- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) !! " #!$ % & '!$$ (&& )* !++( & , !++& " #! ' &- &+&&& % Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' (#% ' . ' $ &.&& &&& ' ' $ ! ! ' ! ' ' ' $ /! $ $ # /! $ % 01230 405 677568 9: 89:45; <1= 6;>9::91? @940 405 A1?:5?4 1< 856=?5; A12?:58 <1= 405 76=495: 94 9: 46B5? 27 <1=<9?68;9:71:68 & 09: 677568 9: <985; 6369?:4 405 C2;3>5?4 6?; 6@6=; ;645; &.&& 76::5; DE 405 =9?A9768 5?91= 9F98$2;356?; 686D2=6399? 1&1<&& ( 05 <6A4: 1< 405 A6:5 6=5 4064 1? &&. @0985405A869>6?4681?3@94009:@9<5@5=57=1A55;9?341 09?A06?:11= 1? 6 >141=AEA85 D56=9?3 =539:4=6491? 1(&& 405 =9;5= 1< 6?1405= >141=AEA85 - 3 - D56=9?3 =539:4=6491? 1(&& =1;5 94 9? 0930 :755;6?;=6:06?;?538935?4>6??5=6?;;6:05;41405 >141=AEA85 1< 405 A869>6?4 ;25 41 @09A0 05 <588 1? 405 3=12?;6?;:2:469?5;3=95F12:9?C2=95: 05=5<1=5 05 <985; 6 A869> 7549491? D5<1=5 405 =9D2?68 A869>9?3 A1>75?:6491? 1< :&& 05 =9D2?68 A1?:9;5=9?3 405 5?49=5 5F9;5?A5 1? =5A1=; 3=6?45; A1>75?:6491? 1< :. @940 9?45=5:4 64 G 76 <=1> 405 ;645 1< 7549491? 4988 =5689:6491? 6?; ;9=5A45; =5:71?;5?4 1&?:2=6?A5 1>76?E 41 ;571:94 405:6>5 + 33=95F5;DE405:69;C2;3>5?46?;6@6=;405 9?C2=5; A869>6?4 06: 7=5<5==5; 409: 677568 9? @09A0 94 9: A1?45?;5; 4064 405 6775886?4 @6: ;19?3 A5?45=9?3 @1=B 6?;@6:56=?9?3:&75=>1?40D24405 =9D2?68 5==5; 9? 46B9?3 09: 9?A1>5 64 :(&+ 75= >1?40- 05 :2:469?5; (=; 40 6?; +40 >546A6=768 :4 6?; &?; >546A6=768 D6:5 1< =9304 06?; 6?; <=6A42=5 1< 7=1H9>68 70686?35: 1< &( 6?; +40 415 1? 405 =9304 :9;5 6: 75= - 4 - H@12?; A5=49<9A645 6?; @6: 01:794689:5; <1= ( ;6E: 6?;H.9:405;9:A06=35A6=;6?;H9:405;9:6D9894E A5=49<9A6452?;5=@09A0405 1A41=6::5::5;405;9:6D9894E 64GD24405 =9D2?6806:A1?:9;5=5;405;9:6D9894E1?8E 64 &&G- 405 A1>75?:6491? 3=6?45; 2?;5= 1405= 056;: 9: 9?6;5I2645 05=5<1=5=5I25:45;<1=5?06?A5>5?41<405 A1>75?:6491? 56=;4056=32>5?4:1<D140:9;5: 05 6775886?4 @6: 635; E56=: ;19?3 A5?45=9?3 @1=B 01230 05 :4645; 4064 05 @6: 56=?9?3 :&75=>1?400506:?147=1;2A5;6?E5F9;5?A5 41 7=1F5 09: 9?A1>5 05=5<1=5 6: 75= 405 329;589?5: 1< 4056=?646B6464553685=F9A5:2401=94E405 =9D2?68 06: 46B5?09: ?1491?68 9?A1>5 64 :(&+ 75= >1?40 @09A09:C2:46?;7=175= 056775886?45H6>9?5;405 1A41=6:&6?; 405 1A41= 06: :4645; 4064 405 A869>6?4 06: :2:469?5; ;5381F9?3 A=2:0 9?C2=E 1< =9304 <114 A=2:0 9?C2=E 1< =9304 - 5 - 06?; <=6A42=5 1< (=; 40 +40 >546A6=768 :4 6?; &?; >546A6=768 D6:5 6?; <=6A42=5 1< 7=1H9>68 70686?35: 1< &(6?;+4041@9?405=9304:9;5@09A06=53=95F12:9? ?642=556=?5;A12?:58<1=4056775886?4:4645;4064405 6775886?4 @6: 4=5645; 9? ?642=556=?5;A12?:58<1=4056775886?4:4645;4064405 6775886?4 @6: 4=5645; 9? 01:79468: 6?; 2?;5=@5?4 :2=35=95:6?;68:101:794689:5;<1=(;6E: 05;1A41= 06: 6::5::5; 405 ;9:6D9894E 64 G 05 =9D2?68 06: A1?:9;5=5; (=; 1< 94 6: &&G 25 41 405 9?C2=95: :2:469?5; 9? 405 6AA9;5?4 405 <2?A491?68 ;9:6D9894E 1< 405 6775886?4 >9304 06F5 6<<5A45; 3=1::8E 05=5<1=5 409: 12=4<9?;:94=56:1?6D854146B509:;9:6D9894E64(G . 1?:9;5=9?3 405 635 1< 405 6775886?4 405 >28497895=1<(6;1745;DE405 =9D2?689:C2:46?;7=175= 05=5DE 405 81:: 1< <242=5 56=?9?3: A1>5: 41 :(&+H&H(H(GJ:& 05 =9D2?68 06: 3=6?45; 6 :2> 1< :++ 41@6=;: >5;9A68 5H75?:5: 6?; 94 ?55;: ?1 9?45=<5=5?A5 - 6 - & 1?:9;5=9?3 405 ?642=5 1< 9?C2=95: 75=91; 1< 01:794689:6491? 6?; 1405= <6A41=: 409: 12=4 <9?;: 94 =56:1?6D85 41 5?06?A5 405 6>12?4 6@6=;5; DE 405 =9D2?6841@6=;:769?6?;:2<<5=9?341:81:: 1< 6>5?9495: 41 : 6?; ;954 6?; 6445?;6?4 A06=35:41:+ ( 05 6775886?4 >9304 ?14 06F5 6445?;5; 6?E @1=B64856:4<1=675=91;1<:9H>1?40: 05=5<1=5059: 5?49485; <1= :.+ #(&+ H % 41@6=;: 81:: 1< 9?A1>5;2=9?3869;2775=91; 5?A54056775886?49:5?49485;<1=405>1;9<95; A1>75?:6491?2?;5=;9<<5=5?4056;:6:D581@ 69?6?;:2<<5=9?3 : 5;9A685H75?:5: :++ 1::1<<242=556=?9?3: :& 1::1<9?A1>5;2=9?3869;2775=91; :.+ 9546?;6445?;6?4A06=35: :+ 1::1<6>5?9495: : 1468 5::6@6=;5;DE =9D2?68 ?06?A5>5?4 :((+ :. * +, - 7 - 02: 405 6775886?4 9: 5?49485; <1= 5?06?A5; A1>75?:6491? 1< :&.(+ @940 9?45=5:4 64 G 75= 6??2>6?;405=5<1=5405677568;5:5=F5:41D56881@5;9? 76=4 + ?405=5:284405<1881@9?31=;5=9:76::5; #9% 775689:6881@5;9?76=4 #99% 05 6775886?4A869>6?4 9: 5?49485; <1= 405 5?06?A5; A1>75?:6491? 1< :&.(+ @940 9?45=5:4 64 G 75= 6??2> <=1> 405 ;645 1< 7549491? 4988 405 ;645 1< =5689:6491? #999% 5:71?;5?4 1&?:2=6?A5 1>76?E 9: ;9=5A45; 41 ;571:94 405 6<1=5:69; A1>75?:6491? 6>12?4 @9409?1?5>1?40<=1>405;6451<409:C2;3>5?4 #9F% ? :2A0 ;571:94 405 6775886?4 9: 75=>9445; 41 @940;=6@ 405 5?49=5 6>12?4 681?3 @940 9?45=5:4 6AA=25; 1?94 *-. &% ( $ 9:4181(