Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43380 (KAR)
MADIWALAPPA v. SAVITRI AND ORS
WP/203198/2024 · 2025-10-08
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43380 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43380 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"!#
$ %&"%"%
'%(
!"! # $%
%
&
! ! '"
%
(
%
(
((
$
& %% !"! # $
! "" "
( ))&
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
) )
& )
%
"*!!"*
*
"!%) +
, &
)
%
*
"! )% ,&
) %
) ) )
) %
) %
-%
! $
-%
&
./0/012.3 451 06 7.8.2792/ 1! 02 1*
"! 06 :.813. /506 1;3/ :.02< 9<<30.=.7 :> /5.137.379/.7"*!!"*?966.702/5.69076;0/:>/5. - 3 -
77@ .20130=0@;7<.0A9>9?;39$8136513/B/5.309@ 1;3/C&
5. 309@ 1;3/ 450@. 9@@1402< /5. 9??@0D9/012 80@.7 :> /5. 3.6?127.2/6?@902/088 16! /1 ( ;27.3 37.3'
;@.!"$&1817.180=0@31D.7;3.$8136513/ B-& 596 703.D/.7 /5. ?./0/012.37.8.2792/ 1! /1 9??.93:.813./5.1;3/813<0=02<:@11769E?@.6813 /.6/ (
5. 9:1=. 6;0/ 06 813 ?93/0/012 927 6.?939/. ?166.66012 80@.7 :> /5. ?@902/08863.6?127.2/6 5.3.02 9<9026/ 7.8.2792/ 1!?.//012.3 5.3.02 / 06 D12/.27.7 /59/?@902/0881!3.6?127.2/1!06/5.408.927?@902/088 16927(F3.6?127.2/16927(5.3.0293./5.6126 187.8.2792/1!927?./0/012.35.3.02/06:96.712/506 3.@9/012650? /5. ?@902/08863.6?127.2/ 16! /1 ( 5.3.02 59=.61;<5/ 813 ?93/0/012 927 6.?939/. ?166.66012 18 6;0/ 6D5.7;@.?31?.3/0.6
- 4 -
* .8.2792/ 1!?./0/012.3 5.3.02 596 7.20.7 /5.3.@9/012650?927/5.D@90E18/5.?@902/08863.6?127.2/ 16!/1(5.3.02
2 6;??13/ 18 /5.03 D12/.2/012 ?@902/0886 3.6?127.2/ 16! /1 ( 5.3.02 59=. 977;D.7 139@ 927 71D;E.2/93> .=07.2D. 927 59=. 9@61 .G9E02.7 /41 40/2.66.629E.@>9597.=9??99279650:9045193./5. D1EE129DH;902/92D.18/5.?@902/08869277.8.2792/1! F ?./0/012.3 5.3.02 96 927 ( 3.6?.D/0=.@> 5.> 59=.9@61<1/E93I.771D;E.2/93>.=07.2D.02/5.29/;3. 18 6D511@ @.9=02< D.3/080D9/. 975993 937 @.D/012 7.2/0/>937?51/1<39?56450D593.E93I.796G6! /1(927(*/1(
' /9??.936/5.?@902/0886F3.6?127.2/61!/1( 5.3.02 12 .93@0.3 1DD96012 597 80@.7 60E0@93 9??@0D9/012 ;27.3 37.3 ++
;@. !" 18 17. 18 0=0@ 31D.7;3. 12
"'"! 02 1 450D5 D9E. /1 :. 3.A.D/.7 <<30.=.7 :> 450D5 /5. ?@902/0886 597 9??319D5.7 /506
- 5 -
1;3/ :> 80@02< 30/ ./0/012 1"!! "! 5. 1 137029/.%.2D518/5061;3/=07.137.379/.7"" "* 9@@14.7/5.430/?./0/01202?93/6./9607./5.6907137.3 3.6/13.7/5.9??@0D9/012$1&/1/5.80@.927703.D/.7 /5. 309@ 1;3/ /1 D12607.3 /5. 6907 9??@0D9/012 98/.3 D12D@;601218/5..=07.2D.:>/5.?93/0.65.0E?;<2.7 137.3 6;:A.D/ E9//.3 18 ?3.6.2/ ?./0/012 596 /5;6 :..2 ?966.7:>/5.309@1;3/028;3/5.392D./1/5.6907137.3 ?966.7:>/5.1137029/.%.2D518/5061;3/9@@1402</5. 69079??@0D9/012703.D/02<7.8.2792/1!?./0/012.35.3.02 /1 9??.93 :.813. /5. 1;3/ 813 <0=02< :@117 69E?@.6 813 /.6/
.932.7D1;26.@813/5.?./0/012.36;:E0/6/59/ /5. 309@ 1;3/ 596 21/ <0=.2 @.<9@@> 9DD.?/9:@. 3.96126 3.H;0302< 6;:A.D/02< 7.8.2792/ 1!?./0/012.3 5.3.02 813 /.6/ 02 /5. @0<5/ 18 /5. E9/.309@ .=07.2D. 9@3.97> ?317;D.7 :.813. /5. 1;3/ . 6;:E0/6 /59/ /5. 309@ 1;3/ 40/51;/ 69/068>02< 0/6.@8 40/5 3.<937 /1 /5. /.6/ 18 B.E02.2/ 2..7C 96 .E?5960J.7 :> /5. ?.G 1;3/ 02 /5. - 6 -
D96.18
!1;<5/21//1 59=. ?31D..7.7 /1 9@@14 /5. 9??@0D9/012 E.D5920D9@@> 6;:A.D/02</5.?./0/012.3813/.6/.9@613.@0.6;?12 /5. A;7<E.2/ 18 /5. ?.G 1;3/ 02 /5. D96. 18
/1 D12/.27 /59/ /5. 309@ 1;3/ 1;<5/ /1 59=. ?31/.D/.7 /5.
02/.3.6/ 18 /5.?93/>C6 30<5/ /1 ?30=9D> 927 70<20/> :.813. 6;:A.D/02< 7.8.2792/ 1!?./0/012.35.3.02813/.6/.6;:E0/6/59/0/06 6.//@.7 ?31?160/012 18 @94 /59/ 6;:A.D/02< /5. ?93/0.6 813 /.6/ D9221/ :. <392/.7 813 E.3. 96I02< ;2@.66 /5. 1;3/?96602</5.137.369/0680.79:1;//5.3.H;03.E.2/18 /5. 69E. . 6;:E0/6 /59/ /5. 3.96126 9660<2.7 02 /5. 0E?;<2.7137.37121/706D@16.6;D592..759=02<:..2 9??3.D09/.7:>/5.309@1;3/.2D./5.137.39DD13702< /150E06;26;6/9029:@. 51;<5 /5. 21/0D. 18 /506 ?./0/012 596 :..2 6.3=.7 12 /5. ?@902/0886 3.6?127.2/6 /5.3. 06 21 3.?3.6.2/9/012
- 7 -
K .937.3;6.7/5.3.D1376
!" ;0/0612.813?93/0/0129276.?939/.?166.66012 80@.7 :> /5. ?@902/088 16! /1 ( 3.6?127.2/ 16! /1 ( 5.3.02 D@90E02< 7.8.2792/ 1! ?./0/012.3 /1 :. /5. 5;6:92718?@902/0881!92789/5.318?@902/08816927 ( 450D5 3.@9/012650? 596 :..2 7.20.7 :> 7.8.2792/ 1! ?./0/012.3 6 9@3.97> 21/.7 9:1=. 9?93/ 831E .G9E0202</41027.?.27.2/40/2.66.6966927(/5. ?@902/088659=.9@61?317;D.771D;E.2/93>.=07.2D.02/5. 29/;3. 18 /39268.3 D.3/080D9/. 6D511@ @.9=02< D.3/080D9/. 97593937.@.D/012D9376927?51/1<39?56
!! 5.1137029/.%.2D518/5061;3/12.93@0.3 1DD96012 =07. 0/6 137.3 79/.7 "" "* ?966.7 02 1"!! "! 597 703.D/.7 /5. 309@ 1;3/ /1 3. D12607.3/5.69079??@0D9/012450D50/5973.A.D/.7:>0/6 .93@0.3 137.3 79/.7 '""! 98/.3 D12D@;6012 18 .=07.2D. 18 /5. ?@902/088 927 7.8.2792/ 1! 2 1/5.3 41376 /506 1;3/ 597 027..7 0270D9/.7 /59/ 6907
- 8 -
9??@0D9/012 /1 :. D12607.3.7 08 98/.3 .=9@;9/012 18 /5. .=07.2D. /5. 309@ 1;3/ 81;27 0/ 2.D.6693> /1 ?31D..7 8;3/5.3 /1 ?966 137.36 12 6907 9??@0D9/012 506 D92 :. 028.33.7831E/5.@.<9@?31?160/012@9077142:>/5.?.G 1;3/ 02 /5. D96. 18 02 450D5 9/ ?939<39?516!!!!(!*!'!927!K5965.@796 ;27.3
! " #
#
$ % &
$ $#
"# '
% $
" # "% & #$
"# $"% &
(
)
% *
+ ,( )
% *
+! - . /01 ! $ 2
#
# # 2
# #
" # $
#
$ . % -3! - 9 -
% 4 "
# 5
6 # 7"
)86 +86 #$
%&# $
)86
#
" % 9
$ #
# # 6 %$%
#
# $ $
$
# )86 !
% &
" : # #
# ##
#
"
%9 # # #
$
# $ $
$ #
% ; 2 $
$ $ # # # < #
$ $ #
" <
%= &
#$
"#
"
" $ #
! " " #
% & # > .(
)
,(
)
%* +! -. /01! %-3! % ? 9
# #
"
$ $7"
- 10 -
#
$
$
% # # # #>
! $
# #
# $
"
$
% & ! $
"
" #
"
#% ;! " " # #
"! ## 2 #
$
$# $ #
"% " #
## $ # #
% & # #
# $
" #
$ $
## %= # #
" %9 $! #"! $
% (
$
# ##! # :!>
" #
$
# %% 2 # ! %&
" #
$
$ ! $
" ! "# #
$
#
- 11 -
" " " $#
"% :
! '
##)86
"
## "
)86! % # # % 6
$! " :
$ # '
$
##)86%@
$ $# #>
# % ! "
! ##
$
## #
! $
# #
%
$
#
"!+! #-
$# ##
##
" % &#! # #
"
## "
$ )86 ! " #
% :
# $ #
#
- 12 -
#
$
"#
##$%
"
&
##
#
#
#>%"! $
$ "
$ #
"
! $$ "
$"%=
! 2/5.026/92/D96./51;<5/5.309@1;3/596 /9I.221/.183.H;03.E.2/183.D13702<0/6802702<612/5. .G06/.2D.18B.E02.2/2..7C9681;279/?939<39?56!(927 !*514.=.39/?939<39?56!927!'180/6137.3/5.309@ 1;3/5961:6.3=.796;27.3 %
$ #
# ;A ;
$#(:!$ %&+# ##8%-!B)#
## #
$ ### 8%%657%*%57%*%0 $ : " " # #
# 8%
$
<
- 13 -
7
$7 2
#
%
3%
! ##
"" # )86 & "
$ #
## 8% - # 8%% )# 8% $
"
$
"
##! "
$#$
$)86&%=
!( 5;6 96 6..2 9:1=. .GD.?/ 97=.3/02< /1 /5. .=07.2D. @.7 :> /5. ?@902/0886 :> ?317;D02< 71D;E.2/93> .=07.2D. G6 /1 K /5.
309@ 1;3/ 596 21/ <0=.2 92>69/0689D/13>3.961202<8130//1D1E./1/5.D12D@;6012 18 /5.3. :.02< /5. .G06/.2D. 18 B.E02.2/ 2..7C
.96126 514.=.3 9660<2.7 93. /59/ /.6/ 41;@7 :. B:.6/ .=07.2D.C /1 .6/9:@065 /5. /3;/5 506 06 21/ /5. /.6/ D12/.E?@9/.7 /1 6;:A.D/ ?93/> 813 /.6/ 6 21/.7 9:1=. /5. ?.G 1;3/ 596 1:6.3=.7 /59/ .G06/.2D. 18 B.E02.2/ 2..7C D92 :. 81;27 98/.3 9??3.D09/02< /5.1/5.3 E9/.309@.=07.2D.E97.9=90@9:@.123.D137450D502/5. 026/92/ D96. 71.6 21/ 6..E /1 59=. :..2 D1E?@0.7 40/5
- 14 -
:> /5. 309@ 1;3/ 2 1/5.3 41376 /5. 309@ 1;3/ 496 3.H;03.7/19??3.D09/./5..=07.2D.@.7:>/5.?93/0.6927 98/.3D1E02</1/5.D12D@;6012/59//5.6907.=07.2D.496 21/ 6;880D0.2/ 12@> /5.3.98/.3 /5. 309@ 1;3/ D1;@7 59=. D1E. /1 /5. D12D@;6012 18 3.H;03.E.2/ 18 6;:A.D/02< /5. ?./0/012.3813/.6/69@615.@7:>/5.?.G1;3/08 02 /5. .=.2/ 18 309@ 1;3/ D1E02< /1 /5. D12D@;6012 18 3.H;03.E.2/ 18 D127;D/02< /.6/ 0/ D92 D9@@ ;?12 7.8.2792/ 1! ?./0/012.3 /1 6;:A.D/ 50E6.@8 813 <0=02< :@11769E?@.927085.3.8;6.6/1D1E?@>40/5/5.69E. 97=.36. 028.3.2D. D92 :. 73942 %;/ 813 /506 /5. 309@ 1;3/596/18036/69/068>/5./.6/18B.E02.2/2..7C450D506 9:6.2/02/5.0E?;<2.7137.3
!* 2=0.418/5.9:1=.89D/;9@@.<9@?160/01218/5. E9//.3 /506 1;3/ 06 18 /5. D12607.3.7 =0.4 /59/ /5. ?3.6.2/ ?./0/012 :. 706?16.7 18 40/5 /5. 81@@1402< 703.D/0126 $9& 5.137.30E?;<2.7659@@21/:.<0=.2.88.D/ /1/0@@/5.309@1;3/9??3.D09/.6/5.E9/.309@
- 15 -
.=07.2D. ?@9D.7 12 3.D137 :> /5. ?93/0.6 3.<93702< /5.03 3.@9/012650? 2@> 98/.3 9??3.D09/02< /5. E9/.309@ .=07.2D. 9@3.97> ?@9D.7123.D13708/5.309@1;3/D1E.6/1 /5. D12D@;6012 3.<93702< /5. .G06/.2D. 18 B.E02.2/ 2..7C 12@> /5.2 D9@@ ;?12 /5. ?./0/012.3 /1 ?3.6.2/ 50E6.@8 /1 <0=. /5. :@117 69E?@.6 96 703.D/.7 02 /5. 0E?;<2.7 137.3 $:& ;D5 137.3 659@@ 514.=.3 :. ?966.7 98/.3 ?31=0702<6;880D0.2/1??13/;20/>/1/5.?93/0.6 3.<93702<.G06/.2D.18B.E02.2/2..7C $D& 0@@6;D5137.306?966.7/5.0E?;<2.7137.3 659@@:.I.?/029:.>92D. 0/5/5.9:1=.1:6.3=9/0126/5.?./0/01206## $
")* '%"%( &! ! (*