Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43424 (KAR)

RAJU v. RAMDAS AND ANR

MFA/201779/2024 · 2025-10-25

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #! $ %!#! $ %!"%& " ! !## '&( ) ! " # $ % ! ! & ' ! (! ! !)* $ ! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " #! +(, -! *!( ( % + + *)#% + + ()!!( () !*'( ( + + + ! !(' . + / + & ! + + 0 ! ! ! 0 ! ! % #0 ! ! !% 123 455647 23 89 :16 ;742<4=: >276? @=?6A 6;:2B= *)#%B>:16B:BA612;763;:-862=C4CCA26D6?89 :16E@?C<6=:4=?4F4A??4:6?()!!( ()54336?89:16 ??7! 6=2BA 2D27 @?C6 . 2E4945@A4 2= B!*'( ( 366G2=C6=14=;6<6=:B>;B<56=34:2B=! - 3 - (! +4;:3 C2D2=C A236 :B :16 >272=C B> :16 455647 8A26>79 3:4:6? 4A6 :14: B= ! )!( 4: 4AB@=? !' 4!<! ?6;6436? 4=?4 B @G4A4< 276G4A F43 5AB;66?2=CB=:16AB4?89F47G:BF4A?361@C4B=B=:16 6H:A6<676>:32?62=BA?6A:B5@A;1436D6C6:48763!16= 316F432=>AB=:B>66A44AC447F4?261@C4B= I! 4D672 23:! @=6 4: :14: :2<6 4 B76AB 665 864A2=C B!.'. ;4<6 >AB< :16 B55B32:6 ?2A6;:2B= ?A2D6= 89 2:3 ?A2D6A 2= 4 12C1 3566? 4=? ?4316? :B :16 ?6;6436?! 3 4 A63@7: 316 ?26? B= :16 35B:! 6;6436? F434?2DBA;664=?@36?:B3:49F2:116A8AB:16A2!6!:16 56:2:2B=6A! )! 16?6;6436?F4314764=?1647:194::16:2<6 B> 4;;2?6=: 4=? F43 4C6? ' 964A3 4=? F43 64A=2=C 3! . 56A <B=:1 >AB< 4CA2;@7:@A47 FBAG 4=?B@:B> :16 342? 3474A9 316 16752=C :16 56:2:2B=6A 2= <42=:42=2=C :16 >4<279! @6 :B @=:2<679 ?64:1 B> ?6;6436? :16 56:2:2B=6A 7B3: 123 323:6A 4=? 473B :16 3B@A;6 B> 2=;B<6! 6=;6:16;742<4=:>276?:16;742<56:2:2B=@=?6A6;:2B= - 4 - B> B:BA 612;763 ;: 86>BA6 :16 742<3 A28@=47 366G2=C;B<56=34:2B=>BA:16?64:1B>?6;6436?4=?4! '! @A3@4=: :B :16 3@<<B=3 :1B@C1 =B:2;6 36AD6? A635B=?6=: B! A6<42=6? 4836=;6 4=? F43 574;6? 6H54A:6! 635B=?6=: B!( 45564A6? 4=? >276? FA2::6= 3:4:6<6=: ?6=92=C :16 4D6A<6=:3 <4?6 2= :16 ;742<56:2:2B=! ! =:1684323B>:165764?2=C3B>:1654A:263:16 742<3 A28@=47>A4<6?:16233@634=?:16A64>:6AA6;BA?6? :16 6D2?6=;6! 16 ;742<4=: 2= BA?6A :B 5ABD6 :16 ;436 CB: 6H4<2=6? 12<367> 43 . 4=? CB: 6H1282:6? ?B;@<6=:3=4<679H!:BH!*!B6D2?6=;676:2=B= 86147> B> A635B=?6=: 8@: CB: <4AG6? ;B59 B> 2=3@A4=;6 5B72;943H!!! ! 16742<3 A28@=4789:162<5@C=6?E@?C<6=: 167?:14: :16 4;;2?6=: :BBG574;6B= 4;;B@=:B> A431 4=? =6C72C6=: ?A2D2=C B> :16 ?A2D6A B> :16 B>>6=?2=C B76AB 665 43 4 A63@7: B> F12;1 ?6;6436? 3@3:42=6? - 5 - 2=E@A2634=?3@;;@<86?:B:162=E@A263! 16 A28@=47@5B= ;B=32?6A2=C :16 BA47 4=? ?B;@<6=:4A9 6D2?6=;6 574;6? 86>BA6 2: 167? :14: :16 ;742<4=: 23 6=:2:76? :B ;B<56=34:2B= B> 3!) . 47B=C F2:1 2=:6A63: 4: :16 A4:6B>J5!4!4=??2A6;:6?A635B=?6=:B!(=3@A4=;6 ;B<54=9 :B ?65B32: :16 ;B<56=34:2B= 4<B@=:! 62=C ?2334:23>26? F2:1 :16 I@4=:@< B> ;B<56=34:2B= :16 ;742<4=:2386>BA6:123B@A:! *! 16764A=6?;B@=367>BA:16;742<4=:A4236?:16 >B77BF2=C;B=:6=:2B=3 4% 16764A=6?;B@=367>BA:16;742<4=:;B=:6=?6? :14:4::16:2<6B>4;;2?6=:?6;6436?F434C6?'964A3 4=? 316 F43 64A=2=C 3! . 56A <B=:1 89 ?B2=C 4CA2;@7:@A47 FBAG 4=? 316 F43 16752=C :16 56:2:2B=6A :B <42=:42=:16>4<279! 8% 6;B=?79 16 143 ;B=:6=?6? :14: :16 A28@=47 143;B<<2::6?4=6AABA2==B:CA4=:2=C4=9;B<56=34:2B= @=?6A :16 164? 7B33 B> ?656=?6=;9! +@A:16A ;B=:6=?6? - 6 - :14:(JB>:162=;B<6143:B864??6?:BF4A?37B33B> >@:@A65AB356;:32=D26FB>:16E@?C<6=:B>:1656HB@A: 2= A65BA:6?2=! ;% 43:79163@8<2:3:14:4356A:16E@?C<6=:2= !" ! "##$! %$!# & '( )* !% $! +!,-.;742<4=:236=:2:76?>BA;B<56=34:2B=B> 3!' .@=?6A:16164?B>K>27247;B=3BA:2@</! ! = :16 B:16A 14=? 764A=6? ;B@=367 45564A2=C >BA:16=3@A4=;6B<54=9;B=:6=?:14::16;742<56:2:2B= 143 866= >276? - 964A3 4>:6A :16 4;;2?6=:! 16 ?6;6436? F43 4 ?2DBA;66 4=? F43 =B: 72D2=C F2:1 :16 ;742<4=: 4=? 16=;6 316 23 =B: ?656=?6=: @5B= :16 2=;B<6 B> :16 ?6;6436?! 16 ;742<4=: 143 123 BF= 3B@A;6 B> 2=;B<6 4=? 16 143 4?<2::6? :14: 123 ;127?A6= 4A6 FBAG2=C! 16A6>BA6 @=?6A :1636 ;2A;@<3:4=;63 :16 A28@=47 143 A2C1:79 =B: CA4=:6? 4=9 ;B<56=34:2B= :BF4A?3 7B33 B> ?656=?6=;9! - 7 - -! 6;B=?79 :16 764A=6? ;B@=367 >BA :16 =3@A4=;6 B<54=9 ;B=:6=?6? :14: ;B=32?6A2=C :16 4C6 4=? 4DB;4:2B=B>:16?6;6436?BD6A477;B<56=34:2B=4F4A?6? 89:16 A28@=4723E@3:4=?A643B=4876! ! 64A? :16 764A=6? ;B@=367 >BA :16 54A:263 56A@36? :16 E@?C<6=: 4=? 4F4A? 2=;7@?2=C :16 455647 5456A3! ! : 23 =B: 2= ?235@:6 :14: ?6;6436? 4=?4 B @G4A4< 276G4A ?26? 2= 4 AB4? :A4>>2; 4;;2?6=: :14: :BBG 574;6B=! )!( ?@6:B:16A4314=?=6C72C6=:?A2D2=C B> :16 ?A2D6A B> B76AB 665 864A2=C B!.'. ! D6=:1B@C1:16;742<56:2:2B=143866=>276?4>:6A-964A3 4>:6A:164;;2?6=::16 A28@=471436=:6A:42=6?:16;742< 56:2:2B= 4=? 4F4A?6? ;B<56=34:2B= 89 2:3 E@?C<6=: 4=? 4F4A? F12;1 A6<42=3 @=;14776=C6? :277 ?4:6 4=? 34<6 23 =B:?235@:6?89:162=3@A4=;6;B<54=9! (! : 23 :16 356;2>2; ;436 B> :16 ;742<4=: :14: ?6;6436? 23 123 323:6A 4=? 316 F43 4 ?2DBA;66! 16 F43 - 8 - A632?2=CF2:1:16;742<4=:4=?16F43?656=?6=:@5B=:16 2=;B<6B>:16?6;6436?!D6=2=:16;AB33.6H4<2=4:2B=B> !!=B:12=CFBA:1F1276143866=672;2:6?:B5ABD6:14: :16;742<4=:23=B:?656=?4=:B=:162=;B<6B>?6;6436?! 16A6>BA6 ;B=32?6A2=C :16 6D2?6=;6 B> :16 54A:263 4=? <4:6A2474D4274876B=A6;BA?4=?473B2=D26FB>E@?C<6=: B>2=:16;436B>! /0 !1 2 A65BA:6?2= $31!$4 ;B=32?6A2=C :16>4;:3B>:16;436B=14=?4=?:16;4:6=4B>E@?C<6=: B>:123B@A:F64A6B>:16B52=2B=:14:7B33B>63:4:6143 :B 86 ;B=32?6A6? 4: )A? B> :16 2=;B<6 B> ?6;6436?! 1B@C1 ;742<4=: ;742< :14: ?6;6436? F43 64A=2=C 3! . 5!<! >AB< 4CA2;@7:@A47 FBAG 8@: =B 5ABB> B> ?B;@<6=:3143866=5AB?@;6?! 16A6>BA62=:164836=;6 B>5ABB>B>2=;B<6=B:2B=472=;B<64356A:16C@2?672=63 233@6? 89 :16 4A=4:4G4 :4:6 6C47 6AD2;63 @:1BA2:9 :162=;B<64:3! .5!<!>BA:164;;2?6=:B>:16964A ( 143 :B 86 :4G6= 2=:B ;B=32?6A4:2B=! 16 <@7:25726A - 9 - 45572;4876 :B :16 4C6 CAB@5 B> ?6;6436? 23 K'/! ;;BA?2=C797B33B>63:4:6143866=4336336?43@=?6A =;B<6B>?6;6436?:4G6=433! .5!<!)A? B> :16 34<6 ;B<63 :B 3!( .! 3!( H ( H' L3!)) . F12;1 4<B@=: :16 ;742<4=: 23 6=:2:76? :BF4A?37B33B>63:4:6!=4??2:2B=:B:14::16;742<4=:23 6=:2:76? >BA 4 3@< B> 3! . :BF4A?3 >@=6A47 6H56=363 B> ?6;6436?! 1@3 2= :B:47 :16 ;742<4=: 23 6=:2:76?>BA:B:47;B<56=34:2B=B>3!) .! )! =:16A63@7:F65433:16>B77BF2=C 4% 164556472356! 8% 16 E@?C<6=: 4=? 4F4A? B> :16 742<3 A28@=4723<B?2>26?! ;% 16 ;742<4=: 23 6=:2:76? :B 4 :B:47 ;B<56=34:2B= B> 3!) . 43 4C42=3: - 10 - 3!) . 4F4A?6? 89 :16 A28@=47 47B=C F2:12=:6A63:4::16A4:6B>J56A4==@<! ?% 16635B=?6=:B!(.=3@A4=;6B<54=923 ?2A6;:6? :B ?65B32: ;B<56=34:2B= 4<B@=: 47B=C F2:1 2=:6A63: 4: :16 A4:6 B> J 56A 4==@< >AB< :16 ?4:6 B> >272=C B> :16 ;742< 56:2:2B= :277 :16 ?4:6 B> A6472M4:2B= F2:12= 4 56A2B?B>32HF66G3>AB<:16?4:6B>A6;625:B> 4;B59B>:123E@?C<6=:! 6% = ?65B32: B> ;B<56=34:2B= 4<B@=: 6=:2A6 4<B@=: 31477 86 A676436? 2= >4DB@A B> :16 ;742<4=:4>:6A?@6D6A2>2;4:2B=! !*+ '#!( % !*+ '"%& "( % 23:B!7B!