- 1 - !"#" $# %% && '%( ) ! " # $ %&"'( ( )) ) %&*"'" ! )(+ "& '( ('("," Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) "-" ) . . .'', / ) ) , "- '- ('"$ *"('"( ) )) 0 # 1233456756 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4: "- '- ('"$ ?2@@4: AB 457C> 7D73 9:64 25: 4;A4> , 9::4A7123 EC> @1C>< F<>7A9523G 75 5C *"('"( <17@ 2??4237@E734: ( >7 2>@12D2>:125 237?2<73 342>54: HC95@43 @9A;7<<4: <12< 2??423 =2@ AB H327;25< EC> 45125H4;45< CE HC;?45@2<7C5 < =2@ @9A;7<<4: <12< C5 '" '" ('"" =145 H327;25<=2@<>2D43756759<C>7HI@12=A42>7565C ,* 2<237IC<7, 952@267>C2:542>589;25 761H1CC3 7<@:>7D4> :>CD4 7< 75 >2@1 25: 54637645< ;2554> :94 <C =17H1 H327;25< - 3 - =2@<1>C=5C9<CED417H3425:7<@>42>=1443>25CD4>14>34E< ECC< 25: @14 =2@ :>2664: EC> @C;4 :7@<25H4 4@?7<4 <2I756 <>42<;45< @14 :7: 5C<>4HCD4> E933B 25: @9@<2754: ?4>;2545< ?1B@7H23:7@2A737<B25:3C@@CE42>5756H2?2H7<B 14>4EC>4 @14 E734: H327; ?4<7<7C5 95:4> 4H<7C5 "** CE C<C> 417H34@ H< 26275@<C=54>25:75@9>4>CE9<C>7HI@12= 4@?7<4 @4>D7H4 C=54> :7: 5C< 2??42> 25: =2@ ?32H4: 5@9>4> C??C@4: H327; ?4<7<7C5 :45B756 CHH9>>45H4 CE 2HH7:45< :94 <C >2@1 25: 54637645< :>7D756 AB :>7D4> CE 75@9>4: D417H34 233C=756 ?2@@4564>@ A4BC5: @42<756 H2?2H7<B25:23346756D7C32<7C5CE<4>;@25:HC5:7<7C5@CE?C37HB CE75@9>25H4 . 2@4: C5 ?342:756@ <>7A9523 E>2;4: 7@@94@ 25: >4HC>:4: 4D7:45H4 327;25< 4J2;754: 14>@43E 2@ " 25: J17A7<@ " <C "' =4>4 6C< ;2>I4: EE7H723 CE 75@9>4> =2@ 4J2;754:2@ "25:6C<;2>I4:J17A7< " 5 HC5@7:4>2<7C5 <>7A9523 143: 2HH7:45< 12: CHH9>>4::94<C>2@125:54637645<>7:756CE75@9>4:D417H34AB 7<@ :>7D4> H327;25< 12: @9@<2754: ?4>;2545< ?1B@7H23 - 4 - :7@2A737<B3C@@ CE 42>5756 H2?2H7<B 25: =2@ 45<7<34: EC> HC;?45@2<7C52@EC33C=@ 3 5C 42:@ ;C95< " 275@9EE4>756 @ ( ''','' ( 4:7H234J?45@4@ @ " '& *'','' C@@CE75HC;4:9>756327:9??4>7C: @ & ''','' . C@@CE2;457<74@ @ ''','' >2D433756K2<<45:25<H12>64@ @ "' ''','' *+, - 7@@2<7@E74:=7<1@2;4 H327;25<=2@752??423 * < =2@ E7>@<3B @9A;7<<4: J ,=C95: H4><7E7H2<4 =C93: 75:7H2<4 H327;25< @9@<2754: E>2H<9>4 CE ?123B5J CE 34E< <C4 HC5<9@7C5 CD4> 34E< @4HC5: <C4 =7<1 E>2H<9>4 CE ?>CJ7;23 ?123B5J CE 34E< @4HC5: <C4 =7<1 :7@3CH2<7C5 CE ?>CJ7;23 75<4> ?123B564C38C75< 14>4EC>4 2=2>:CE@ ''',<C=2>:@F3C@@ CE 2;457<74@G =2@ C5 3C=4> @7:4 < =2@ @9A;7<<4: <>7A9523 2=2>:4:;4264> HC;?45@2<7C5 <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CE 75HC;4 :9>756 327:,9? ?4>7C: < =2@ @9A;7<<4: <1C961 H327;25< <CCI <>42<;45<EC>:2B@ 2=2>:CE@ "' ''',<C=2>:@75H7:45<23 4J?45@4@ =2@ C5 3C=4> @7:4 5 2ACD4 6>C95:@ @C961< EC> 45125H4;45< - 5 - - 5 C<14> 125: >7 9:12>@125 342>54: HC95@43 EC> 75@9>4> C??C@4: 2??423 < =2@ @9A;7<<4: <2I756 5C<4 CE 7589>74@ @9@<2754: AB H327;25< <>7A9523 12@ 2=2>:4: 89@< HC;?45@2<7C5 25: <14>4 7@ 5C @HC?4 EC> 45125H4;45< 25: @C961<:7@;7@@23CE2??423 & 42>: 342>54: HC95@43 EC> ?2><74@ 25: ?4>9@4: 7;?9654:89:6;45<25:2=2>: $ )>C; 2ACD4 25: @75H4 7< 7@ H327;25<G@ 2??423 EC> 45125H4;45< ?C75<<12<=C93:2>7@4EC>HC5@7:4>2<7C57@ "' HH9>>45H4CE2HH7:45<75DC3D75675@9>4:D417H34:94 <C >2@1 25: 54637645< :>7D756 AB 7<@ :>7D4> 25: H327;25< @9@<2757567589>74@2>45C<75:7@?9<4 @CA@4>D4:AB<>7A9523 >4E4>>756 <C J , =C95: H4><7E7H2<4 H327;25< @9@<2754: HC5<9@7C5=C95:@25:E>2H<9>4CE?123B5JCE34E<<C4 <>25643B 7< 7@ H327;4: <12< @14 <CCI 75,?2<745< <>42<;45< EC> @2;4 EC> ?4>7C: CE F :2B@G 2@ ?4> J & 5 25B H2@4 <>7A9523 12@ 2=2>:4:@ ( ''',<C=2>:@F?27525:@9EE4>756GHC5@7:4>7567< 2@ ;28C> E>2H<9>4 =C93: A4 ;C>4 <125 2:4L92<4 < 12@ 2=2>:4:@ " '& *'',<C=2>:@;4:7H234J?45@4@26275@<A733@ - 6 - ?>C:9H4:EC>@ " '& **,=17H17@2:4L92<425::C4@5C<H233 EC> 4@H232<7C5 < 2=2>:4: @ & ''', <C=2>:@ F3C@@ CE 75HC;4 :9>756 327:,9? ?4>7C:G <2I756 ;C5<13B 75HC;4 CE H327;25< 2< @ . ''', 327;25<12@@<2<4:<12<@14=2@=C>I7562@CC374 25: 42>5756 @ * ''', ?4> ;C5<1 C=4D4> @14 E2734: <C @9A@<25<72<4@2;4 C<7C52375HC;4EC>@27:B42>7@@ * ''', 2@ 2:C?<4: AB EC> @4<<34;45< CE H2@4@ A4EC>4 CI :232<1 45H4 <>7A9523 =2@ 5C< 89@<7E74: 75 2=2>:756 75HC;4 :9>756327:9??4>7C:2<@ & ''', 2;412@<CA445125H4: <C@ "( ''',@ * ''',J( "" C>;233B HC5<9@7C5=C95:@25:E>2H<9>4CE?123B5J CE 34E< <C4 =C93: 5C< 342: <C 25B :7@2A737<B C=4D4> <>7A9523 12@2=2>:4:@ ''',<C=2>:@F3C@@CE2;457<74@G 52A@45H4 CE25B@?4H7E7H4D7:45H425:@75H4H327;25<12@5C<4J2;754: 25B:CH<C> <14>4=C93:A45C@HC?4EC>;C:7E7H2<7C5 "( 7I4=7@4 2=2>: CE @ "' ''', <C=2>:@ <>2D43756 25:2<<45:25<H12>64@EC>:2B@=C93:23@C2??42>2:4L92<4 19@ ?C75<EC>HC5@7:4>2<7C57@25@=4>4:?2><3B752EE7>;2<7D4 C5@4L945<3B EC33C=756 - 7 - 7 ??4237@ + 77 9:6;45<25:2=2>::2<4:"- '- ('"$?2@@4: AB 457C> 7D73 9:64 25: 4;A4> , 9::4A7123755C *"('"(7@ 777 327;25< 7@ 45<7<34: EC> 2::7<7C523 HC;?45@2<7C5 CE @ . ''', =7<1 75<4>4@< 2< >2<4 CE *M ?4> 2559; E>C; :2<4 CE H327; ?4<7<7C5<733:4?C@7< 7D 5@9>4> 7@ 143: 372A34 <C ?2B @2;4 25: 7@ :7>4H<4: <C :4?C@7< @2;4 =7<1 75<4>4@< A4EC>4 >7A9523=7<175EC9>=44I@ D 5 :4?C@7< 45<7>4 2;C95< <C A4 >4342@4: 75 E2DC9>CEH327;25< >7 9:12>@125 342>54: HC95@43 7@ ?4>;7<<4: <C E734 D2I232<152;2=7<175<=C=44I@ ./ '%% ( # 7@<C "3C &