Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43465 (KAR)
SHIVARAJ v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201939/2025 · 2025-12-11
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43465 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43465 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"% ""
"
&'&()*'+& )) ,
! " #
$% ! "
& ! "
'
$%
' %(
& !##
"
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
'
$) ' !" $ ' ! *" *
%% %)
' '
#'
' # $ %(
'
'' )( %$ $%%$+'
# ' *#
# ,
#
##
-./012.2.34./5.61789012.2.341: ;<<=/173=471: 1<2.34$35-;:;2.9;;>;:.?=:;?/-;;4-.2; /11?.4>>:;4235:1>=6;:8;.6.4 3%% %);:./.4>3=2 35 :.@13$ %( 35 -;2;?; -.4<-36. 36.<1 2;2.34 ./2.7;:53:2-135514<10=4./-;861=471:1<2.34/)( %$ $%%;471<2.34$+3547.;414;6 371%+ 0147.4>342-15.613561;:417 .A.6=7>1;47#' 3=:2 -;6?. -1 0:3/1<=2.34 <;/1 .4 8:.15 ./ 2-;2 34 %(2-1<3@06;.4;42-;A=:;3B-3B;/7:.A.4>;
63::9 63;717 B.2- % 234/ 35 =: 7;6 A;6=17 ;2
- 3 -
;00:3C.@;2169Rs.% ;634>B.2-2-1<61;41:B;/ 0:3<117.4> 23B;:7/ =:4336 A.; 2-1 -;6?.D=@4;8;7 :3;72;83=2%%0@41;:-;2;?; -.4<-366. :3// ; @323:<9<61 <3@.4> 5:3@ 2-1 3003/.21 7.:1<2.34 /230017 2-163::9;472B3=4?43B401:/34/;6.>-2175:3@.2334 2-1:1;521: ;432-1: @323:<9<61 ;::.A17 ;47 2-:11 @3:1 =4?43B4 .47.A.7=;6/ E3.417 2-1@ -1/1 5.A1 01:/34/ ;661>1769 53:@17 ;4 =46;B5=6 >:3=0 53:<.869 8:3=>-2 2-1 <3@06;.4;42 .423 2-1 <;8.4 35 2-1 63::9 ;47 81>;4 ;//;=62.4>-.@
-1:1;521: 2-1 ;//;.6;42/ ;661>1769 7:3A1 2-1 63::923B;:7/;6;/;4>.;B;95:3@2-1A.66;>16.@.2/-1 <3@06;.4;42;472-1<61;41:B1:153:<.8697:;>>173=235 2-1 <;8.4 ;47 2-:1;21417 23 0;:2 B.2- @3419 -1 142.:1 .421:;<2.34.//2;21723-;A12;?1406;<1.4;44;7;-1 ;//;.6;42/ ;661>1769 233? Rs.+
5:3@ 2-1 <3@06;.4;42F/ 03<?12 ;47 2-14 <3@016617 832- 2-1 <3@06;.4;42 ;47 2-1 <61;41: 23 83;:7 341 35 2-1 @323:<9<61/-163::9;634>B.2-2-15337>:;.4/63;717
- 4 -
2-1:1.4 B;/ ;661>1769 /23614 89 2-1 012.2.341: ;47 32-1: <3;<<=/17 01:/34/ ;/17 34 2-./ .4<.7142 ; <:.@.4;6 <;/1 <;@1 23 81 :1>./21:17 ;47 ;521: .4A1/2.>;2.34 2-1 4A1/2.>;2.4>55.<1:-;/43B5.6172-1<-;:>1/-112 $ 1;:417 <3=4/16 53: 2-1 012.2.341: :1.21:;2.4> 2-1 ;A1:@142/ =:>17 .4 2-1 012.2.34 -;/ <345.417 -./ /=8@.//.34/ 0:.@;:.69 23 2-1 .//=1 35 .7142.29 35 2-1 012.2.341: ;47 -./ ;661>17 <3441<2.34 B.2- 2-1 <:.@1 1/01<.;669 43B 2-;2 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 -;/ 8114 5.617 9 :151::.4> 23 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 :1<3:7/ <3=4/16 03.42/ 3=2 2-;2341-.A?=@;: 344;:;3-=8;-;/8114<-;:>1 /-11217 53: 2-1 35514<1/ .4 G=1/2.34 ;47 ./ ;::;917 ;/ ;<<=/17 3 4 <342:;/2 2-1 012.2.341:F/ 4;@1 ;/ :1561<217 .4 -./ ;7-;;: <;:7 ;47 7:.A.4> 6.<14<1 ./ -.A;:;E 344100;2./2-=/<342147172-;22-1;::1/2 .2/165 ./ 5=47;@142;669 .661>;6 ;47 2-;2 2-1 012.2.341: -;/ 8114 5;6/169 .@06.<;217 71/0.21 -;A.4> 43 41C=/ B-;2/31A1:B.2-2-1;661>17<:.@1
- 5 -
1:<342:;2-161;:417.>- 3=:23A1:4@142 61;71:/=8@.2/2-;22-1;7-;;:<;:7;477:.A.4>6.<14<1 :16.17=034892-1012.2.341:<;443281<34/.71:17;22-./ /2;>1 2 ./ 03.4217 3=2 2-;2 2-1/1 73<=@142/ B1:1 382;.417 89 2-1 012.2.341: ;521: 2-1 5.6.4> 35 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 2-1:189 :;./.4> /1:.3=/ 73=82 :1>;:7.4> 2-1.: ;=2-142.<.29 ;47 :16.;8.6.29 -1 35514<1 7;21/ 8;<?
23 %( ;47 2-1 3:.>.4;6 <-;:>1 /-112 B;/ 5.617 .4 % B-1:1.4 ;<<=/17 3 B;/ /-3B4 ;/ ;8/<347.4> 61;7.4> 23 2-1 5.6.4> 35 ; /06.2=0 <-;:>1 /-112 4 /=<- <.:<=@/2;4<1/ .2 ./ <34214717 2-;2 2-1 73<=@142/ 43B :16.17 =034 89 2-1 012.2.341: <;4432 81 ;<<10217 ;/ <:17.861@;21:.;62./2-=/=:>172-;22-././432;5.2<;/1 53:>:;42358;.6 + 034-1;:.4>2-161;:417<3=4/1634832-/.71/ ;47 34 01:=/;6 35 2-1 :1<3:7/ 2-1 53663B.4> 03.42 ;:./1/ 53:<34/.71:;2.34
- 6 -
H*-12-1:2-1012.2.341:-;/@;713=2;<;/153: >:;4235:1>=6;:8;.6IJ ( 4 ; <;:15=6 1C;@.4;2.34 35 2-1 <-;:>1 /-112 @;21:.;6/ .2 ./ 1A.7142 2-;2 2-1 012.2.341: ./ ;::;917 ;/ ;<<=/17 3 -1 ;661>;2.34 ;>;.4/2 -.@ ./ 341 35 <3@@.22.4> ; :3881:9 .4A36A.4> 2-1 7.A1:/.34 35 ; 63::9 <;::9.4> %234/35=:7;6A;6=17;2Rs.% -1 @;441: .4 B-.<- 2-1 A1-.<61 B;/ .421:<10217 2-1 <3@06;.4;42B;/;661>1769;//;=6217;472-15=66963;717 63::9B;/7.A1:217:1A1;6/2-1>:;A.29352-135514<1
2 ./ ;6/3 4321B3:2-9 2-;2 2-1 012.2.341:
:1@;.417 =42:;<1;861 5:3@ %( =42.6 % B-.<- <3@016617 2-1 2:.;6 <3=:2 23 0:3<117 89 .//=.4> ; /06.2=0 <-;:>1 /-112 469 =034 /1<=:.4> -./ 0:1/14<1 2-:3=>- 0:3<6;@;2.340:3<117.4>/-;/2-1012.2.341:43B;001;:17 ;47/3=>-2237./0=21-./.7142.29*-12-1:2-1012.2.341: ./.47117-.A;:;E 344100;;474322-1-.A?=@;: 3 44;:;3 -=8; ;::;917 ;/ ;<<=/17 3 ;:1 .//=1/ 2-;2
- 7 -
:1G=.:15=665617>172:.;6;47<;443281;7E=7.<;217;22-1 /2;>1358;.6 ) .A14 2-1 012.2.341:F/ 0:3634>17 ;8/<34714<1 2-1 /1:.3=/41// 35 2-1 ;661>;2.34/ ;47 2-1 @;441: .4 B-.<-2-135514<1./;661>1723-;A18114<3@@.22172-./ 3=:2 ./ 432 .4<6.417 23 1C1:<./1 7./<:12.34 .4 5;A3=: 35 >:;42.4> 8;.6 -1 73<=@142/ 0:37=<17 89 2-1 012.2.341:
B-.<- ;:1 382;.417 .4 % B-.61 <-;:>1/-112 ./ 5.617 .4 % .4 2-1 <34/.71:17 A.1B 35 2-./ 3=:2 <;4432 81 :16.17=034;22-.//2;>1;472-138E1<2.34/:;./17892-1 61;:417 .>- 3=:2 3A1:4@142 61;71: <;::9 /=8/2;42.;6 B1.>-2 <<3:7.4>69 2-1 03.42 53: <34/.71:;2.34 ./ ;4/B1:17.42-141>;2.A1 % '3: 2-1 53:1>3.4> :1;/34/ ;47 B.2-3=2 1C0:1//.4> ;49 30.4.34 34 2-1 @1:.2/ 35 2-1 <;/1 2-1 012.2.34./ -* & "") %
./23%63%