- 1 - ! " #$ % %!$$ &$' ! !"" # $!! % & ' ( # )! ) (## ) ) (## ) ) ( " #(## )* ) ( Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! (## )" ( !( + $! # (# # )" ) ( +, $! * ( )"! ) (- $"!" % & !. (! * ' * # ! ) /0 123425/1 4556 7892:4; <8/ =>4 ?4=0=0824/ 125 /012@12@8951 0/151/ 7892:4; <8/ /4:?82542=: =8 ! >1341??41/4502?4/:82 - 3 - >4 8/54/ 51=45 !! ?1::45 A6 =>4 /; 4208/ 030; 95@4 125 4BA4/ $ 0C161?9/ 02 8!""(" 3054 224D9/4$ 0: 71;;45 02=8 E94:=082 02 =>0: /0=4=0=08282:434/1;@/8925:1::4=89=02=>4 4B8/1259B 8</0=4=0=082 >4:>8/=<17=:1/4=>4:4) 24#1;;1??1#131=1@05045021815/1<<07770542=82 " 82=42502@=>1==>461/4=>44@1;/4?/4:42=1=034: 8< =>4 54741:45 =>4 7;10B12=: <0;45 1 7;10B ?4=0=082 02 8!""(" 7;10B02@ 78B?42:1=082 >46 B154 =>4 8F24/8<=>4 1/125=>4 2:9/1274 8B?1261:/4:?82542=: <=4/=>40::912748<=>428=074=>4 2:9/1274 8B?126<0;451 F/0==42:=1=4B42=125:?470<071;;6782=42545=>1==>4 1/F1: @802@F16=88<1:=125>0==>4:=1=08245/10;4/>46<0;4512 0B?;41502@1??;071=082=80B?;415824 /12=8:>(88>051: 124782=42502@=>1=>0:21B4F1::>8F21:1779:45802 =>4 125 7>1/@4 :>44= >4 :1B4 F1: 8AC47=45 A6 =>4 7;10B12=:>4/0A921;50:B0::45=>41??;071=082254/=>4:4 70/79B:=1274: =>4 2:9/1274 8B?126 >1: <0;45 =>4 /0= 4=0=082 - 4 - " 892:4; <8/ =>4 /4:?47=034 ?1/=04: 9/@45 :434/1; 782=42=082: 892:4; /0 123425/1 4556 :9AB0=: =>1= =>4 7>1/@4 :>44=F1:<0;451@102:==>4?/8?8:450B;41502@1??;0712=1:F4;; 1: =>4 5/034/ 8< =>4 02:9/45 1/ 4274 =>4 2:9/1274 8B?126 F1: C9:=0<045 02 B1G02@ 12 0B?;41502@ 1??;071=082 892:4;?;1745/4;0127482=>45470:08202 02 /012@12@8951 0/151/ 7892:4; <8/ =>4 7;10B12=: C9:=0<045=>4/4C47=0828<=>41??;071=082 4D= >4 :9AB0=: =>1= =>4 7;10B12=: 1/4 =>4 02B1=4: 8< =>4 1/ 125 =>46 1/4 =>0/5 ?1/=04: 4 :9AB0=: =>1= =>4 ?/8?8:450B?;41502@1??;0712=0:28=12474::1/6?1/=6 <9/=>4/ :9AB0::082 0: B154 =>1= =>4 2:9/1274 8B?126 >15 :4==;45 =>4 50:?9=4 F0=> =>4 7;10B12=: >4 2:9/1274 8B?126 F1: 1F1/4 8< =>4 <17= =>1= 12 9202:9/45 =/10;4/ F1: ?1/G45 02 =>4B055;4 8< =>4 /815 54:?0=4 =>4 :105 <17==>4 2:9/1274 8B?126>1578B4<8/F1/5125:4==;45=>4 - 5 - B1==4/ F0=> =>4 7;10B12=: 4274 =>4 2:9/1274 8B?126 71228=0B?;415=>48F24/8<=>4/10;4/1==>0:C927=9/4 892:4;34>4B42=;6782=42545=>1=0=0:=>47>80748<=>4 7;10B12=: =8 0B?;415 125 B1G4 /4:?82542= 1: 1 ?1/=6 =8 =>4 ?/8744502@: 4 :9AB0=: =>1= =>0: 89/= >15 :?470<071;;6 50/47=45=>4/01; 89/==850:?8:48<=>47;10B?4=0=082F0=>02 =>/44B82=>: 1:=;6 >4 :9AB0=: =>1= =>4 71:4 0: :4=$58F2 <8/ 1/@9B42=:A4<8/4=>4/0A921; 892:4;=>4/4<8/4:9AB0=:=>1= =>4/0=4=0=082B16A450:B0::45 ! 41/5=>41/@9B42=:125?4/9:45=>4/0=?1?4/: F0=>71/4 >4 :0B?;4 ?802= =>1= /4E90/4: 782:054/1=082 0: F>4=>4/ =>4 /0A921; 0: C9:=0<045 02 /4C47=02@ =>4 0B?;41502@ 1??;071=082 * >40::94<1;;:F0=>02121//8F78B?1::125/4;1=4: =8 =>4 /4C47=082 8< =>4 ?;41 =>1= =>4 =/10;4/ F1: ?1/G45 >1?>1H1/5;682=>4/815:054F0=>89=126:0@21;:8/025071=8/: :>8F02@ 1 ;17G 8< 719=082 8 A4 ?/470:4 =>4 2:9/1274 - 6 - 8B?126>15:?470<071;;6782=42545=>1=F0=>89=17=031=02@=>4 >1H1/5 ;0@>=: 8/ 126 8=>4/ 025071=8/: =>4 =/10;4/ F1: ?1/G45 1;82@=>4/815:054025071=02@171/4;4::1??/817> >4/0A921;>1:/4C47=45=>41??;071=08282=>/447892=:) >47;10B?4=0=082F0;;A450:B0::45<8/282$ C80254/ 8< 2474::1/6 ?1/=04: 0< =>4 =/10;4/ 5/034/(8F24/0:1=<19;=<8/=>41770542= >4 7;10B ?4=0=082 F0;; A4 50:B0::45 0< =>4 54741:45 F1: 1 C802= =8/=<41:8/ 02 =>4 0270542= < =>4/4 0: 782=/0A9=8/6 24@;0@4274 =>4 2:9/1274 8B?126 0: ;01A;4 =8 ?16 =>4 78B?42:1=082 >4/41:82:1::0@245<8/=>4/4C47=0821/492=421A;4>4 /41:820:1??1/42=>4 2:9/1274 8B?12602=425:=80B?;415 =>4 8F24/ 8< =>4 /10;4/ 82 =>4 :8;4 @/8925 =>1= =>4 ;17G 8< 719=082F1:430542=1:=>4/10;4/F1:?1/G4582=>4:0548<=>4 /815 F0=>89= 126 025071=8/: 8/ >1H1/5 ;0@>=: 0342 =>4 70/79B:=1274:8<=>4921==42545=/10;4/82=>4:>89;54/8<=>4 /815 F0=>89= >1H1/5 ;0@>=: =>4 ?/4:4274 8< =>4 0B?;41502@ - 7 - 1??;0712= 0: 0B?4/1=034 >4 8/54/ ?1::45 A6 =>4 /0A921; 0: ;01A;4=8A4:4=$1:054778/502@;60=0::4=$1:054 >4 /0= 8< 4/=08/1/0 0: 8/54/45 >4 8/54/ 51=45 !!?1::45A6=>4/;4208/ 030;95@4125 4BA4/ $ 0C161?9/ 02 8!""(" 3054 224D9/4$ 0: E91:>45>40B?;41502@1??;071=0820:1;;8F45>4/01; 89/= 0:50/47=45=850:?8:48<=>471:41:4D?450=089:;61:?8::0A;4 F0=>021289=4/;0B0=8<<034B82=>:</8B=>4/4740?=8<74/=0<045 78?68<=>0:8/54/ 4:9;=12=;6=>4/0=4=0=0820: !" () &%!$$' % # 0:=8);8)