=1>: 05: =05 ;136 >9;= 812H12258 =05 291= >:
H31:=31:3B161=C 1= <>HH1==58 3: 5;;>; BC A1D1:A 3 71:81:A >:=05H5;1=2:=012A;>9:832E566=05344536;5J91;52 =>B5366>E58 + :D15E>7=053B>D5=05H3==5;;5J91;52=>B5 ;5H1==58=>=05;136>9;==>;5<>:2185;=0545=1=1>:71658 BC=0534461<3:=37;5201:3<<>;83:<5E1=063E37=5;A1D1:A 3:>44>;=9:1=C=>366=0543;=152 ) 1B5;=C 12 ;525;D58 => =053445663:= =>4;>89<5 =0523658558BC7161:A=05:5<5223;C34461<3=1>:B57>;5=05 ;136>9;=
: D15E >7 =05 3B>D5 E5 4322 =05 7>66>E1:A >;85;*
)*+) 1& 0534453612$
- 8 -
11& 05K98AH5:=83=58! -( !432258BC =05 881=1>:36 12=;1<= 98A5 363B9;3A1 1:1D1612<>('( 1225=32185 111& 05 H3==5; 12 ;5H1==58 => =05 ;136 >9;= E1=0 3 81;5<=1>: => ;5<>:2185; =05 <325 37;520 37=5; A1D1:A 3: >44>;=9:1=C => =05 43;=152=>71653:C3881=1>:368><9H5:=2
1D& 66<>:=5:=1>:2>7=0543;=1523;5G54=>45: 05;136>9;=1281;5<=58=>;5<>:2185;=05 H3==5; 37;520 1: 3<<>;83:<5 E1=0 63E E1=0>9= B51:A 1:7695:<58 BC 3:C >B25;D3=1>:2 H385 BC =012 >9;= 1: =012 >;85; *, &" ' $
*, &!$%!' $ '12=>*!6>*!