- 1 - !" !""# $#% & ! ! " # ! $% !! !& '( '%)$* & +$(%#*# ! ,$ ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '( '%)$* ! +$(%#*# ) !! !!& +$(%#*# !! - )- #" ! #.) #" ! ! ! &*,##*#! #(# *#, & ! ! ! ! ! &! ! / ! ! / - 3 - " ! / !" 012 344536 12 78 905 :631;3<9 =165> ?<>5@ 5:91A< #.) #"A=905A9A@501:652:9#((751<B3BB@15C5>78 905D?>B;5<93<>3E3@>>395>*,##*#43225>78905 >>191A<365<1A@1C16 ?>B53<>'1D3834?@3 1< A#(# *#, 255F1<B 5<03<:5;5<9 A= :A;45<2391A< 3:92 B1C1<B @125 9A 905 =161<B A= 905 344536 7@15=6829395>3@59039A<%##*#)3937A?9(,$3; 9051<D?@5> 459191A<5@E324@A:55>1<B9A012?2?36EA@FA< 012 ;A9A@:8:65 753@1<B @5B129@391A< A( )*$# &05< 05 @53:05> A44A2195 A= 303@3D3 !A956 3< ?9A@1:F203E753@1<B@5B129@391A<A( %)$*751<B >@1C5< 78 192 >@1C5@ 6A29 :A<9@A6 AC5@ 905 C501:65 :3;5 =@A; E@A<B 21>5 39 3 01B0 2455> 3<> 1< 3 @320 3<> <5B61B5<9;3<<5@>3205>9A905C501:65A=905459191A<5@ 2 3 @52?69 A= 905 3=A@5231> 3::1>5<9 905 459191A<5@ 2?2931<5> 1<D?@152 3<> E32 0A2419361G5> 39 !A241936 - 4 - ?5 9A 012 25@1A?2 :A<>191A< 05 E32 201=95> 9A C32908 !A2419361D3834?@ E05@5 05 E32 9@5395> 3<> >12:03@B5> A< ##*#) 78 245<>1<B 0?B5 3;A?<9 05@53=95@ 05 ?<>5@E5<9 =?@905@ 9@539;5<9 =A@ 053@1<B 3<> 7@53901<B 4@A765;21<6';55<5>1:36A665B51D3834?@ ) 05:631;3<9=165>3459191A<?<>5@5:91A<#%% A= 905 :9 75=A@5 905 631;2 @17?<36 255F1<B :A;45<2391A<=A@9051<D?@1522?2931<5>1<905@A3>9@3==1: 3::1>5<99E32=?@905@4653>5>90399053::1>5<9A::?@@5> 4?@568A<3::A?<9A=905@3203<><5B61B5<9>@1C1<BA=905 A==5<>1<BC501:6578192>@1C5@ , < 25@C1:5 A= <A91:5 @524A<>5<9 A2# 9A ) 34453@5> 90@A?B0 9051@ :A?<2562 524A<>5<9 A) =165> E@1995< 29395;5<9 >5<81<B 905 3C5@;5<92 ;3>5 1< 905 :631;459191A< $ < 905 73212 A= 4653>1<B2 A= 905 43@9152 905 631;2@17?<36=@3;5>905122?523<>905@53=95@@5:A@>5> 905 5C1>5<:5 05 459191A<5@ 1< A@>5@ 9A 4@AC5 905 :325 - 5 - 5H3;1<5> 01;256= 32 &'# 7521>52 5H3;1<1<B 905 >A:9A@ 32 &' 3<> BA9 5H017195> >A:?;5<92 <3;568 H# 9A H$ < 75036= A= @524A<>5<92 A<5 E19<522 12 5H3;1<5> 32 &# 3<> BA9 ;3@F5> =A?@ >A:?;5<92 32 H2#9A, % 05 631;2 @17?<36 78 905 1;4?B<5> D?>B;5<9056>90399053::1>5<99AAF463:5A< 3::A?<9 A= @320 3<> <5B61B5<9 @1>1<B 78 905 @1>5@ A= 905 A==5<>1<B C501:65 32 3 @52?69 A= E01:0 905 :631;3<9 2?2931<5> 1<D?@152 05 @17?<36 =?@905@ 056> 9039 905 :631;3<9 12 5<91965> 9A 3 :A;45<2391A< A= 2%*%* ' 36A<BE1901<95@52939905@395A=%I433<>>1@5:95>905 @524A<>5<9<A2#3<>)DA1<9683<>25C5@36683<>90583@5 >1@5:95> 9A >54A219 905 :A;45<2391A< 3;A?<9 36A<B E190 1<95@52951<B>1223912=15>E190905:A;45<2391A<3E3@>5> 78 905 @17?<36 905 4@525<9 344536 12 =165> 255F1<B 5<03<:5;5<9A=:A;45<2391A< . 05653@<5>:A?<256=A@905:631;3<9032@3125> 905=A66AE1<B:A<95<91A<2 - 6 - 3" 1@2968 >?5 9A 905 3::1>5<9 905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5>B@15CA?21<D?@15205:631;3<90325H3;1<5>905 >A:9A@ 32 & E0A >54A25> 9039 905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5>>123716198A=$I9A)*I9A905E0A657A>8?9 905@17?<360323225225>(I>1237161989A905E0A657A>8 3<>90523;512A<9056AE5@21>5 7" 05 =?@905@ :A<95<>5> 9039 39 905 91;5 A= 3::1>5<9905:631;3<9E3253@<1<B2##*** '4;=@A; ::A?<93<9 ?45@C12A@ EA@F !AE5C5@ 905 @17?<36 032 3225225><A91A<361<:A;5A=>5:5325>392,$** 'E01:0 12A<9056AE5@21>5 :" 32968 205 032 :A<95<>5> 9039 >?5 9A 905 3::1>5<9905:631;3<90322?==5@5>B@15CA?21<D?@83<>05 E321<'43915<9=A@345@1A>A=)>382!50322?==5@5>6A9 A= 431< >?@1<B 905 9@539;5<9 3<> 905 :A;45<2391A< 3E3@>5>78905@17?<369AE3@>431<3<>2?==5@1<B6A22A= 3;5<19152 3<> A905@ 3::1>5<936 5H45<252 12 A< 905 6AE5@ - 7 - 21>5 !5<:5 205 2A?B09 =A@ 5<03<:5;5<9 A= :A;45<2391A< ( 5@ :A<9@3 653@<5> :A?<256 34453@1<B =A@ 905 @524A<>5<9 + 1<2?@3<:5 :A;43<8 :A<95<> 9039 5C5< 90A?B0>A:9A@0323225225>E0A657A>8>12371619839$I 9A )*I 05 032 <A9 3225225> 905 61;7 >123716198 05@5=A@5 905 @17?<36 032 @1B0968 3225225> 905 E0A65 7A>8 >123716198 39 (I !5 =?@905@ :A<95<>5> 9039 5C5< 90A?B0 :631;3<9 032 :631;5> 9039 05 E32 53@<1<B 2##*** ' 45@ ;A<90 05 032 <A9 4@A>?:5> 3<8 >A:?;5<99A52937612090523;505@5=A@5905@17?<36 032@1B09683225225>905<A91A<361<:A;5A=905:631;3<939 2,$** '4; 32968 05 032 :A<95<>5> 9039 :A<21>5@1<B 905 5C1>5<:5 A= >A:9A@ 3<> 1<D?@152 2?==5@5> 78 905 :631;3<9 905 :A;45<2391A< 3E3@>5> 78 905 @17?<36 9AE3@>2 431< 3<> 2?==5@1<B 6A22 A= 3;5<19152 A905@ 1<:1>5<936 1<D?@152 3@5D?293<>@532A<3765!5<:52052A?B09=A@>12;12236 A=905344536 - 8 - #* !53@> 905 653@<5> :A?<256 =A@ 905 43@9152 45@?25>905D?>B;5<93<>3E3@>A=905@17?<363<>362A 9053445364345@2 ## 9 12 <A9 1< >124?95 9039 905 :631;3<9 032 2?==5@5> 1<D?@8 1< 3 @A3> 9@3==1: 3::1>5<9 A::?@@5> A< %##*#)>?59A@3203<><5B61B5<9>@1C1<BA=>@1C5@A= ?9A1:F203E753@1<B5BA'( '%)$*912362A <A91<>124?959039>?59A90537AC53::1>5<9905:631;3<9 0322?==5@5>1<D?@152<3;56837@321A<EA?<>AC5@90565=9 43@15936@5B1A<65=953@7655><32367655>3:?952?7>?@36 7655>1<@1B09=@A<9A95;4A@36@5B1A<3:?951<90565=9 95;4A@3643@15936@5B1A<>1==?25:5@57@36A>5;<3=@3:9?@5 A= 65=9 95;4A@36 7A<5 @1B09 =@A<936 7A<5 05;A@@03B5 :A<9?21A< # 05:631;3<90325H3;1<5>905>A:9A@32& E0A9@5395>01;<0125C1>5<:5&>54A25>9039905 :631;3<90322?==5@5>$I9A)*I>1237161989A905E0A65 7A>8 ?9 05 032 <A9 3225225> 905 61;7 >123716198 - 9 - A<21>5@1<B 905 5C1>5<:5 A= >A:9A@ 3<> ;5>1:36 @5:A@>2 E5 3@5 A= 905 A41<1A< 9039 E0A65 7A>8 >123716198 :3< 75 3225225>39#*IC5<90A?B0905:631;3<9:631;5>9039 05E3253@<1<B2##*** '4;7?905032<A94@A>?:5> 3<8 5C1>5<:5 9A 529376120 905 23;5 <>5@ 90525 :1@:?;293<:52905<A91A<361<:A;50329A753225225>A< 90573212A=905B?1>561<52122?5>789053@<393F39395 5B36 5@C1:52 ?90A@198 =A@ 905 3::1>5<9 A::?@@5> 1< 905 853@*#)3<>905<A91A<361<:A;50329A75:A<21>5@5>39 2.*** '4;990591;5A=3::1>5<9905:631;3<9E32 3B5>37A?9)853@205;?6914615@34461:37659A9053B5 B@A?412J#(K::A@>1<B686A22A==?9?@553@<1<B032755< @5'3225225>32?<>5@ 2.***H#H#(H#*IL2#$#** ' #) ?5 9A 905 3::1>5<9905:631;3<9 032 2?==5@5> B@15CA?21<D?@8!5E321<'43915<9=A@345@1A>A=)>382 !50322?==5@5>6A9A=431<>?@1<B9059@539;5<975:3?25 A=>1237161983<>0329A2?==5@?<03441<522>?@1<B01261=5 - 10 - A<21>5@1<B9055C1>5<:5A=>A:9A@3<>1<D?@82?==5@5>78 905:631;3<9E53@51<:61<5>9A5<03<:5905:A;45<2391A< 9AE3@>2 J431< 3<> 2?==5@1<BK =@A; 2)**** ' 9A 2.**** ' 1F5E125 :A;45<2391A< 3E3@>5> ?<>5@ 905 053> J6A22 A= 3;5<19152K 12 5<03<:5> =@A; 2**** ' 9A 2$**** ' 05 :631;3<9 12 362A 5<91965> =A@ :A;45<2391A<9AE3@>26A22A=1<:A;5>?@1<B631>?445@1A> =A@ 90@55 ;A<902 15 2#*** ' 2.*** H )" 05 :A;45<2391A< 3E3@>5> ?<>5@ A905@ 053>2 3@5 D?29 3<> @532A<3765 #, < @5'322522;5<9 3<> @5'>595@;1<391A< 905 :A;4?9391A<A=:A;45<2391A<1232?<>5@ '()*+,-+. /-0+(1*- 31<3<>2?==5@1<B 2.**** ' 5>1:365H45<252 2,*$** ' A22A=1<:A;5>?59A 45@;3<5<940821:36 >123716198 2#$#** ' AA>3<><A?@120;5<9 2)**** ' 995<>3<9:03@B52 2**** ' - 11 - A<C583<:5:03@B52 2**** ' A22A=3;5<191523<> =?9?@5?<03441<522 2$**** ' -23 (45 56 #$ <905@52?69E54322905=A66AE1<B 3"0534453612 7" 05 D?>B;5<9 A= 905 631;2 @17?<36 12 ;A>1=15> :" 05 :631;3<9 12 5<91965> 9A 3 9A936 :A;45<2391A< A= 2.,%,** ' 32 3B31<29 2*%*%* '3E3@>5>78905@17?<3636A<B E1901<95@52939905@395A=%I45@3<<?; >" 05524A<>5<9A)'<2?@3<:5A;43<812 >1@5:95> 9A >54A219 5<91@5 :A;45<2391A< 3;A?<9 36A<B E190 1<95@529 39 905 @395 A= %I 45@3<<?;=@A;905>395A==161<BA=905:631; 459191A< 9166 905 >395 A= @5361G391A< E1901< 3 - 12 - 45@1A>A=21HE55F2=@A;905>395A=@5:5149A= 3:A48A=9012D?>B;5<9 5" 05 >54A219 3<> @565325 20366 75 32 45@ 905 A@>5@A=905@17?<36 76 $ % " 76 $"#% " 129A#6A,$