Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43457 (KAR)

SHRI PRALHAD AND ORS v. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/203122/2023 · 2025-09-23

Jyoti Mulimani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $" % %!"" &' ! " " # # $ % & '' Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' " '' $ % ( # ! # & ( ' ' ' # ' ( ' )* +,-.,-/,0123456072+/8696/,/,246+5-4:+,-08-+ -2 -024; <,/8 +,-00,=-+>34 -83=-+ 72+ /86 +65924:64/5-996-+6:,496+524 86 <+,/ 96/,/,24 ,5 7,06: 566=,4; /86 72002<,4; +60,675 -& 2,5536-<+,/276+/,2+-+,2+-:,+61/,24/2?3-58/86 2+:6+ :-/6: " ,4 ',06 42 "" 9-556: @A /86 7,+5/ +65924:64/ -3/82+,/A-5,006;-0-4:-+@,/+-+A.,:6 446B3+6 - 3 - @& 2,5536-<+,/27-4:-C35:,+61/,4;+65924:64/5 -4: 42/ /2 :606/6 /86 4-C6 27 /86 96/,/,246+5 ,4 +65961/ 27 A2D %DE& C6-53+,4; " 1+65 5,/3-/6:-/ C-0-93+ ,00-;6-03=--4:,5/+,1/,:-+ " 8696/,/,24-.6+C64/5-+6/8656 / ,5 5/-/6: /8-/ /86 96/,/,246+5* ;+-4:9-+64/5 ,6 -+-5-99- 234:-99- -4: C/-0-CC- (2-+-5-99- <6+6 ,5536: <,/8 )* '2+C 34:6+ '2+C 2D ,4 +65961/ 27 /86 92+/,24 27 0-4: ,4 A2D C6-53+,4; " 1+65 5,416 /86A <6+6 ,4 /86 130/,.-/,24 27 /86 5-C6 86 0-4: ,4 A2D /2/-00A C6-53+,4; F 1+65 34/-5 <-5 2+,;,4-00A 2.6+4C64/-+-C982= -4:-4:/86+6<-5-+676+6416/2/86 96+5245 @6024;,4; /2 /86 186:306: -5/6 12CC34,/A ,4 130/,.-/,2427/865-,:0-4:72+-024;/,C6-596+/86+692+/27 /866.643645961/2+-4:461655-+A64/+,65<6+6C-:6,4/86 96+/-,4,4;/2/860-4:5,416FDDF/,00FF"F3+53-4/ /2 /86 ,553-416 27 '2+C /86 4-C6 27 96/,/,246+5* ;+-4:9-+64/5 <6+6 :30A +67061/6: ,4 /86 +6.6436 +612+:5 96+/-,4,4; /2 /86 0-4: @6-+,4; A2D C6-53+,4; /2 -4 6B/64/ 27" 1+657+2C FFF 24<-+:5 7/6+ /86:6-/8 27 - 4 - /86,+ ;+-4:9-+64/5 /86 4-C6 27 96/,/,246+5* 7-/86+ -,:-99- 2-+-5-99- <-5 C3/-/6: ,4 /86 7/6+ /86 :6-/8 27 /86,+ 7-/86+ /86 4-C6 27 /86 96/,/,246+5 -+6 C3/-/6: ,4 /86 / ,5 5-,: /8-/ /86+6 <-5 - +6?3,+6C64/ 72+ /86 65/-@0,58C64/ 27 - 2.6+4C64/ 18220 -/ C-0-93+ ,00-;6 6416 /86 ::,/,24-0 693/A 2CC,55,246+ 8-: 523;8/ ,472+C-/,247+2C/86693/A2456+.-/2+27'2+65/566=,4;/86 461655-+A ,472+C-/,24 +6;-+:,4; 0-4: ,4 A2D C6-53+,4; F 1+6534/-527 C-0-93+ ,00-;6.,:612++65924:6416 :-/6:-4:,4+6592456/2/865-,:06//6+/86277,16 27 /86 /8,+: +65924:64/ ,5536: 10-+,7,1-/,24 /8-/ /86 0-4: ,4 A2D ,5 46,/86+ - 42/,7,6: 42+ - +656+.6: 72+65/ 34:6+ 61/,2427/86'2+65/ 1/42+,5,/-:66C6:72+65/G82<6.6+ ,/,5-)*-4:)*10-550-4:@6,4;/+-4576++6:@A/866.6436 69-+/C64/,47-.2+27/86'2+65/69-+/C64/ 86 96/,/,246+5 124/64: /8-/ /86A <6+6 ,5536: <,/8 - 42/,16@A/86277,1627/867,+5/+65924:64/@-56:24/86-006;6: +692+/ +616,.6: @A /86 /8,+: +65924:64/ +6;-+:,4; /86 -006;6: 641+2-18C64/ -4: /86 5-C6 @6,4; /86 :66C6: 72+65/ -5 /86 - 5 - -85,0:-+ ,:-+ 8-4:6: 2.6+ /86 5-,: 0-4: /2 /86 '2+65/ 69-+/C64/.,:606//6+:-/6:DFDF-4:/86+672+6523;8/ /2124:31/-4,4?3,+A8696/,/,246+53@C,//6:-00/86+612+:5 96+/-,4,4; /2 /86 0-4: -4: 523;8/ /2 :+29 /86 9+2166:,4;5 2<6.6+ /86 /8,+: +65924:64/ 7,06: -42@>61/,24 +60A,4; 3924 /86 0,5/ 27 )* -4: )* 0-4:5 523;8/ /2 @6 /+-4576++6: @A /86 -85,0:-+ ,4 7-.2+ 27 /86 '2+65/ 69-+/C64/ -56: 24 /86 124/64/,24 +-,56: @A /86 /8,+: +65924:64/ /86 55,5/-4/ 2CC,55,246+ 9+2166:6: /2 820: /8-/ /86 -85,0:-+ 8-: 42 -3/82+,/A /2 ,5536 /86 2+:6+ 27 ;+-4/ @A 124/64:,4; /8-/ /86 0-4:@6,4;0-55)*-4:)*34130/,.-@060-4:-4:/865-C6<-5 8-4:6: 2.6+ /2 /86 '2+65/ 69-+/C64/ ,4 FDF / ,5 -052 2@56+.6: /8-/ /86 53@>61/ 0-4: 7-005 <,/8,4 " =C5 +-:,35 27 ,:-+ 34,1,9-0 ,C,/5 86416 ;+-4/ C-:6 @A /86 -85,0:-+ ,5 124/+-+A /2 306 %,.& 27 /86 #-+4-/-=- -4: +-4/ 3065 FF-4:9+2166:6:/2820:/8-//8653@>61/0-4:,5/86'2+65/ -4:-4:42/-6.6436 -4:-4:/869+2.,5,24527#-+4-/-=- -4:+-4/3065-+642/-990,1-@06-4:56/-5,:6/862+:6+27 -85,0:-+ ,553,4; '2+C -4: /86 5-C6 <-5 1-416006: -4: :,+61/6:/860-4:/2@6+653C6:-4:.65/6:,4/862.6+4C64/ 7+667+2C-006413C@+-4165@A:,+61/,4;/86-85,0:-+/2C-=6 - 6 - 64/+,65 ,4 /86 -5 H'2+65/ 69-+/C64/ 2.6+4C64/ 27 #-+4-/-=-* ,4 822C, 27/<-+6 .,:6 2+:6+ :-/6: " 4:6+/86561,+13C5/-4165/8696/,/,246+,5@672+6/8,523+/ 234560 72+ /86 +65961/,.6 9-+/,65 3+;6: 56.6+-0 124/64/,245 +;,4; 56.6+-0 124/64/,245 1234560 72+ /86 96/,/,246+ 90-16:+60,-41624/86:61,5,24,4 # ,4 ( 2F :,59256: 2724 86 5/-/6C64/ 27 2@>61/,245 ,5 42/ 7,06: @A /86 2.6+4C64/ 2<6.6+ 3+;,4; 56.6+-0 124/64/,245 /86 2.6+4C64/90-16:+60,-41624/8672002<,4;:61,5,245 & ' # # ( I D"FD"FF & ' I (% & DFF ' FF "& ' ID - 7 - 6-+: /86 -+;3C64/5 -4: 96+356: /86 (+,/ 9-96+5 <,/8 1-+6 86 7-1/5 -+6 5377,1,64/0A 5-,: -4: :2 42/ +6?3,+6 +6,/6+-/,2486,5536+6.20.65-+234:/866B6+1,5627/8692<6+ @A /86 55,5/-4/ 2CC,55,246+ 34:6+ /86 9+2.,5,245 27 /86 #-+4-/-=- -4:6.6436 1/F377,16,//242/6/8-//86 0-4: ,4 A2D C6-53+,4; F 1+65 34/-5 5,/3-/6: -/ C-0-93+ ,00-;6<-5-2.6+4C64/-+-C982= -4:-4:/86 5-C6 <-5 34:6+ 130/,.-/,24 27 34-3/82+,J6: 96+5245 4:6+ - 2/,7,1-/,242" F:-/6:F"FF/86-8-5,0:-+ ,5536:-6+/,7,1-/627-;3.-0,8,/ /,5-+;36:24@68-0727/862.6+4C64//8-//860-4:,4 ?365/,24,50-55)*-4:)*34130/,.-@060-4:-4:/86-85,0:-+ .,:606//6+DFDF/+-4576++6:-4:8-4:6:2.6+/860-4:/2 /86'2+65/69-+/C64//,5-+;36:24@68-0727/8696/,/,246+ /8-/ /86 0-4: ,4 A2D ,5 46,/86+ - 42/,7,6: 42+ - +656+.6: 72+65/ 34:6+ 61/,24 27 /86 '2+65/ 1/ 42+ ,5 ,/ - :66C6: 72+65/ 24 ,45/+31/,24 53@C,/5 /8-/ 2/,7,1-/,24 34:6+ 61/,24,542/,5536:,4+65961/270-4:55,/3-/6:-/ C-0-93+ ,00-;6 - 8 - ;+6-/:6-027-+;3C64/,5-::+6556:-@23/561/,2427 /86'2+65/ 1/86=6A-5961/527/86-+;3C64/-+66B-C,46: 61/,24 27 /86 '2+65/ 1/ :6-05 <,/8 42/,7,1-/,24 @A /86 ;2.6+4C64/-4:,/+6-:5-572002<5 61/,242/,7,1-/,24@A2.6+4C64/I%&(8646.6+,/ 8-5@664:61,:6:/21245/,/3/6-4A0-4:-+656+.6:72+65//86 /-/62.6+4C64/58-00,5536-42/,7,1-/,24 %-& :610-+,4; /8-/ ,/ 8-5 @664:61,:6: /21245/,/3/6 53180-4:-+656+.6:72+65/G %@& 5961,7A,4; -5 46-+0A -5 9255,@06 /86 5,/3-/,24 -4:0,C,/52753180-4:G-4: %1& -992,4/,4; -4 277,16+ %86+6,4-7/6+ 1-006: /86 K'2+65/ 6//06C64/ 77,16+L& /2 ,4?3,+6 ,4/2 -4: :6/6+C,46 /86 6B,5/6416 4-/3+6 -4: 6B/64/ 27 -4A +,;8/5 10-,C6: @A 2+ -006;6: /2 6B,5/ ,4 7-.23+ 27 -4A 96+524 ,4 2+ 2.6+ -4A 0-4: 12C9+,56: <,/8,4 5318 0,C,/5 2+ ,4 2+ 2.6+ -4A 72+65/ 9+2:316 -4: /2 :6-0 <,/8 /86 5-C6 -5 9+2.,:6:,4/8,58-9/6+ - 9 - %& 86 277,16+ -992,4/6: 34:6+ 10-356 %1& 27 53@ 561/,24 %& 58-00 @6 - 96+524 42/ 820:,4; -4A 72+65/ 277,16 6B169/ /8-/ 27 '2+65/ 6//06C64/ 77,16+G@3/-'2+65/ 77,16+C-A@6-992,4/6:@A /86 /-/6 2.6+4C64/ /2 +69+6564/ ,/ ,4 /86 ,4?3,+A 34:6+ /8,5 8-9/6+ @A /86 '2+65/ 6//06C64/ 77,16+ 86 2.6+4C64/ 8-5 90-16: +60,-416 24 - 5/-/6C64/ 582<,4; /86 +6C-,4,4; )* -4: )* 0-55 0-4: %2.6+4C64/ -4:& /+-4576++6: /2 /86 '2+65/ 69-+/C64/ 27 -03=- ,:-+ 5,;46: @A /86 -85,0:-+ 24 DFDF /2 124/64: /8-/ /86 72+65/ 0-4: 1230: 42/ 8-.6 @664 ;+-4/6: /2 /86 96/,/,246+5* ;+-4:9-+64/5 -;3.-0, 8,/ 1230: 42/ 8-.6 @664 ,5536: ,4 +65961/27-72+65/0-4:86124/64/,2427/862.6+4C64//8-/ ,/*5-72+65/0-4:1-442/@6535/-,46:-5,/,59,.2/-0/242/6/8-/ /86 '2+65/ 1/ 8-5 12C6 ,4/2 72+16 ,4 F" 82<6.6+ ,4 /86 -@56416 27 - 42/,7,1-/,24 34:6+ 61/,24 27 /86 #-+4-/-=- '2+65/ 1//86-85,0:-+-996-+5/28-.69+69-+6:-5/-/6C64/ /8-/ /86 53@>61/ 0-4: 8-5 @664 /+-4576++6: /2 /86 '2+65/ 69-+/C64/66:0655/25-A/86'2+65/ 1/C-4:-/65,553-416 - 10 - 27-2/,7,1-/,2434:6+61/,24 5-0+6-:A42/6:-@2.6/86+6 ,5422/,7,1-/,2434:6+61/,2427/86#-+4-/-=-'2+65/ 1/ F"86+672+6/86124/64/,2427/862.6+4C64//8-/,/,5- 72+65/0-4:C35/461655-+,0A7-,0 6B/ 06/ C6 1245,:6+ <86/86+ /86 55,5/-4/ 2CC,55,246+1230:8-.64300,7,6:/86'2+C-7/6+-0-95627 -0C25/ /<64/A4,46 A6-+5 86 -45<6+ ,5 42 86 +6-524 ,5 5,C906 86 0-< ,5 <600 56//06: /8-/ /86 92<6+ C35/ @6 6B6+1,56:<,/8,4-+6-524-@06/,C64/869+6564/1-56/86+6 ,5-4,42+:,4-/6:60-A4CA.,6</869+2166:,4;5-+6106-+0A @-++6:@A0-1865'3+/86+C2+6/862.6+4C64/1230:42/8-.6 6B6+1,56:92<6+/21-4160/86;+-4/524/86;+234:/8-//86+6 ,5 - .,20-/,24 27 306 27 /86 #-+4-/-=- -4: 6.6436 3065 23456072+/86+65961/,.69-+/,6590-16:+60,-41624/86 :61,5,245 +676++6: /2 539+- :2 42/ /8,4= /8-/ /86 0-< ,5 ,4 :23@/-18:61,5,24/3+4524,/52<47-1/5869+6564/1-56,5 -052/65/6:,4/860,;8/27/86-72+65-,::61,5,245 - 11 - '2+/86+6-52455/-/6:-@2.6/862+:6+27/86 55,5/-4/ 2CC,55,246+ ,5 0,-@06 /2 @6 56/ -5,:6 112+:,4;0A ,/ ,5 56/ -5,:6 D 86 (+,/ 27 6+/,2+-+, ,5 2+:6+6: 86 +:6+ :-/6: " 9-556: @A /86 55,5/-4/ 2CC,55,246+ ,4 ',06 42 "" .,:6 446B3+6 ,5 ?3-586: 6530/-4/0A/86(+,/6/,/,24,5 61-356 27 /86 :,5925-0 27 /86 (+,/ 6/,/,24 964:,4; ,4/6+0213/2+A -990,1-/,245 ,7 -4A -+6 :,59256: 27 -4: /86 ,4/6+,C:,+61/,24,7-4A5/-4:5:,518-+;6: () &%!""' % # ,5/202"