- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '( ) ! " # $! # % & % % " # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &$% # %! & ' ( '&& ) * " + ## $ , '#! !!! ! ( -&%# , .! , -&% ) * , / & + , , !*+ , 0! , " !# " , - 3 - , , " 1" % 234566758349387:5;53<4==27>?:;@7<=5<:5A5B: :5=7: !# 65447: CD =27 7<3EB 3F38 "?:;7 5<: ",2EB56?B*9EB42EB=GE@@3443E<7BH+3< E E9 <7 7B5665 77B742 A54 AEBI@5< ?<:7B B746E<:7<= E 54 5 :B3F7B E9 5B?=3 A39= J3B7 K5B C75B3<;7; E'!! !!!5<:27@7=A3=25<5KK3:7<= E<#A238727A54E<:?=D5<::37:E<=27A5D =E=272E463=587A5425F3<;=AEA3F745<:=AEK238:B7< =E75K2A39734A3F74K238:B7<5<:65B7<=49387:5K853@ 67=3=3E< C79EB7 =27 E@@3443E<7B K853@3<; KE@67<45=3E< E94# 'A3=23<=7B74=5=L65 ! 27 E@@3443E<7B KE<43:7B3<; =27 7<=3B7 7F3:7<K7 E< B7KEB: ;B5<=7: KE@67<45=3E< E9 - 4 - 4&% 'A3=23<=7B74=5=&L659BE@=27:5=7E9 67=3=3E< =388 3=4 B758345=3E< 5<: :3B7K=7: B746E<:7<= E' <4?B5<K7E@65<D=E:76E43==2745@7 # ;;B37F7:CD=27453:>?:;@7<=5<:5A5B:=27 K853@5<=4 25F7 6B797BB7: =234 566758 3< A23K2 3= 34 KE<=7<:7:=25==27E@@3443E<7B2545A5B:7:3<=7B74=5= &L67B5<<?@9BE@=27:5=7E967=3=3E<=388B758345=3E< C?==2745@734=EC75A5B:7:5=L659BE@=27:5=7 E95KK3:7<==388B758345=3E<5467B7K=3E<#*!+*5+E9=27 @68ED774 E@67<45=3E< K= 27 :7K7547: A54 75B<3<; 4& ' 67B @E<=2 5<: 4 ' C5==5 67B :5D C?= =27 E@@3443E<7B 254 ABE<;8D =5I7< =27 3<KE@7 5= 4#& ' 67B @E<=2 27B79EB7 B7M?74=7: 9EB 7<25<K7@7<=E9KE@67<45=3E< & 75B:=275B;?@7<=4E9CE=243:74 % 279E88EA3<;4?C4=5<=358M?74=3E<4E985A5B347 9EBKE<43:7B5=3E<3<=234566758 - 5 - 3+ 27=27B =27 E@@3443E<7B A54 >?4=3937: 3< 5A5B:3<; =27 3<=7B74= 5= &L 65 9BE@ =27 :5=7E967=3=3E<=388B758345=3E<E95@E?<=3<4=75: E95A5B:3<;L3<=7B74=659BE@=27:5=7E9 =275KK3:7<==3883=4B758345=3E<5467B7K=3E<# *!+*5+E9@68ED774E@67<45=3E<K=0!N 33+ 27=27B =27 E@@3443E<7B A54 >?4=3937: 3< =5I3<; =27 3<KE@7 E9 =27 :7K7547: 5= 4#& ' 67B @E<=2 3<4=75: E9 4& ' 67B @E<=2 54 6B74KB3C7: ?<:7B =27 7<=B58 EF7B<@7<= E=393K5=3E< 344?7: ?<:7B 7K=3E< #E9=27@68ED774E@67<45=3E<K=0!N = 34 4=5=7: =25= =27 :7K7547: A54 75B<3<; 4& ' 67B @E<=2 5<: 4 ' :538D C5==5 7 A54 AEBI3<;545:B3F7B5<:@7=A3=25<5KK3:7<=3<=27D75B 27B79EB7 54 67B =27 E=393K5=3E< 344?7: CD =27 7<=B58 EF7B<@7<= :5=7: !& C75B3<; E & *+ =27 3<KE@7 E9 =27 :7K7547: 34 =E C7 =5I7< 5= 4& ' 67B @E<=2 5<: 54 3= 34 5 K547 E9 :75=2&LE94& '34=EC7=5I7<9EB=276?B6E47 E9 :7=7B@3<5=3E< E9 =27 KE@67<45=3E< A23K2 KE@74 =E - 6 - 4& ' 4 =27 :7K7547: A54 5;7: 0 D75B4 =27 B787F5<= 95K=EB 56683K5C87 34 00 2?4 =27 KE@67<45=3E< KE@74 =E 4& O 00 P 4&## ' 65B=9BE@=25==275667885<=45B7584E7<=3=87: 9EB5<5@E?<=E94& '=EA5B:49?<7B587O67<474 0 2?4 3< 588 =27 K853@5<=4 5B7 7<=3=87: 9EB 5 =E=58KE@67<45=3E<E94&00# 'A3=23<=7B74=5=L 67B 5<<?@ 9BE@ =27 :5=7 E9 5KK3:7<= =388 B758345=3E< 27 6E3<=49EBKE<43:7B5=3E<5B75<4A7B7:5KKEB:3<;8D <=27B74?8==279E88EA3<;EB:7B3465447: *3+ 6675834588EA7:3<65B= *33+ 27 5667885<=4 K853@5<=4 5B7 7<=3=87: 9EB =27 =E=58 KE@67<45=3E< E9 4&00# ' 54 5;53<4= 4&% ' 5A5B:7: CD =27 E@@3443E<7B A3=2 3<=7B74= 5= L 67B 5<<?@ 9BE@ =27 :5=7 E9 5KK3:7<= =388 =27:5=7E9B7583J5=3E< - 7 - *333+ 746E<:7<= E'<4?B5<K7 E@65<D 34 :3B7K=7: =E :76E43= =27 59EB7453: KE@67<45=3E< 5@E?<= A3=23<E<7@E<=29BE@=27:5=7E9=234>?:;@7<= *3F+ < 4?K2 :76E43= =27 5667885<=4 5B7 67B@3==7: =EA3=2:B5A=277<=3B75@E?<=58E<;A3=23<=7B74=5KKB?7: E< 3= 54 67B =27 566EB=3E<@7<= @5:7 CD =27 E@@3443E<7B *+, '&!! ( % 34= E8 E