Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43415 (KAR)
CHANNA BASAYYA AND ANR v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/203452/2018 · 2025-11-04
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43415 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43415 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"!#$%
& %'"%"%
()"*
! !"#$%
!"#$%
&
!"#$%
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
!"#$%
'&(
'$
) ' * + ' ' ,
%#!%-!%+
./ #%$!"
0!'1 %"! %*!%$
0! 2 $!%-!%*%!&
&
0! 3 ) ' &' $ *& - ' 4 5 ' ' ) ) '
'
)
- 3 -
5
! 5
64 748989/.4:; ,:4 14</:4 869; /=:8 ;44>9.? </@@/A9.?:4@94<;
! " #
$
%
! " $
&
%'
'! "
( ) * + ,
, -
-
'
,
+
. %' , - + / !00 (
102( 3-
4 5 -
- /60 &
, 7
+-
--, - + - 00* *
+7 -
64 2,;4 /< 748989/.4:; 9; 86,8 /.4 6,..,1,;;,B, ;/ ,3,;69C,BB, A,; 864 /:9?9.,@ /A.4:
/< @,.3 9. B/*& D4,;=:9.? - ,2:4; ;98=,843 ,8
- 4 -
4://:C9@@,?44C,3=:?,,@=>,926=:9;8:9286,8864 ;,93 6,..,1,;,BB, /:9?9.,@ /A.4: 3943 @/.? 1,2> @4,C9.? 1469.3 69; </=: 269@3:4. 1B .,D4 ,3,;69C,BB, =?,DD,
44:=7,>;6,BB, ,.3 933,BB, :4;7/.34.8 /$64:49. & ,3,;69C,BB, ;8 ;/. 3943 @4,C9.? 1469.3 69;
8A/;/.; .,D4@B /D,.,86 748989/.4: / 64:49. ,.3 :,16,>,:
44:=7,>;6,BB, &:3 ;/. 3943 @4,C9.? 1469.3 69; ;/.; 6,..,1,;,BB, 748989/.4: / 64:49. ,.3 6,.3:,;64>6,: ,.3 , 3,=?684:!,:C,8,BB,
64 =?,DD, 3,=?684: D,::943 8/ /.4 933,BB, 864 ;,93 933,BB, 4E79:43 ;//. ,<84: 69; D,::9,?4 =?,DD, 6,; 144.?9C4.,</:4;,93@,.3</:64:D,9.84.,.2464;,93 =?,DD, 3943 9. 864 B4,: --# A986/=8 @4,C9.? 1469.3 ,.B 269@3:4. 22/:39.?@B 748989/.4:; ,.3 8649: 1:/864:; ;=22443438/;,93@,.3
$ 6,8=7/.86434D9;4/< =?,DD,748989/.4:;
,.3 :4;7/.34.8 /$ ?,C4 ,. ,77@92,89/. 8/ :4;7/.34.8
- 5 -
/& </: D=8,89.? 8649: .,D4; 9. 864 :4C4.=4 :42/:3; 9. :4;7428/<864,</:4;,93@,.3
" 933,BB,!:4;7/.34.8/$$86;/. 2@,9D9.?8/ 6,C4,2F=9:43864:9?68/C4:8647:/74:8B9.84:D;/<864 )9@@ 3,843 -%"% 4E42=843 1B =?,DD, <9@43 ,. ,77@92,89/. ;44>9.? D=8,89/. /< 69; .,D4 9. 864 :4C4.=4 :42/:3;
* 4;7/.34.8 /& 9.989,843 864 4.F=9:B =.34: 4289/.#/<864,:.,8,>,,.34C4.=428-*$</:
;6/:8 G864 28H B :34: 3,843 $%-% .,D4 /< :4;7/.34.8/$A,;D=8,8439.864:4C4.=4:42/:3;
+ 48989/.4:; 7:4<4::43 ,. ,774,@ =.34: 4289/. &* /< 864 28 14</:4 :4;7/.34.8 / 4;7/.34.8 / A986/=8 2/.;934:9.? 864 7:/C9;9/.; /< @,A 39;D9;;43 864 ;,93 ,774,@ 1B /:34: 3,843 %"%*%$ 49.? ,??:94C43 864 748989/.4:; 7:4<4::43 :4C9;9/. 748989/. 14</:4 :4;7/.34.8 / A6/ 1B /:34: 3,843 %#%-%+ :4I42843864:4C9;9/.748989/.2/.<9:D43864/:34:7,;;43
- 6 -
1B:4;7/.34.8/;,.3&49.?,??:94C431B864;,D4 864748989/.4:;,:414</:4869;/=:8
# 4,:.43 2/=.;4@ ,774,:9.? </: 864 748989/.4:;
:4@B9.?=7/.864I=3?D4.8/<864<=@@4.26/<869;/=:89. 864 2,;4 /<
:47/:8439. ! "# $%& ' ;=1D98; 86,8 864 D=8,89/. 1,;43 /. 864 )9@@ 9; ./8 74:D9;;91@4 4 ;=1D98; 86,8 :4;7/.34.8 /; & ,.3 A986/=8 ,3C4:89.?
8/ 869; @4?,@ 7/;989/. 6,C47:/2443438/342@9.48/2/.;934:864/1I4289/.:,9;43 1B 864 748989/.4:; ,.3 6,C4 D=8,843 864 .,D4 /< :4;7/.34.8/$2/.8:,:B8/864;488@437:9.297@4;/<@,A 4.24;44>;</:,@@/A9.?864748989/. - 4,:.43 33989/.,@ /C4:.D4.8 3C/2,84 /. 864 /864: 6,.3 ;=1D98; 86,8 864 7,:894; ,:4 4.898@43 8/ 6,C4 8649: :9?68; 3484:D9.43 14</:4 864 2/D7484.8 /=:8 /<@,A/A4C4:643/4;./839;7=848647/;989/./<@,A,;
- 7 -
4.=.29,8431B 864'=@@ 4.26 /<869; /=:8 9. 864 2,;4/<
% 4,:34:=;43864:42/:3;
'=@@ 4.26 /< 869; /=:8 9. 864 2,;4 /<
,8 7,:,?:,76 /;" 8/ % 6,;64@3,;=.34: 8 1
+
+ - * - *
7
- +
! ++-
! + . -
+ - *
! ++- -,
0
9 -
9 +
+ :00-
. - + -
% ) *00
+
0 ! ! + - % *- *
- * -0 ,
0* 0 0
,
-! + 0
! 0
! , , . - ; +
- +
! ++- --
+ ! ++- ,
! ++- + 2 * ! ,0 +
+ - . - + -
-0
! ++-
3 ! & )
! ++-
0* 2+ 10
*0
" - *
-
0*+ ,
+- 9
-
9
+
, *
. <! ,
*
-
00 3 ! & . - + - ! * + ! &
- 8 -
. - + - 0 *
+ -
+
-
, . - + - 0* + -9 +
. - 0 *
+ ,
+
- )+ -9 --
!! -
-
, + 0
* 0
-- * ,
0
0 +
0
+
+ ! +
00 00 * -9 + -
- ++- * 00
+, ! -
, , )+ 7 -
- ! -
- ++- 000
-0+ 7 -
+
-
+
00 9
7 - + , -,
,
-
0+. - ,2 -0
, -
-
+ ,
0 +:001
! + ! 0
, + :00 . --
6 & 0 !
:00 +
3 ! &
-0 +,-,
& 0
+
+
- ,
,
1 ! --
6 - 0 ,
*00 -+ 1
+
6, 1 , -
--
3 ! =++- - -
:00 -,
-
:00 . - ' +,0 ,, 9 - 00 7
-0 -
*
1 -
0 -0 + 0* +
0 ,0 ,
* -0
+ 0 0 = *
0
- + *
,0
, 0
* >*00? - 9 -
0
0
0 0
*
- ! ++
,
* >:00? )! *+ ! -,
-
++ -
+ *00
30 ' + @ 2 A
3 ! 30
0 * 0 , + )
! -
+ - 00
9
-
. ++- + 3 ! ( ,
90
2 , +*-
- 00 ! --
) - -00
-
+
9 00 0 0 0-
00
-
+ ,
1 0
-
00
-+ ++- 0
9
0+ *- 00 -
+,, + +- 0-
9
+
- =+ -
0 ! - -
&,, - + .(! *
-00 +01
+
-,
-0
! ! ++- * B 0
9
- + -
! & 1 ! +-
+, -
,
+
,2
-0 0 +
- +
-
- ! & )+ 0
,,!0
- 0
-
9
! & ,- 0
-
+ * ! )
+ 0-
! & -
- - 0 9 + ,
-! + 0
! 0
! ,
7
-
- 10 -
9 + 0
- + ,,!0
*-
"-0! 0 ! &!0&
& 30 ' *
-0, 0
0 :00+
+ ,
! -
+ - ,
3 ! & 0
, +-
+
-,
!0 ! -
+
:00-,
* + 0 -- $ ! + . - *
* + 0
0
0 0 --
!! -
! * - 0 0 *
-,
0
0 +
-
* 0 0 *00--,
0 +
+
" - )+ :00
!
0 0 * -9 0
--
!! -
-0,
:00 *
0 )+ :00
- + + :00 9
. - %'
% + .-- -
! :
! & ! +,
-
, +
9
+
0
+ :00+ * ! +
! & 9 *0
C
--, -
! & ! 7
-
!0
+ :00 9
+ 0
- + 0 1
- + 3 ! &
- 0
+- 1 3 ! & -
9 + 0 +
0
* +
-, -00
-,
++ +0 -
,
, 2 -
- 11 -
- 2 ! + 30 ' - + :00
#, + - -0
! ++- 7
- 9
-
+ :00 ! + 0,
+ ,2
,
+00
"-0! 0 * 7
- + &!0 &
*
* --
0 D
4@4C,.8 7/:89/. /< 864 /:34: /< 864 47=8B /DD9;;9/.4::4,3;,;=.34: !"#$%&'()
)*+,#-./) 01+)(232(!45672(3))(8)8$19(:
; ,#-./ <= 2 -> ?13 ,1# 8 @&2 ! 2A1#BC2DE2(< FG(H:
?13,1#%<I "!())(J11(<9 KH+ L& 2(3))(8)./ %<L 9MN(<1* O( L& 2(3))(8)P(1?13,1#2DH< QN(<1* 8$(/,#-<9R,!<9./Q1;,#-./E2 ( (@,SL 2 -> ?1* ,1# . 1T(H <!<(!-)($8UFGH(2 2=1
1+() )*+ ()6 C "!( (@,SL 8=2& RV1(:H(2 2%'(:
W2D))((-K8 01+ (2 21=8/+ 2 C67)1+ 6681X 1* 3R*(: )($(
W 2DJ 1,JU
R) (2D 2(2 E,U 9MJK8/ 1*
"!( ,+ )($( (2D ,YG(<JK8/
H+ E2 W2D 2(1=(: 51*(:
& @4,:@B 864 :4;7/.34.8!,=86/:9894; 6,C4 7:/2443438/D=8,84864.,D4/<:4;7/.34.8/$</=.3
- 12 -
9. 864 )9@@ 3,843 %+--$ 7=:7/:843@B 4E42=843 1B =?,DD,
$ . C94A /< 864 ,</:4;,93 7/;989/. /< @,A 864 /:34:;9D7=?.432,../814;=;8,9.43
" 64A:98748989/.9;,@@/A43
* 64 9D7=?.43 /:34:; ,8 ..4E=:4! ,.3 ' ,:4F=,;643
+ 9.24 864 4E42=89/. /< )9@@ 1B =?,DD, 9. <,C/=: /< :4;7/.34.8 /$ 9; 39;7=843 98 9; </: 864 :4;7/.34.8/$8/,C,9@;=26:4D43B,;D,B14,C,9@,1@4 14</:4,2/D7484.8/=:8/<@,A
# 64 :4;7/.34.8!,=86/:9894; ;6,@@ 2/.;934: 864 :47:4;4.8,89/. /< 748989/.4:; A6/ ,:4 2@,9D9.? 8/ 6,C4 ;=22443438/7:/74:8B/< =?,DD,
"+) (%"%* '! +$(