Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43437 (KAR)

KASHINATH v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200261/2025 · 2025-09-11

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $%&$'$ '' ( !" ! # !" !" $ % !" ! !" & '$ ( ) * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) + %! ! ! " & ' ( ) '!( ) '( !% !%! , !%!%! " -' ( * !%!) ) )) -'!( -'!( -'( '( '!( "'!( % ! !'( '!( * -% ) !%! '('.('/( '!('0( ) ' ) ( * ) ) !%!%! ) $ * 1$ - 3 - #! ' 1$ ( 23455366478/93:7;4<<=/3> ?"8?-4.3/33@:7; ;.478?A.3;=64.94:6:7.:B3 ? !%!?A647>?6:<3 848:?7 4649=.4;: >:/8.:<8 C:82:7 823 D=.:/>:<8:?7 ?A 634.73> >>:8:?746 :/8.:<8 47> 3//:?7/ $=>;3 4649=.4;: .3;:/83.3> A?. 823 ?AA37<3/ 5=7:/24963 =7>3. 3<8:?7/ -'!(-'!(-'( '( '!("'!( % ! !'( '!( .34> C:82 3<8:?7 -% ?A 24.48:E4 E4E4472:84!%!'A?./2?.8F !%!,(47> =7>3. 3<8:?7/ '('.('/( 47> '!('0( ?A 823 <23>=63> 4/83/47><23>=63> .:93/'.30378:?7?A8.?<:8:3/(<8 - -'A?./2?.8F '(<8,( ! 34.> .: 4D3/2 ?>>4B47: 634.73> ?=7/36 A?.823455366478/47>.: ?546@.:/2744>40634.73> :;2 ?=.8 ?03.7B378 634>3. A?. .3/5?7>378 ? + 8483 47> .3/5?7>378 ?! + <?B564:7478 3.=/3> 823 B483.:46/?7.3<?.> - 4 - 7 0:3C ?A 823 .:046 <?78378:?7/ =.;3> 9E 823 634.73><?=7/36A?.9?8282354.8:3/8235?:788248C?=6> 4.:/3A?.BE<?7/:>3.48:?7:/ !"#$% E47/C3.8?82349?035?:78:/:7823F , A?.823A?66?C:7; 23 :7A?.B478 93:7; 823 A4823.:764C ?A 823 >3<34/3>6?>;3>A:./8:7A?.B48:?74;4:7/84<<=/3> ?/8? A?. 240:7; <4=/3> 823 >3482 ?A 823 >3<34/3> 47> 4//4=68:7; 823 3E3C:873//3/ =.:7; :703/8:;48:?7 823/3 455366478/ C3.3 455.3237>3> 4..4E:7; 823B 4/ 4<<=/3> ?C823:703/8:;48:?7:/<?B56383>47><24.;3/233824/ 9337A:63>47>823455366478/4.34..4E3>4/4<<=/3> ?/" 8?- - 5 - /53.<?6=B7 ?G?A823<24.;3/2338:8C4/ 4<<=/3> ?/ 8? C:82 <?BB?7 :78378:?7 8? <4=/3 823 >3482?A823>3<34/3>4//4=683>2:BC:82<6=94/4.3/=68 ?AC2:<223>:3>?7823/5?8<<=/3> ?/8?2403 4//4=683> * C:82 823 /4B3 C345?7 47> <4=/3> :7D=.:3/8?2:B 23.34A83.4<<=/3> ?/"8?%<4B38? 823/5?8<?7/5:.3>C:824<<=/3> ?47>4668234<<=/3> 2403A63>A.?B823/5?88://8483>8248**8? *-4.38233E3C:873//3/8?823:7<:>378 " 8 :/ 9.?=;28 8? 823 7?8:<3 ?A 82:/ ?=.8 8248 4<<=/3> ?%4;4:7/8C2?B/:B:64.4663;48:?7/4.3B4>3 :/ 3764.;3> ?7 94:6 4/ 53. 823 ?.>3. >483> % !%! :7 .:B:746 55346 ?!%%!%!%! :7<3 823 ?03.84<8/ .3;4.>:7; 4//4=68:7; 47> <4=/:7; 823 >3482 ?A 823 >3<34/3> 47> 46/? <4=/:7; :7D=.:3/ 8? 823 3E3C:873// :/ 4;4:7/84<<=/3> ?/8?/:7<37??03.84<8/4.34663;3> 4;4:7/8 5.3/378 455366478/ 47> /:7<3 823 455366478/ 4.3 378:863>8?8239373A:8?A54.:8EC:824<<=/3> ?%4B - 6 - ?A823?5:7:?78248823455366478/4.3378:863>A?.;.478?A 94:6 G ?7/:>3.:7;466823/3A4<8/47><:.<=B/847<3/ 4B ?A 823 ?5:7:?7 8248 >38378:?7 ?A 823 455366478/ :7 <=/8?>EC?=6>4B?=788?:7A.:7;3B3788?823:..:;288?6:A3 47>6:93.8E37<34B?A823?5:7:?78248823455366478/ 4.3 378:863> 8? 93 3764.;3> ?7 94:6 /=9D3<8 8? <?7>:8:?7/ C2:<2 C:66 84@3 <4.3 ?A 823 :783.3/8 ?A 823 5.?/3<=8:?7 <<?.>:7;6E47/C3.82349?035?:78:7823 47>5.?<33>8?54//823A?66?C:7; :( 23<.:B:746455346:/ ::( 23455366478/4<<=/3> ?/"8?-4.3?.>3.3> 8? 93 3764.;3> ?7 94:6 :7 .:B3 ? !%! ?A 647> ?6:<3848:?74649=.4;::/8.:<87?C537>:7;?7823A:63 ?A 634.73> >>:8:?746 :/8.:<8 47> 3//:?7/ $=>;3 4649=.4;: ?7 ?984:7:7; 823 9?7> :7 4 /=B ?A /!%%%%% '=533/ C? 4@2/ ?76E( 34<2 C:82 8C? - 7 - /=.38:3/ A?. 823 6:@3/=B 8? 823 /48:/A4<8:?7 ?A 823 D=.:/>:<8:?746?=.8/=9D3<88?823A?66?C:7;<?7>:8:?7/ 4( 23 455366478/ /2466 7?8 <?BB:8 /:B:64. ?AA37<3/ 9( 23 455366478/ /2466 7?8 82.34837 ?. 84B53.C:828235.?/3<=8:?7C:873//3/ <( 23 455366478/ /2466 45534. 93A?.3 823 ?=.84/47>C237.3H=:.3> :::( A :7 <4/3 823 455366478/ 0:?6483 47E ?A 823 <?7>:8:?7/ 4/ /8483> 49?03 823 5.?/3<=8:?7 C:66 93 48 6:93.8E 8? B?03 823 .:46 ?=.8 /33@:7; <47<36648:?7 ?A 94:6 :0( 7 A=.7:/2:7; 823 /=.38:3/ 9E 823 455366478/ 823 .:46 ?=.8 :/ 48 6:93.8E 8? >:.3<8 823 703/8:;48:7; AA:<3. 8? 03.:AE 823 <?..3<873// ?A 823 4>>.3// 47> 4=82378:<:8E?A823>?<=B378/A=.7:/23>9E823455366478/ 47> 823 /=.38:3/ 47> 4 .35?.8 B4E 93 <4663> A?. :7 8248 .3;4.> C2:<2 :/ 8? 93 /=9B:883> 9E 823 703/8:;48:7; AA:<3.C:82:7>4E/ 23 .:46?=.8?7/48:/A4<8:?7B4E - 8 - 5.?<33>8?4<<358823/=.38:3/A?.8235=.5?/3?A.3634/:7; 823455366478/?794:6 )% $!!' # :/8 ?6 ?