Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43344 (KAR)
MAHEBOOB ALI v. MALLAPPA AND ANR
MFA/202812/2023 · 2025-10-17
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43344 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43344 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ % &
&&
'()
*
!! " #
!! $$ % &&'& ($) ! ($ ' ! ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!! $ ! "
&* )
$ ! #
& &
+$"# &
! !! & ! ! $+$),! ! &
$ (
-! & & ! . & ,
!! &
/
/ 0
! %
1234561237891:5;<=><56;?41;
6?;2@@12A?;=?A14>B561CA2?92:5272?:;5561 D84791:5 2:4 2E234 42514
@2;;14 >B 561 1:?<3 ?F?A 8471 2:4 A2:4 G=<3 ;6<35 H3?>8:2AIJ?:<
$+$);11K?:71:62:C191:5<= C<9@1:;25?<:
- 3 -
$ 61 ?:D8314 CA2?92:5 2714 L B123;
915 E?56 2: 2CC?41:5 <:
2:4 ;8;52?:14 73?1F<8;
?:D83?1;
1 =?A14 2 CA2?9 @15?5?<: >1=<31 561 3?>8:2A ;11K?:7 C<9@1:;25?<: <= ;
61 3?>8:2A 2=513 C<:;?413?:7 561 1:5?31 1F?41:C1 <: 31C<34 2E23414 561C<9@1:;25?<:<=;
$ ( E?56?:5131;525L-@13 2::89 =3<9 561 4251 <= @15?5?<: 5?AA 312A?M25?<: 2:4 4?31C51431;@<:41:5<
:;832:C1<9@2:B5<@2B561 C<9@1:;25?<: ( 773?1F14 >B 561 ;2?4 2E234 561 2@@1AA2:5 CA2?92:562;@31=1331456?;2@@12A 92?:ABC<:51:4?:75625 5613?>8:2A62;2E23414912731C<9@1:;25?<:8:4132AA 6124;
5?;C<:51:4145625CA2?92:562;;8;52?:14?:D83B 5<561A1=56?@D<?:5 A1=5A172:4=<<52:4?:D83B5<5616124 2:4<5613@235;<=561><4B2:461E2;6<;@?52A?M14=<3 42B; 56131618:413E1:5;83713?1;2:42A;<52K1:=<AA<E 8@ 5312591:5 =<3 ;1F132A 42B; 2:4 ?:C83314 9<31 562: ;
914?C2A 1N@1:;1; 2:4 ; =<3 ;@1C?2A 4?15 >85 561 3?>8:2A 2E23414 912731 29<8:5
- 4 -
8:413 561;1 6124;
5 ?; =835613 C<:51:414 5625 561 CA2?92:5 E2; E<3K?:7 2; 2: 73?C8A583?;5 2:4 123:?:7 ;
@13 9<:56 2:4 561 3?>8:2A 62; :<5 C<:;?41314 561 ;291
5 ?; 2A;< C<:51:414 5625 561 4?;2>?A?5B2;;1;;14>B5613?>8:2A25+
-?;<:561A<E13 ;?41 E6?C6?;31O8?3145<>131C<:;?41314312;<:2>AB2:4 568;
31O81;514 =<3 1:62:C?:7 561 C<9@1:;25?<: ?: 6?; =2F<83
5 ?; ;8>9?5514 >B 561 A123:14 C<8:;1A =<3 31;@<:41:5 < P :;832:C1 <9@2:B 5625 561 C<9@1:;25?<:2E23414>B5613?>8:2A?;D8;52:4@3<@13 2:4:114;:<?:513=131:C1 L ; @13 N
!L <8:4 135?=?C251 CA2?92:5 62; ;8;52?:1473?1F<8;?:D83?1;2:456131E131?:513:2A=?N25?<:
<=?9@A2:5;
:;8@@<35<=6?;C<:51:5?<: 561CA2?92:562;
1N29?:14561<C5<32;!2:4!62;?;;814N
!P ?;2>?A?5B 135?=?C251 2CC<34?:7 E6?C6 ! =<8:4 561 =<AA<E?:7?:D83?1;;8==1314>B561CA2?92:5?:5612CC?41:5/
- 5 -
!" #
$#
%&
# '# ( ) % * + , # - %./0
+ :F?1E<=5612><F1@6B;?C2A?9@2?391:5;
! 62; 2;;1;;14 E6<A1 ><4B 4?;2>?A?5B 25
-
85 561 3?>8:2A 62; 52K1: 561 4?;2>?A?5B 25 +
- 5< 561 E6<A1 ><4B
; @13 N
! P ?;2>?A?5B 135?=?C251 !
62;
;52514 @6B;?C2A ?9@2?391:5; <= (- 5< A1=5 A<E13 A?9>
61:C1 56?;<835=?:4;?5312;<:2>A15<52K1$34<=(-
// -2;561=8:C5?<:2A4?;2>?A?5B<=561CA2?92:5
6<876 561 CA2?92:5 ;5251; 5625 61 E2; 123:?:7; @139<:56 6162;:<5@3<48C142:B 4<C891:5 5< @3<F1 561 ;291 2:4 56131=<31 561 3?>8:2A 2; @13 561 C6235 ?;;814 >B 561 23:252K2 5251 172A 13F?C1; 856<3?5B C<:;?41314 6?; ?:C<91 2; ; +
- 6 -
@139<:562;5612CC?41:5<=561B123
CC<34?:7AB
561CA2?92:5?;1:5?5A14=<3A<;;<==85831123:?:7C2@2C?5B 2;8:413/ ;
+NN+N-Q;
$ )
) 61 CA2?92:5 E2; 249?5514 ?: 561 6<;@?52A =<3 42B;2:4?5?;;525145625619?765:<562F12551:414 2:BE<3K25A12;5=<32@13?<4<=(9<:56;
6131=<31 56?;
<835 =?:4; ?5 312;<:2>A1 5< 732:5 2: 29<8:5 <= ;
( =<3@2?:2:4;8==13?:7 ; =<3A<;;<= 291:?5?1;
;
$
=<3 532:;@<3525?<:
1N532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5 C62371; 2:4 =<83 9<:56;
?:C<91 // ;
(+ 5<E234; A<;; <= ?:C<91 483?:7 A2?4 8@ @13?<4
<E1F13 561 29<8:5 732:514 >B 561 3?>8:2A 5<E234; 914?C2A 1N@1:;1; ?: 2 ;89 <= ;
):114;:<?:513=131:C1 61 C<9@1:;25?<: 2E23414 >B 561 3?>8:2A ?; 9<4?=?142;8:413/
- 7 -
A < 124; E234>B561 3?>8:2A E234>B56?; <835
!2?: 2:4 ;8==13?:7 ;
;
(
14?C2A N@1:;1; ;
) ;
) $ <;; <= =85831 123:?:7C2@2C?5B ; +) ++ ;
$ )
( 32:;@<3525?<:
1N532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5 C62371; ;
;
$
<;; <= 291:?5?1; ;
;
L <;; <= ?:C<91 483?:7 A2?4 8@ @13?<4 ;
( $ ;
(+
<52A ;
$ ( ;
L
(L 6131E?AA>11:62:C191:5<=; ++ )L$
:56131;8A5 561=<AA<E?:7<3413?;@2;;14/
"?# @@12A?;
- 8 -
"??# 61 CA2?92:5 ?; 1:5?5A14 =<3 561 1:62:C14 C<9@1:;25?<: <= ; ++ )L$ E?56 ?:5131;5 25 L- @13 2::89 =3<9 561 4251 <= @15?5?<:5?AA5614251<=312A?M25?<:
"???# 1;@<:41:5 < P :;832:C1 <9@2:B ?; 4?31C514 5< 41@<;?5 561 2=<31;2?4 C<9@1:;25?<:29<8:52A<:7E?56?:5131;5E?56?: <:19<:56=3<95614251<=56?;D84791:5
"?F# : ;8C6 41@<;?5 561 CA2?92:5 ?; @139?55145<E?56432E5611:5?3129<8:52A<:7 E?56?:5131;52CC3814<:?5
+,- '& ) %
?;5<
/A<
/+$ /