Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43417 (KAR)
SRI. ADRUSHYA KADESHWARA SWAMIJI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203149/2025 · 2025-10-17
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43417 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43417 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"!# $
% &'"""&!&
(&")
! "!#
! $
!! " " %&&&
! " ! " %'&
( ! ( !#
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$!$ ! $
! %' $ ! $
! $ ! ) %&&%
! "
$
((""(&(&%"*
" " $
&&% ! $ +! $ , ! " $
! - !! *! - !! # . /01 234/56.17 41/5/56. /01 41/5/56.18 906 5: /01 3/37543/56;57703<5853/03.1853=>?38@585:/852/ 6=034>803:23==175.A>1:/56./015B4><.176871873/17 %&&% C1385.< 6 ((""(&(&%
- 3 -
43::17 CD /01 :126.7 81:46.71./E14>/D !6BB5::56.18
"5F3D34>83 5:/852/ 90181CD /01 41/5/56.18 03: C11. 81:/835.17;86B1./185.</01/1885/6853==5B5/:6;"5F3D34>83 5:/852/;68/01418567;86B&&%/6&%3: 418..1G>81E
138.17 26>.:1= 3441385.< ;68 /01 41/5/56.18 815/183/5.</01<86>.7:>8<175./0141/5/56.:>CB5/:/03/ /01 5B4><.17 68718 5: 38C5/838D 5==1<3= 3.7 32/>3/17 CD 1G/83.16>: 3.7 46=5/523= 26.:57183/56.: / 5: 26./1.717 /03/ /0181 381 .6 B3/1853=: 903/:61@18 /6 5.@6?1 :>C :12/56. # 6; 12/56. 6; /01 0383/5D3 3<385? >83?:03 3.05/3 & 01 41/5/56.18 3226875.< /6 =138.1726>.:1=B181=D5./1.7:/6438/52543/15./01>.D3 5/05 6; 3B38/0 37<>8> 085 5770383B1:09383 30383F38> 3/ 3:3@3.3 3<19375 5:/852/ "5F3D34>83 :2017>=17 6. /0 3.7 H/0 2/6C18 &% / 5: ;>8/018 >8<17 /03/ /01 41/5/56.18 037 3=8137D 26BB1.217 05:
F6>8.1D ;86B 6=034>8 /6 "5F3D34>83 /6 3//1.7 /01 :357 81=5<56>: <3/0185.< 3.7 /03/ /01 5::>3.21 6; /01
- 4 -
48605C5/68D687183//011=1@1./006>83B6>./:/6375812/ 5.;85.<1B1./ 6; 05: ;>.73B1./3= 85<0/: <>383./117 >.718 8/52=1I#7#6;/01!6.:/5/>/56.6;.753.:>4468/6; 05::>CB5::56.:81=53.215:4=32176./01F>7<B1./6;/01 6.,C=1>481B1!6>8/5. /6 26./1.7 /03/ 81:/852/56.: 6. B6@1B1./ B>:/ :3/5:;D /01 /1:/: 6; .121::5/D3.7486468/56.3=5/D
18 26./83 /01 =138.17 7@623/1 1.183= 81=D5.<>46./01B3/1853=4=32176.8126873.7/015.4>/: ;>8.5:0175./0146=52181468/:>CB5/:/03//0141/5/56.18,: 48646:17@5:5/5:=5?1=D/675:/>8C4>C=52687183.7B3D=137 /6 C81320 6;41321 1 465./: 6>//03/ /0181381 28175C=1 5./1==5<1.21 5.4>/: 5.7523/5.< 9571:48137 486/1:/: 3=8137D C15.< 68<3.5J17 CD 71@6/11:
5. 81:46.:1 /6 /01 41/5/56.18,: 8121./ >:1 6; 3C>:5@1 3.7 5./1B4183/1 =3.<>3<1 3<35.:/ 3.6/018 46./5;; =325.< 81=53.21 6. /01 485.254=1: =357 769. CD /01 6.,C=1 >481B1 !6>8/ 5. ! "
#
- 5 -
$% & & '& 01 26./1.7: /03/ 901. /01 37B5.5:/83/56. 5: :3/5:;517 6. /01 C3:5: 6; 6CF12/5@1 B3/1853= /03/ 3 418:6.,: 481:1.21 5: =5?1=D /6 1.73.<18 4>C=52 /83.A>5=5/D 5/ 5: 91== 95/05. 5/: 46918 /6 5::>1 3 481@1./5@168718>.71812/56.6;/01 &/ 5: /0>: :>CB5//17 /03/ /01 5B4><.17 68718 5: .15/018 38C5/838D .68 1G21::5@1 C>/ 3 =1<5/5B3/1 481@1./5@1 B13:>81/6481:18@14>C=5241321
05: !6>8/ 03: 2381;>==D 26.:571817 /01 85@3= :>CB5::56.: 37@3.217 CD C6/0 =138.17 26>.:1= 3.7 03: 418>:17/01812687:5.2=>75.</015B4><.17687183.7/01 F>7<B1./:81=517>46.CD/01438/51: % 01:068/A>1:/56./03/385:1:;6826.:57183/56. 5./05:41/5/56.5:K
- 6 -
! " # $ ! % &'
1;681/05:71=@1: 5./6 /01 B3//18 5/ 96>=7 C1 3446:5/1/61G/832//01:/3/1B1./B371CD41/5/56.18/01 :3B15:1G/832/173:>.718L #
M !
"#$ % & '() *+, -$ ./ 01$
23 4$ $567 8 9:;<6 = >? N@A 7@(@B 7C-@A 7@(@B 7C-0& - A;D 0@+EF0@+G0$/ C$-H I70-@+5H " 0 % J @+ K(LM $30$ (C8(09%N O. .0.P QR S T 2 M T &$8(09 C 2 UM ! 7$ %0O C ; @CR @ ' @A 7@ (@B 7C- 2 7V ;-@+ T %(09 (W X@ )- (YZ; @ (V- ; C3 ! / V3 / 0= T3 T0;$-=(L09[.WL\OE<2 2+B GC$ ]^_ (CB ]` ] (C$- C]2M T0%N \8 T 8(^_$< [ G2T
@$@
- 7 -
*$ :0a ( (9'.0@b ; c!b ;<* + O. 7c (.$@U B+ dM@I @( ! 7$ a e @@+
= Uf % J 6 -5@+ T $G:
%g [8(-6 @( -1M2 / C [8(-6 7C:
%-@+ T.
:& !M B403:5::>44=517CDB1# H /5:.676>C/>.;68/>.3/1/03/75;;181.21:03@1 385:1. C1/911. /96 81@1817 :4585/>3= =13718: 3.7 /01 41/5/56.18C15.<346./5;;26BB3.75.<26.:57183C=14>C=52 ;6==695.<5:1G412/17/61G05C5/26B46:>81/6=183.213.7 81:/835./ 1@1. 5. /01 ;321 6; 486@623/56. 691@18 /01 B3/1853= 4=3217 C1;681 /05: !6>8/ 81@13=: /03/ /01 41/5/56.18,: 8132/56. /6 /01 81B38?: B371 CD 3.6/018 46./5;; 93: .6/ 26.;5.17 /6 3 75<.5;517 81C>//3= C>/ 71<1.183/175./6>:16;/0813/1.5.<3.73C>:5@1=3.<>3<1 5.2=>75.< :/3/1B1./: :><<1:/5@1 6;40D:523= 3::3>=/ >20 26.7>2/ CD 3.D B13:>81 5: 906==D 5.26.:5:/1./ 95/0 /01 B683=3.7:4585/>3=75:254=5.11G412/176;381=5<56>:0137 3.718671:/0175<.5/D3//32017/605:6;;521418:6.906
- 8 -
2066:1: /6 81:46.7
5. :>20
3. 5./1B4183/1 3.7 486@623/5@1 B3..18 23..6/ B181=D CD @58/>1 6; 05:
122=1:53:/523= 46:5/56. 2=35B 5BB>.5/D ;86B /01 6875.38D 344=523/56. 6; =39 68 :11? 5.7>=<1.21 >.718 /01 <>5:1 6; 81=5<56>:;81176B ' 05=1 /05: !6>8/ 5: 5.;68B17 3C6>/ /01 41/5/56.18,: 81@1817 :/3/>81 5/ 23..6/ 6@18=66? /01 ;32/ /03/05:>//183.21:03@13=8137D81:>=/175.4>C=52486/1:/:
3.7 2813/17 43=43C=1 /1.:56. 3B6.< 71@6/11: . :>20 2582>B:/3.21: /01 481@1./5@1 B13:>81: 3764/17 CD /01 5:/852/ 7B5.5:/83/56. C3:17 6. 28175C=1 5./1==5<1.21 5.4>/:23..6/C1:357/6C138C5/838D6875:486468/56.3/1 0185<0//6B6@1B1./>.7188/52=1I#7#238851:95/0 5/ /01 6C=5<3/56. /6 1.:>81 /03/ 5/: 1G1825:1 761: .6/ 5B4185= 4>C=52 41321 01 41/5/56.18 5.:/137 6; 3::18/5.< 05:85<0/5.71;53.216;481@35=5.<2582>B:/3.21:6><0//6 71B6.:/83/1:4585/>3=B3/>85/DCD@6=>./385=D71;1885.<05: @5:5/5./01=38<185./181:/6;B35./35.5.<4>C=5268718
- 9 -
I 01:26416;/01;>.73B1./3=85<0/<>383./117 >.718 8/52=1 I#7# 6; /01 !6.:/5/>/56. 90520 26.;18: >46.1@18D25/5J1./0185<0//6B6@1;811=D/086><06>//01 /1885/68D 6; .753 5: .6/ 3C:6=>/1 3.7 5: :>CF12/ /6 813:6.3C=181:/852/56.:>.7188/52=1I%#5./015./181:/:
6; /01 <1.183= 4>C=52 01 6.,C=1 >481B1 !6>8/ 5.
" (
") * +,- ++ 03:
01=7 /03/ ;81176B 6; B6@1B1./ 68 1G481::56. 23..6/ C1 1G1825:175.3B3..18/03/75:/>8C:4>C=5268718686;;1.7:
26BB>.3= 038B6.D 5B5=38=D 5. ./ 0) //
#)1 *+, ' 5/ 03: C11. 815/183/17 /03/ 905=1 25/5J1.: 03@1 3 85<0/ /6 B6@1 ;811=D 3.73::1BC=141321;>==D/01/3/15:1A>3==D1B4691817 /681<>=3/1:>2085<0/:/6481@1./C813206;41321 & . /01 481:1./ 23:1 /01 5B4><.17 48605C5/68D 6871803:C11.5::>176./01C3:5:6;28175C=15./1==5<1.21 5.4>/: 5.7523/5.< /03/ /01 41/5/56.18,: @5:5/ /6 3:3@3.3 3<19375 5: =5?1=D /6 /85<<18 486/1:/: 3.7 75:/>8C 4>C=52 /83.A>5=5/D 01 B3/1853=:
6. 812687 5.2=>75.< /01
- 10 -
:/3/1B1./: B371 CD /01 41/5/56.18 81@13= /01 >:1 6; 3C>:5@13.77186<3/68D=3.<>3<1906==D>.C126B5.<6;3 418:6. 2=35B5.< :4585/>3= :/3/>:
01. :>20 26.7>2/ 5:
2343C=1 6; 5.;=3B5.< 81=5<56>: :1./5B1./: 3.7 486@6?5.< >.81:/ /01 481@1./5@1 B13:>81: 3764/17 CD /01 5:/852/ 7B5.5:/83/56. 23..6/ C1 /18B17 38C5/838D 68 1G21::5@1 01 81:/852/56. 5B46:17 5: .38869=D /35=6817 /6 481@1./ 5BB5.1./ 75:68718 3.7 761: .6/ 418B3.1./=D 2>8/35= /01 41/5/56.18,:85<0/>.7188/52=1I#7#
/ 5: 1G412/17 6; 3 418:6. 06=75.< /01 1G3=/17 46:5/56.6;3:4585/>3=01376846./5;;/632/95/081:/835./ 0>B5=5/D 3.7 3 :1.:1 6; 81:46.:5C5=5/D C1;5//5.< /01 ;35/0 3.781@181.218146:175.05BCD/01;6==6918::35./68 81=5<56>: =13718 622>451: 3 4=321 6; B683= 5.;=>1.21 3.7 :4585/>3=<>573.215.:6251/D3.7/0181;68105:9687:3.7 32/56.:2388D;38813205.<26.:1A>1.21:6./0126.7>2/6;
71@6/11: 01 41/5/56.18 C15.< 3 46./5;; 6; 26.:57183C=1 ;6==695.<6><0//6C126.:256>:/03/3.D:/3/1B1./6832/ 418215@17 3: 486@623/5@1 68 7186<3/68D 23. 03@1 3
- 11 -
23:2375.<1;;12/6.4>C=52413213.768718./01481:1./ 23:1 /01 812687 75:2=6:1: /03/ /01 41/5/56.18,: 481@56>:
>//183.21: 26./35.17 =3.<>3<1 /03/ 93: 2=138=D 3C>:5@1 3.7 >.C126B5.< 6; 3 :4585/>3= =13718 90520 03: 3=8137D =17/69571:48137486/1:/:3286::/01/3/1
01.:>203. 3/B6:40181 6; /1.:56. 481@35=: 48>71.21 71B3.7: /03/ /01 41/5/56.18 :06>=7 @6=>./385=D 71;18 68 3@657 05: 48646:17 @5:5/ /6 3:3@3 3<19375 ?1145.< 5. @519 /01 =38<18 5./181:/ 6; B35./35.5.< 26BB>.3= 038B6.D 3.7 4>C=52/83.A>5=5/D
01 85<0/ <>383./117 >.718 8/52=1 I#7# 6;
/01 !6.:/5/>/56. 23..6/ C1 2=35B17 5. 5:6=3/56. 75@68217 ;86B /01 26881:46.75.< 7>/D /6 1.:>81 /03/ 5/: 1G1825:1 761: .6/ 1.73.<18 41321 68 4>C=52 68718 :4585/>3= =13718 B681 /03. 3.D 6/018 25/5J1. 5: 1G412/17 /6 1G1B4=5;D /6=183.21 3.7 :1=;81:/835./ 3.7 /6 85:1 3C6@1 418:6.3= <851@3.21: 5. 68718 /6 486B6/1 038B6.D 3.7 B>/>3=81:412/ 3B6.< 26BB>.5/51:0181;681901. /01 5B4><.17 48605C5/68D 68718 5: C3:17
6.
28175C=1
- 12 -
5./1==5<1.21 5.4>/: 3.7 35B: /6 481@1./ 46/1./53= >.81:/ /05:!6>8/ ;5.7: .6 <86>.7 /6 5./18;1813: /01 41/5/56.18 CD 81;835.5.< ;86B :>20 @5:5/ 96>=7 5. ;32/ C1 >406=75.< /01 /8>1 :4585/ 6; 05: 23==5.< 3.7 :1//5.< 3 .6C=1 1G3B4=1 ;6805:;6==6918:
. " # $%
! & & '& /01 6.,C=1 >481B1 !6>8/ >401=7 3 :5B5=38 48605C5/68D 68718 81:/835.5.<1./8D 5./6 3 75:/852/ 06=75.< /03/ 901. 28175C=1 B3/1853= 5.7523/1: /01 =5?1=50667 6; C81320 6; 41321 481@1./5@1 32/56. CD /01 37B5.5:/83/56. 26.:/5/>/1: 3 813:6.3C=1 81:/852/56.>.7188/52=1I#7#01!6>8/6C:18@17/03/ /01 85<0/ /6 B6@1B1./ B>:/ D51=7 /6 /01 4383B6>./ 5./181:/6;B35./35.5.<4>C=52687183.7/83.A>5=5/D
. 26./83:/ 81=53.21 6. 5:B5:4=32173:/03/ 23:1 713=/ 95/0 81<56.9571 81:/852/56.: 3;;12/5.< /01 <1.183= 4>C=52 3.7 1G3B5.17 /01 486468/56.3=5/D 6;
26./5.>5.< =5B5/3/56.: 6. B6@1B1./ 3.7 26BB>.523/56. - 13 -
01 481:1./ 23:1 0691@18 5.@6=@1: 3 .38869=D /35=6817 481@1./5@1 B13:>81 75812/17 3<35.:/ 3. 5.75@57>3= 906:1 69.3C>:5@13.7486@623/5@1>//183.21:03@13=8137D=17 /6 486/1:/: 3.7 /1.:56. 3B6.< 71@6/11: 01 5B4><.17 68718 C3:17 6. 26.281/1 5./1==5<1.21 5.4>/: 5: /0>: 3 =1<5/5B3/1 3.7 486468/56.3/1 1G1825:1 6; 46918 >.718 12/56. 6; /01 0383/5D3 D3D3 3.05/3 & 5./1.717:6=1=D/6481@1./5BB5.1./75:/>8C3.21/64>C=52 68718 % 01:26416;F>75253=81@5196;3.6871843::17 CD 3. G12>/5@1 3<5:/83/1 >.718 12/56. 6; /01 0383/5D3 3<385? >83?:03 3.05/3 & 5: .121::385=D =5B5/17 >20 68718: 381481@1./5@1 3.7 37B5.5:/83/5@1 5. .3/>81 5::>17 6. /01 C3:5: 6; :>CF12/5@1 :3/5:;32/56. ;68B17 ;86B B3/1853= 4=3217 C1;681 /01 3>/0685/D 81<3875.< 3. 3448101.717 C81320 6; 41321 01 !6>8/ 905=1 1G1825:5.< F>85:752/56. >.718 8/52=1 6; /01 !6.:/5/>/56.761:.6/:5/5.34413=6@18/01:3/5:;32/56.6; /01G12>/5@13<5:/83/168:>C:/5/>/15/:69.645.56.;68
- 14 -
/03/6;/0126B41/1./3>/0685/D./18;181.215:93883./17 6.=D 90181 /01 68718 5: :069. /6 C1 43/1./=D 95/06>/ F>85:752/56.@5/53/17CDB3=3;571:C3:176..6B3/1853= 68:>;;18:;86BB3.5;1:/38C5/8385.1::6=6.<3:/0168718 5:;6>.717>46.81=1@3./3.728175C=15.4>/::>4468/17CD 26./1B4683.16>: 81468/: 6; /01 =39 1.;6821B1./ 3<1.251: 3.7 /01 :3/5:;32/56. 81268717 5: .6/ 71B6.:/83C=D 418@18:1 68 5883/56.3= /01 !6>8/ 96>=7 C1 :=69 /6 5./18;181 01 F>75253= ;62>: 5. :>20 81@519 5: 26.;5.17/61G3B5.5.</017125:56.B3?5.<48621::83/018 /03. /01 7125:56. 5/:1=; /0181CD B35./35.5.< /01 71=523/1 C3=3.21 C1/911. 5.75@57>3= =5C18/D 3.7 /01 .121::5/D 6;
481@1./5@1 32/56. 5. /01 5./181:/ 6; 4>C=52 68718 1.21 /01 81:/852/56. ;3==: 95/05. /01 3BC5/ 6; 8/52=1 I%# 3.7 761:.6/23==;685./18;181.21
. 6@183== 26.:57183/56.
/05: !6>8/ ;5.7: /03/ /01 5B4><.17 48605C5/68D 68718 5: C3:17 6. 81=1@3./ B3/1853=3.75:.15/01838C5/838D.681G21::5@10168718 81481:1./: 3 =1<5/5B3/1 481@1./5@1 B13:>81 5::>17 5. /01
- 15 -
5./181:/ 6; B35./35.5.< 4>C=52 68718 6 <86>.7 5: B371 6>//693883./5./18;181.215.1G1825:16;985/F>85:752/56. ! 5 01985/41/5/56.:/3.7:75:B5::17 55 01 5B4><.17 68718 73/17 %&&% 43::17CD/01:126.781:46.71./E14>/D !6BB5::56.18
"5F3D34>83 5:/852/ 5: 0181CD>401=7 555 / 5: 0691@18 B371 2=138 /03/ /01 41/5/56.18:03==C13/=5C18/D/681.1905: 81A>1:/ ;68 1./8D 3;/18 /01 418567 :/54>=3/175./01687181G4581::>CF12//6 /01481@35=5.<=393.768718:5/>3/56. 5@ 6687183:/626:/:
"+, (""&!&) '! 5:/6=6 !