- 1 - !!"!#"$ % &"! ""$$ '() * !"#$$ % & ' ! $ () )""* !"*$$ & +!))"' ) % & , $*)! $ ' Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $*)&$' $$# *$" - &! &- ' ./0 122314 /0 56 7.3 841/91:71223441:7 1;1/:07 7.3 <=>;93:7 1:> 1?1@> >173> *$" /: A$$# 21003> 56 7.3 B >>4 /07@/87 =>;3 /<1612=@1 &CA@ 0.A@7 D7.3 @/5=:14E' 8144/:; /: F=307/A:4/15/4/76/38A:7@/5=7A@6:3;4/;3:83A:7.3>@/G3@ AC7.3=9=90A140A7.3F=1:7=9AC8A923:017/A: .3 >173 AC 188/>3:7 /:GA4G393:7 AC 7.3 G3./843 /:<=@6 0=071/:3> 56 841/91:71223441:7 1@3 :A7 /: - 3 - >/02=73 .3 A:46 >/02=73 /:GA4G3> /: 7.3 122314 ?/7. @3023877A7.3C1073:/:;AC!H8A:7@/5=7A@6:3;4/;3:83A: 7.3 >@/G3@ AC7.3=9=910 ?344 107.3 /:1>3F=186AC 8A923:017/A: ) 31@> @/ 1:;1:15101G1 17/4 431@:3> 8A=:034 12231@/:; CA@ 7.3 1223441:7841/91:7 1:> @/ =>1@0.1: 431@:3> 8A=:034 12231@/:; CA@ @302A:>3:7 A /:0=@1:83 8A921:6 />3 A@>3@ >173> $*)! :A7/83AC7./0122314A:@302A:>3:7A$/0>/023:03>?/7. ( @/ 1:;1:15101G1 17/4 431@:3> 8A=:034 ?/7. 144 G3.393:83 0=59/773> 7.17 7.3 @/5=:14 /: 7.3 2@303:83 AC 2A4/83 @38A@>0 ?./8. 8431@46 >32/87 7.17 7.3 2A4/83.1G3@3;/073@3> 1;1/:077.3>@/G3@AC7.3 1:> 140A C/43> 8.1@;3 0.337 1;1/:07 7.3 01/> >@/G3@ A@38A@>0?3@31G1/415437A0.A?7.177.3@3?10@10.1:> :3;4/;3:7>@/G/:;A:7.321@7AC7.3=9=9>@/G3@?./8. .1> 8A:7@/5=73> 7A 7.3 188/>3:7 7.3@356 3@@3> /: 7.3 C1073:/:;AC!H8A:7@/5=7A@6:3;4/;3:83A:7.3>@/G3@AC - 4 - 7.3 =9 =9 .3 3:7/@3 @38A@> 8431@46 307154/0.30 7.17 7.3 >@/G3@ AC 7.3 ?10 @302A:0/543 CA@ 7.3 188/>3:7.17121@77.3A?:3@AC7.3=9=9?10:A7 1 21@76 /: 7.3 2@A833>/:;0 3@346 5381=03 7.3 A?:3@ AC 7.3=9=9?.A?10140A0=071/:3>/:<=@6C/43>1841/9 237/7/A:?./8./08A::3873>/:7.391773@7.3@/5=:14A: 7.3 510/0 AC 83@71/: 1>9/00/A:0 91>3 /: 7.3 8@A00 3I19/:17/A: CA=:> 7.17 ?./43 .3 ?10 @37=@:/:; 7A ./0 @30/>3:83C@A9A@7.7A7.3A=7.7.3188/>3:7A88=@@3> 177.33>;3A:7.33073@:0/>3107.3A:8A9/:;G3./843 ?108A9/:;C@A9A=7.7AA@7.A:46A:7.3510/0AC7./0 1>9/00/A: 7.3 @/5=:14 .10 C1073:3> !H 8A:7@/5=7A@6 :3;4/;3:83 A: 7.3 >@/G3@ AC 7.3 =9 =9 .3@3 1@3 :A >A8=93:70 1G1/41543 7A 7.17 3CC387 :A7 3G3: 7A 0=;;307 7.3 0193 7A >=@/:; 8@A00 3I19/:17/A: >9/773>46 :A 02A7 0J378. ?10 2@A>=83> .3 91.1K1@ 10 ?344 10 8A9241/:7?./8.8431@460.A?07.177.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9 =9?10;A/:;567.30/>3AC@A1>1023@7.37@1CC/8=430 1:> /7 /0 7.3 >@/G3@ AC 7.3 ?.A 8193 A: 7.3 - 5 - ?@A:; 0/>3 1:> 81=03> 7.3 188/>3:7 =@7.3@ .10 0=59/773> 7.17 :3/7.3@ 7.3 >@/G3@ :A@ A?:3@ AC 7.3 8.1443:;3> 7.3 8.1@;30.337 53CA@3 7.3 122@A2@/173 CA@=9 :7.3038/@8=9071:8307.3C/:>/:;AC7.3@/5=:14 C1073:/:;!H4/15/4/76A:7.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=981440 CA@/:73@C3@3:83177.3.1:>0AC7./0A=@700193/0:A7 0=071/:1543/:73@90AC41? ! 3 C=@7.3@ 0=59/70 7.17 7.3 1223441:7841/91:7 .10 0=CC3@3> C187=@30 AC # 7A + @/50 1:> 188A@>/:; 7A 7.3 >A87A@ ?.A .10 533: 3I19/:3> .10 07173> 7.17 7.3@3 /0 >/015/4/76 AC H 7A 7.3 ?.A43 5A>6 A?3G3@ 7.3 @/5=:14 .10 :A7 8A:0/>3@3> 7.3 0193 7A 1?1@> 8A923:017/A: =:>3@ 7.3 .31> 4A00 AC C=7=@3 31@:/:; A 140A 7.3 8A923:017/A: 1?1@>3> =:>3@ 7.3 A7.3@ .31>0 3I8327 93>/814 3I23:030 1@3 A: 4A?3@ 0/>3 7 @3F=/@30 @38A:0/>3@17/A:1:>@3 >373@9/:17/A:88A@>/:;460A=;.7 7A 144A? 7.3 122314 1:> 037 10/>3 7.3 8A:7@/5=7A@6 :3;4/;3:8301>>43>A:7.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=90A140A 3:.1:837.38A923:017/A: - 6 - # 3C=7/:; 7.3 0=59/00/A:0 AC 431@:3> 8A=:034 12231@/:;CA@7.3@302A:>3:7A@/=>1@0.1:?/7. 144 G3.393:83 0=59/70 7.17 7.3@3 /0 1 8173;A@/814 1>9/00/A:;/G3:567.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=90717/:;7.17 .3?108A9/:;C@A9A@7.7AA=7.A:7.3@A1>.3@A1> /0 @=::/:; A@7. 7A A=7. 1:> A: 8A9/:; G3./843 ?10 8A9/:;C@A9A=7.7AA@7.7.3188/>3:7.1071J3:24183 A: 7.3 3>;3 AC A7.3@ 0/>3 /3 7A?1@>0 307 0/>3 ./0 8431@460.A?07.177.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=9.1>;A:3A: 7.3 ?@A:; 0/>3 1:> 81=03> 7.3 188/>3:7 .3 93@3 1503:83AC1:68.1@;30.3371;1/:077.301/>23@0A:/:7.3 2@303:83 AC 1>9/00/A:0 /0 :A7 @3F=/@3> 7A 53 8A:0/>3@3> 88A@>/:;46 7.3 @/5=:14 .10 8A:0/>3@3> 7.3 0193 1:> C1073:3> 4/15/4/76 AC !H A: 7.3 >@/G3@ AC 7.3 =9 =9 7.A=;..3?10:A7121@764/7/;1:7/:7.3237/7/A:A:.1:> 5=7/:1:A7.3@841/9237/7/A:/07.3841/91:71:>?10G3@6 9=8. 2@303:7 53CA@3 7.3 A=@7 : 7.303 8/@8=9071:830 7.3 4/15/4/76 C1073:3>>A30:A78144CA@ 1:6 /:73@C3@3:83 17 7.3.1:>0AC7./0A=@7 - 7 - * A C1@ 10 7.3 F=1:7=9 /0 8A:83@:3> 7.3 C@187=@30 1@3 A:46 7A 7.3 @/50 1:6 >/015/4/76 10 .10 533: 07173>567.3)53CA@37.3@/5=:14>A30:A71@/031:> 7.3 @/5=:14 .10 2@A23@46 8A:0/>3@3> 7.3 0193 1:> 1?1@>3> 8A923:017/A: 7.A=;. 7.3 8A923:017/A: ?./8. .10533:1?1@>3>567.3@/5=:14/03IA@5/71:70/:837.3 /:0=@1:83 8A921:6 /0 :A7 /: 122314 7.3 0193 916 53 @371/:3>88A@>/:;460A=;.77A>/09/007.3122314/:/70 3:7/@376 " 1G/:;.31@>7.3431@:3>8A=:03412231@/:;CA@ 7.3 21@7/30 23@=03> 7.3 3:7/@3 122314 2123@0 1:> 7@/14 A=@7@38A@> + .32A/:707.171@/03CA@968A:0/>3@17/A:/0 /' .37.3@ 7.3 @/5=:14 /0 <=07/C/3> /: C1073:/:;!H8A:7@/5=7A@6:3;4/;3:83A: 7.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=9L //' .37.3@ 7.3 @/5=:14 /0 <=07/C/3> /: 1?1@>/:;7.38A923:017/A:L - 8 - $ 61:0?3@7A7.315AG32A/:70AC8A:0/>3@17/A: /0 /' A/:7A$ :7.3:3;17/G3 //' A/:7A :7.31CC/@917/G3 CA@7.3CA44A?/:; $$ A/:7 A$ 7 /0 :A7 /: >/02=737.17 7.3 A?:3@ G3./84310?344107.3>@/G3@AC7.3G3./843?3@3:A721@7/30 /:7.3841/9237/7/A:C/43>567.32@303:71223441:7.3@3/: .3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=9.10140A0=CC3@3>/:<=@/30C/43> 10321@173841/9237/7/A:7.A=;./7?1084=553>5=7/:7.3 01/>841/9237/7/A:140A7.3A?:3@AC7.3=9=9?10:A7 91>310121@76.3@/5=:14.109/003>7./0102387AC 7.3 91773@ : 7.3 1503:83 AC 7.3 21@76 4/15/4/76 /0 C1073:3>7A2167.38A923:017/A:/07.3@3CA@33@@A:3A=0 : 7.303 8/@8=9071:830 7.3 @/5=:14 .10 8A99/773> 1 03@/A=03@@A@/:C1073:/:;7.34/15/4/76A:7.321@76?/7.A=7 .31@/:; A@ ?/7.A=7 ;/G/:; ./9 1:6 A22A@7=:/76 7A 1:0?3@ - 9 - 7.3/00=30C@193>1:>1:0?3@3>567.3@/5=:14./0/01 8431@G/A417/A:AC2@/:8/2430AC:17=@14<=07/83.17121@7 /:7.31503:83AC21@76.1G/:;533:91>31021@764/7/;1:7 /: 7.3 5A7. 841/9 237/7/A:0 93@346 5381=03 7.3@3 1@3 83@71/: 1>9/00/A:0 ?/7.A=7 7.3/@ 53/:; 1:6 510/0 CA@ 7.3 0=8. 0=;;307/A:0 ?./8. 1@3 431> /: 34/8/7/:; 0=8. 1>9/00/A:0 81::A7 53 71J3: /:7A 8A:0/>3@17/A: 7 /0 037743> 2@/:8/2430 AC 41? 7.17 7.3 3:7/@3 3G/>3:83/0 7A 53 431>101?.A431:>:A707@1603:73:830?.3:7.33:7/@3 3G/>3:83431>1:>7.3>A8=93:702@A>=83>8431@460.A?0 7.177.3>@/G3@AC7.3?10@10.1:>:3;4/;3:7/: >@/G/:;7.3G3./8431:>@302A:0/543CA@7.3188/>3:7 7/0 ;3@91:37A93:7/A:7.17:3/7.3@7.3>@/G3@:A@7.3A?:3@ AC7.3.10C/43>1:68A9241/:71;1/:077.3>@/G3@ AC 7.3 =9 =9 G3./843 ?./8. /0 140A /:GA4G3> /: 7.3 188/>3:7 A 8.1443:;3 91>3 7.3 1:> 8.1@;3 0.337 41/> 1;1/:07 7.39 : 7.303 8/@8=9071:830 7.3 @/5=:14 .108431@463@@3>/:.A4>/:;7.177.3>@/G3@AC7.3=9=9 /0 :3;4/;3:7 1:> 8A:7@/5=73> !H 7A?1@>0 188/>3:7 - 10 - @3F=/@30/:73@C3@3:831:>188A@>/:;467.30193/0.34>10 23@G3@03 /: 7.3 2@303:83 AC >A8=93:70 1:> 3G/>3:83 88A@>/:;46 7.3 01/> C/:>/:; /0 037 10/>3 0/>3 .3 3:7/@3 4/15/4/767A?1@>07.3@10.1:>:3;4/;3:7?10A:7.321@7AC 7.3 >@/G3@ AC 7.3 88A@>/:;46 7.3 /:0=@1:83 8A921:6 AC 7.3 01/> /0 4/1543 7A 216 7.3 8A923:017/A: /: /70 3:7/@376 88A@>/:;46 7.3 2A/:7 CA@ 8A:0/>3@17/A:@1/03>/:2A/:7:A$/01:0?3@3>/:C1GA=@AC 7.3 841/91:7 1223441:7 1:> 1;1/:07 7.3 /:0=@1:83 8A921:6 $ A/:7 A A C1@ 10 7.3 8A923:017/A: /0 8A:83@:3> 10 .10 533: @/;.746 0=59/773> 56 7.3 431@:3> 8A=:03412231@/:;CA@7.3/:0=@1:838A921:6/:7.38103 A: .1:> 7.3@3 1@3 A:46 C@187=@30 AC @/50 4AAJ/:; 7A 7.3 8A923:017/A: 1?1@>3> 56 7.3 @/5=:14 0193 /0 <=07 1:> 2@A23@ .3@3 81::A7 53 1:6 >/015/4/76 7A?1@>0 7.3 C@187=@30AC@/50.3@/5=:14.10@/;.7468A:0/>3@3>7.3 8103 1:> :A7 1?1@>3> 1:6 8A923:017/A: =:>3@ 7.3 .31> 4A00ACC=7=@331@:/:;.A=;.7.38A923:017/A:1?1@>3> - 11 - 033907A534/7743A:7.3./;.3@0/>35=7?.3:8A921@3> 7A7.3/:<=@/301@38A:83@:3>0A140A7@31793:771J3:7./0 A=@7 /0 AC 7.3 A2/:/A: 7.17 7.3 0193 53 J327 /:7187 88A@>/:;46 7.3 F=307/A: /0 1:0?3@3> 1;1/:07 7.3 1223441:7841/91:7 1:> 7./0 A=@7 2@A833> 7A 2100 CA44A?/:; / 22314/0 // .3 /92=;:3> <=>;93:7 1:> 1?1@> >173> *$" 21003> /: A$$# 56 7.3 B >>4 /07@/87 =>;3 /<1612=@1/0.3@3569A>/C/3>, /// .3 C/:>/:; AC C1073:/:; !H 8A:7@/5=7A@6 :3;4/;3:83A:>@/G3@AC=9=9/0.3@356 037 10/>3 1:> 7.3 3:7/@3 :3;4/;3:83 /0 C1073:3>A:7.3>@/G3@AC - 12 - /G .3 @302A:>3:7 A /:0=@1:83 8A921:6 0.144 >32A0/7 3:7/@3 19A=:7 1?1@>3> 56 7.3 @/5=:14 1C73@ >3>=87/:; 7.3 19A=:7 14@31>6 >32A0/73> 14A:; ?/7. 188@=3> /:73@307 1?1@>3> 56 7.3 @/5=:14 ?/7./: 1 23@/A>AC0/I?33J0C@A9>173AC@383/27AC 8A26AC7./0A@>3@ G :>32A0/7AC7.319A=:7567.3/:0=@1:83 8A921:6 3:7/@3 19A=:7 0.144 53@343103> /:C1GA=@AC7.3841/91:7 G/ AA@>3@107A8A070 "+, '!) &! /07A$4A)