Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43420 (KAR)

MALLAMMA W/O TIMMAPPA AND ANR v. HANUMANTHRAYA S/O NINGAPPA AND ORS

MFA/202001/2022 · 2025-10-14

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " # !" $%# ! & $'($ $%'$'($ $%()" $%# Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' '& $%###* !+ & , & , & '" &&)'!" & "& " & + ###* & ++& $ %#) ) ###$ & & &- ' & + .+ - 3 - $ /012/3/456778694594538:;0<6:=45540> ?43/@0>58>30; A03/54:85 3/856=84536B8>17;0</86<4>2 /45 677869 45 ;498: 6264>53 3/8 C1:2=8>3 6>: 6?6<: :638: ##* 76558: AD 3/8 8>40< 4E49 +1:28 6>: +& 6>: ::4340>69 $ /6/671< 4> 0% 0; #) >8 4==6776 628: % D86<5 =83 ?43/ 6> 6@@4:8>3 0> #*# 6>: :48: 45 ?4;8 6>: 50> ;498: @964= 7834340> @964=4>2 @0=78>56340> 0; 5) ###$ ?43/ 4>38<853 /8 3<4A1>69 @0>54:8<8:3/88>34<88E4:8>@80><8@0<: 6>:2<6>38: @0=78>56340>0;5% ) %##$?43/4>38<853633/8<6380;(F 78< 6>>1= ;<0= :638 0; 6@@4:8>3 3499 <869456340> 6>: :4<8@38: <8570>:8>3 0$0?>8< 0; 3/8 3<6@30< 3<6498< 30 76D 3/8 @0=78>56340>?43/4>0>8=0>3/ ' 22<48E8: AD 3/8 564: 0<:8< 3/45 677869 45 ;498: 4> ?/4@/ 43 45 @0>38>:8: 3/63 3/8 6@@4:8>3 0@@1<<8: :18 30 @0991540>0;3<6@30<A86<4>2<82453<6340>0$'( $%'6>: 6130 A86<4>2 <82453<6340> 0$''( > 3/8 6130 3/8 58634>2 @676@43D 45 ' G A13 % 78<50>5 ?8<8 3<6E894>2 6>: 3/8<8;0<8 3/8<8 45 E4096340> 0; 78<=43 AD 3/8 6130 :<4E8< > - 4 - @6580;E4096340>6578<8@340>%(0;3/8@3 78<=43@6>A8 @6>@8998: 6>: 78>693D @6> A8 4=7058: 1>:8< 8@340> * 0; 3/8@3345;1<3/8<53638:3/633/8:8@8658: 4==6776?65 :04>262<4@1931<69?0<B6>:86<>4>25# ###$78<=0>3/ A13 3/8 <4A1>698<<8:4>36B4>2/454>@0=8655* ###$78<=0>3/ 6>: 6?6<:8: =8628< @0=78>56340> /8 3<4A1>69 /65 >03 2<6>38:6>D6=01>31>:8<3/8/86:90550;8H78@36>@D6>:3/8 <638 0; 4>38<853 6?6<:8: 63 (F 78< 6>>1= >88:5 30 A8 8>/6>@8:30%F 86<:3/86<21=8>350>A03/54:85 /8 :8@8658: 4==6776 ?/498 3<6E8994>2 4> 6> 6130 A86<4>2 <82453<6340> 0$''$( 3/8 :<4E8< 0; 3/8 6130 :<4E8> 43 4> 6 <65/ 6>: >829428>3 =6>>8< 6>: :65/8: 30 3/8 3<6@30< A86<4>2 0$'( $%' @0=4>2 ;<0= 3/8 07705438 :4<8@340> 65 3/8<8 45 >829428>@8 0> 3/8 76<3 0; A03/ 3/8 :<4E8<5 3/8 6@@4:8>3 0@@1<<8: :18 30 @0991540> 0; 3/858 3?0 E8/4@9856>:@/6<285/88345;498:6264>533/8:<4E8<50;A03/3/8 E8/4@985 13 3/8 7834340>8<5 >03 4=7986:8: 3/8 0?>8< 0; 3/8 3<6@30<6>:69503/84>51<8<0;3/86130 /86@@4:8>30@@1<<8: :18 30 @0991540> 0; A03/ 3/8 E8/4@985 3/8<8 45 @0>3<4A130<D - 5 - >829428>@80;#F0>3/8:<4E8<50;A03/3/8E8/4@9856>:86@/ 0; 3/8 4>51<6>@8 @0=76>D0?>8< 45 946A98 30 76D #F 0; 3/8 @0=78>56340> ( /012/ 43 45 53638: 3/63 4==6776 ?65 628: % D86<5 6>:?6586<>4>25# ###$78<=0>3/ >0:0@1=8>345 ;498: 30 7<0E8 /45 4>@0=8 5 /8 =83 ?43/ 3/8 6@@4:8>3 0> #*# 6578<3/8214:6>@80;3/86<>636B636388269 8<E4@8513/0<43D /454>@0=84530A836B8>635% ###$78< =0>3/6>:3/8=19347948<67794@6A9845* ) /8 :8@8658: 45 8>34398: ;0< #F 30?6<:5 ;131<8 7<0578@356578<3/8:4@31=0; 0>IA9878H01<3 6>: 3/15 3/8 6=01>3 ?019: A8@0=8 5% %##$ 78< =0>3/ !% ###$ G#F" 5 78< 3/8 214:894>85 0; 3/8 0>IA98 78H 01<3 4> :4@31=0; 4; 3/8 :8@8658: ?65 =6<<48: 6>: =0<8 3/6> 3?0 :878>:6>35 '<: 0; /45 4>@0=8 30?6<:5 /45 78<50>69 8H78>585 /65 30 A8 :8:1@38: /15 3/8 4>@0=8 0; 3/8 :8@8658: 6;38< :8:1@34>2 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 * Retyped and replaced vide court order dated 14.11.2025. - 6 - 78<50>698H78>585@0=85305 %()$78<=0>3/!% %##$J '<:" /86280;3/8:8@8658:45%D86<5 6>:3/867794@6A98 =19347948< 45 * /15 3/8 @0=78>56340> 30?6<:5 9055 0; :878>:8>@D@0=85305( '' ('($! %()$HH*" %&1<3/8< 3/80>IA9817<8=801<3 AD<8438<634>23/8 @0=7<8/8>54E8 4>38<7<836340> 0; K@0>50<341=I 24E8> 4> 3/8 613/0<43D 0; ! " # $ # % & 6>: 4> 3/8 613/0<43D A83?88> ' " ()*( + ;0<34;48:3/86=01>35;0<90550;@0>50<341=@@0<:4>29D 4345 C153 6>: <8650>6A98 30 6?6<: 5# ###$ 86@/ 48 5%# ###$30?6<:590550;@0>50<341=303/8@964=6>35 /8 @964=6>356<869508>34398:;0<6>6=01>30;5'# ###$1>:8< 3/8 @0>E8>340>69 /86:5 65 78< 3/8 @436340> 4> 3/8 @658 0; /15 3/830369@0=78>56340>@0=85305) ' ('($ 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 * Retyped and replaced vide court order dated 14.11.2025. - 7 - * /86?6<:0;@0=78>56340>76558:AD3/8 <4A1>6945 =0:4;48:651>:8< 86:5 =01>34>17885 0550;:878>:8>@D ( '' ('($ 0550;@0>50<341= %# ###$ ' 0>E8>340>69/86:5 '# ###$ 0369 !* * + # 86<>8: @01>589 ;0< 3/8 >51<6>@8 @0=76>D @0>38>:8:3/633/86130?65@6<<D4>2*78<50>54>@91:4>23/8 :<4E8<633/834=80;3/86@@4:8>36>:=0<80E8< 3/878<=43?65 E694: 1730 % B490=83<85 4> 3/8 /6/671< @43D 94=43 13 /8 3<6E8998: 1730 6:628<6 ?/4@/ 45 5431638: 63 6 :4536>@8 0; '# B490=83<85;<0=/6/671<53/8<845E4096340>0;3/878<=43 65 78< 3/8 C1:2=8>3 4> 3/8 @658 0; <870<38: $ , ( - $ <870<38: 4> ./01&/0 76D6>:<8@0E8<D@6>A80<:8<8: 86<>8: @01>589 ;0< 3/8 7834340>8<$@964=6>35 /65 <8948: 170> 3/8 C1:2=8>3 4> 3/8 @658 0; /626776 5 * Retyped and replaced vide court order dated 14.11.2025. - 8 - =3BB6==6 6>: 03/8<5 :8@4:8: 4> & 0##'(# ?&0#')(#)0>)#'4>?/4@/434553638: 3/63 3/012/ 3/8<8 45 E4096340> 0; 38<=5 0; E8/4@98 78<=43 4>51<6>@8@0=76>D/65304>:8=>4;D3/8@964=6>36>:<8@0E8< 3/856=8;<0=3/80?>8<0;3/8E8/4@98 /8 986<>8: @01>589 ;1<3/8< @0>38>:8: 3/63 4>51<6>@8@0=76>D456394A8<3D30<8@0E8<;<0=6>D0>80;3/8 C04>330<3;8650<56578<3/8C1:2=8>34>3/8@6580;( * $ $, <870<38:4>./2134& '>3/8942/30;3/86A0E80A58<E6340> 3/8;0990?4>2 0<:8<4576558: !4" /8677869456990?8:4>76<3 !44" /8 7834340>8<$@964=6>35 6<8 8>34398: ;0< 3/8 @0=78>56340> 0; 5) ' ('($ ?43/ 4>38<853 <638 0; (F 78< 6>>1= !444" 8570>:8>3 0' J 4>51<6>@8 @0=76>D 45 :4<8@38: 30:8705435) ' ('($?43/4>38<85363<6380;(F78<6>>1= ?43/4>0>8=0>3/;<0=3/8:6380;3/450<:8< * Retyped and replaced vide court order dated 14.11.2025. - 9 - !4E" > 51@/ :870543 3/8 7834340>8<5 6<8 78<=4338: 30 ?43/:<6?3/88>34<86=01>3690>2?43/4>38<8536@@<18:0>43 8L1699D !E" 8570>:8>30'456394A8<3D30<8@0E8<#F0;3/8 @0=78>56340>;<0=3/80?>8<0;3/83<6@30<6>:3<6498< AD:18 7<0@8550;96? !E4" 53/8@0>3<4A130<D>829428>@80;A03/3/8E8/4@985 ?65;4H8:63#F0>86@/0;3/8= 0?>8<6>:4>51<8<0;6130 A86<4>2 0$''( 6<8 6950 946A98 30 76D #F 0; 3/8 @0=78>56340> !E44" 5 <8570>:8>3 0' 45 :4<8@38: 30 :870543 8>34<8 6=01>3 43456394A8<3D30<8@0E8<#F;<0=3/80?>8<0;3/8 6130A86<4>20$''(@@0<:4>29D @0<<8@340>45@6<<48: 0134>76280*0;3/8C1:2=8>3 !E444" > E48? 0; 3/8 0<:8< :638: '## 76558: 0> 0# 3/8 @964=6>35 6<8 >03 8>34398: ;0< 4>38<853 ;0< 3/8:896D8:78<40:0;(:6D54>;494>23/8677869 ,-+ &% ( $ 453090) * Retyped and replaced vide court order dated 14.11.2025.