- 1 - ! " #$ % % "" &%' ( ! " # $%&!'! Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( " )* " $'''!+ *(, !(')('( ! " * * !-+ ! * * " !-'!('!) * .!+ !!+('! * / * * " - 3 - 0 $ 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 4556774=< . >742?4=< 366@2=A6=14=>6?6=<B8>B?56=34<2B=434C4D9692=<16 EF9A?6=< 4=9 4C4D9 94<69 !-'!('!) 543369 2= B!!+('! :; <16 992<2B=47 23<D2>< 4=9 6332B=3 F9A6 4=9 6?:6D .!+ 2E4;45FD4 8BD 31BD<GD2:F=47H '( 16 84><3 76492=A <B 8272=A B8 >742? 56<2<2B= 4D6 43F=96D. 14< B= (!'-('! 4< 4:BF< !''' 4? <16 4556774=<.>742?4=<:62=A9D2I6DB84F<B.D2>@314C:64D2=A 6AB .(%.')'C439D2I2=A1234F<B.D2>@314C<BC4D93 2E4;45FD4 8DB? 6I4D412554D4A2 4< <14< <2?6 4 DF>@ 2>16D:64D2=A6AB .(%..!- >4?68DB? B55B32<6 92D6><2B= 2= 4 12A1 35669 4=9D431 4=9 =6A72A6=< ?4==6D 4=9 9D2I6D 7B3< >B=<DB7 BI6D <16 3429 I612>76 4=9 943169 - 4 - 4A42=3< <16 4F<B.D2>@314C F6 <B C12>1 <16 >742?4=< 3F3<42=69AD26IBF32=EFD26316>742?4=<<4@6=<D64<?6=< 4=9 82769 <16 >742? 56<2<2B= 16 D2:F=47 43363369 >B?56=34<2B= 4=9 543369 <16 2?5FA=69 4C4D9 16 >742?4=< 143 82769 <16 5D636=< 455647 366@2=A 6=14=>6?6=<B8<16>B?56=34<2B= '+ 64D9 764D=69 >BF=367 8BD <16 4556774=< . >742?4=< 4=9 764D=69 >BF=367 8BD D635B=96=< B( $ 2=3FD4=>6>B?54=; ' 64D=69 >BF=367 8BD <16 4556774=< . >742?4=< CBF79>B=<6=9<14<<16"($9B><BDC1B143233F69<16 9234:272<; >6D<282>4<6 4< J) 143 3<4<69 <14< <16D6 23 4 56D?4=6=<9234:272<;B8<164556774=<.>742?4=<B8!'<B(' 56D>6=<B8<16C1B76:B9;4=92=352<6B8<14<<16D2:F=47 143=B<<4@6=<1634299234:272<;4=9=B<4C4D969<167B33 B88F<FD62=>B?668FD<16D3F:?2<3<14<<16D62341649 2=EFD; 4=9 8D4><FD6 B8 =4347 :B=6 C2<1 768< 54D26<47 16?4<B?44=9>B=3296D2=A<1634?69234:272<;143<B:6 - 5 - 4336336968FD<16D3F:?2<3<14<=B<2B=472=>B?682J6943 56D<1614D<5D654D698BD36<<76?6=<B89235F<632=B@. 9474<1 :; <16 4D=4<4@4 6A47 6DI2>63 F<1BD2<; <16 =B<2B=47 2=>B?6 8BD <16 ;64D ('! 23 3%'''. 56D ?B=<168FD<16D3F:?2<3<14<<16>B?56=34<2B=4C4D969 F=96D<161649B87B33B82=>B?69FD2=A<167429F556D2B9 23 B= 7BC6D 3296 16 D2:F=47 143 =B< 4C4D969 <16 >B?56=34<2B= <BC4D93 7B33 B8 4?6=2<263 4<<6=94=< 4=9 >B=I6;4=>6 >14DA63 "2<1 <1636 16 5D4;3 <B 477BC <16 455647 ' 64D=69 >BF=367 8BD D635B=96=< B( $ 2=3FD4=>6>B?54=;CBF79>B=<6=9<14<<169F6<B2=EFD; <16>742?4=<143=B<3F3<42=694=;9234:272<;B=3296D2=A <16 34?6 <16 D2:F=47 143 D2A1<7; =B< 4C4D969 <16 7B33 8F<FD6 2=>B?6 4=9 >B?56=34<2B= 4C4D969 F=96D B<16D 164934D6EF3<4=95DB56D"2<1<1636165D4;3<B923?233 <16455647 - 6 - '& 4I2=A164D9764D=69>BF=3678BD<164556774=< . >742?4=< 4=9 764D=69 >BF=367 8BD D635B=96=< B( $ 2=3FD4=>6 >B?54=; <123 BFD< 56DF369 <16 2?5FA=69 EF9A?6=<4=9<16?4<6D2473574>69B=D6>BD9 '- 164556774=<$>742?4=<C434A69(;64D343 B=<1694<6B84>>296=<4=916C4349D2I6D:;B>>F54<2B= "( $ B><BD C1B 143 233F69 J) $ 9234:272<; >6D<282>4<6C16D62=2<233<4<69<14<<16>742?4=<2314I2=A !'<B!56D>6=<9234:272<;B8<16C1B76:B9;16>742?4=< 143 3F3<42=69 1649 2=EFD263 4=9 8D4><FD6 B8 =4347 :B=6 B=3296D2=A <16 34?6 4=9 <16 9234:272<; 3<4<69 :; <16 9B><BD<16>742?4=<236=<2<769<B7B33B88F<FD62=>B?6:; <4@2=A<169234:272<;4<-K164556774=<$>742?4=<C43 4A69 4:BF< ( ;64D3 4< <16 <2?6 B8 4>>296=< <16 5DB56D ?F7<25726D45572>4:7623!! '% =I26CB8<164:BI6<16>742?4=<236=<2<769<B 7B33B88F<FD62=>B?643F=96D. 3%'''.J!(J!!J-KL3-+)('. - 7 - ') 16 D2:F=47 143 D2A1<7; 4C4D969 <16 >B?56=34<2B= 4< 3+''''. <BC4D93 542= 4=9 3F886D2=A 4=9 3('''. <BC4D93 ?692>47 6J56=363 4=9 6J<D4 =BFD231?6=< !' B=3296D2=A <16 8D4><FD6 B8 =4347 :B=6 <16 4556774=< $ >742?4=< 23 6=<2<769 <B 7B33 B8 4?6=2<263 2= 4 3F?B83+''''. !! 16D2:F=47143=B<4C4D969<16>B?56=34<2B= <BC4D934<<6=94=<4=9>B=I6;4=>6>14DA6316D68BD6<16 >742?4=< 23 6=<2<769 <B >B?56=34<2B= <BC4D93 4<<6=94=< 4=9>B=I6;4=>6>14DA634<3!''''. !( 16D2:F=471434C4D9693!'%''.<BC4D93 7B33 B8 2=>B?6 9FD2=A<16 7429 F556D2B9B=3296D2=A <16 8D4><FD6 4=9 B<16D 2=EFD263 <16 4556774=< $ >742?4=< 23 6=<2<769<B7B33B82=>B?69FD2=A<167429F556D2B98BD<CB ?B=<132=43F?B83%'''.J(L3!&'''. - 8 - !+ =I26CB8<164:BI6<164556774=<$>742?4=<23 6=<2<769<B<B<47>B?56=34<2B=43F=96D. ) *+,- ./0*1-+231 /0*1-+231 +4+5,*,67283-952 ! B33B88F<FD62=>B?6 3-+)('. ( 42=4=93F886D2=A 3+''''. + 692>476J56=363 3('''. <<6=94=< 4=9 >B=I6;4=>6>14DA63 3!''''. B33 B8 2=>B?6 9FD2=A <167429F556D2B9 3!&'''. & B33B84?6=2<263 3+''''. 2+) -: ; ! = I26C B8 <164:BI6 <164556774=< $ >742?4=< 4D6 6=<2<769 <B <B<47 >B?56=34<2B= B8 3!%)('. 43 4A42=3<3!'%''.434C4D969:;<16D2:F=47 - 9 - ! 16 D2:F=47 143 4C4D969 <16 2=<6D63< 4< <16 D4<6 B8 )K 54 4=9 <16 34?6 23 B= 12A16D 3296 4=9 C2<1BF< 4=; :4323 6=>6 <16 4556774=< $ >742?4=< 23 6=<2<769<B2=<6D63<4<<16D4<6B8&K548DB?<1694<6B8 56<2<2B= <277 2<3 D6472M4<2B= B= <16 6=14=>69 <16 >B?56=34<2B= !& 16 4556774=< $ >742?4=< 23 =B< 6=<2<769 <B 2=<6D63< 8BD <16 9674; 56D2B9 B8 (+( 94;3 2= 8272=A <16 4556474356DBD96D94<69!!(('(' !- =I26CB8<164:BI6<168B77BC2=A, 1645564723477BC692=54D< 16EF9A?6=<4=94C4D994<69!-'!('!)5433692= B!!+('!:;<16 992<2B=4723<D2><4=9 6332B=3 F9A6 4=9 6?:6D .!+ 2E4;45FD4 23?B92826943F=96D. - 10 - 16 4556774=< $ >742?4=< 23 6=<2<769 <B <B<47 >B?56=34<2B= B8 3!%)('. 43 4A42=3< 3!'%''.434C4D969:;<16D2:F=4747B=AC2<1 2=<6D63< 4< <16 D4<6 B8 &K 54 8DB? <16 94<6 B8 56<2<2B= <277 2<3 D6472M4<2B= B= <16 6=14=>69 >B?56=34<2B= 164556774=<$>742?4=<23=B<6=<2<769<B2=<6D63<8BD <169674;56D2B9B8(+(94;32=8272=A<16455647 16 D635B=96=< B( $ 2=3FD4=>6 >B?54=; 31477 965B32< <16 3429 4C4D9 4?BF=< C2<1 2=<6D63< :68BD6 <16 D2:F=47 C2<12= '% C66@3 8DB? <123 94; 84272=A C12>1 2< 23 724:76 <B 54; 2=<6D63< 4< <16 D4<6 B8 )K 54 ,; & % %' $ 23<B!7B++