- 1 - ! " # $ ! %&# $ %&# ' $$ ! " # ()##) & )# $ * &# Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * + %&# $ * $ * , * $ %#& ' #- $ - $ ! * & #! #)*#. / ! .& #)*#. * $ " " - 3 - " ! 0123 450 6012703 8(97:06 1;;012<7= >(2 450 1;;066174:17316:(45060127038(97:061;;012<7=>(2450 20:;(73074: 5<: ?2<4 1;;016 <: ><603 8516607=<7= 450 (2302 ;1::03 @A 450 6012703 <7=60 93=0 <7 (#)*#. 31403 .& ?5020<7 450 6012703 <7=60 93=0 51B<7= 8(7:<30203 450 C1402<16 8(C0: 4( 450 8(7869:<(7 4514 450 06084<(7 (CC<4400 ?074@0A(73450402C:(>45020829<4C0747(4<><814<(7173 51: 1?12303 C12D: 4(45020:;(73074 (& ?5<85 50 3<3 7(4(@B<(9:6A30:02B017345<:51:20:96403<71?2(7=>96 1;;(<74C07451B<7=@007C130501;;(<74C074(>450 20:;(73074(&<:188(23<7=6AE91:503 50 6012703 <7=60 93=0 16:( 41D07 7(40 (> 450 C12D:1?12303<7<7402B<0?4514<:1:;02450;2(B<:<(716 C02<4 6<:4 450 70F4 C(:4 C02<4(2<(9: 8173<3140 ?1: 450 ;04<4<(70251B<7=:089203)&&.>450C12D:1?123034( 20:;(73074 (& <: 0:850?03 173 <4 <: 1::9C03 4514 50 - 4 - ?1:=<B07#C12D:@A166450><B0C0C@02:(>06084<(7 (CC<44000B07450750?(963@0074<46034((76A) 1: 1=1<7:4 )& 173 45<: ?(963 20:964 <7 450 ;04<4<(702 @0<7= C(20 C02<4(2<(9: 51B<7= :089203 )&&. <780 450 ;04<4<(702 ?(963 @0 450 C(:4 C02<4(2<(9: 8173<3140 0B07 1:;02450C12D:1?12303@A45006084<(7(CC<44001 3<2084<(7 513 @007 <::903 4( 450 20:;(73074 ( 4( 1;;(<74 450 ;04<4<(702 1: 1 6<7<816 :A85(6(=<:4 <7 450 ;6180(>20:;(73074(&0780166(?03450;04<4<(7 5060127038(97:061;;012<7=>(21;;066174:?(963 B050C0746A 8(74073 4514 450 6012703 <7=60 93=0 51: 8(CC<4403 17 022(2 <7 166(?<7= 450 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 173 E91:5<7= 450 0126<02 7(4<><814<(7 173 =9<306<70: <::903 <7 450 7(4<><814<(7 173 450 :1C0 (9=54 7(4 4( 51B0 @007 3(70 7 B<0? (> :9@:0E90746A 817806<7= (> 450 0126<02 7(4<><814<(7 <7 450 C017: (> 70? 7(4<><814<(7 31403 #%#, B<30 770F920 (9=54 7(4 4( 51B0 206<03 9;(7450><2:47(4<><814<(7<0770F920 - 5 - & 50 6012703 8(97:06 16:( B050C0746A 8(74073 4514 450B02A1;;2(185(>4506012703<7=6093=0<:022(70(9: 173 450 20:;(73074 ( 51B<7= >96><6603 450 06<=<@<6<4A 82<402<1 ?1: 396A 8(7:<30203 >(2 450 ;(:4 173 188(23<7=6A ?1:396A<::903?<451;;(<74C074(230231403##% 51B<7=8(C;604035<:;2(@14<(712A;02<(3392<7=;073078A (> 450 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 173 @0<7= 30861203 4( @0 450 ;02C17074 0C;6(A00 (> 450 7:4<494<(7 <: :(9=54 4( @0 3<:492@03@AB<2490(>450<C;9=703(230220>022<7=4(450 7(7 0F<:4<7= 82<402<1 173 ?<45(94 :044<7= 1:<30 450 1;;(<74C074(2302<::903<7>1B(92(>20:;(73074(<: 5<=56A<660=1617320E9<20:4(@0<7402>0203?<45 50 6012703 8(97:06 16:( B050C0746A 8(74073 4514 450 06084<(7 (CC<4400 51: 396A 8(7:<30203 450 ;02>(2C1780 <7 450 <7402B<0? ?5<60 1::<=7<7= 450 C12D: @1:03(7450;02>(2C17801734500F;02<0780173<7450 1@:0780(>17A;2((>450;2(80::13(;403@A45006084<(7 (CC<4400 8(963 7(4 51B0 @007 <7402>0203 ?<45 @A 450 6012703<7=6093=0 - 6 - ) 1B<7=5012345060127038(97:06>(24501;;066174: 173450C1402<161B1<61@60(7208(23450<C;9=703(2302 ;1::03@A4506012703<7=6093=045<:(92451:4(41D0 7(40 (> 770F920 31403 #%#, ?5020<7 20829<4C074>(2450B18174;(:4:<7B12<(9:30;124C07414 <312 7:4<4940 (> 03<816 8<0780: <312 173 3041<6: 120 16:(=<B07?<4520=1234(450?16D <7 <7402B<0?7(4<><814<(7 ?5020<7450C045(3(>:06084<(782<402<1<:16:(C074<(703 173 :9@:0E90746A 1>402 450 <::91780 (> 770F920 1 8(22<=0739C?1:<::9031:;02770F920 ?5020<7450 ;(:4 (> 6<7<816 :A85(6(=<:4: <: 0F869303 >2(C ?16D <7 <7402B<0?>(2B12<(9:;(:4>(2<3124(@05063(7 ##.#,1417=16(2050;(:4(>6<7<816:A85(6(=<:4 ?<66@0816603:0;121406A1B<7=<::903450770F920: 173 173 :9@:0E90746A 9;(7 770F920 31403 #%.#, <: <::903 (76A <7 20:;084 (> 6<7<816 :A85(6(=<:4 :0;121406A 173 ?5020<7 450 C045(3 (> :06084<(7 <: (7 450 @1:<: (> %G E916<>A<7= 0F1C<714<(7 C12D:173#C12D:>(2<7402B<0?50C02<46<:41::0::03 - 7 - (7 450 @1:<: (> ;02>(2C1780 (> 450 1;;6<8174 173 450 C12D:(@41<703<7450<7402B<0?450:1C0<:H9:4(;;(:<40 4(450C045(3(>:06084<(7:1:C074<(703<7770F920 , 50 6012703 <7=60 93=0 16:( 41D07 7(40 (> 450 C045(3 (> :06084<(7 1: ;20:82<@03 <7 770F920 770F920 173 16:( 770F920 ?5<85 <: ;61803 (7 208(2316(7=?<4545<:1;;016?5<85860126A3<:86(:0:4514 450 :0608403 8173<3140 =(4 (76A 18130C<8 ;0280741=0 (> )# 173 16:( 0F4218403 450 :1C0 <7 450 (2302 51B<7= 1?12303 450 C12D: <7 450 <7402B<0? 1: #&, 1=1<7:4 # 17316:(41D077(40(>4508173<3140?5(5138516607=03 <7 450 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 <0 6(& ?5( =(4 450 18130C<8 ;0280741=0(>,1731664508(CC<4400C0C@02:=<B07 8(7:<:40746AC12D:0185173<720:;084(>450:0608403 8173<3140 166 450 8(CC<4400 C0C@02: 51B0 =<B07 # # #) # 173 # C12D: 0185 ?5<85 C1D0: #&,50?2<4;04<4<(702?1:1?12303(76AC12D:@A 166 450 C0C@02: 173 450 :1C0 <: 16:( 41D07 7(40 @A 450 6012703 <7=60 93=0 173 770F920 <: B02A 860126A - 8 - 3<:86(:0:4514<4<:7(45<7=@94><:5A<7450C14402?5<60<7 450;2(80::(>:06084<(7 % 50 8173<3140 ?5( <: 162013A ?(2D<7= <7 1 B02A :1C0 7:4<494<(7 :5(?7 >1B(2<4<:C 173 450 :1C0 <: 16:( 41D07 7(40 @A 450 6012703 <7=60 93=0 173 450 B02A ;2(80::<:<660=16 . 50 6012703 <7=60 93=0 0B07 <7 450 (2302 ;124<896126A<7;121=21;5(&0F4218403450C12D:?5<85 51B0 @007 1?12303 @A 450 06084<(7 (CC<4400 173 ;124<896126A <7 ;121=21;5 ( 3<:89::03 450 :1C0 ?<45 20=123 4( 450 1B021=0 (> #&, C12D: @A 450 06084<(7 (CC<4400 C0C@02: <7 20:;084 (> 20:;(73074 (& 173 1?12303(76AC12D:@A166450C0C@02:<720:;084(> 450;04<4<(702<7450?2<4;04<4<(7 # 50 6012703 <7=60 93=0 16:( 41D07 7(40 (> 450 0126<02 7(4<><814<(7 <0 770F920 173 16:( 450 :9@:0E9074 9;(7 770F920 1: ?066 1: <7 ;121=21;5 (# 8140=(2<8166A C130 17 (@:02B14<(7 4514 (94 (> 450 - 9 - # C12D: # C12D: 8(963 @0 1?12303 (76A <> 450 8173<3140 ;(::0::03 450 :;08<><8 E916<><814<(7 173 1 C1F<C9C (> C12D: (76A 8(963 @0 1?12303 >(2 450 ;02>(2C1780<7450<7402B<0?1:;02I770F920 / ## 7 ;121=21;5 (## 16:( 41D07 7(40 (> 1: 1=1<7:4 450C1F<C9C(>C12D:45148(96351B0@007=217403 @A450(CC<440017<C;(::<@60:9C(>#C12D:51B0 @0071?12303?5<85<:860126A<C;02C<::<@60 # 50 6012703 <7=60 93=0 16:( 41D07 7(40 (> 450 C1402<161B1<61@60(7208(23?5<858(C0:4(18(7869:<(7 45141B02A06084<(7(CC<4400?074@0A(73450402C: (>45020829<4C0747(4<><814<(717351:1?12303C12D:4( 450 20:;(7303 (& ?5<85 50 3<3 7(4 (@B<(9:6A 30:02B0 173 45<: 51: 20:96403 <7 1 ?2(7=>96 1;;(<74C074 51B<7= @007 C130 50 1;;(<74C074 (> 450 20:;(73074 (& <: 188(23<7=6AE91:503 # 50 201:(7: 1::<=703 @A 450 6012703 <7=60 93=0 ;124<896126A 41D<7= 7(40 450 C045(3 (> :06084<(7 1: - 10 - C074<(703 <7 770F920 173 45(9=5 6012703 8(97:06 1;;012<7= >(2 450 1;;066174: <7 5<: 12=9C074 ?(963 B050C0746A 8(74073 4514 14 450 4<C0 (> <::91780 (> 770F920 <0><2:47(4<><814<(745020?1:7(1320173 0829<4C074 960: >(2 :5(24 I J 960:/! @94 16:( 8140=(2<8166A13C<4:4514144504<C0(><::91780(>:08(73 7(4<><814<(7 45020 ?1: 16:( 7( 17A J 960: 2<4 <7 450714920(>8024<(212<><603?514C130450C4(?<45321? 4500126<027(4<><814<(7173<::903450:08(737(4<><814<(7 7(45<7=<:17:?0203@A45060127038(97:06?5(1;;012: (7 @0516> (> 450 1;;066174: 4( :9@:4174<140 5<: 12=9C074 17316:(450C1402<161B1<61@60(7208(237(:985C1402<16 173 :08(73 7(4<><814<(7 <: <::903 (76A 4( 188(CC(3140 450<2(?78173<3140173:08(737(4<><814<(7<:16:((76A4( 45<:;(:4173(4502;(:47(:98517A7(4<><814<(7 #& 1B<7=8(7:<30203450C045(3(>:06084<(7<7402C: (> 770F920 1: ?066 1: :;08<><8 C045(3 (> :06084<(7 C074<(703 <7 770F920 <4 860126A 3<:86(:0: 4514 450 06084<(7 (CC<4400 (76A ?<45 17 <74074<(7 4( - 11 - 188(CC(3140 450 20:;(73074 (& <7 450 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 <::903 450 :08(73 7(4<><814<(7 173 16:( :;08<><8166A C074<(703 1 C045(3 (> :06084<(7 ;20:82<@<7= %G 4( 450 18130C<8 C12D: 173 450 # C12D: >(2 :06084<(7 ?<45(94 17A =9<306<70: >(2 1?123<7= 450 C12D: <7 450 :06084<(7 ;2(80::?5<85860126A3<:86(:0:<7770F920 30;<84:4514 1 >1B(2<4<:C <: C130 @A 450 06084<(7 (CC<4400 185 06084<(7(CC<4400C0C@02:1?12303(76AC12D:4( 450 ;04<4<(702 <7 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 173 8(C;12<7= 4( 450 770F920 0F80;4 450 8173<3140 ?5( =(4 450 5<=50:4 C12D:(>,G<745018130C<81?123030E9166A@A166 4508(CC<4400C0C@02:?<4517 <74074<(74(;20B074450 ;04<4<(702<7450?2<4;04<4<(77(44(=04C(20C12D:<7450 <7402B<0? ?<45 17 <74074<(7 4( 188(CC(3140 450 :0608403 8173<3140 5020>(20 41D<7= 166 450:0 >184(2: <74( 8(7:<30214<(74506012703<7=6093=02<=546A;1::03450 (2302173?03(7(4><7317AC02<4<74501;;016><603@A 4501;;066174: - 12 - # 50 6012703 8(97:06 1;;012<7= >(2 450 1;;066174: 16:( @2(9=54 4( 7(4<80 (> 45<: (924 4514 450 1==2<0B03 8173<3140162013A><603171;;016@0>(2045<:(92445020 <: 7( 0F;61714<(7 @A 450:0 1;;066174: 4( ><60 45<: ;20:074 ?2<41;;016 #) 5020 <: 1 3061A (> &. 31A: <7 ><6<7= 450 ;20:074 ?2<4 1;;016 50 1==2<0B03 ;124A 162013A 1;;2(18503 @0>(20 45<: (924 @94 7( 0F;61714<(7 (7 450 ;124 (> 450 1;;066174:<7><6<7=45<:1;;016@0614036A<01>40261;:0(> &. 31A: 7 450 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 ?5020 ?2<4 (> 8024<(212< <: :(9=54?<4559=0(>3061A <4<:7(45<7=@94171@9:0(> ;2(80::(>61?0780<4<:1><481:04(3<:C<::4501;;016 ?<4517 0F0C;612A 8(:4 0780 45<:1;;016 <: ?<45 17 0F0C;612A 8(:4 (> :#* 9;00: 70 1D5 76A!(94(>4514G<:;1A1@604(45020:;(73074 ( ?5( <: 450 :9880::(2 <7 450 ?2<4 ;04<4<(7 173 20C1<7<7= G :5166 B0:4 ?<45 450 4140 1A 450 8(:4 ?<45<7 4?( ?00D: > 7(4 ;1<3 0=<:42A <: 3<208403 4( 208(B02450:1C0<7188(231780?<4561? - 13 - #, 50;073<7=:3(7(4:92B<B0>(28(7:<30214<(7<7 B<0?(>3<:;(:16(>4501;;016 !" #" <:4("#6(" "