- 1 - ! " #$ "" %& ' ! " # $ % & % % ' ( ! " # % '#$) !!'!'' $ % % !# $ % $% ''! & % % % Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % ! !'! * ''! & % % +!!! ', !!!!! ', % - % $ # - %$ ./01. 2.34 562278 34 93427: ;/8 6:53443/< =32. 2.7 >/<47<2 /; ?/2. 2.7 @682374 2.34 562278 34 26A7< 0@ ;/8 ;3<69 :34@/469 ' .346@@76934;397:>6993<13<B07423/<2.7C0:157<2 6<: 6=68: @6447: ?D 2.7 /553443/<78 %/8 5@9/D774 /5@7<4623/< 6<: 83<>3@69 7<3/8 3E39 0:17 696?08613 3< /''! &:627:! !'! */<2.718/0<:/;B06<205 ?/2. /< 3<>/57 64 =799 64 2.7 :346?3932D >/<43:787: ?D 2.7 5@9/D774/5@7<4623/</553443/< - 3 - .34 6@@769 =64 6:53227: /< ! !&'!' /< 2=/ 40?426<2369 B07423/< /; 96= 87168:3<1 3<>/57 64 =799 64 @78>7<2617/;:346?3932D%/8764D87;787<>72.7B07423/</;96= ;8657:68787@8/:0>7:=.3>.876:464;/99/=4 ! "#$% & ' ( ) * ()+, , -. ./+*0 & 768: 83 6?0 72610::6 9768<7: >/0<479 6@@7683<1 ;/8 2.7 6@@7996<2 F >96356<2 ?7;/87 2.7 >/553443/< ;/8 75@9/D77 >/5@7<4623/< 6<: 83 05?68 9768<7: >/0<479;/8874@/<:7<2/'F<4086<>7/5@6<D3:7/8:78 :627: !!'!''</23>72/874@/<:7<2/ 34:34@7<47:=32. 83 6?0 72610::6 =32. 699 E7.757<>7 40?53227:2.622.7 83?0<69.647887:3<26A3<12.7 3<>/5762 2.78627/;4!!!642.76>>3:7<2=64/>>0887:3<2.7D768 '! .7=61793532.642/?77<.6<>7:0@2/4!!!64 - 4 - @874>83?7:0<:787>23/<&# $/;>2.73<C087:=64 =/8A3<1646>976<78>>/8:3<12/2.7>.682@87@687:?D2.7 97169478E3>7602./832D3<4/;68640<4A3997:96?/08;/82.7D768 '! 34 >/<>78<7: 2.7 3<>/57 34 ;3G7: 62 4H!!! < 2.7 >647/<.6<:2.76@@7996<2346>976<786<:.7347<23297:;/8 4H!!!@78 5/<2. 64@78 2.7 3<>/57 ;3G7: 6<: 2.7 4657 /01.22/.6E7?77<>/<43:787:42.34346>64768343<1/02/; >9635 .7<>7 .7 34 </2 7<23297 ;/8 %02087 8/4@7>204 ./01. 2.7 />2/8 .64 42627: 2.7 :346?3932D 62 ', 2.7 83?0<69.64>/553227:6<788/83<26A3<12.7465762 8:37 62,>>/8:3<19D2.7465787B0387487>/<43:78623/< + 7;023<1 2.7 40?53443/</; 2.7 9768<7: >/0<479 ;/8 2.7 6@@7996<2>96356<2 83 05?68 =32. 699 E7.757<>7 40?53227: 2.62 2.7 83?0<69 3< 2.7 6?47<>7 /; 6<D @8//; /; 3<>/57 6<: 3< 2.7 6?47<>7 /; 4262757<2 /; /?C7>23/< ?D 874@/<:7<2 / 26A7< 2.7 3<>/57 62 4!!! 6<: 26A3<1 3<2/ >/<43:78623/< 2.7 :346?3932D 40;;787:2/@6823>0968 935? 2.7 465726A7<62 8:=.3>.34C0426<:@8/@786<::/74</2>699 ;/86<D3<278;787<>7622.7.6<:4/;2.34/082 - 5 - H 6E3<1.768:2.79768<7:>/0<4796@@7683<1;/82.7 @682374@78047:2.77<23876@@769@6@78464=799648369/082 7>/8:/<2.740?426<2369B07423/</;96= < 27854 /; 2.7 40?426<2369 B07423/< /; 96= 42627: 3234</23<:34@0272.622.73<>3:7<2.6426A7<@96>73< 2.7D768'! <2.76?47<>7/;6<D4262757<2/;/?C7>23/< ?D874@/<:7<2/ 2.7C0869879623/<4.3@?72=77<2.73<C087: 6<:874@/<:7<2/ 34</2:34@027:2>6<2.787;/87?746;79D 42627: 2.62 .7 =64 6< 75@9/D77 0<:78 874@/<:7<2 / ./01. 56<D 62275@24 687 56:7 ?D 2.7 874@/<:7<2 F <4086<>7/5@6<D2/>/<27<:2.622.78734</@8//;/;3<>/57 @8/:0>7: 6<: C0869 879623/<4.3@ ?72=77< 874@/<:7<2 / 6<: 2.775@9/D772.783?0<69.64@8/@789D>/<43:787:2.626C0869 879623/<4.3@ ?72=77< 75@9/D78 6<: 75@9/D77 :3: 7G3424 ./=7E78.64>/553227:64783/04788/83<26A3<12.73<>/5762 4!!!;/82.7D768'! .34/082.64;3G7:2.73<>/57 ;/86<0<4A3997:96?/08;/82.7D768'! 624H!!! 6E3<1 >/<43:787: 2.7 3<>/57 62 4H!!! 9//A3<1 2/ 2.7 3<C08D 40;;787:2.783?0<69.64>/553227:64783/04788/826A3<12.7 - 6 - :346?3932D 62 8: >>/8:3<19D 2.7 3<>/57 34 26A7< 62 4H!!! ;/8 >/<43:78623/< .7 83?0<69 .64 ;6397: 2/ >/<43:78 2.7 ;6>2 2.62 2.7 >9635 @72323/< ;397: 0<:78 2.7 5@9/D774/5@7<4623/<>2<2.72772./;7E3:7<>7?D2.7 />2/842623<12.622.7:346?3932D62',2.783?0<69/01.22/ .6E7 >/<43:787: 2.7 4657 3<4276: /; 8: < 2.747 >38>05426<>74?/2.2.740?426<2369B07423/</;96=;8657:?D 2.34 /082 687 6<4=787: 3< ;6E/08 /; 6@@7996<2>96356<2 6<: 6163<42 2.7 874@/<:7<2 F <4086<>7 /5@6<D < E37= /; 26A3<1 2.7 3<>/57 62 4&'!! #H!!! G +! !!$ 6<: 2.7 :346?3932D62',6<:6@@9D3<18797E6<2;6>2/862I'!H*J2.7 >/5@7<4623/< 6=68:7: ?D 2.7 83?0<69 87B03874 87 >/<43:78623/< * >>/8:3<19D /< 87:727853<623/< 2.7 4657 =/09: >/5742/4' H*#4&'!!G'!H*G' !!$=.3>.34 8/0<:7: /;; 2/ 4' *!!! .7 6@@7996<2>96356<2 :07 2/ 3<C0837440;;787:?D.35.7.643<>0887:2.757:3>697G@7<474 /;4!' 64@78G&?7;/872.783?0<69.787;/872.7 6@@7996<2>96356<2 34 7<23297: ;/8 6 2/269 >/5@7<4623/< /; ( )=.3>.348/0<:7:/;;2/( ) - 7 - ! >>/8:3<19D 2.34 /082 @8/>77:4 2/ @644 2.7 ;/99/=3<1 3$ .76@@76934 33$ .7>96356<26@@7996<2347<23297;/86<7<.6<>7: >/5@7<4623/< /; 4'!!! #=/ 6A.4 %3;2D %3E7 ./046<: /<9D$ =.3>. 4.699 >688D 3<278742 62 2.7 8627 /; ', ;8/5 2.7 :627 /; 6>>3:7<2 2399 87693K623/< 333$ .7 874@/<:7<2 /' F <4086<>7 /5@6<D 4.699 :7@/432 2.7 >/5@7<4623/< 87:727853<7: =32.3< 6 @783/:/;43G=77A4;8/52.7:627/;87>73@2/;>/@D /;2.34/8:78 3E$ //8:78642/>/42 E$ <:7@/4322.77<238765/0<2?787693K7:3<;6E/08 /;2.76@@7996<2>96356<2/<@8/@783:7<23;3>623/< *) %& $ 342/ 9/H